Rentals, second homes and keep-or-move
Is giving up a 3% mortgage to move worth it? Pricing the lock-in
Giving up a $350,000 mortgage at 3.25% to borrow the same amount at 7.40%, the 30-year fixed average in Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey for the week of October 15, 2026, raises the payment by $717 a month and adds about $146,500 of interest over 10 years. That figure is the price of the lock-in, and it is worth knowing in dollars before weighing it against the reasons to move. The answer to "is it worth it" depends on what the move buys you that the old house cannot, how long you will stay in the next one, and how much you will borrow to get there. This page prices the mortgage side only: three balance and rate pairs across 5, 10 and 15 years, the borrowing power your current payment would buy at today's average, and the routes that keep a low rate in the picture.
Worksheet steps (11)
- What lock-in means in measured terms
- What to gather before you price a move
- The lock-in cost table: three loans, three horizons
- Reading the table without fooling yourself
- Comparing payments instead of comparing the same debt
- What your current payment buys at today's average
- Why the budget view matters more than the interest view for some movers
- Routes that keep a low rate in the picture
- How assumption works under FHA, VA and USDA rules
- When the lock-in cost is the smaller number
- Do not count on a later refinance to rescue the math
What lock-in means in measured terms
Lock-in is the reluctance to sell a home because the mortgage on it carries a rate far below what a new loan would cost. It is not only a feeling. A working paper by Federal Housing Finance Agency researchers Ross M. Batzer, Jonah Coste, William M. Doerner and Michael J. Seiler, FHFA Working Paper 24-03, The Lock-In Effect of Rising Mortgage Rates (posted March 18, 2024, checked October 22, 2026), estimates that for every percentage point by which market mortgage rates exceed a borrower's origination rate, the quarterly probability of sale falls by 18.1%.
The paper's finding does not tell any one household what to do, but it does describe how strongly the rate gap holds people in place, and it explains why the decision feels heavier than the monthly payment alone would suggest. The useful response is to turn the gap into dollars on your own balance and horizon, then decide with that number on the table.
Those low rates are not rare. In the FRED copy of the PMMS 30-year series (MORTGAGE30US, source Freddie Mac, checked October 22, 2026), the weekly average reached 2.65% in the week of January 7, 2021, and the 2021 weekly readings averaged 2.96%. The FHFA paper's abstract (March 2024) adds that nearly all of the roughly 50 million active U.S. mortgages have fixed rates and that most carry rates far below prevailing market rates, the situation the pairs in the table below are built to show.
What to gather before you price a move
Each number the tables below use comes from one of these items, so collect them first. The list is in the order the rest of the page uses them.
- Copy the rate, balance and months remaining from your latest mortgage statement.
- Note the date and value of the PMMS average you are comparing against; on October 15, 2026 it was 7.40% for a 30-year fixed.
- Decide the loan amount you expect on the next home, not just the price, and run it at your quoted rate, not the average.
- Price the extra interest over the years you expect to stay in the next home, and note the balance gap at that point.
- Compute what your current payment would borrow at the new rate, and size the shortfall you would cover with equity or a smaller loan.
- If you have an FHA, VA or USDA loan, ask your servicer whether a buyer could assume it and what review the buyer would face; if VA, ask how your entitlement would be treated.
- If you might keep the house as a rental, read the occupancy section of your security instrument and confirm with your servicer before you plan around it.
- If the goal is a lower payment rather than a different home, price a recast before you price a move.
- Do not build the plan on a future refinance; price the move at the rate you can get now.
The lock-in cost table: three loans, three horizons
Every input is stated so the table can be checked line by line. Each household is assumed to borrow the same amount on the next home that it owes today, so the comparison isolates the rate and the term restart rather than a bigger or smaller loan. The new loan is a 30-year fixed at 7.40%, the PMMS average for the week of October 15, 2026. That figure is a weekly market average, not a quote; your own rate depends on credit, down payment, points and lender. Each payment covers principal and interest only, worked out from the usual fixed-rate payment formula and rounded to the dollar. Taxes, insurance and mortgage insurance are left out because they change with the house, not the rate.
| Current loan | Monthly payment: keep / new | Monthly increase | Extra interest over 5 years | Extra interest over 10 years | Extra interest over 15 years | Owed at 10 years: keep / new |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 at 2.75%, 25 years left | $1,153 / $1,731 | $578 | $58,251 | $115,883 | $170,980 | $169,944 / $216,507 |
| $350,000 at 3.25%, 25 years left | $1,706 / $2,423 | $717 | $73,185 | $146,504 | $217,671 | $242,733 / $303,110 |
| $450,000 at 4.00%, 26 years left | $2,322 / $3,116 | $794 | $77,475 | $156,003 | $233,340 | $328,928 / $389,712 |
Reading the table without fooling yourself
Start with the extra-interest columns, because that is money that buys nothing except the right to have moved. For the middle household, five years in the new home costs $73,185 more in interest than five years in the old one. At 15 years the figure is $217,671, about three-fifths of the original balance.
