Behind on the mortgage: every hardship option compared
If you cannot pay your mortgage, you have 6 main options, and federal rules generally bar the first foreclosure filing until the loan is more than 120 days delinquent (12 CFR 1024.41(f), checked October 2026). The options are forbearance, a repayment plan, a payment deferral (a partial claim on FHA loans), a loan modification, a short sale, or a deed in lieu of foreclosure. The first four keep the house; the last two end the loan without a foreclosure sale. A HUD-approved housing counselor can walk through every option with you for free at (800) 569-4287. Which option fits depends on one question more than any other: is the hardship temporary, or has your income permanently changed?
Worksheet steps (9)
- Call for free help before you pick anything
- The six options in one table
- Choosing by the shape of the hardship
- Keeping the house: how the four retention tools differ in practice
- Three payments behind: the repayment plan and the deferral on the same loan
- Leaving on your own terms: short sale and deed in lieu
- What your servicer has to do, and by when
- Why a refinance rarely rescues a loan that is already behind
- Taking the first short-term offer and stopping there
Call for free help before you pick anything
The single most useful step costs nothing. HUD lists a national line for finding a HUD-approved housing counselor, (800) 569-4287, on its HUD contact page, next to its online HUD housing counselor search (both checked October 22, 2026). The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says HUD-approved agencies provide foreclosure prevention counseling free of charge, and it also points homeowners to the HOPE Hotline at (888) 995-4673, which it describes as open around the clock. A counselor can read your servicer's letters with you, help assemble the application, and tell you how foreclosure works in your state, which matters because the process and your liability after a sale are set by state law, not by any single federal rule.
The CFPB is just as direct about the other side of that coin. Its page on options when you cannot pay your mortgage says help is available at no cost from your servicer or a HUD-approved agency, and it warns against paying anyone upfront to save your home. A company that asks for a fee before doing anything, tells you to stop talking to your servicer, or promises a specific result is not offering anything a free counselor cannot. If papers from a court or a trustee have already arrived, the CFPB suggests talking with an attorney, and this page is not a substitute for one.
One more ground rule. Nothing here suggests skipping a payment to become eligible for something. Several options below are only offered once a loan is already behind, but that describes how servicers sort cases, not a strategy. Late payments carry late fees under your note, a 60-day or worse delinquency is the kind of mortgage history Fannie Mae's lending rules screen for, and every missed month shortens the runway before the 120-day line. If you can still pay, even in part, tell your servicer about the hardship now and ask in writing how it treats a short payment, since policies differ and can change when a loan is sold.
The six options in one table
The CFPB lists the same family of tools servicers may make available: refinance, loan modification, repayment plan, forbearance, short sale, and deed in lieu of foreclosure. The table below adds what each one actually does to your balance and your future borrowing. Program rules are taken from the Fannie Mae Servicing Guide because it publishes them in full; FHA, VA, USDA, Freddie Mac and privately held loans follow their own rulebooks, and your servicer applies whichever one owns or insures your loan. Federal law does not require a servicer to offer any particular option: 12 CFR 1024.41(a) states that nothing in that section "imposes a duty on a servicer to provide any borrower with any specific loss mitigation option." What the law does require is a fair process, covered further down.
