Mortgage hardship and relief

FHA partial claim and payment deferral: what is repaid when you refinance

An FHA partial claim stays interest-free until the first mortgage is paid off, and an FHA streamline is the only refinance where HUD agrees to subordinate it instead. Any other refinance repays the lien at closing, as it does a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac deferral. On a $17,400 claim, holding rate and closing costs equal, that moves break-even from month 22 to as late as month 51.

Worksheet steps (11)
  1. What the second balance is, in the owners' own words
  2. When each balance becomes payable
  3. Paying a partial claim early is allowed, but it saves no interest
  4. How HUD says to find and pay a partial claim
  5. What can be inside the claim, so you can sanity-check the payoff figure
  6. Four ways the closing can go, depending on the new loan
  7. Why a hardship lien and a deferred balance are classified differently
  8. Same rate, same costs: what paying off the $17,400 changes
  9. When the 80% cap binds: the cash a lien payoff pulls in
  10. Paying off the lien turns $17,400 of free money into 6.75% debt
  11. What changes if the balance is a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac deferral

What the second balance is, in the owners' own words

Two different things get called a deferral. They behave alike at the closing table and differ almost everywhere else, so the first job is to know which one is on your loan. If the hardship that created the balance is not behind you yet, the servicer options are in the mortgage help hub, and the exits from a forbearance plan are priced in our forbearance guide.

An FHA partial claim is a loan from HUD. After a hardship, the servicer advances the missed payments, FHA reimburses the servicer, and the borrower signs a note and a second mortgage in HUD's favor. HUD's Handbook 4000.1, as updated by Mortgagee Letter 2025-06 (effective February 2, 2026; read October 23, 2026), requires the partial claim to be secured by a zero-interest note and a subordinate mortgage that the borrower signs in HUD's favor, and adds that "No interest will accrue on the Partial Claim." It is capped: the total of all partial claims and payment supplements "must not exceed 30 percent of the Mortgage's unpaid principal balance, as of the date of Default at the time of payment of the initial Partial Claim."

A Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac payment deferral is not a lien at all. The servicer moves the missed principal and interest into a separate, non-interest-bearing balance on the same loan. Fannie Mae's Servicing Guide D2-3.2-04 (08/13/2025) says the deferred amount is "due and payable at maturity of the mortgage loan, or earlier upon the sale or transfer of the property," and also on "refinance of the mortgage loan, or payoff of the interest-bearing UPB." Freddie Mac's Guide Bulletin 2023-8 (March 29, 2023) uses the same trigger list for its payment deferral.

Same word, different object. The HUD balance sits behind your mortgage as its own recorded lien with its own payoff process. The Fannie or Freddie balance rides inside the servicer's payoff statement. That difference decides who you call, who must be paid at closing, and what a title company will find.

When each balance becomes payable

Nothing is owed monthly on any of these balances, which is why people forget them. The question at refinance time is simply which events switch them on. The table lines up the triggers as each owner states them.

Events that make the set-aside balance payable (rule text read October 23, 2026)
WorkoutInterestPayable atRefinance-specific wording
FHA partial claim (HUD lien)None; "No interest will accrue"Maturity, sale or transfer, assumption, payoff of the mortgage, or termination of FHA insurance if the note says so (Handbook 4000.1 via ML 2025-06)Payoff of the mortgage triggers it, "except that HUD will agree to subordinate the Partial Claim Note to a Streamline Refinance"
Fannie Mae payment deferralNone (non-interest-bearing balance)Maturity, sale or transfer, refinance, or payoff of the interest-bearing balance (Servicing Guide D2-3.2-04, 08/13/2025)Refinance is named as a trigger
Freddie Mac payment deferralNone (non-interest-bearing balance)Maturity, sale or transfer, refinance or payoff of the interest-bearing balance (Guide Bulletin 2023-8)Refinance is named as a trigger
Fannie Mae Flex Modification principal forbearanceNone; "Interest must not accrue on any principal forbearance"Maturity of the modification, sale or transfer, refinance, or payoff of the interest-bearing balance (Servicing Guide F-1-27, 08/13/2025)Refinance is named as a trigger

Paying a partial claim early is allowed, but it saves no interest

HUD adds one sentence worth keeping: it "does not prohibit partial or total payment on the Partial Claim at any time prior to the due date for the Partial Claim." You may pay it early. Whether you should is a separate question, and the worked example below puts numbers on it.

How HUD says to find and pay a partial claim

The practical trouble is that the lien is easy to miss. In FHA INFO 2025-02 (January 9, 2025), HUD says the point of its proposed payoff-statement changes is that "borrowers, closing agents, attorneys, and title agents are aware of the partial claim subordinate lien amount owed on the mortgage loan," and ties the goal to preventing "potential challenges related to the subordinate lien for those refinancing their mortgage or selling their home." In other words, HUD itself treats an unnoticed second lien at closing as a known problem.

