Closing costs

Discount points and break-even: what a point buys, and when it loses

A discount point costs 1 percent of the loan and pays for itself in the month its savings add up to that cost. Counted in interest saved, that month is roughly 12 divided by the rate cut the point buys: a 0.25-point cut repays in about month 48, a 0.125-point cut in about month 96, and the size of your loan barely matters. Discount points are the clearest trade in a refinance: you hand the lender cash at closing and in return the note rate on the loan is lower for as long as you keep it. The payment saving is real, but it arrives slowly, a month at a time, while the cost arrives in one lump on day one. Whether points help depends on a single comparison: how many months of the lower payment it takes to return the cash, against how many months you will actually stay in this loan. That is break-even math, and it is the same math this site applies to every refinance decision, just with a bigger cost in the numerator.

Worksheet steps (13)
  1. What a point is, and is not
  2. The points break-even, in isolation
  3. What one point buys on a $400,000 refinance
  4. The 12-divided-by rule, and why your balance barely matters
  5. Points stack on top of total break-even
  6. In 2023, two in three refinances paid points, and the median bill was 2.4 times its 2021 level
  7. When points lose
  8. A point against the same cash paid toward principal
  9. How to price points before you buy them
  10. Reading the rate a point buys off two Loan Estimates
  11. Cash or rolled in: the same point costs more inside the loan
  12. Points on a refinance and the tax return
  13. Points when another refinance is possible

What a point is, and is not

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it plainly: one point equals 1 percent of your loan amount. One point on a $100,000 loan is $1,000. One point on a $400,000 loan is $4,000. Points do not have to be round numbers. CFPB notes a quote might carry 1.375 points, 0.5 points, or 0.125 points, and each fraction scales the same way off your balance. Points appear on page 2, Section A of the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure, alongside other origination charges.

Two things a point is not. It is not a rate, and it does not buy a fixed, published rate reduction. CFPB is explicit that how much a point lowers your rate depends on the lender, the kind of loan, and market conditions that day. Any rule of thumb you have heard about a set reduction per point is not a promise. The only rate reduction that matters is the one on your own same-day quote, with and without points, from the same lender on the same loan. A temporary 2-1 or 3-2-1 buydown is a different product: it lowers only the first years' payments from an escrow account, and if you refinance before it ends, the unspent balance follows the payoff rules set out in refinancing during a temporary buydown.

The points break-even, in isolation

Isolate the points decision from the refinance decision. First, does the refinance itself pay back its ordinary closing costs before you expect to move or refinance again? Second, and separately, do the points pay back? The points math is: points cost divided by the extra monthly payment saving the points create, compared with the zero-point version of the same loan. The answer is a month count, the same as every break-even on this site.

Work it as a reading exercise. Suppose a quote sheet shows that paying one point costs $4,000 and lowers your monthly payment by $65 compared with the zero-point quote. Divide $4,000 by $65 and the points break even in month 62, rounded up. Stay in the loan past month 62 and the points are ahead. Move, sell, or refinance again before month 62 and the points finish underwater, because the lower rate stops the day the loan ends. The numbers in your quote will differ. The division does not.

What one point buys on a $400,000 refinance

Stated example: a $400,000 balance, 27 years left on the current loan, a new 30-year term, and $6,000 of closing costs before points, with a planned stay of seven years in the new loan. One point on this balance costs $4,000 at closing. Suppose the same-day, zero-point quote and the one-point quote differ by $65 a month in payment: the point alone breaks even in month 62, which is inside the 84-month stay, so this household would collect on it. Fold the point into the refinance and total closing costs rise to $10,000, so the whole deal must also be re-tested in the calculator at the lower rate before the point earns its place.

The 12-divided-by rule, and why your balance barely matters

The payment division above is the familiar version. There is a second way to count the saving that is closer to the truth and easier to remember. A point that cuts the rate by 0.25 of a percentage point saves about 0.25 percent of the balance in interest every year, which is 0.25 divided by 12, or about 0.0208 percent, every month. The point costs 1 percent. One percent divided by 0.0208 percent is 48. So the point is repaid, in interest saved, in about month 48, and the same logic gives month 96 for a 0.125 cut, month 32 for 0.375, and month 24 for 0.50. In short: the interest payback month is about 12 divided by the rate cut per point.

