Refinancing after forbearance or a loan modification: FHA payment counts and the retired Fannie Mae rule
Fannie Mae no longer requires three on-time payments after a forbearance or modification: the temporary rule in Lender Letter LL-2021-03 was retired on February 15, 2023, and what remains is a current loan plus no 60-day late in the past 12 months. FHA still counts: three consecutive payments after forbearance for most refinances, twelve for cash-out, and six under a modification agreement.
Worksheet steps (11)
- The payment record and the set-aside balance: the two things a lender reads
- FHA's 3 payments after forbearance (12 for cash-out) and Fannie Mae's retired rule, cell by cell
- A Refer on an FHA file means manual underwriting, not a denial
- LL-2021-03 is retired: the credit-report test Fannie Mae uses instead
- FHA dates for one forbearance borrower and one modification borrower
- Consecutive means one missed month restarts the FHA count
- What VA and USDA say, and what they leave open
- What the workout leaves on the loan, and who gets repaid at closing
- A reinstatement leaves nothing behind; the other workouts do
- Pricing the set-aside balance: a $30,000 forbearance in the new loan
- A $30,000 set-aside balance moves the break-even rate by about 0.65 points
The payment record and the set-aside balance: the two things a lender reads
A workout leaves two kinds of footprints, and lenders read them separately. The first is the payment record: how many on-time payments have posted since the plan ended or the modification took effect, and whether any 60-day or worse late sits inside the last 12 months. The second is the loan itself: whether it is current today and whether it still carries a balance that was set aside during the hardship.
Programs weigh those two footprints differently. FHA writes out payment counts, in Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 and the Handbook. Fannie Mae writes a current-status test and a delinquency lookback, and for a time added a count that has since been retired. VA's text is about the age of the loan and says little about workouts. USDA's is a clean-record rule. The table below puts each program's published text in one place so you can see which clock is yours.
This page is about the period after the workout. If you are still deciding whether to refinance or to modify, the comparison is in our guide to loan modification versus refinance. For the general seasoning clocks that apply to any early refinance, see how soon you can refinance. The refinancing after life events hub collects the guides for situations like this one.
FHA's 3 payments after forbearance (12 for cash-out) and Fannie Mae's retired rule, cell by cell
Each cell below is the agency's own wording or a close paraphrase, with the document and its date. "Refer" is FHA shorthand for a loan the automated scorecard sends to a person for manual underwriting. It is not a denial; the section after the table explains what it means in practice. Where a program's published text does not address a situation, the cell says so rather than filling the gap with a lender's habit.
| Program and refinance type | After a forbearance plan | After a loan modification | Where it is written |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae, any refinance | No waiting period is stated in the pages read. The existing loan must be current when the application is taken, which the guide defines as 45 days or fewer since the last paid installment. A loan is ineligible if a mortgage tradeline shows a 60-, 90-, 120- or 150-day delinquency within the 12 months before the credit report date. A March 2023 FAQ says payments missed during a COVID-19-related forbearance are not counted as historical delinquencies for that rule. | The same current-status test and 12-month lookback apply to the modified loan. The pages read contain no modification-specific wait. | Selling Guide B3-5.3-03 (07/25/2017); Fannie Mae FAQ of March 30, 2023 |
| Fannie Mae, cash-out refinance | The loan being paid off "must be at least 12 months old," measured from its note date to the new note date. | The page does not say whether a modification changes the note date that is measured. Ask the lender how it counts. | Selling Guide B2-1.3-03 (12/10/2025) |
| Fannie Mae, the retired three-payment rule | Under LL-2021-03, a borrower who resolved missed payments through a repayment plan, deferral or modification needed three timely payments (or the three-month trial plan) before a new loan. | Same. | Retired February 15, 2023 (LL-2021-03, updated February 15, 2023). A lender may still keep a similar overlay. |