Then look at the balance column. The new loan starts a fresh 30-year clock, while the old loan had 25 or 26 years left. After 10 years the middle household would owe $303,110 on the new loan against $242,733 on the old one, a gap of $60,377. That gap is principal that has not been repaid yet, which is why the balance difference and the interest difference should not be added together as if both were pure cost. The interest is gone; the balance gap is debt you still carry but can still repay.
Notice what the monthly increase does and does not tell you. The 4.00% household faces the largest dollar increase, $794, but the smallest rate gap, 3.40 points. The 2.75% household has the largest rate gap, 4.65 points, but the smallest balance, so its increase is $578. The lock-in cost scales with both the gap and the size of the debt you would replace, which is why two neighbors with the same rate can face very different prices for the same move.
Finally, the table assumes the same loan amount. If the move is a downsize and the new loan is smaller, the cost shrinks; if the next home needs a bigger loan, it grows. To reproduce a row on your own loan in the stay-or-refinance calculator, enter your current balance, rate and years left, put your quoted rate for the next loan in the new-rate field with a 30-year term, set closing costs to $0, and set the stay to the years you expect in the next home. Read the new payment, the monthly change, the interest on the current loan over your stay, and the new loan's interest over the same stay; the gap between those last two is the lock-in cost as this table defines it. The verdict sentence at the top is written for refinance quotes, so treat "staying put wins" there as a statement about the rate, not about whether to move. For a different loan amount, generic payment math belongs on CalculatorVillage.
Comparing payments instead of comparing the same debt
The most common way to understate the lock-in is to compare the old payment with a new payment on a smaller loan, then call the difference the cost of moving. If the next loan is $100,000 smaller because sale equity went into the down payment, the payment comparison mixes two separate effects: the higher rate, which costs money, and the larger down payment, which uses money you could have kept. Price them separately. First run the same balance at both rates to see the rate cost, as in the lock-in table. Then decide how much equity to put down, knowing that equity placed in the house is cash you no longer hold.
What your current payment buys at today's average
Another way to see the lock-in is to hold the monthly budget fixed and ask how much it would borrow at the current average. The figures below solve the amortization formula for the loan amount a payment supports over 30 years at 7.40%, principal and interest only.
| Current loan | Current payment | Same payment borrows at 7.40% over 30 years | Shortfall against today's balance |
|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 at 2.75%, 25 years left | $1,153 | $166,567 | $83,433 |
| $350,000 at 3.25%, 25 years left | $1,706 | $246,340 | $103,660 |
| $450,000 at 4.00%, 26 years left | $2,322 | $335,397 | $114,603 |
Why the budget view matters more than the interest view for some movers
The shortfall column answers a different question than the lock-in table. It asks how much more cash at closing, or how much less house, it would take to keep the monthly mortgage cost where it is now. For the 3.25% household, matching the current $1,706 payment on a new loan at 7.40% means borrowing about $103,660 less than it owes today. Equity from the sale can close some or all of that gap, and that is exactly where a mover's numbers diverge from a neighbor's.
This page does not estimate what your home would sell for or what the next home would cost, and it does not forecast where prices or rates will go. Those numbers belong to your own listing agent, appraiser and lender. What the table gives you is the mortgage half of the equation in dollars, so that when you do have those other numbers, the loan cost is already priced.
The budget view also exposes one easy mistake: assuming the old payment will roughly carry over. On the figures above, the same payment borrows roughly 25% to 33% less than the current balance, depending on the pair. A move planned around the current payment, without that adjustment, will come up short at the lender's desk.
Routes that keep a low rate in the picture
A fixed-rate mortgage is secured by the house it was made on, so the low rate generally belongs to that house and that loan. The routes below, part of our wider keep-or-move topic, are the ones we could verify against official rules. Each has a cost of its own, and none of them is a way around a lender's terms. The occupancy and due-on-sale limits, and a full-year rent-versus-cost sheet, are in renting out a home while keeping its mortgage.