| Option | What it does | What you owe afterward | What the official rules say about cost and later borrowing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forbearance | Pauses or reduces payments for a set period. Fannie Mae plans run in increments of no more than 3 months, up to 12 months in total, unless Fannie Mae approves more (D2-3.2-01). | Everything skipped or reduced. The CFPB says it may be repaid in one lump sum, through higher payments, by adding payments at the end of the loan, or with a new loan. | The CFPB says interest on paused or reduced amounts could continue to add up until repaid. When a Fannie Mae plan ends, the loan must be reinstated, moved into another workout, paid off, or referred to foreclosure. |
| Repayment plan | Keeps the regular payment and adds a slice of the past-due amount each month until the loan is current. | The arrears, spread over the plan. Nothing is added to the balance. | Fannie Mae caps the total plan payment at 150% of the full contractual payment, and plans over 12 months need its written approval (D2-3.2-02). |
| Payment deferral (conventional) or partial claim (FHA) | Moves missed principal and interest out of the monthly payment. Fannie Mae defers 2 to 6 months of past-due P&I into a separate balance (D2-3.2-04). On FHA loans, HUD pays a partial claim and you sign a subordinate mortgage in HUD's favor (24 CFR 203.371). | The deferred balance, in a lump sum later. Fannie Mae's deferred amount is non-interest-bearing and comes due at maturity, or earlier on sale, transfer, refinance, or payoff. The FHA amount is a second lien that HUD's payoff process collects. | Your monthly payment returns to the old amount. Fannie Mae limits deferrals to 12 months of P&I over the life of the loan, requires the hardship to be resolved, and offers it only when you cannot reinstate or afford a repayment plan. |
| Loan modification | Rewrites the loan terms. The CFPB says that can mean a longer term, a lower rate, or a reduced principal balance. Fannie Mae's Flex Modification produces a fixed-rate loan after a trial period (D2-3.2-06). | A new, usually larger, balance: Fannie Mae measures the modified loan with the arrears capitalized into it. | The CFPB warns that if you still cannot make the modified payment, you may lose the home. Fannie Mae will not evaluate a loan already modified three or more times. |
| Short sale | You sell the home for less than the payoff, with the servicer's approval, and the sale proceeds settle the loan. | Possibly a deficiency (the shortfall). Fannie Mae requires its servicers to waive it for loans without mortgage insurance, or where the insurer has delegated that authority (D2-3.3-01). | The servicer may first ask for a cash contribution. For a new Fannie Mae loan later, the waiting period is 4 years, or 2 with documented extenuating circumstances (Selling Guide B3-5.3-07). |
| Deed in lieu (Fannie Mae calls it a Mortgage Release) | You sign the property over to the lender instead of going through a foreclosure sale. Title must be clear, so other liens have to be released first. | Fannie Mae requires a deficiency waiver after it accepts the deed, on the same mortgage insurance conditions as a short sale (D2-3.3-02). | Same 4-year (or 2-year) waiting period as a short sale for a new Fannie Mae loan. A completed foreclosure, by contrast, carries 7 years. |
Choosing by the shape of the hardship
Most of the choice follows from two facts you can state today: whether the income problem is over or ongoing, and how many payments you have missed. Use the rules below as a way to frame the conversation with your servicer and counselor, not as a prediction of what any servicer will approve.
- Hardship ahead but not yet behind (a layoff notice, a medical leave starting): call the servicer now. Fannie Mae's forbearance eligibility list asks for an eligible hardship, not a missed payment, and Fannie Mae's Flex Modification has an imminent-default path for borrowers who are still current.
- Hardship over, a month or two behind, some room in the budget: a repayment plan clears the arrears without changing the loan, if one and a half payments a month is affordable.
- Hardship over, income back to normal, but neither a lump sum nor a repayment plan is affordable: a payment deferral or FHA partial claim returns you to the old payment and parks the arrears until sale, payoff or another event the program names; a conventional deferral comes due on a refinance, while an FHA partial claim can stay in place behind an FHA streamline.
- Income permanently lower: a modification is the tool built for this, since forbearance and deferral only move the missed money around.
- No affordable payment on any terms, or a planned move anyway: compare a short sale and a deed in lieu against foreclosure on deficiency, later-borrowing waits, and how much time each gives you to relocate.
- Unsure which bucket you are in: complete the full application anyway, because a complete application is what triggers the evaluation for every option and the foreclosure protections described in the servicer-deadline section below.
