Refinance break-even, explained with the costs left in
Refinance break-even is the month your savings repay the closing costs: closing costs divided by the monthly saving. $6,000 of costs against a $250 monthly saving breaks even in month 24. That one division is the right first test, but on a loan with 15 years left it can call month 6 for a refinance that needs until month 23 once interest is counted. This page works both methods to the month, the structures that break the division (a shorter term, rolled-in costs, lender credits, mortgage insurance, a second refinance) and the balance check that decides which quote wins over the years you will actually stay. It is arithmetic on stated inputs, not a loan offer and not financial advice.
Worksheet steps (13)
- The break-even formula
- What counts as a closing cost
- Payment saving or interest saving: why the two methods disagree
- How many years you have left changes the answer
- When the new payment is higher: break-even on a shorter term
- The two ways break-even gets dressed up
- Break-even when no cash changes hands: rolled costs and lender credits
- Count mortgage insurance in the saving, and leave escrow out
- A second refinance: costs you already paid are sunk
- When break-even is the wrong test: cash-out refinances
- How to use this number when lenders quote you
- Count the balance you will still owe on the day you move
- What taxes do to the month
The break-even formula
Break-even month = total closing costs divided by monthly payment savings. If a refinance costs $6,000 in closing costs and lowers the payment by $200 a month, the break-even point is month 30. Move, sell, or refinance again before month 30 and the deal lost money, no matter how good the new rate looked on paper.
That is the simple version, and it is the right place to start. The fuller version, worked further down this page, counts interest instead of payments. Two loans with the same payment can charge very different interest in the early years, because interest is front-loaded in a level-payment amortization schedule. Our calculator shows both views: the payment break-even and the interest comparison over the years you actually plan to stay.
Two companion guides build on this division. The how to refinance step by step guide places break-even as the first step of the full procedure, before any lender is chosen, and the how much does it cost to refinance worksheet builds the numerator line by line from lender fees, third-party fees, points, prepaids, and lender credits, so the total you divide here is assembled rather than guessed.
What counts as a closing cost
Closing costs are everything you pay to get the new loan that you would not pay by keeping the old one. The Loan Estimate lays them out in a fixed order set by Regulation Z (12 CFR 1026.37(f) and (g), checked October 28, 2026): Loan Costs, made up of Origination Charges (Section A), Services You Cannot Shop For (B) and Services You Can Shop For (C); then Other Costs, made up of Taxes and Other Government Fees (E), Prepaids (F), the Initial Escrow Payment at Closing (G) and Other (H). Only some of those lines belong in a break-even calculation.
- Lender charges (Section A): origination, application, processing, underwriting, and any discount points you buy.
- Third-party services (Sections B and C) and government fees (Section E): appraisal, title search and insurance, credit report, flood certification, recording fees, and transfer taxes where your state charges them.
- Prepaids and escrow (Sections F and G): homeowner's insurance, property taxes, and per-diem interest. These are mostly timing, not true cost, because you would pay them on the old loan too. Ask which sections a quoted closing cost figure includes; a total that mixes F and G in with A through C is not the number to divide.
Payment saving or interest saving: why the two methods disagree
There are two defensible ways to count the monthly saving, and they give different months. The payment method divides closing costs by the drop in the principal and interest payment. It is the quicker of the two, because the payment is the number on the statement. The interest method adds up, month by month, how much less interest the new loan charges than the old one, and finds the month that running total passes the closing costs.
They differ because a payment is two things. Part of it is interest, which is a cost. The rest is principal, which is your own money moving from your bank account into home equity. When a refinance stretches the debt over more years, part of the lower payment comes from paying less principal each month, not from paying less interest. The payment method counts that slower paydown as a saving. The interest method does not, because the balance you still owe when you leave is higher by exactly that amount.
Take a $400,000 balance at 7.50 percent with 27 years left, about $2,883 a month in principal and interest, refinanced to a hypothetical 6.50 percent on a fresh 30-year term at about $2,528 a month, with $6,000 of closing costs. The payment saving is about $355 a month, so the payment method calls break-even in month 17. The interest saved runs a little slower: about $3,970 after 12 months and about $7,549 after 23, and it passes $6,000 in month 19. By month 84 the payment method has counted about $29,792 of savings, but $3,800 of that is principal the new loan has not yet repaid, so the honest saving after seven years is about $25,992 before costs and about $19,992 after them.
One shortcut keeps the arithmetic manageable. When the old and new loans start from the same balance, the interest saved by any month equals the payment saving minus the extra balance still owed on the new loan, to the dollar. So counting interest and counting payments plus the balance gap are the same test. The horizon total later on this page is that test run over a full stay; the interest method is the same test asked a simpler question, which month the costs are repaid.