| FHA, purchase or no-cash-out refinance (full underwriting) | Fewer than three consecutive monthly payments since completing a forbearance plan sends the file to Refer. A borrower who kept paying as agreed under the original note is treated as if not in forbearance, provided the plan is terminated at or before closing. | The payment history follows the modification agreement for the period it covers, and the borrower "must have made at least six payments under the modification agreement to be eligible for a no-cash out refinance." | Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 (September 10, 2020); Handbook 4000.1 II.A.4.b.iii(K), August 12, 2026 redline |
| FHA, cash-out refinance | A current delinquency, any delinquency within 12 months of the case number date, or fewer than 12 consecutive monthly payments since completing a forbearance plan sends the file to Refer. | Payment history follows the modification agreement for the period it covers; the 12-month delinquency test still applies. | Mortgagee Letter 2020-30; Handbook 4000.1 II.A.4.b.iii(K), August 2026 redline |
| FHA, streamline refinance, no credit check | The borrower must have completed the forbearance plan and "made at least three consecutive monthly Mortgage Payments within the month due" since completing it. | Six payments under the modification agreement are needed on the loan being refinanced. | Handbook 4000.1 II.A.8.d.vi, August 2026 redline; Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 |
| FHA, streamline refinance with credit check | A borrower still in forbearance, or with fewer than three payments since it ended, can qualify if all payments were made within the month due for the six months before the forbearance and there was no more than one 30-day late in the previous six months. | Six payments under the modification agreement are still required. | Handbook 4000.1 II.A.8.d.vi, August 2026 redline; Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 |
| FHA streamline, seasoning on any loan | At case number assignment: six payments made on the loan being refinanced, six full months since its first payment due date, and 210 days since its closing date. | Where the loan was modified, the six payments must be under the modification agreement. | Handbook 4000.1 II.A.8.d.vi(C)(4), August 2026 redline |
| VA interest rate reduction refinance (IRRRL) | The text read has no forbearance-specific count. The loan being refinanced must be seasoned: its first payment due date at least 210 days before the refinance closes, and six consecutive monthly payments made. | The text read does not address modifications. VA proposed in November 2022 that payments before a modification would not count toward the six, but that proposal, which would amend VA's IRRRL regulation at 38 CFR 36.4307, has not been finalized, and the current text of 36.4307 has no seasoning language at all. | 38 U.S.C. 3709(c); VA Circular 26-19-22 (August 8, 2019); Federal Register proposed rule 2022-23387 |
| USDA Section 502, streamlined-assist refinance | No defaults in the 12 months before the refinance application. | The same no-default test applies to the loan as modified. | 7 CFR 3555.101(d)(3)(i)(C) |
| USDA Section 502, any refinance | Borrowers must have "maintained a current account for the 180 days prior to application." | Same. | 7 CFR 3555.101(d)(3)(iii) |
| Freddie Mac, any refinance | No Freddie Mac waiting rule is stated on this page. We could not open the Freddie Mac refinance eligibility text, so only its deferral terms (balance due at refinance) are included. | Not stated here. | Guide Bulletin 2023-8 (March 29, 2023), deferral terms only |
A Refer on an FHA file means manual underwriting, not a denial
The FHA rows say a loan "must be downgraded to a Refer and manually underwritten." Read that as a change of process, not a rejection. A human underwriter has to evaluate the file instead of the automated scorecard approving it, and the lender needs the paper trail the Handbook asks for: where a loan shows payments under a modification or forbearance plan inside the 12 months before the case number, the lender must obtain a copy of the modification or plan and evidence of the payment amount and date of payments during the agreement term. Documentation of a forbearance plan itself is not required if the forbearance was due to the COVID-19 National Emergency.
Practically, that means a borrower at two consecutive payments after a forbearance plan is not barred by FHA. The file simply takes the slower, stricter path. Whether a given lender takes manually underwritten files is the lender's own decision; FHA's text does not tell lenders to refuse them.
The cash-out row is stricter. Twelve consecutive payments after a forbearance plan, and no delinquency inside twelve months of the case number date, are the conditions that avoid Refer. A borrower who needs equity out of the house soon after a hardship should price the alternative of a separate loan against the house, as in our guide to cash-out refinance risks, before waiting a year.
