Rentals, second homes and keep-or-move

Pay off a low-rate mortgage or invest? The after-tax return an extra dollar has to beat

An extra dollar sent to a 3.25% mortgage earns a certain 3.30% a year after compounding, with nothing taken out by tax for a household that takes the standard deduction, while the 10-year Treasury par yield was 4.94% on October 30, 2026 (5.00% as an effective annual yield, 3.80% after 24% federal tax). At the 7.24% Freddie Mac average for October 29 the order reverses: the loan costs 7.49% effective. Whether the interest was saving any tax depends on one line, the standard deduction.

Worksheet steps (12)
  1. A prepayment is a certain return equal to the loan's rate, less the tax the interest used to save
  2. The standard deduction decides whether the interest ever saved any tax
  3. Publication 936 limits that change the arithmetic: debt caps, home equity money, points and mortgage insurance
  4. The bracket you save at, the 37% haircut, and the dollars that straddle the line
  5. The interest shrinks every year, and with it the deduction
  6. Three lump sums worked from balance to horizon
  7. What Treasury par yields were in October 2026
  8. The mortgage rate at which a Treasury yield and a prepayment tie
  9. I bonds: a fixed rate that lasts and an inflation add-on that resets
  10. The return a taxable fund has to earn to match: pre-tax, by account type
  11. A bad first year raises the bar for the nine years that follow
  12. What a lump sum leaves unchanged, and what other routes do instead

A prepayment is a certain return equal to the loan's rate, less the tax the interest used to save

Every dollar sent to a fixed-rate mortgage stops accruing interest at that loan's rate for as long as the loan would have run. The saving is set by the note, not by any market, so the comparison with an investment pairs a known yield with an unknown one. The first job is to put the known yield on the same footing as anything it is compared with. Two adjustments do that. The first is compounding. A mortgage charges interest monthly, so a 3.25% note rate costs 3.30% over a year, a 6.00% note rate costs 6.17%, and the 7.24% Freddie Mac 30-year average for the week of October 29, 2026 costs 7.49%. Savings accounts, Treasury notes and funds quote annual yields, so those effective figures are the ones to set beside them. The second adjustment is tax.

Mortgage interest is deductible only for a household that itemizes. Publication 936, the IRS guide to the deduction, lists conditions for deducting home mortgage interest at all, among them that you file Form 1040 or 1040-SR and itemize deductions on Schedule A and that the loan is a secured debt on a qualified home in which you hold an ownership interest. A household that takes the standard deduction has no deduction to lose, so the interest a prepayment saves is a full-value return with nothing taken out. A household that itemizes loses a deduction when the interest falls, and the loss is worth its marginal tax rate times the part of the lost interest that was above the standard deduction line. Call the share of each dollar of interest that was actually saving tax d. Then the after-tax cost of the loan, which is the return a prepayment earns, is the loan's monthly rate times (1 minus the bracket times d), compounded for twelve months.

The value of d is 0 for a household whose itemized total is under the standard deduction, 1 for a household far above it, and between the two for a household near it. The bracket comes from IRS tables for 2026. The yield on the other side of the comparison comes from the Treasury's own published curve for October 2026 and from TreasuryDirect's I bond page. Those yields are dated snapshots of what was on offer, not predictions of what any account will earn, and nothing here says what to do with a spare dollar: it sets a hurdle and shows what clears it.

One honest limit applies to all of it. A prepayment return exists only while there is a loan to prepay. Money sent to a 3% loan earns its 3% until the loan would have been repaid, and a lump sum applied to a loan with 25 years left earns that rate for up to 25 years, but a bond held to a five-year maturity earns its yield for five years and then needs a new home. Where the two run for different lengths, the comparison needs a stated horizon, and every example below states one.

The standard deduction decides whether the interest ever saved any tax

Rev. Proc. 2025-32, the IRS inflation-adjustment notice for tax year 2026, sets the 2026 standard deduction at $32,200 for married couples filing jointly and surviving spouses, $24,150 for heads of household, and $16,100 for single filers and married individuals filing separately. For 2025 the same notice records $31,500, $23,625 and $15,750. The notice explains that the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made the higher base amounts permanent, so the 2026 figures are inflation adjustments of a permanent number rather than a temporary one that lapses at year end. They apply to taxable years beginning in 2026, and the notice reflects the law as it stood on October 9, 2025.