A 1-point drop on $400,000 with 27 years left, counted to the month
A $400,000 balance at 7.5% with 27 years left costs about $2,883 a month in principal and interest. Refinancing to a hypothetical 6.5% on a new 30-year term drops that to about $2,528, saving about $355 a month. With $6,000 of closing costs, the payment method puts break-even in month 17 and the interest method in month 19. Stay seven years and the refinance comes out about $19,992 ahead after costs once the higher balance still owed on the 30-year loan is counted. Price the same rate on the 27 years you actually had left and the payment saving shrinks to about $261, but lifetime interest falls to about $449,599 against about $510,178 on the fresh 30-year term and about $534,071 on the current loan. Run your own numbers on the calculator; small rate or cost changes move the answer a lot.
How many years you have left changes the answer
The gap between the two methods is not a rounding detail. It depends almost entirely on how many years are left on the loan you hold, because that decides how much of the new, lower payment comes from stretching the term. The chart below holds everything else still: a $400,000 balance at 7.50 percent, a hypothetical 6.50 percent quote on a fresh 30-year term, and $6,000 of closing costs. Only the years left on the current loan change.
Show the break-even months behind this chart
| Years left on current loan | Current payment | Payment drop to the new 30-year loan | Payment method | Interest method |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 | $2,797 | $269 | Month 23 | Month 18 |
| 25 | $2,956 | $428 | Month 15 | Month 19 |
| 20 | $3,222 | $694 | Month 9 | Month 20 |
| 15 | $3,708 | $1,180 | Month 6 | Month 23 |
Read the rows from the bottom. With 15 years left, the current payment is about $3,708 and the new 30-year payment about $2,528, so the payment drops by $1,180 and the payment method declares victory in month 6. But after six months the new loan owes about $5,163 more than the old one would have, so only about $1,915 of the $7,079 counted as savings is interest actually saved. The interest method puts break-even in month 23, almost two years out. Most of that "saving" was the borrower lending the bank the same money for 15 more years.
Now the top row. With a full 30 years left, the two loans have the same term, the lower rate pays the balance down faster, and the payment method is the conservative one: it says month 23 while the interest method says month 18. So the payment method is not always too optimistic. It turns too optimistic once the new term runs a few years longer than the term you have left: on this example it is still conservative with 29 years left (month 21 against 19), even at 28 (19 and 19), and optimistic from 27 years left down. That is the common case for anyone more than a few years into a 30-year loan. Price the same rate on your remaining term as well, and the payment method turns conservative: on the 27-years-left example the term-matched loan pays about $2,622, saves about $261 a month, and breaks even in month 24 by the payment method against month 18 by the interest method.
When the new payment is higher: break-even on a shorter term
The payment method breaks completely on one common refinance: moving to a 15-year loan. The payment goes up, so there is no saving to divide by, and a calculator built on the payment method reports that the refinance never breaks even. The interest method still works, and in the example below it gives the fastest interest-method break-even on this page.
Freddie Mac's survey for the week of October 29, 2026 put the 15-year fixed average at 6.60 percent, 0.64 of a point under the 30-year average of 7.24 percent. Keep that gap and price the same $400,000 balance with 27 years left at 7.50 percent into a 15-year loan at a hypothetical 5.875 percent with the same $6,000 of costs. The payment rises from about $2,883 to about $3,348, about $466 a month more. But the interest saved passes $6,000 in month 11, and by month 84 the 15-year loan has charged about $62,773 less interest and owes about $255,987 against about $357,865 on the current loan. Over its life the 15-year loan charges about $202,725 of interest against about $534,071 left on the current path.
So the question for a term cut is not break-even; on these numbers it arrives inside the first year. The question is whether the budget carries the higher payment through bad months, and whether the cash would do more somewhere else. If the answer to the first is uncertain, the same rate on a 30-year term with voluntary extra principal keeps the option to pay less in a hard month, at the cost of a somewhat higher rate. Biweekly payments vs refinancing to a shorter term prices that voluntary extra principal against a 15-year refinance.
The two ways break-even gets dressed up
The first trick is the no-closing-cost refinance, covered in its own guide. The costs do not disappear; they move into a higher rate or a bigger loan balance, where they stop appearing in the break-even math entirely.
The second trick is restarting the clock. Extending a loan with 24 years left back out to 30 years lowers the payment even at the same rate, so the payment break-even looks wonderful while lifetime interest climbs. A break-even claim that does not mention the new term is only telling you half the story.