LL-2021-03 is retired: the credit-report test Fannie Mae uses instead
Fannie Mae's Selling Guide has no table of waiting periods for ordinary forbearance, repayment plans, deferrals or modifications. What it has is the payment-history topic, B3-5.3-03. It requires the existing mortgage to be current when you apply and defines that as at most 45 days since the last installment was paid. It also makes a loan ineligible for delivery if any mortgage tradeline shows a delinquency of 60, 90, 120 or 150 days within the 12 months before the credit report date.
Put those two sentences next to a typical hardship and the waiting period is implied rather than printed; our late-payment lookback by program turns each window into a reopening month. A borrower who was 90 days late a year and a half ago and has paid on time since is outside the lookback. A borrower whose 60-day late was reported seven months ago is not, and the practical wait is until that entry is more than 12 months before the credit report date.
For a while the policy was more specific. Fannie Mae's Lender Letter LL-2021-03 required borrowers who had resolved missed payments through a workout to show three timely payments: three payments under a repayment plan, three consecutive payments after a payment deferral, or the completed three-month trial period for a modification. The letter was updated on February 15, 2023, and says those temporary eligibility requirements were retired then. The follow-up FAQ of March 30, 2023 spells out what replaced them: standard Selling Guide policy. A lender can still apply a version of the old rule as its own overlay, which is why two lenders can give you different answers on the same file.
One carve-out in that FAQ matters for anyone whose hardship was the pandemic. It states that payments missed during a COVID-19-related forbearance "are not considered to be historical delinquencies for purposes of complying with Excessive Mortgage Delinquency in B3-5.3-03." The sentence names COVID-19 specifically. For a forbearance that began for another reason, a flood or a job loss, the FAQ does not say, so ask the lender how it reads the credit report entries.
- Order your own credit report before you apply and look at the mortgage tradeline's 24-month grid. You are checking for any 60-day or worse mark and for how the servicer reported the plan months.
- Ask the servicer for a payment history letter that shows which months were paid under the plan, under the modification, or as scheduled. The lender will otherwise ask for it.
- If a deferral or modification left a balance behind, ask the servicer for a payoff statement now, not at lock time. The set-aside balance is part of what the new loan must pay.
FHA dates for one forbearance borrower and one modification borrower
Rules read cleanly until you put dates on them. The first borrower finished a forbearance plan with a lump-sum reinstatement and has an FHA loan. The second had an FHA loan modified. Both illustrate FHA's counts, which are the most specific in print; dates are invented for the illustration.
| Borrower and refinance type | Event that starts the count | Payments that must follow | Earliest case number date |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Forbearance ended June 30, 2026; full underwriting, no cash out | Plan completed June 30, 2026 | Three consecutive: July, August, September 2026 | October 1, 2026 |
| A. Same borrower, cash-out refinance | Plan completed June 30, 2026 | Twelve consecutive: July 2026 through June 2027, with no delinquency in those 12 months | July 1, 2027 |
| A. Same borrower, streamline with no credit check | Plan completed June 30, 2026 | Three consecutive since the plan, plus six payments, six full months and 210 days on the loan being refinanced | October 1, 2026, if the seasoning clocks have also run |
| A. Same borrower, streamline with credit check | No count after the plan; the test looks at the six months before the forbearance | None after the plan, if those prior six months were clean | Earlier than October 2026, subject to seasoning and the lender |
| B. Modification, first modified payment due January 1, 2026; no cash out or streamline | First payment under the modification agreement | Six: January through June 2026 | Once the June 2026 payment is made |
Consecutive means one missed month restarts the FHA count
Two cautions. The FHA counts run from the end of the plan, not from the start of the forbearance, so a plan that ended last month has produced no payments toward the count yet. And because the payments must be consecutive and made within the month due, one missed month breaks the run; the earliest dates in the table assume nothing else goes wrong. The FHA rows also assume the lender will take the loan; a lender overlay is not in the published rules but can add months.