The same notice is explicit about status: "this draft is not official departmental policy and cannot be used in connection with any FHA-insured mortgage until finalized. FHA's existing policies remain in effect until amended." We searched HUD's mortgagee letter listings on October 23, 2026 and found no finalized version of the payoff-statement letter, so the procedure below is the one HUD publishes on its servicing pages today, not the draft's.

  1. Identify the case. HUD accepts "only ONE case number per request," so each FHA case number gets its own request. Find the FHA case number on the original deed of trust, the partial claim note or the closing papers from the loan that created the claim.
  2. Make the request through HUD's SMART Integrated Portal. HUD's single family servicing page says "Borrowers, Lenders, and third parties with authorization" can set up accounts to get documents online. HUD's servicing contractors page says payoff and subordination checklist requests can be made through the portal and describes the turnaround as "often with a very short turnaround." HUD publishes no guaranteed number of days, so build slack into the closing date.
  3. If you email instead, HUD asks you to include "Partial Claim" in the subject line. The FHA Resource Center takes questions about partial claims, subordination and releases at 1-800-CALLFHA (1-800-225-5342), 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM Eastern on non-federal-holiday weekdays.
  4. Get the payoff letter before the closing date is set. The letter has to travel with the funds. HUD's instruction for mailed payments is that "A copy of the payoff letter must be included with the funds."
  5. Pay it the way HUD accepts. Online payment through Pay.gov is the preferred method, and HUD describes a form for title companies, attorneys, bankruptcy trustees and borrowers. By mail, the payment must be "in the form of a cashier's check, escrow check or certified funds," payable to HUD. HUD states that it does not accept wire transfers for HUD-held lien payoffs, and it warns that a payoff statement showing wiring instructions is fraudulent, with the FHA Resource Center as the number to call. If a closing agent proposes wiring a partial claim payoff, stop and verify first.

What can be inside the claim, so you can sanity-check the payoff figure

The claim is built from arrears, so its contents are narrower than people expect. Under Handbook 4000.1 as revised by Mortgagee Letter 2025-06, a partial claim has to fully reinstate the delinquent mortgage. The servicer may add one extra monthly payment to the arrearage, to cover the time the borrower takes to return signed documents, and the Handbook says "No other fees or costs may be included in the Partial Claim." The servicer must run an escrow analysis so that the missed payments in the claim reflect the escrow actually required. The minimum claim is $1,000, with an exception for claims tied to a presidentially declared major disaster.

Two consequences follow for anyone holding a payoff figure. Because no interest accrues, a payoff that exceeds the principal on your signed note is a question for HUD, not a number to accept. And the 30 percent ceiling is measured on the unpaid principal balance on the date of default, a figure that stays fixed for the life of the mortgage, so a claim that looks large against today's balance may still sit well inside it.

HUD has a sibling instrument, the payment supplement, with its own promissory note, agreement and subordinate mortgage. It counts toward the same 30 percent ceiling with any partial claims, and HUD's contractor page lists "Partial Claim and Payment Supplement Payoff Requests" together. If your hardship file mentions a supplement, request both payoffs.

Four ways the closing can go, depending on the new loan

What happens to the lien depends on what the new loan is. The routes below are the ones the published rules actually address.

Partial claim at a refinance or sale, by route (Handbook 4000.1 via ML 2025-06 and the August 12, 2026 redline; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, 10/08/2025; read October 23, 2026)
RouteWhat happens to the HUD lienWhat to check
FHA streamline refinanceHUD "will agree to subordinate the Partial Claim Note to a Streamline Refinance." The Handbook says existing subordinate financing "must be resubordinated to the Streamline Refinance," and adds that there is no maximum combined loan-to-value ratio.The subordination request for a HUD-held lien goes to HUD, not just to the first-mortgage servicer. Ask the lender who files it and when.
Conventional refinance (Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan)The lien is paid off, because payoff of the first mortgage is a trigger. If the lien is left in place instead, Fannie Mae requires that existing liens be "clearly subordinate to the new refinance mortgage," and the HUD rule names the streamline as the case where it agrees to subordinate.Fannie Mae limited cash-out allows paying off a subordinate lien only if it was "used to purchase the property." A hardship lien was not, so expect the lender to ask how the loan is classified (see below).
Sale of the homeSale or transfer makes the claim payable, so it comes out of the proceeds. The pre-foreclosure sale rules in the same Handbook show the same expectation: "the entire outstanding Partial Claim amount must be paid" when net sale proceeds are calculated, with funds remitted to the loan servicing contractor that HUD uses.Add the partial claim to the payoff line in your net-proceeds estimate. See the sell-or-stay guide.
Assumption by a buyer or a transferThe partial claim becomes payable on assumption or transfer, except for non-borrowers who acquired title through an exempted transfer.Check the exemption with HUD before assuming a payment is waived. The assumption guide covers the loan side.