The balance falls out of the arithmetic, because both the price of the point and the interest it saves scale with the loan amount. One point on $250,000, $400,000, or $600,000 at 7.00 percent with a 0.25 cut repays its interest in month 48 every time, and in month 60 by the payment division. The payment version runs about a year slower because part of the payment saving is principal you would have paid anyway; the lower rate sends more of each payment to the balance, and that is your own equity, not a saving. Neither number moves much with the rate level: the payment-method month for a 0.25 cut is 63 at a 6.00 percent starting rate, 60 at 7.00 percent, and 58 at 8.00 percent.

How fast one discount point pays back, by the rate cut it buys Lines show cumulative interest saved as a percentage of one point's cost over 120 months on a 30-year loan at 7.00 percent. A 0.50 cut crosses 100 percent in month 24, 0.375 in month 32, 0.25 in month 48, and 0.125 in month 96. Lines are cut off at 300 percent. 0%50%100%150%200%250%300%024487296120Months after closingRepaid0.125 point drop per point: repaid in month 960.125-point cut0.25 point drop per point: repaid in month 480.25-point cut0.375 point drop per point: repaid in month 320.375-point cut0.5 point drop per point: repaid in month 240.5-point cut
How fast one discount point pays back, by the rate cut it buys Illustration with stated inputs: 30-year fixed loan at 7.00 percent, one point paid in cash, the point lowering the rate by the amount shown. The result is the same at any balance. Dots mark the month each line reaches 100 percent. StayOrRefi amortization arithmetic, computed October 24, 2026. The CFPB states that how much a point lowers the rate depends on the lender, the loan and the market, so the four cuts are scenarios, not typical values.
Show the payback months by rate cut
Rate cut bought by one pointPayment saving per $100,000Payback, payment methodPayback, interest methodShare of the point repaid by month 36
0.125$8.37 a monthMonth 120Month 9638%
0.25$16.70 a monthMonth 60Month 4875%
0.375$24.99 a monthMonth 41Month 32113%
0.50$33.23 a monthMonth 31Month 24151%

This is why the stay horizon matters more than the balance. A household that expects to keep the loan four years can afford a point only if it buys at least about a quarter of a percentage point. One that expects ten years can make a 0.125 cut work, barely. The quote sheet tells you which cut you are being offered; the rule tells you how long you have to stay to collect it. The same split between payment and interest applies to the whole refinance, which the break-even guide works through, and the point itself is one line in the stack built in the refinance cost worksheet.

Points stack on top of total break-even

A purchased point is a closing cost like any other, so it also belongs in the total picture. If a refinance carries $6,000 of true closing costs and you add one $4,000 point, the loan now has to repay $10,000 before it is ahead. Even when the points eventually pay back on their own clock, they push the whole refinance's break-even later and increase the cash you must bring, or the balance you must borrow if costs are rolled in.

That is why the cleanest test uses the calculator twice. Run your balance, rate, term, and closing costs once at the zero-point rate, and once at the points rate with the point added to closing costs. The break-even guide walks through the base math, and the third-party fees and lender fees guides show which costs count as true closing costs instead of prepaids. Points are always true cost. They never come back at payoff.

In 2023, two in three refinances paid points, and the median bill was 2.4 times its 2021 level

Paying points used to be a minority choice. HMDA data reported by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau show that among first-lien refinances of single-family principal residences, the share paying any discount points ran between 38.1 percent and 44.3 percent from 2018 through 2021, then jumped to 60.6 percent in 2022 and 67.7 percent in 2023. The money changed even faster. The median amount paid by refinancers who bought points was about $1,619 in 2021 and about $3,902 in 2023 (CFPB, 2023 Mortgage Market Activity and Trends, December 2024, Table A2, checked October 24, 2026).