Both tricks share one tell: a new payment compared with the old payment without asking how many years each payment runs. A lower payment spread over more years is often a more expensive loan wearing a friendlier outfit.
Break-even when no cash changes hands: rolled costs and lender credits
Two common structures make the division look broken, because the cost no longer arrives as cash at closing.
Rolled-in costs. Add the $6,000 to the loan instead of paying it, and the new balance is $406,000. On the 27-years-left example the payment at a hypothetical 6.50 percent becomes about $2,566, so the payment still drops by about $317 a month and you paid nothing at the table. The cost has moved onto the balance. Counted honestly, the rolled loan starts $6,000 behind, and its interest saving passes that $6,000 in month 21, two months later than paying cash, because the $6,000 itself is now charging 6.50 percent. After seven years the rolled loan owes about $5,425 more than the cash-paid version and has charged about $3,186 more in payments. The test is the same: divide the rolled amount by the saving, and treat the result as a floor, because interest on the rolled amount pushes the true month a little later.
Lender credits. A credit is a negative closing cost paid for with a higher rate. If a credit covers every fee, there is nothing to divide and the simple break-even is month zero, which is why credit quotes look so good on this test. The cost is real; it just arrives monthly. The right comparison is a second division, the credit divided by the extra payment the higher rate creates, which this site calls the credit horizon. The no-closing-cost refinance guide works it on a $412,000 loan where the credit is the cheaper structure at three years and the expensive one at seven.
Count mortgage insurance in the saving, and leave escrow out
The monthly saving in the division is the change in what the loan itself costs each month: principal, interest, and any mortgage insurance. Escrow for property taxes and homeowner's insurance does not belong in it, because the tax bill and the insurance premium are the same whichever loan you hold. Mortgage insurance is different. It is a charge of the loan, and a refinance can remove it, add it, or change it.
Take a $300,000 balance at 6.75 percent with 25 years left, about $2,073 a month in principal and interest, plus a hypothetical $150 a month of mortgage insurance. A refinance to a hypothetical 6.50 percent on a fresh 30-year term, with enough equity that no mortgage insurance is charged, costs about $1,896 a month. Counting principal and interest alone, the saving is about $177 a month, and $5,000 of closing costs breaks even in month 29. Counting the insurance that disappears, the saving is about $327 a month and break-even moves to month 16. The second number is the true one for this borrower; the first understates the refinance by more than a year.
The same correction runs the other way. A refinance that adds mortgage insurance, or moves a loan into a program with an annual premium, has a smaller saving than the principal and interest line suggests. Read the Projected Payments table on page 1 of the Loan Estimate, which lists mortgage insurance on its own row, and use principal, interest and mortgage insurance together. If the insurance can come off the current loan without a refinance, that is a separate and cheaper route; how to remove PMI sets out the rules, and the FHA-to-conventional guide covers the case where the premium is the main reason to refinance.
A second refinance: costs you already paid are sunk
Owners who refinanced a year or two ago often add the old closing costs to the new division, on the theory that the first refinance has not paid for itself yet. It should not be added. The money spent on the first refinance is gone whether or not you refinance again; the only question the new division can answer is whether the new costs come back before you leave. Suppose the first refinance cost $6,000 and a new one costs $5,000 and saves $180 a month. The honest break-even is $5,000 divided by $180, month 28. Adding the old $6,000 would push it to month 62 and could talk a borrower out of a refinance that pays.
Two things from the old loan do carry over. The first is points you are still deducting. IRS Publication 936 lets you deduct the remaining balance of spread-out points in the year a mortgage ends early, including through a refinance, but adds: if you refinance the mortgage with the same lender, you cannot deduct any remaining balance of spread points. That changes the tax picture, not the break-even month. The second is the term. A second fresh 30-year loan restarts the clock again, so the balance check further down this page matters more on each repeat; refinancing too often prices three refinances in four years against one.
When break-even is the wrong test: cash-out refinances
A cash-out refinance usually exists to raise money, not to lower a payment, so the payment often goes up and there is no saving to divide. Forcing a break-even month onto it produces nonsense. The useful comparison is what the cash costs on each route: the new rate applied to the whole balance, including the part you already owed, against a second lien that leaves the first mortgage alone. Cash-out refinance or HELOC prices that trade on a $340,000 loan and finds the current rate at which each route wins, and the cash-out risks guide covers what the larger balance does to equity and to a later sale.