Keeping the house: how the four retention tools differ in practice
Forbearance is a bridge, not a solution, and the Fannie Mae rules make that plain. Its plans must reduce or suspend the payment, they are granted a few months at a time, and when the plan ends one of four things must happen: you pay what is owed, you move into another workout option, the loan is paid off, or it goes to foreclosure referral. Fannie Mae requires its servicers to begin reaching out no later than 30 days before any forbearance term expires. Treat that call as the real decision point. Before it comes, know whether your income is back, and how much of the skipped amount you could repay each month.
A repayment plan suits a short, finished hardship with a modest amount behind. It is the least invasive tool because the loan itself does not change. The catch is arithmetic: the 150% ceiling means the most a Fannie Mae plan can add is half of one payment each month, so every missed payment takes two months of the plan to clear. A household that fell four payments behind faces eight months of payments at one and a half times the usual amount. If that budget does not work on paper, it will not work in month five.
A payment deferral exists for the household whose income has recovered but who cannot produce a lump sum. Under Fannie Mae's version, the borrower must have resolved the hardship, be able to make the full monthly payment again, and be unable to reinstate the loan or afford a repayment plan, so it is a fallback after a repayment plan rather than a free alternative to one. The loan must also be at least 12 months old, and it must be at least two and no more than six months delinquent when evaluated. The deferred amount sits at the back of the loan without interest. That is generous, but it is not forgiveness: the full amount is due the day you sell or refinance. FHA's partial claim works on a similar principle with a different structure. HUD's regulation at 24 CFR 203.371 has the borrower sign a mortgage in HUD's favor for the claim amount, so a second lien appears on your title. HUD runs a separate payoff process for partial claims through its single family servicing office; under HUD Mortgagee Letters 2025-12 and 2025-21 the claim is a zero-interest subordinate note, with a $1,000 minimum and a cap of 30 percent of the loan's unpaid principal balance, and HUD will subordinate it to an FHA streamline refinance. Ask your servicer for the exact figures on your loan, and see what happens when forbearance ends for the repayment events.
A modification is the tool for a permanent change, such as a lower salary, a lost second income, or a divorce. It can lower the payment by stretching the term or cutting the rate, and Fannie Mae's Flex Modification can also be offered before you fall behind if your servicer determines the payment is in imminent default. You typically make trial payments first. The cost is that the arrears usually join the balance, so you may owe more than before the hardship, and a longer term means more total interest. Ask the servicer for the new balance, rate, term, and payment in writing, and compare the old and new loans across the years you expect to stay, the same way this site compares any refinance against keeping your loan.
Three payments behind: the repayment plan and the deferral on the same loan
Illustration only, with every input stated and the rate labelled an illustration, not a market quote. A $300,000 30-year fixed loan at 6.50% has a principal and interest payment of $1,896 a month (taxes, insurance and late fees are left out to keep the arithmetic clear). Four years in, the balance is about $285,179. A job loss leads to three missed payments, so $5,688 of principal and interest is past due. Under a Fannie Mae repayment plan capped at 150% of the contractual payment, the most the monthly bill can rise to is $2,844, which adds $948 a month toward the arrears; at that pace the $5,688 clears in exactly 6 months. Had the household missed four payments ($7,584), the same ceiling would stretch the plan to 8 months. If the servicer finds that the household cannot afford that plan or reinstate, which is a Fannie Mae condition for a deferral, the payment instead stays at $1,896 from the first month back, and the $5,688 becomes a non-interest-bearing balance due at maturity or earlier on a sale, transfer, refinance or payoff. If this owner refinances three years later, the new loan has to cover the remaining principal plus that $5,688, so the deferral that helped in the hard year adds $5,688 to the payoff figure a lender works from. What comes due at a later refinance is worked in the partial claim and deferral payoff guide.
Leaving on your own terms: short sale and deed in lieu
Sometimes the honest answer is that no payment the household can afford keeps this house. The two liquidation options exist so that answer does not have to end in a foreclosure sale. A short sale lets you sell for what the market will pay, with the servicer accepting the proceeds as settlement. A deed in lieu hands the property back directly. Both usually take longer than people expect, because the servicer must value the property, clear any second liens, and approve the terms, and both require you to keep talking to the servicer while the clock runs.