Median discount points paid on refinances, 2018 to 2023 Bar chart of the median dollar amount of discount points paid by refinance borrowers who paid points: $1,690 in 2018, $1,782 in 2019, $1,667 in 2020, $1,619 in 2021, $2,878 in 2022 and $3,902 in 2023. The share of refinances paying points was 44.3, 38.2, 38.1, 40.8, 60.6 and 67.7 percent. $0$1,000$2,000$3,000$4,0002018: median $1,690 paid by refinances that paid points; 44.3% of refinances paid points$1,690201844.3%2019: median $1,782 paid by refinances that paid points; 38.2% of refinances paid points$1,782201938.2%2020: median $1,667 paid by refinances that paid points; 38.1% of refinances paid points$1,667202038.1%2021: median $1,619 paid by refinances that paid points; 40.8% of refinances paid points$1,619202140.8%2022: median $2,878 paid by refinances that paid points; 60.6% of refinances paid points$2,878202260.6%2023: median $3,902 paid by refinances that paid points; 67.7% of refinances paid points$3,902202367.7%Paid points:
Median discount points paid on refinances, 2018 to 2023 Bars are the median dollars paid by refinances that paid points; the line of percentages under each year is the share of refinances that paid any points. First-lien, closed-end refinances on site-built single-family principal residences, HMDA reporters. Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2023 Mortgage Market Activity and Trends (December 2024), appendix Table A2, checked October 24, 2026.
Show the HMDA points data
YearMedian points paid, refinances that paid pointsMean points paidShare of refinances paying points
2018$1,690$2,34344.3%
2019$1,782$2,46238.2%
2020$1,667$2,30438.1%
2021$1,619$2,35040.8%
2022$2,878$3,86560.6%
2023$3,902$5,00667.7%

Two readings follow, and neither is a forecast. First, with 67.7 percent of 2023 refinances paying points, ask for the zero-point version of the same loan beside any points quote, so you can measure what the points buy. Second, many of those points were paid near a rate peak: Freddie Mac's 30-year average reached 7.79 percent in the week of October 26, 2023, its highest weekly reading since November 2000. If rates later fall far enough to refinance again, any points not yet repaid are simply left behind, which is the case the rule above is built to catch before you sign.

When points lose

Points lose most often on time. A household that expects to move in three years, or that has refinanced twice in five years, is buying a lower rate for a loan it is unlikely to keep long enough to collect on. They also lose when the balance is small: one point on a small loan is cheaper in dollars, but the monthly saving shrinks with it, and the month count to repay can stretch just as long. They lose when the rate reduction on offer is thin, when cash at closing is tight, or when the same cash would do more work reducing the balance itself.

There is a quieter losing case. Points are paid once and are easy to forget, so borrowers compare the points rate against rate ads and headlines instead of against their own zero-point quote from the same hour. A points rate can look impressive next to a competitor's zero-point rate while being the worse deal of the two. The comparison that matters never crosses lenders or days.

The point only has to beat one quote: the zero-point version of your own loan, offered the same day, by the same lender.

A point against the same cash paid toward principal

The month-48 rule compares a point with doing nothing. The fairer rival is the other thing the same cash could do on the same loan: go straight to principal. Prepaid principal earns your loan rate, guaranteed, and unlike a point it is not spent; it stays in your equity, which is counted when you sell or refinance.

Take a $400,000 loan at 7.00 percent on a 30-year term and $4,000 of cash. Spent on one point that cuts the rate to 6.75 percent, the cash buys about $83 a month of interest savings at first. Paid as principal on the 7.00 percent loan, with the payment unchanged, it saves about $23 a month at first and the saving grows as the extra principal compounds. Score each by what you are ahead of doing nothing, remembering that the point's $4,000 is spent while the prepayment's $4,000 is still yours in equity. After 36 months the point is still about $987 short of repaying itself, while the prepayment has saved about $932. After 60 months the point is about $1,033 ahead and the prepayment about $1,671. The point only overtakes the prepayment in month 73, and by month 120 it leads about $6,064 to $4,039.