- Stay and borrow against the house instead. If the reason to move is cash for a project rather than a different home, our comparison of the four ways to tap home equity shows how a second lien leaves a low first-mortgage rate untouched.
- Stay and reshape the loan. If the aim is a lower payment rather than a different house, a recast applies a lump sum to principal and recalculates the payment at the same rate. Our guide to recasting instead of refinancing covers who can recast and how the math works.
- Keep the loan and rent the house out. Your current mortgage stays in place at its rate, but your next home needs its own financing at market rates, and the occupancy promise in your existing loan still applies. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide defines a principal residence as a property the borrower occupies as their primary residence and refers to owner occupancy being established as required by the security instrument (Selling Guide B2-1.1-01, dated October 5, 2022, checked October 2026). Read the occupancy section of your own security instrument, and ask your servicer, before planning a rental.
- Let a buyer assume the loan. Assumption keeps the low rate with the house and passes it to the buyer, not to you. It can matter to the sale, but it does not carry your rate to the next home. How much of the rate a seller can turn into a price premium is worked out in what an assumable mortgage is worth to a seller.
- Assume someone else's loan on the next home. The same programs that let your buyer take over your loan can let you take over a seller's FHA, VA or USDA loan, subject to the lender's or agency's review of you as the new borrower.
How assumption works under FHA, VA and USDA rules
Assumption is the closest thing to a rate that survives a sale, so it is worth knowing which rules apply to which loan. HUD's Mortgagee Letter 2025-21, dated September 24, 2025, updates the FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 and states plainly that all FHA-insured mortgages are assumable (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-21, checked October 2026). The FHA regulation at 24 CFR 203.512 sets a policy of free assumability, and under 203.512(b), where the mortgage requires approval, the lender cannot approve a sale unless at least one buyer is found creditworthy, the seller keeps an ownership interest, or the transfer is by devise or descent.
VA-guaranteed loans also carry a credit review. Under 38 CFR 36.4303(l), lenders with automatic authority must examine the purchaser's creditworthiness, and other lenders submit a credit package to VA. Entitlement is the other VA question. The VA rule at 38 CFR 36.4302(j)(2) provides for a veteran-transferee who assumes the outstanding balance to consent to the use of their own entitlement in place of the seller's. If the buyer is not a veteran substituting entitlement, ask VA or your servicer how your entitlement will be treated before you agree to an assumption.
For USDA guaranteed loans, 7 CFR 3555.256 requires the lender to obtain agency approval before consenting to a transfer with assumption, and the buyer must meet the program's eligibility rules. In some transfers that do not trigger the due-on-sale clause, the rule lets the transferee assume the loan on the rates and terms in the existing note.
Two practical points follow. First, an assumption transfers the remaining balance, not the house's value, so a buyer usually needs cash or separate financing for the difference between the price and the loan balance. Second, ask the servicer or agency whether the assumption will include a written release of your liability for the loan, and get any release in writing rather than assuming it comes with the sale. For the release-of-liability steps and how VA entitlement is treated, see our guide to mortgage assumption and release of liability, which works the buyer's equity gap on a $425,000 sale.
When the lock-in cost is the smaller number
Some moves are not optional, and some are worth more than any interest figure. A job in another city, a household that has outgrown its space, the need to be near family, or a house that no longer fits a disability or age are all reasons the lock-in table cannot weigh. The point of pricing the lock-in is not to argue against those moves. It is to make sure the decision is made with the cost visible.
There are also cases where the table overstates the cost for a particular household:
- A smaller next loan. Downsizing with a large share of sale equity can shrink the new balance enough that the new payment lands near the old one, even at 7.40%.
- A short remaining term on the old loan. If the old loan has only a few years left, its remaining interest is small, so there is less low-rate interest to give up.
- Faster repayment on the new loan. Extra principal payments reduce the extra interest, though they also raise the monthly outlay you budget for.
- Costs already being paid to stay. If staying means renting a second place, long commutes, or a major renovation, those costs belong on the stay side of the ledger.
Do not count on a later refinance to rescue the math
It is tempting to price the new loan as temporary: move now, refinance when rates fall. That plan rests on a rate path no one can promise, and this site does not forecast one. Price the move as if the new rate is the rate you will keep. If rates do fall and a refinance later clears its own break-even, that is a gain on top of a decision that already worked, not the support holding it up. For the owner who keeps the loan instead, the after-tax return on sending spare cash to a low-rate mortgage is set against Treasury and I bond yields in paying off a low-rate mortgage or investing.