The money questions are the deficiency and the contribution. On a Fannie Mae loan, a successful short sale or Mortgage Release must come with a release from any deficiency, provided the loan has no mortgage insurance or the insurer has delegated that decision to Fannie Mae. If mortgage insurance is involved and that delegation does not exist, the insurer has a say, and the release is not automatic. For short sales, Fannie Mae tells its servicers to start by requesting a cash contribution of the greater of 20% of your non-retirement cash reserves or four times the monthly payment including taxes and insurance, rounded to the nearest $100 and capped at the deficiency. That is a starting request, not a fixed price; servicers can approve less where it is warranted. Loans owned by other investors follow other rules, and state law decides whether a lender can pursue a deficiency at all after foreclosure, which is why the Closing Disclosure carries a Liability after Foreclosure statement that tells you to consult an attorney.
The later-borrowing gap is the other real difference. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide sets a 4-year wait after a short sale or deed in lieu before a new loan it will buy, cut to 2 years with documented extenuating circumstances. After a completed foreclosure the standard wait is 7 years, with a 3-year path for documented extenuating circumstances that carries extra limits until year 7. The guide treats short sale and preforeclosure sale as the same term. Other programs set their own periods, so this is one useful benchmark rather than the universal rule.
What your servicer has to do, and by when
Regulation X, the federal mortgage servicing rule, sets the process every covered servicer follows. Early intervention comes first. Under 12 CFR 1024.39 (checked October 2026), a servicer "shall establish or make good faith efforts to establish live contact with a delinquent borrower no later than the 36th day of a borrower's delinquency," and must send a written notice "no later than the 45th day of the borrower's delinquency." That written notice must include the web address for the CFPB or HUD list of housing counselors and the HUD toll-free number, so the counselor route is built into the letter you receive.
Once you apply, 12 CFR 1024.41 takes over. If the application arrives 45 days or more before a foreclosure sale, the servicer must tell you in writing "within 5 days (excluding legal public holidays, Saturdays, and Sundays)" whether it is complete or incomplete, and list what is missing. If a complete application arrives "more than 37 days before a foreclosure sale," the servicer must evaluate you "for all loss mitigation options available" and send its decision "within 30 days." Any denial of a modification must state the specific reasons. Where the complete application came in 90 days or more before a sale, or during the pre-foreclosure period, you can appeal a modification denial within 14 days of the decision, the appeal must be reviewed by different staff, and the servicer has 30 days to answer.
The foreclosure guardrails sit in the same section. A servicer "shall not make the first notice or filing required by applicable law for any judicial or non-judicial foreclosure process" unless the loan "is more than 120 days delinquent," apart from due-on-sale and other-lienholder cases. A complete application submitted before that first filing blocks the filing until you are found ineligible and any appeal is done, you reject every offer, or you fail an agreed plan. One submitted after the filing but more than 37 days before a sale blocks the sale on the same conditions. Offers come with a response window: you get at least 14 days to accept or reject when the complete application came in 90 days or more before a sale, and at least 7 days when it came in between 90 and 38 days out.
Know the limits of these rules too. Under 12 CFR 1024.30, the early intervention and loss mitigation procedures apply only to a loan secured by your principal residence, and small servicers are exempt from most of them, though they still cannot make the first foreclosure filing before the 120-day mark or foreclose while you perform under an agreed plan. State foreclosure law adds its own notices, mediation programs, and timelines on top, and those vary widely. A housing counselor or an attorney in your state can tell you which apply. The mortgage help hub collects related guides on these rules as they are published.