How to use this number when lenders quote you
Start with the Loan Estimate, not the advertisement. The advertisement gives you a rate; the Loan Estimate gives you the closing cost figure that belongs in the numerator. Split that figure into lender charges, third-party fees, and prepaids, leave the prepaids out, and divide what remains by the monthly payment saving. That single division is your break-even month, and it is the first number to ask every lender to defend.
Then ask for the same rate on the term you actually have left. On the worked example above, moving from a 30-year term to the 27 years remaining shrinks the payment saving and pushes break-even later, while cutting lifetime interest by far more. Both quotes are legitimate; they answer different questions. The payment quote answers how the loan feels each month. The term-matched quote answers what the loan costs while you hold it. A good decision needs both answers on the page at the same time.
Finally, compare break-even against your earliest realistic exit, not your hoped-for stay. If work, family, or a possible sale could move you inside the break-even window, treat the refinance as unproven until the numbers survive that shorter horizon. Run the shorter horizon in the calculator as well. A refinance that only wins on the longest stay you can imagine is a weaker deal than the same refinance winning on the stay you can defend. To see how far a given rate drop gets you on your balance and fee total, the break-even grid by balance and closing cost prices drops of 0.25 to 1.00 point in months.
- Get the closing cost total in writing, split into lender charges, third-party fees, and prepaids.
- Price the new rate on your remaining term as well as on a fresh 30-year term.
- Test break-even against your earliest realistic move date, not your longest possible stay.
Count the balance you will still owe on the day you move
The simple break-even division treats every dollar of payment saving as the same kind of dollar. Part of each payment is principal, though, and principal is not a cost or a saving. It is your own money moving into home equity. When you sell or move, the balance still owed comes straight out of your proceeds, so two loans that save the same amount each month can leave you in different places on the day you leave. The fuller test is a horizon total: every payment you will make during the stay, plus the closing costs paid at closing, plus the balance still owed at the end of the stay. Add those three for keeping your loan and for refinancing, on the same stay length, and the lower total wins on that horizon.
Work it on one stated stay. You owe $360,000 with 24 years left at 7.25%, about $2,641 a month in principal and interest. Closing costs are $6,500, paid at closing, and you will stay seven years, or 84 payments. Both refinance rates below are hypothetical illustrations, not lender offers. A fresh 30-year term at a hypothetical 6.25% costs about $2,217 a month, saving about $424 a month, so the simple break-even lands in month 16. The same hypothetical 6.25% priced on the 24 years you actually have left costs about $2,416 a month, saving about $225 a month, so its simple break-even lands in month 29. On the simple test, the fresh 30-year wins easily.
Now count the balances at month 84. Keeping the current loan charges about $171,046 in interest over the stay and leaves about $309,204 still owed. The fresh 30-year charges about $150,314 in interest, about $20,732 less, but its slower schedule leaves about $324,121 still owed, about $14,917 more than keeping your loan. The term-matched loan charges about $146,113 in interest and leaves about $303,149 owed, about $6,055 less than keeping your loan. Add payments, closing costs, and the ending balance together: keeping the loan totals about $531,046, the fresh 30-year about $516,814, and the term-matched loan about $512,613. The term-matched quote is ahead by about $18,433 on this horizon, about $4,201 more than the fresh 30-year, even though its simple break-even arrived 13 months later. That gap is the part the payment-only test cannot see, and it grows whenever a new term slows the principal schedule down.
Use both tests in order. The simple break-even tells you how soon the refinance stops losing money. The horizon total tells you which structure leaves you better off if you stay the full period you named. If the two tests point at different quotes, trust the horizon total for the stay you can defend, and rerun both tests on a shorter stay before you sign. The same balance check applies when a move would replace a low-rate loan; our lock-in cost table prices that trade over 5, 10 and 15 years.
What taxes do to the month
Very little, on the numbers here. IRS Publication 936 (2025 edition, checked October 28, 2026) says points paid to refinance are generally not deductible in full in the year you pay them; they are deducted ratably over the life of the loan. One point of $4,000 on a 30-year refinance becomes about $133 a year of deduction, and only for a household that itemizes. That is too small to move a break-even month by more than a rounding error, so this page leaves taxes out of the division. A mortgage credit certificate is the exception, because a refinance can end a credit worth thousands a year; refinancing with a mortgage credit certificate works the break-even with that credit kept and lost. The exceptions, including the rule that lets you deduct the unamortized balance when the loan ends early, are worked in the refinance closing costs and taxes guide.
Finding your own break-even month
- Get the closing cost figure in writing, split into lender charges, third-party fees, and prepaids.