Why a hardship lien and a deferred balance are classified differently

Two cautions about the conventional row. First, the cash-out classification in the conventional row comes from reading Fannie Mae's rule text literally, plus a March 30, 2023 Fannie Mae FAQ on a related situation. That FAQ says that "if a second lien is in place that was used to resolve outstanding amounts/missed payments from a COVID-19-related forbearance, the transaction will be considered a cash-out refinance because the second lien was not used to purchase the property." The FAQ is about COVID-era liens, and a lender may read a partial claim differently, so get the classification in writing from the lender before you rely on a limited cash-out price.

Second, the same Selling Guide section is friendlier to deferred balances. It lists "a deferred balance resulting from completion of a prior loss mitigation solution" among the amounts a limited cash-out refinance may pay off, and the FAQ's fourth answer confirms that a deferred balance on the payoff statement "can be included in the payoff amount on a limited cash-out refinance transaction." So a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac deferral and an FHA partial claim are treated differently by the same buyer of loans, which is another reason to know which you have.

Same rate, same costs: what paying off the $17,400 changes

One FHA borrower, three ways to refinance, with every input stated. The rate is held equal across all three refinance columns, and so are the closing costs, so the only thing that differs is what happens to the lien. The 6.75% rate is an illustration, not a quote, and sits below the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey 30-year average of 7.24% for the week ending October 29, 2026 (checked November 1, 2026 at freddiemac.com/pmms); it describes a borrower who would actually need to qualify for it.

The loan is a $302,000 FHA balance at 7.50% with 28 years (336 months) remaining, so principal and interest is $2,153. A $17,400 partial claim sits behind it from a 2024 hardship, about 5.8% of the balance. The home is worth $390,000, and the borrower expects to stay five years. Closing costs are $4,100, paid in cash.

One borrower, equal rate and costs, four paths over a 5-year stay (principal and interest only; whole dollars)
Keep the current loanFHA streamline, lien stays subordinatedConventional, payoff read as cash-outConventional, payoff read as limited cash-out
New first-lien balance$302,000 (28 years left)$302,000, new 30-year term$312,000 (80% cap), 30-year term$319,400, 30-year term
Rate7.50%6.75%6.75%6.75%
Closing costs, paid in cashNone$4,100$4,100$4,100
Extra cash to cover the lien and stay under the capNoneNone$7,400None (loan is 81.9% of value)
Monthly principal and interest$2,153$1,959$2,024$2,072
Monthly saving against todayNone$194$129$81
Break-even on the $4,100Not applicableMonth 22Month 32Month 51
Partial claim still owed at month 60$17,400$17,400None, paid at closingNone, paid at closing
Mortgage balance at month 60$282,754$283,505$292,892$299,839
Cash paid plus debt owed at month 60$429,326$422,531$425,810$428,236

When the 80% cap binds: the cash a lien payoff pulls in

The two conventional columns are two readings of the same payoff, per the caution above. The lien payoff added to the $302,000 balance makes a $319,400 loan, 81.9% of the $390,000 value. Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix (dated August 5, 2026) shows a maximum of 80% for a one-unit principal residence cash-out refinance under Desktop Underwriter, against 97% for limited cash-out on the same property. If the payoff is read as cash-out, the loan is capped at $312,000 and the borrower brings $7,400 to the table on top of the $4,100 of costs. If it is read as limited cash-out, the cap does not bind and the loan is the full $319,400.

The cash need moves with the appraised value. At a $319,400 payoff-plus-balance and an 80% cap:

Extra cash needed to keep a $319,400 loan inside an 80% cap (closing costs not included)
Appraised value80% of valueExtra cash needed
$380,000$304,000$15,400
$390,000$312,000$7,400
$400,000$320,000None
$410,000$328,000None

Paying off the lien turns $17,400 of free money into 6.75% debt

With rate and costs identical, the streamline still wins: break-even in month 22 against month 32 or 51, and $6,795 ahead of doing nothing at month 60, against $3,516 and $1,089 for the two conventional readings (cash paid plus debt owed, so the lien counts on both sides). The streamline keeps the claim at zero interest. Each conventional column converts it into a balance that charges 6.75%: $97.88 of interest in the first month alone ($17,400 times 6.75% divided by 12), or about $113 a month of added payment over 30 years. That is the gap between the streamline's $1,959 and the limited cash-out column's $2,072.

The cash-out column has a lower payment than the limited cash-out column only because the borrower put $7,400 of cash in to reduce the loan. That cash is not a fee; it is principal paid down, which is why its five-year position is better than the last column even though its break-even month is later than the streamline's. Compare the columns on both measures, not on break-even month alone.