So on these numbers, a 0.25 cut per point beats prepaying only for a household that will keep the loan more than about six years. A 0.125 cut never catches the prepayment on this loan, not even over the full 30 years; a 0.375 cut overtakes it in month 41 and a 0.50 cut in month 29. The mortgage extra-payment payoff calculator on CalculatorVillage runs the prepayment side on your own balance, and its points calculator handles generic point math; the comparison between the two is the part this page adds.

How to price points before you buy them

Ask for the zero-point quote first, then the same loan with one point, then half a point if it is offered. You are buying a rate reduction, so make the seller state its size and price side by side. By law, CFPB notes, points shown on the disclosure must be connected to a discounted rate. If a Loan Estimate shows points without a rate improvement over the zero-point quote, that is a question to put to the lender in writing before you proceed.

Then divide. Points cost by the monthly saving the points alone create, and compare the month count with your actual stay horizon, not an optimistic one. If the count is comfortably inside the months you are confident you will keep this loan, points can be a reasonable purchase of a lower payment. If the count sits near your horizon, the points are a bet, and you should know you are placing it.

Reading the rate a point buys off two Loan Estimates

You cannot see the price of a rate cut on one Loan Estimate. You need two from the same lender on the same day for the same loan: one at zero points, one with points. Page 1 of each shows the interest rate. Page 2, Section A, Origination Charges, shows the points as a percentage of the loan amount and in dollars. The rate cut per point is the difference between the two rates divided by the points on the second estimate.

Worked from two hypothetical estimates on a $400,000 loan: zero points at 7.000 percent, and 0.75 points ($3,000) at 6.750 percent. The cut is 0.25 of a percentage point for 0.75 points, which is 0.333 per point. By the rule above, that pays back its interest in about 12 divided by 0.333, month 36, and by the payment division in month 45: the payment falls from about $2,661 to about $2,594, a saving of about $67 a month against $3,000. Compare that with a lender whose second estimate shows one full point for the same 6.750 percent: 0.25 per point, month 48 by interest and month 60 by payment. Same rate, a year apart in payback. How a points quote's full-term APR and its cost over a five-year stay can rank it in opposite orders is worked in APR or interest rate for a short stay.

  1. Get the zero-point and the points estimate from the same lender, on the same day, for the same loan amount and term.
  2. Confirm the Section A points line equals the stated percentage of the loan amount.
  3. Divide the rate difference by the points to get the cut per point; 12 divided by that cut is your interest payback month.
  4. Divide the points dollars by the payment difference for the payment-method month, and add the points to the total closing costs before rerunning the whole refinance break-even.
  5. If the points would be financed rather than paid in cash, rerun the payback on the rolled cost, interest included.
  6. Set both months beside the stay you can defend with dates, not the stay you hope for.

Cash or rolled in: the same point costs more inside the loan

Points can be paid two ways, and the break-even math above quietly assumes the cheaper one. Paid in cash at closing, one point on a $360,000 loan costs exactly $3,600, once. Rolled into the loan balance, that same point becomes $363,600 of borrowing, and you pay interest on the point itself for as long as the loan runs. CFPB's points guidance, re-checked October 19, 2026, is unchanged on the underlying facts: one point equals 1 percent of the loan amount, and no rule fixes how much rate a point buys.

Labelled illustration, arithmetic verified: at a hypothetical 6.50 percent on a fresh 30-year term, the $360,000 loan pays about $2,275 a month. The $363,600 loan pays about $2,298 a month, about $23 a month more. Over a seven-year stay, the rolled point has cost about $1,911 in extra payments and the balance still sits about $3,255 higher than the cash case, so the point that cost $3,600 in cash has cost about $5,166 in total by month 84, roughly $1,566 of it interest on the point itself. The monthly saving the point buys does not change between the two cases. Only the price of the point changed.