- Divide true closing costs by the monthly payment saving. That is your break-even month.
- Ask whether you will plausibly stay past that month. Job moves, family changes, and a possible sale all count.
- Compare lifetime interest for both loans, not just the payment.
- Check whether the new term restarts the clock, and price the same rate on your remaining term too.
- If the new term is longer than the years you have left, rerun break-even by the interest method; the payment method will call it early.
Common questions
What is a good break-even period for a refinance?
There is no universal good number. The test is personal: break-even should land comfortably before the earliest date you might move, sell, or refinance again. A break-even in month 48 can be fine for a household confident it will stay ten years, and a break-even in month 18 is not good enough if a move next year is likely. Run the shorter horizon as well as the hopeful one.
Do discount points count toward break-even?
Yes. Points are a closing cost you pay to buy the rate down, so they go into the numerator. A point that costs $4,000 and saves $60 a month needs 67 months just to repay itself, before any other closing costs are counted.
Should I roll closing costs into the loan balance?
Rolling costs in raises the balance, which raises interest on every future payment. It can still be the right move when cash is tight, but count the rolled amount as a cost in your break-even math, because it is one.
Should taxes and insurance be counted in break-even?
No. Prepaid taxes, insurance, and escrow deposits are your own bills collected early. You owe them on the old loan too, so they are timing, not a cost of refinancing. Count lender charges, third-party fees, and any points you buy. The prepaid and escrow guides on this site show how to separate the two stacks on a closing statement.
What if my break-even lands just after I might move?
Treat that as a warning, not a rounding error. Break-even is the month the savings have repaid the costs; moving before it means the refinance lost money even if the new rate looked better. Either negotiate the fee stack down, test a lender credit structure with a shorter horizon, or keep the current loan and revisit the math when your stay is clearer.
Why can the quote with the later break-even still win over my stay?
Because break-even only divides closing costs by the monthly payment saving. It does not count how fast each loan pays down the balance. A fresh 30-year term lowers the payment partly by stretching the debt, so more of the balance is still owed when you move. Over a stated stay, add the payments, the closing costs, and that ending balance for each quote. The quote with the lower horizon total wins on that stay, even when its simple break-even month arrives later.
Which break-even method is the quick one, and when does it mislead?
The payment method is the quick one: closing costs divided by the drop in principal and interest. It is a fair first test, but when the new loan runs longer than the years you have left, part of that payment drop is slower principal paydown, not saved interest. On a $400,000 loan with 15 years left refinanced to a 30-year term, the payment method says month 6 and the interest method says month 23. Ask for the same rate on your remaining term and the gap narrows, though the payment method then errs the other way: month 27 against 19 on the 15-years-left example.
Should mortgage insurance be counted in the monthly saving?
Yes, when the refinance changes it. Mortgage insurance is a charge of the loan, so a refinance that removes it saves that amount every month. On a $300,000 example, counting only principal and interest gave a $177 saving and break-even in month 29; counting $150 of insurance that disappears gave $327 and month 16. Taxes and homeowner's insurance in escrow stay out, because those bills do not change with the loan.
Sources and verification
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Loan Estimate explainer: Explains origination charges, services you can and cannot shop for, points as an upfront fee for a lower rate, and lender credits as a rebate to offset closing costs that can come with a higher rate. Checked October 28, 2026.
- Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.19(f)(1)(ii): The creditor must ensure the consumer receives the Closing Disclosure no later than three business days before consummation, so the final cost stack can be checked against the Loan Estimate before signing. Checked October 28, 2026.
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey: Weekly benchmark for national average mortgage rates. The release for the week of October 29, 2026 put the 30-year average at 7.24% and the 15-year at 6.60%; used here only as dated market context, never as an example rate. Checked November 1, 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 936 (2025), Home Mortgage Interest Deduction: Points paid to refinance are generally not deductible in full in the year paid and are deducted ratably over the life of the loan; any remaining balance is deductible when the mortgage ends early, except that a borrower who refinances with the same lender cannot deduct the remaining balance of spread points. Checked October 28, 2026.
- Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.37(f) and (g), Loan Estimate closing cost details: Loan Costs subheadings Origination Charges, Services You Cannot Shop For, Services You Can Shop For and Total Loan Costs; Other Costs subheadings Taxes and Other Government Fees, Prepaids, Initial Escrow Payment at Closing and Other. Checked October 28, 2026.
This page teaches the method. It does not know your rate quote, your closing cost estimate, or how long you will stay, and those three inputs decide the answer. The calculator on this site runs the same math on your numbers. Educational only, not a loan offer or financial advice.