What VA and USDA say, and what they leave open
VA's IRRRL seasoning rule is about the age of the loan being refinanced, and it is written in the statute. 38 U.S.C. 3709(c) bars a guaranty until the later of two dates: the date the borrower has made at least six consecutive monthly payments on the loan being refinanced, and 210 days after that loan's first payment due date. VA's cash-out regulation, 38 CFR 36.4306, repeats the same clock for a VA-to-VA refinance; VA's IRRRL regulation, 38 CFR 36.4307, has no seasoning text. VA Circular 26-19-22 (August 8, 2019) restates the test in terms of the first payment due date and six consecutive payments, and says the first payment due date at least 210 days before closing is the anchor. A veteran with a modified VA loan therefore wants to know whether the modification restarts that count.
VA proposed an answer in a rule published November 1, 2022 (RIN 2900-AR58). The proposal says that for a modified loan, "any payment made before the modification date does not count" toward the six consecutive payments, and that the 210 days would be measured from the first payment due date of the modified loan. It was a proposed rule. The proposal would amend VA's IRRRL regulation, 38 CFR 36.4307; VA proposed further changes on March 7, 2024, and the Federal Register shows no final rule as of October 28, 2026, so we treat the modification language as not adopted. VA's Circular on seasoning also notes that remedial action is not possible when the refinanced loan was not properly seasoned. If you have a VA loan with a modification, ask the lender in writing how it counts seasoning.
USDA keeps it short. The streamlined-assist refinance requires that the applicant has not had "any defaults during the 12 month period prior to the refinance loan application," and any existing borrower seeking to refinance needs "a current account for the 180 days prior to application." On a USDA loan that has been through a workout, the practical question is whether the servicer reported the plan months as defaults, so ask the servicer how it coded them.
What the workout leaves on the loan, and who gets repaid at closing
Meeting the waiting rules is half the problem. The other half is the money the workout set aside. Every program below treats the set-aside amount as interest-free while it sits, and every one of them calls it due when the first mortgage is refinanced. The table lists what to look for on the payoff statement.
| Workout | What is set aside | Interest while set aside | At a refinance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae payment deferral | Missed principal and interest moved to a separate balance | None | Due and payable; can be included in a limited cash-out payoff (Servicing Guide D2-3.2-04, 08/13/2025; Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, 10/08/2025) |
| Freddie Mac payment deferral | Two to six months of missed principal and interest, up to 12 cumulative | None | Due on refinance of the mortgage (Guide Bulletin 2023-8, March 29, 2023) |
| Fannie Mae Flex Modification | Principal forbearance when the loan-to-value ratio after modification exceeds 50% | None | Payable when the loan is refinanced or the interest-bearing balance is paid off (F-1-27, 08/13/2025) |
| FHA partial claim | Missed payments advanced by FHA and secured by a lien in HUD's favor | None | Payable on payoff of the mortgage, except HUD agrees to subordinate to a streamline (Handbook 4000.1 via Mortgagee Letter 2025-06); see partial claim and deferral payoffs |
| Repayment plan or reinstatement | Nothing; the arrears are cleared by payment | Not applicable | Nothing left to pay beyond the loan balance |
A reinstatement leaves nothing behind; the other workouts do
A reinstatement or a repayment plan that finishes leaves nothing behind, which is the simplest case. A deferral, a Flex Modification with principal forbearance, and an FHA partial claim each leave a balance that was free while it waited and stops being free the day the new loan pays it. That is the cost the next section prices.