The early-payoff question has the same answer. A partial claim costs nothing to carry, so paying it down early earns nothing before it is due; each dollar sent to HUD could instead reduce a mortgage charging 7.50%. Unless you are selling, refinancing out of the lien, or want the second recorded lien released, the arithmetic usually favors paying the interest-bearing loan first. Your lender and a HUD-approved housing counselor can confirm what applies to your note.

The generic method behind the break-even row is in our break-even guide, and the streamline's own tests, such as the combined-rate and mortgage insurance test, are in the FHA streamline guide. Neither is changed by the lien; the lien changes who is paid at closing and what the leftover balance costs.

What changes if the balance is a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac deferral

With a deferral there is no recorded lien and no separate agency to pay. The deferred amount appears on the servicer's payoff statement, and the new lender pays it as part of the payoff. Fannie Mae's March 30, 2023 FAQ answers the exact question: "If the lender discovers a deferred balance on the subject mortgage payoff statement, is the loan eligible for sale to Fannie Mae? Yes." Because the balance "represents an amount necessary to pay off the existing first mortgage loan," it may be included on a limited cash-out refinance under Selling Guide B2-1.3-02.

The break-even arithmetic is the same trap as in the HUD example, with a different lever. The deferred amount was interest-free, and after the refinance it is interest-bearing. Take a borrower with a $9,000 deferral (six paused principal-and-interest payments of $1,500 each, a stated illustration) and a $280,000 interest-bearing balance at 7.25% with 27 years and 6 months (330 months) left, so the payment is $1,960. An illustrated 30-year refinance at 6.50% on $289,000, the interest-bearing balance plus the deferral, costs $1,827 a month: a $134 saving. On the $280,000 alone the new payment would be $1,770, a $190 saving. The deferral therefore takes $57 a month of the saving back ($9,000 at 6.50% over 360 months is $56.89). With $5,400 of closing costs paid in cash, break-even moves from month 29 (without the deferral in the loan) to month 41 (with it). Run the same two-line check on your own numbers: the payment on the deferral alone at the new rate, then the payment saving on the rest.

Freddie Mac's bulletin says the deferral covers between two and six months of past-due principal and interest, with a cap of 12 cumulative deferred payments (Bulletin 2023-8). The size of your balance is therefore bounded. Servicers must also send reminders: the Freddie Mac bulletin adds "outreach requirements to inform Borrowers when their non-interest bearing UPB will become due soon." If you got a letter like that, it is a prompt to ask for a payoff statement now.

Common questions

Does a refinance reset the 30 percent limit on partial claims?

Not on a streamline. The Handbook says a streamline refinance on the same property by the same borrower is not treated as a new mortgage when the statutory maximum is measured. The ceiling is 30 percent of the unpaid principal balance on the date of default at the time of the initial claim, and it stays constant for the life of the mortgage.

Does a payment supplement work like a partial claim?

It is a related HUD instrument with its own note, agreement and subordinate mortgage, and it counts toward the same 30 percent ceiling as partial claims. HUD's contractor page handles partial claim and payment supplement payoff requests together, so ask for both if your hardship papers mention either.

Does ending FHA mortgage insurance make a partial claim due?

Only if the partial claim note says so. Handbook 4000.1 lists termination of FHA insurance as a trigger "if provided for under the Partial Claim Note," and when a borrower asks for voluntary termination the servicer must warn that the claim becomes immediately due if the note provides for it. Check your note before asking to end the insurance.

Is there a smallest partial claim HUD will make?

Yes. The Handbook sets a minimum of $1,000, except for claims tied to a presidentially declared major disaster. A lien shown at a smaller amount is a prompt to check whether you are looking at a partial claim at all or at another lien.

What if my servicer changed after the hardship?

The lien does not move; it is HUD's. Under Handbook 4000.1 as revised by Mortgagee Letter 2025-06, the new servicer takes over all servicing actions tied to any partial claim and payment supplement on the transfer date, and the payoff request path described above stays the same because it runs through HUD. Ask the new servicer for the FHA case number and the original claim paperwork if your own copies are gone.

If you hold an FHA loan with a partial claim and a rate well above today's market, run the tests in the FHA streamline guide first, because that is the one route that leaves the zero-interest lien in place.

Sources and verification

The example holds rate and closing costs equal across the refinance columns to isolate the lien, uses principal and interest only, and omits taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance premiums and the new loan's escrow; real quotes will differ by route and lender. Whether a lender reads a partial claim payoff as cash-out depends on its reading of Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, since Fannie Mae's March 2023 FAQ speaks to a COVID-era lien rather than a partial claim by name. Freddie Mac's Guide text on refinancing a loan that carries a deferral could not be opened, so only the Bulletin 2023-8 trigger list is stated, and Fannie Mae's cap on deferral months was not read this time. Rules checked October 23, 2026.