Independent mortgage math, no lender rankings

Stay on your rate, or refinance?

A lower rate is not automatically a better loan. Think of this as coaching for one decision: bring the loan you have and the quote in front of you, and we will walk through the payment change, the break-even month, the interest over the years you will actually stay, and whether the new term quietly restarts your clock.

Rate context: Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.28% and the 15-year at 6.66% for the week released November 19, 2026. Your quote will differ; use your quote, not the average.

Run the Stay or Refi Calculator
  • Freddie Mac PMMS rate context, dated on page
  • CFPB closing-cost categories
  • Rates you enter, never a sold quote
  • Educational only, not a loan offer
How the math works

Try it with your numbers

The calculator below runs on your balance, your current rate, the quote in front of you, and the years you expect to stay. It prints its assumptions with the result, including the term restart warning when a new term runs longer than the time left on your current loan.

Read break-even first

Example, replace with your loan: the fields start with a worked example ($400,000 balance, 7.5% to 6.5%, $6,000 closing costs, 7-year stay). They are example inputs, not a rate quote for you. Overwrite every field with your balance, your quote, and your costs.

Saved on this device only. Your entries are stored in this browser so a return visit keeps them; nothing is sent anywhere.

Stay: your current loan

Refinance: the quote in front of you

Your horizon

Break-even month

17

months to repay $6,000 of closing costs from payment savings

Refinancing wins on these inputs if you stay past month 17. Over your 7-year horizon it comes out about $19,992 ahead after closing costs.

Current payment (principal and interest)
$2,883 per month
New payment (principal and interest)
$2,528 per month
Monthly change
$355 less
Break-even month
Month 17
Interest if you stay 7 years, current loan
$200,031
Interest plus closing costs, new loan
$180,040
Net over your stay horizon
$19,992 ahead by refinancing
Lifetime interest difference (full term, after closing)
$17,893 less with the refinance

Term restart warning: the new 30-year term runs longer than the 27 years left on your current loan. A lower monthly payment can still cost more over the full life of the loan. Compare the lifetime interest line above, not just the payment.

Assumptions printed in full: fixed rates for the whole term, no points beyond the closing cost figure you entered, no cash out, no prepayment, taxes and insurance excluded because they do not change with the lender. This is an estimate for education, not a loan offer.

My stay-vs-refi comparison

Print this summary and take it to a lender. It states the inputs you entered, so any lender can reproduce or challenge the math on the spot.

  • Loan balance entered: $400,000
  • Current loan: 7.5% with 27 years left, $2,883 per month
  • Refinance quote entered: 6.5% on a new 30-year term, $2,528 per month
  • Closing costs entered: $6,000
  • Stay horizon entered: 7 years
  • Break-even month: month 17
  • Net over the stay horizon: $19,992 ahead by refinancing
  • Verdict: Refinancing wins on these inputs if you stay past month 17. Over your 7-year horizon it comes out about $19,992 ahead after closing costs.

Educational estimate only, not a loan offer. Rates shown here are the ones entered above, not rates published or promised by this site.

Take these three figures to lenders

Ask every lender for the same three figures, on identical terms, in writing on a Loan Estimate: the same loan amount, the same term, and the same lock period.

  1. The rate for that exact term and lock period, with any discount points stated separately.
  2. Total closing costs: lender charges plus third-party fees, with prepaids and escrow deposits set aside.
  3. The break-even month those figures produce against your current loan.

This site publishes no lender rates and no rankings. Compare lenders on recorded facts and on the Loan Estimates they issue you, never on a rate promised in an advertisement.

Compare lenders on everything except a promised rate →

Short answer

Run the calculator below with the quote in front of you to get its break-even month. To get quotes, the lender directory covers 24 mortgage lenders by recorded facts only, with a 3 question finder and no rates published. Once you have offers in hand, compare them side by side in the refinance offer worksheet, which uses only the numbers you enter.

Couple reviewing refinance paperwork and a calculator at a dining table

Start with the decision

Illustration of a home with moving boxes alongside mortgage documents

Every section on this site

Guides by topic

Family gathered around a dining table at home
Front door of a suburban home in warm light

How StayOrRefi decides what to publish

Every figure on this site traces to a named public source with a check date shown on the page. Rate context comes from Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey. Closing cost categories follow Consumer Financial Protection Bureau guidance and the Loan Estimate format. Where a number is an example, the page labels it as one and states the balance, term, closing costs, and stay horizon behind it. Read the methodology for the formulas, the about page for how publishing works here, and the disclaimer before acting on any example.

Need the general mortgage math instead?

Amortization schedules, extra payment effects, and affordability calculators live on CalculatorVillage. StayOrRefi keeps only the stay-or-refinance decision, and sends you there for the wider math instead of duplicating it. When you have a quote in hand, come back and run it through the calculator with your closing costs and your stay horizon, then check the result against the break-even guide.