Pricing the set-aside balance: a $30,000 forbearance in the new loan
Here is one borrower, all inputs stated. After a modification, the loan has an interest-bearing balance of $262,000 at 7.50% with 444 months (37 years) left, a $1,747 monthly principal-and-interest payment, and a $30,000 non-interest-bearing principal forbearance. The borrower plans to stay five years. A refinance would be a 30-year loan for $297,200: the $262,000, the $30,000 forbearance and $5,200 of financed closing costs. The rates below are illustrations, not quotes, and the first row is the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey 30-year average for the week ending October 22, 2026, 7.32% (checked October 23, 2026 at freddiemac.com/pmms). The comparison column adds cash paid over 60 months to the debt still owed at month 60, so that the forbearance counts on both sides.
| New rate | New monthly payment | Change against $1,747 today | Cash paid plus debt owed at month 60 | Against keeping the modified loan ($388,873) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.32% (PMMS average, October 22, 2026) | $2,042 | +$294 | $403,188 | $14,315 worse |
| 6.75% | $1,928 | +$180 | $394,657 | $5,783 worse |
| 6.25% | $1,830 | +$83 | $387,193 | $1,680 better |
| 5.75% | $1,734 | -$13 | $379,752 | $9,121 better |
A $30,000 set-aside balance moves the break-even rate by about 0.65 points
The payment goes up in three of the four rows. A borrower who sees a lower rate and expects a lower payment is surprised, because the $30,000 that was costing nothing is now part of a loan charging interest, and because the term goes from 37 years back to 30 and the amortization steepens. Over five years, the refinance only beats keeping the modified loan once the rate falls to about 6.36%: at 6.35% it comes out $189 ahead, at 6.40% it is $557 behind.
Run the same borrower without the set-aside balance and the picture changes. If the loan were a plain $262,000 with the same $5,200 of costs financed, the break-even rate over five years would be near 7.0%: at 6.75% the refinance comes out $4,054 ahead, and at the 7.32% average it is $3,616 behind. So the set-aside balance costs this borrower roughly 0.65 percentage points of break-even rate. That is the number to carry into a lender conversation, and it is why a quote that looks fine on the first mortgage alone should be re-run with the full payoff.
The stay horizon moves the answer. At 10 years instead of 5, the same $297,200 loan at 6.75% is $2,697 worse than keeping, and at 6.25% it is $12,190 better; the break-even rate rises from about 6.36% at five years to about 6.66% at ten, because the closing costs have longer to spread. The right tool is the same arithmetic on your own balance, which the stay or refi calculator runs on rates you enter, with the method described in our break-even guide.
Two limits on the grid. It counts principal and interest only, and leaves out taxes, insurance and any mortgage insurance. And it assumes the new loan qualifies on the rules in the table above: a borrower whose workout is recent may only reach a higher-priced loan or a manually underwritten one, which shifts the rate column to the right.
Common questions
Can I refinance while still in forbearance?
Mostly no. The FHA Handbook says that where a mortgage in forbearance will remain open after the new FHA loan closes, the plan must be terminated at or before closing. The one published exception is the credit-qualifying FHA streamline, which allows a borrower still in forbearance if all payments were made within the month due for the six months before the forbearance and the previous six months have at most one 30-day late.
Do the FHA counts apply if the forbearance was not about COVID-19?
Yes. Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 frames the counts around forbearance after a presidentially declared disaster or "some other hardship including the COVID-19 National Emergency." What changes is paperwork: the lender must obtain a copy of the forbearance plan for other hardships, but not when the forbearance was due to the COVID-19 National Emergency. Fannie Mae's March 2023 carve-out for missed payments is worded for COVID-19-related forbearance only.
How does the break-even rate change if I stay ten years instead of five?
On the page's $297,200 example, the refinance beats keeping the modified loan at about 6.36% over five years and at about 6.66% over ten. At ten years, a 6.75% quote is $2,697 behind and a 6.60% quote is about $1,779 ahead. Move the horizon and the crossover moves with it, which is why the stay horizon belongs in every comparison.
Why can my payment rise when the new rate is lower?
Three things move at once. Take the same modified loan at an illustrated 6.25%: re-amortizing the $262,000 over the 444 remaining months would cost $1,516 against $1,747 today, shortening the term to 30 years lifts that to $1,613, and rolling in the $30,000 forbearance plus $5,200 of costs lifts it to $1,830. The rate cut is real; the shorter term and the added balance outweigh it.