A refinance is also not free when it comes, and an owner who listed the house and then pulled it faces its own delisting and occupancy conditions, set out in our guide to refinancing after listing a home for sale. Closing costs restart the break-even clock in months, and a fresh 30-year term restarts amortization again. A move that only works if a refinance happens within two years is a move that depends on a forecast, and our page on when refinancing is a mistake lists the ways a hoped-for refinance can fail to pay off.
Common questions
Are FHA-insured mortgages assumable?
Yes. HUD's Mortgagee Letter 2025-21 states that all FHA-insured mortgages are assumable, and 24 CFR 203.512 bars lenders from restricting assumption except as HUD rules allow. Where approval is required, at least one buyer must be found creditworthy, unless the seller keeps an ownership interest or the transfer is by devise or descent.
Can someone take over my VA loan if I sell?
A buyer can assume a VA-guaranteed loan after a creditworthiness review under 38 CFR 36.4303(l). Your VA entitlement is the issue to settle first: 38 CFR 36.4302(j)(2) provides for a veteran buyer to substitute their own entitlement for yours. If the buyer is not a veteran substituting entitlement, ask VA or your servicer how your entitlement is treated before you agree.
Can I take my low mortgage rate with me to a new house?
A standard fixed-rate mortgage is secured by the house it was made on, and we found no federal program rule that moves the loan to a different property. The low rate stays in play in a move only if you keep the old loan and the house, or if you assume a seller's assumable loan on the next home. Ask your servicer whether your own note has any substitution provision.
Can I rent my house and keep my mortgage?
Your loan's occupancy terms decide that, and they are in your security instrument. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide ties owner occupancy to what the security instrument requires. Read that section, confirm with your servicer, and keep every statement you make to a lender accurate. This page does not cover landlord economics; the next home will also need its own financing.
Does a recast lower my interest rate?
No. A recast applies a lump sum to principal and recalculates the payment over the remaining term at the same rate. That is why it can suit an owner who wants to keep a low rate and reduce the payment without moving. Our recast guide covers eligibility and the math.
How much does the rate gap actually keep people from moving?
FHFA Working Paper 24-03 by Batzer, Coste, Doerner and Seiler estimates that each percentage point by which market rates exceed a borrower's origination rate lowers the quarterly probability of sale by 18.1%. It is a research estimate across many borrowers, not a rule for any one household.
Sources and verification
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: 30-year fixed average 7.40% in the release of October 15, 2026, used as the new-loan rate in every example. Checked October 22, 2026.
- FRED, 30-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average (MORTGAGE30US), source Freddie Mac: Weekly low of 2.65% in the week of January 7, 2021; 2021 weekly readings averaged 2.96%. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Federal Housing Finance Agency, Working Paper 24-03, The Lock-In Effect of Rising Mortgage Rates (Batzer, Coste, Doerner, Seiler): Posted March 18, 2024. Each percentage point by which market rates exceed the origination rate lowers the quarterly probability of sale by 18.1%. Checked October 22, 2026.
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2025-21 (updates to Handbook 4000.1): Dated September 24, 2025: all FHA-insured mortgages are assumable. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 24 CFR 203.512, Free assumability; exceptions: Free assumability policy and the creditworthiness condition for approved transfers. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 38 CFR 36.4303 and 36.4302, VA loan guaranty: Purchaser creditworthiness review on assumption (36.4303(l)); substitution of a veteran-transferee's entitlement (36.4302(j)(2)). Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, 7 CFR 3555.256, USDA transfers and assumptions: Agency approval before a transfer with assumption; transferee eligibility; assumption on existing rates and terms in certain transfers. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B2-1.1-01, Occupancy Types: Dated October 5, 2022: principal residence definition; owner occupancy established as required by the security instrument. Checked October 22, 2026.
This page prices only the mortgage side of a move, on stated illustrations: three balance and rate pairs, the same loan amount on the next home, and the 7.40% PMMS weekly average of October 15, 2026 as the new rate, which is an average and not a quote. It does not estimate sale prices, purchase prices, selling or buying costs, taxes, insurance or moving costs, and it does not forecast rates or home prices. Assumption, entitlement and occupancy outcomes depend on your loan documents, your servicer and the agency involved. Educational only, not a loan offer and not real-estate advice.