Why a refinance rarely rescues a loan that is already behind
Refinancing appears on the CFPB's list of options, and early in a hardship, while every payment is still on time, it can be a real one: a lower payment or a longer term on a new loan might be enough. Once payments are missed, the door narrows quickly, and the rules show why. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide section on previous mortgage payment history says the borrower's existing mortgage must be current on the application date, which it defines as no more than 45 days since the last paid installment date. It also treats any 60-, 90-, 120- or 150-day delinquency reported in the prior 12 months as excessive, which makes the new loan ineligible for sale to Fannie Mae. FHA and other programs have their own payment-history tests, and our FHA streamline guide covers the one that applies to FHA-to-FHA refinances. A household that filed Chapter 13 to stop a foreclosure meets one more layer, a 12-month plan record and the trustee's or court's consent, which our guide to refinancing during a Chapter 13 plan tables by loan program.
Even after recovery, the hardship tools change the refinance math. A Fannie Mae deferred balance comes due when the loan is refinanced, so a refinance has to raise that amount too. An FHA partial claim is a second lien that the title company has to account for at closing, usually through HUD's payoff process. A modification may have added arrears to the balance. Before you price any refinance after a workout, get the full payoff, including deferred or subordinate amounts, and run the comparison in the refinance calculator on the real figure. If credit damage is the obstacle, our guide on refinancing with bad credit explains what lenders review.
Taking the first short-term offer and stopping there
Regulation X lets a servicer offer a short-term forbearance or repayment plan on the strength of an incomplete application. That is legitimate and often helpful, but it is not a full review. Under 12 CFR 1024.41(c)(2)(iii), the servicer must then send you a written notice that says other options may be available and that you can still submit a complete application to be evaluated for all of them, whether or not you accept the short-term plan. Borrowers who accept a three-month forbearance and never finish the application can arrive at the end of it with nothing lined up and a large balance due. If your hardship might outlast the plan, finish the full application while the plan is running, keep copies of everything you send, and note the date the servicer confirms it is complete. To see what each exit costs once the pause ends, our walk-through of what happens when forbearance ends prices a lump sum, a repayment plan, a deferral and a modification on one loan.
Common questions
What happens when a mortgage forbearance ends?
The skipped or reduced amounts are still owed. The CFPB describes the repayment routes as a lump sum when payments restart, higher payments for a period, extra payments added to the end of the loan, or a new loan, and notes that interest on the paused amounts could keep adding up. Under the Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, the servicer must start contacting you at least 30 days before the plan ends to sort out which route applies.
What is a repayment plan on a mortgage?
The CFPB defines it as an agreement with your lender to make up missed payments by paying more each month. On a Fannie Mae loan the total monthly plan payment cannot exceed 150% of your normal payment, and a plan longer than 12 months needs Fannie Mae's written approval, so the size of the arrears sets how long the plan runs.
What is a mortgage loan modification?
It is a permanent change to your loan terms, such as a longer repayment period, a lower rate, or a reduced principal balance, used to bring the payment to a level you can manage. The CFPB cautions that if you still cannot make the modified payment you may lose the home, and suggests talking with a HUD-approved housing counselor before you accept one.
Is help from a HUD-approved housing counselor free?
Yes for foreclosure prevention counseling, according to the CFPB. You can reach the HUD counselor line at (800) 569-4287, search online through the HUD contact page, or call the HOPE Hotline at (888) 995-4673. Your servicer's 45-day delinquency notice must also list the HUD number and counselor website.
Can my servicer start foreclosure while my application for help is being reviewed?
Under 12 CFR 1024.41, the first foreclosure filing generally cannot happen until the loan is more than 120 days delinquent, and a complete application submitted before that filing blocks it until the review, any appeal, and your response are finished. After a filing, a complete application received more than 37 days before a sale blocks the sale on similar terms. State law may add more protection, so check with a counselor or attorney where you live.
Can I refinance if I am already behind on my mortgage?
Usually not on a conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae: its Selling Guide requires the existing mortgage to be current, meaning no more than 45 days since the last paid installment, and treats any 60-day or worse delinquency in the past 12 months as disqualifying. The window for a refinance is before payments are missed; after that, the servicer's hardship options are the route.