Does an FHA streamline with no credit check mean no underwriting?
No. The August 2026 Handbook redline says the mortgagee must manually underwrite all streamline refinances, and that the lender may run the file through the TOTAL scorecard but the scorecard's findings are invalid. "No credit check" describes the non-credit-qualifying version, which relies on the payment record in the table above instead of a new credit review.
Sources and verification
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 (September 10, 2020): FHA underwriting after forbearance: three consecutive payments for purchase and no-cash-out, twelve for cash-out, six payments under a modification, and the streamline provisions. Checked October 23, 2026.
- HUD, Handbook 4000.1 update redline (posted August 12, 2026): Housing obligations and mortgage payment history (II.A.4.b.iii(K)), streamline payment history and seasoning (II.A.8.d.vi). The Refinances heading carries a November 10, 2026 effective date next to an earlier May 25, 2025 date; the thresholds used here also appear in Mortgagee Letter 2020-30. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B3-5.3-03, Previous Mortgage Payment History (07/25/2017): Existing mortgage current at application (45 days since last paid installment), documentation of history, and the excessive mortgage delinquency rule. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B2-1.3-03, Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (12/10/2025): Existing first mortgage at least 12 months old, note date to note date; no modification-specific text. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (10/08/2025): A deferred balance from a prior loss mitigation solution may be paid off in a limited cash-out refinance. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Lender Letter LL-2021-03 (updated February 15, 2023): Temporary three-timely-payment eligibility requirement and its retirement on February 15, 2023. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, FAQ on the retirement of LL-2021-03 (March 30, 2023): Credit report reliance, COVID-19 forbearance months not counted as historical delinquencies, deferred balance in payoff, existing loan current at application. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Servicing Guide D2-3.2-04 and F-1-27 (08/13/2025): Deferral and principal forbearance carry no interest and are payable on refinance or payoff. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Guide Bulletin 2023-8 (March 29, 2023): Payment deferral terms and the refinance trigger. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: Release of October 22, 2026: 30-year fixed 7.32 percent. Checked October 23, 2026.
- eCFR, 38 CFR 36.4306 (Veterans Affairs refinancing): Seasoning: the later of 210 days from the first monthly payment and the sixth monthly payment. The eCFR title 38 showed as up to date through October 21, 2026. Checked October 23, 2026.
- VA, Circular 26-19-22 (August 8, 2019): IRRRL seasoning calculated from the first payment due date, with six consecutive payments; seasoning failures cannot be cured. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Federal Register public inspection copy, VA proposed rule 2022-23387 (November 1, 2022): Proposed treatment of loan modifications in IRRRL seasoning. Proposal only; not in the eCFR text read. Checked October 23, 2026.
- eCFR, 7 CFR 3555.101 (USDA Section 502 refinancing): Streamlined-assist refinance: no defaults in the prior 12 months; current account for the 180 days before application. Checked October 23, 2026.
- 38 U.S.C. 3709(c), IRRRL seasoning: No guaranty until the later of the date the borrower has made at least six consecutive monthly payments on the loan being refinanced and the date 210 days after its first payment due date. Federal Register: VA proposed IRRRL rule changes (amending 38 CFR 36.4307) on November 1, 2022 and March 7, 2024; no final rule found. Checked October 28, 2026.
The rate grid uses one stated modified loan ($262,000 at 7.50% with 444 months left, a $30,000 forbearance and $5,200 of financed costs) and illustrated rates; it counts principal and interest only and says nothing about whether any lender would approve the loan. The FHA counts come from Mortgagee Letter 2020-30 as repeated in the August 12, 2026 Handbook redline, whose Refinances section carries a November 10, 2026 effective date. Fannie Mae's B3-5.3-03 is paraphrased, not quoted in full, except inside quotation marks. Freddie Mac's refinance eligibility text and VA's Lenders Handbook chapter on refinancing could not be opened, so we state no Freddie Mac waiting rule and leave the VA modification question open. USDA rows quote the regulation only. Rules checked October 23, 2026.