So run the payback division twice when a quote offers to finance the points: once on the cash price of the point, once on the rolled cost over your actual stay. A point that pays back comfortably in cash can drift past your horizon once its own interest is counted, and a lender credit conversation gets cleaner too, because cash, credit, and rolled points are three different prices for the same rate dial. Whether the points deduct at all, and when, is worked in the refinance closing costs tax guide.

The mirror image of a point, a lender credit that pays your costs through a higher rate, sits on the same dial and is priced month by month in the no-closing-cost refinance guide.

Points on a refinance and the tax return

IRS Publication 936 (2025 edition, checked October 24, 2026) says points paid to refinance are generally deducted ratably over the life of the loan. The exception: if part of the refinance proceeds substantially improves your main home, the share of the points tied to that improvement can be deducted in the year paid. All of this matters only to a household that itemizes.

The rule that matters for break-even is what happens when the loan ends early. Pay off or refinance the mortgage and the publication lets you deduct any remaining unamortized points in that year, with one exception: refinance with the same lender and you cannot deduct the remainder then; you spread it over the new loan instead. On a $3,902 point bill, roughly the 2023 median, spread over 30 years, the yearly deduction is about $130. Refinance with a different lender after three years and about $3,512 becomes deductible that year. That softens a lost point for an itemizer; it does not refund it, because a deduction lowers taxable income rather than the tax bill dollar for dollar. This page is not tax advice. The closing costs tax guide works the rest.

Points when another refinance is possible

The stay horizon for a point is not the years you will live in the house. It is the years you will keep this particular loan, and a loan ends on the first of three events: a sale, a payoff, or another refinance. A point pays for a benefit that arrives a month at a time and stops the day the loan ends, and falling rates are exactly when you would refinance again.

Put numbers on the risk with the payback curve. A point that buys a 0.25 cut has repaid about 50 percent of its cost in interest by month 24 and about 75 percent by month 36. If you would refinance again on a rate drop of a point or more, and you think there is a real chance of that inside three years, refinancing at month 36 would leave about a quarter of the point's cost unrecovered, and the zero-point quote carries no such loss. If you would keep the loan through any rate move, the curve runs its full length and the point repays as the chart shows. This site does not predict rates, and the decision does not need a prediction: it needs an honest answer to whether you would refinance again, and when.

Common questions

How much does one point reduce my rate?

There is no fixed amount. CFPB says the reduction depends on the lender, the loan type, and market conditions. The only reliable figure is the difference between your own zero-point and points quotes from the same lender on the same day.

Are points the same as origination fees?

Both sit in Section A of the Loan Estimate, but they are not the same thing. Points must, by law, be connected to a discounted interest rate. A general origination charge pays for processing the loan and does not have to buy your rate down.

Do points count toward my refinance break-even?

Yes. Points are a true closing cost paid once and never refunded, so they add to the costs your monthly saving has to repay. Test the refinance with the point included and compare against how long you will keep the loan.

Can I buy a fraction of a point?

Yes. CFPB gives examples of 0.5 and 0.125 points. The cost is simply that fraction of 1 percent of your loan amount, so a half point on a $400,000 loan is $2,000.

When do points usually lose?

When the loan ends before the payback month: a move, a sale, or another refinance inside the first few years. They also lose when the rate reduction offered for the point is small, because a small monthly saving stretches the payback month out.

Does it matter if I roll the points into the loan instead of paying cash?

Yes. Rolled in, the point itself borrows money: on a $360,000 loan at a hypothetical 6.50 percent, financing one $3,600 point adds about $23 a month and about $1,566 of interest cost over a seven-year stay, on top of the $3,600. The rate reduction is the same; the price of buying it is not.

Is one point always worth a 0.25 percent rate cut?

No. The quarter-point figure is a rule of thumb, not a rule. The CFPB says the amount a point reduces your rate depends on the specific lender, the kind of loan and the overall mortgage market. Read the actual cut off two same-day Loan Estimates: a 0.25 cut repays in about month 48 in interest saved, a 0.125 cut needs about month 96.

Sources and verification

Educational explanation, not a quote. The rate reduction a point buys is set by your lender on the day of your quote and cannot be known in advance from this page.