Sources and verification
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, If I can't pay my mortgage loan, what are my options?: The list of options a servicer may offer (refinance, modification, repayment plan, forbearance, short sale, deed in lieu), free help from servicers and HUD-approved agencies, the warning against paying upfront for help, and the HOPE Hotline number. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is forbearance?: Definition of forbearance, the repayment routes after it ends, and the statement that interest on paused or reduced amounts could continue to add up. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a repayment plan on a mortgage?: Definition of a repayment plan and its use after forbearance. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a mortgage loan modification?: What a modification can change and the caution that a borrower who cannot make the modified payment may lose the home. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a HUD-approved housing counseling agency?: Foreclosure prevention counseling is free of charge; HOPE Hotline hours. Checked October 22, 2026.
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Contact HUD: The housing counselor search link and the counselor phone line, (800) 569-4287. Checked October 22, 2026.
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Housing counselor search: HUD's online search for HUD-approved housing counseling agencies, linked from the HUD contact page. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 12 CFR 1024.39, Early intervention requirements: Live contact by the 36th day of delinquency, written notice by the 45th day, and the required HUD counselor information in that notice. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 12 CFR 1024.41, Loss mitigation procedures: No duty to offer a specific option; 5-day acknowledgment; 30-day evaluation of complete applications received more than 37 days before a sale; 14 and 7 day response windows; the 120-day pre-foreclosure rule and dual-tracking limits; appeal rights; short-term options on incomplete applications. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 12 CFR 1024.30, Scope: Principal-residence limit and the small servicer exemption. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.2-01 Forbearance Plan: Plan increments of no more than 3 months, 12-month cumulative limit, outreach 30 days before expiry, and the outcomes required when a plan ends. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.2-02 Repayment Plan: 150% payment ceiling and written approval for plans over 12 months. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.2-04 Payment Deferral: Eligibility (hardship resolved, loan at least 12 months old, 2 to 6 months delinquent), the non-interest-bearing deferred balance and when it is due, and the 12-month lifetime cap. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.2-06 Fannie Mae Flex Modification: Fixed-rate result, trial period plan, capitalized arrearages, imminent-default path, and the three-prior-modification limit. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.3-01 Fannie Mae Short Sale: Deficiency waiver conditions and the initial cash contribution request. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, D2-3.3-02 Mortgage Release (deed-in-lieu of foreclosure): Clear title requirement and the deficiency waiver after the deed is accepted. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-5.3-07 Significant Derogatory Credit Events: Waiting periods: 7 years after foreclosure (3 with extenuating circumstances), 4 years after a deed in lieu or preforeclosure sale (2 with extenuating circumstances). Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-5.3-03 Previous Mortgage Payment History: Existing mortgage must be current (no more than 45 days since last paid installment) and the 12-month excessive-delinquency test. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 24 CFR 203.371, Partial claim: The borrower executes a mortgage in HUD's favor for the partial claim amount. Checked October 22, 2026.
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Single Family Servicing: HUD's process for partial claim payoff requests. Checked October 22, 2026.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-12, Tightening and Expediting Implementation of the New Permanent Loss Mitigation Options: Partial claim minimum of $1,000 and the 30 percent maximum of unpaid principal balance. Checked October 22, 2026.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-21, Updates to Mortgagee Letter 2025-12: Zero-interest subordinate partial claim note, subordination to a streamline refinance, and the 24-month limit on another permanent retention option. Checked October 22, 2026.
This page compares options at the level of published rules; it is educational, not legal or financial advice, and it is not a loan offer. Program detail comes mainly from the Fannie Mae Servicing and Selling Guides because they publish their rules in full; FHA, VA, USDA, Freddie Mac and portfolio loans use different limits, and FHA partial claim terms are those in HUD Mortgagee Letters 2025-12 and 2025-21, which HUD may update. No servicer is required to offer any specific option. Foreclosure procedure, mediation programs and deficiency liability are set by state law and vary widely, and credit-score effects are not covered because the official sources checked do not state them. The worked example uses an illustration rate and leaves out taxes, insurance and fees. All rules were checked October 22, 2026.