Itemizing helps when the sum of the itemized deductions exceeds that figure. Mortgage interest is one entry. The others that matter for most homeowners are state and local taxes (property tax plus income or sales tax), charitable gifts and medical costs above their floor. Public Law 119-21, section 70120, sets the cap on the state and local tax deduction at $40,400 for 2026, reduced by 30% of modified adjusted gross income above $505,000 but never below $10,000, and returning to $10,000 for years after 2029. For 2025 the cap was $40,000 with a $500,000 threshold. A household in a state with modest property and income taxes does not reach the cap, so its state and local deduction is simply what it paid.

The table turns the standard deduction into a threshold. It asks how much mortgage interest a household needs, given its other itemized deductions, before itemizing beats the standard deduction, and what balance that is at three interest rates. A row at $0 of other deductions is the pure case: a couple would need $32,200 of mortgage interest alone. The balance columns divide the needed interest by the rate and are first-year approximations, since interest is a little lower than balance times rate as principal falls during the year.

Mortgage interest needed for itemized deductions to exceed the 2026 standard deduction (Rev. Proc. 2025-32, section 4.14: $16,100 single, $24,150 head of household, $32,200 joint), by other itemized deductions. Balance columns are for joint filers and divide the interest by the note rate. Computed on this site.
Other itemized deductions (taxes, gifts, medical)Interest needed, singleInterest needed, head of householdInterest needed, jointJoint: balance at 3.25%Joint: balance at 5.00%Joint: balance at 7.24%
$0$16,100$24,150$32,200$990,769$644,000$444,751
$5,000$11,100$19,150$27,200$836,923$544,000$375,691
$10,000$6,100$14,150$22,200$683,077$444,000$306,630
$15,000$1,100$9,150$17,200$529,231$344,000$237,569
$20,000$0$4,150$12,200$375,385$244,000$168,508
$25,000$0$0$7,200$221,538$144,000$99,448
$30,000$0$0$2,200$67,692$44,000$30,387
$40,400$0$0$0anyanyany

A joint filer with $10,000 of other itemized deductions needs $22,200 of mortgage interest, which is a balance of about $683,000 at 3.25%, about $444,000 at 5.00% and about $307,000 at 7.24%. The same couple with $25,000 of state taxes and gifts needs only $7,200, which a $221,538 balance at 3.25% already supplies. The lesson of the table is the spread between the columns: the same mortgage balance can sit well below the line at 3.25% and well above it at 7.24%. A $350,000 loan at 3.25% pays about $11,238 of interest in its first year here. At 7.24% a $400,000 loan pays $28,833. Those are the two anchor loans here.

Whether a household itemizes is therefore a fact about the whole return, and it has to be known before the question of a prepayment can be answered. The test is to add the year's mortgage interest, state and local taxes up to the cap, charitable gifts and other itemized items and compare the total with the standard deduction for the filing status. If the total is below it, mortgage interest saves no federal tax, and the required return in the next table is the effective loan rate itself.

Publication 936 limits that change the arithmetic: debt caps, home equity money, points and mortgage insurance

Publication 936 (2025), dated October 28, 2025, allows a deduction for interest on the first $750,000 of home acquisition debt ($375,000 if married filing separately) incurred after December 15, 2017, and on the first $1 million ($500,000 separately) of debt incurred before December 16, 2017. Home acquisition debt means a mortgage secured by the home and used to buy, build or substantially improve it. Public Law 119-21, section 70108, makes the limitation permanent for years after 2025 by deleting the 2025 end date. Interest on a home equity loan or line is deductible only if the money was used to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures it, whenever the debt was taken out.

The cap matters for prepayments in a way most summaries miss. Table 1 in the publication scales the deduction by the qualified loan limit divided by the average balance. On a loan above the limit, deductible interest is the limit times the rate, whatever the balance is above it. At 7.24%, a balance of $800,000, $1 million or $1.2 million all produce the same deductible interest of $54,300 (the $750,000 limit times 7.24%). So a prepayment that reduces a balance that is still above $750,000 removes only interest that was never deductible, and its after-tax return is the full effective rate. Once the balance falls below the limit, each dollar prepaid removes interest that was deductible. The table shows the pattern for a post-2017 loan.

Deductible interest at a 7.24% note rate when a post-2017 acquisition loan exceeds the $750,000 limit, using the ratio in Publication 936 (2025) Table 1, line 14 (limit divided by average balance). Computed on this site; first-year interest approximated as balance times rate.
Average balanceShare of interest deductible (750,000 divided by balance)Interest at 7.24%Deductible interest
$800,0000.938$57,920$54,300
$900,0000.833$65,160$54,300
$1,000,0000.750$72,400$54,300
$1,200,0000.625$86,880$54,300

Three other rules in the publication bear on a payoff. A mortgage prepayment penalty is deductible as home mortgage interest if the penalty is not for a specific service performed or cost incurred in connection with the loan, which softens a penalty only for a household that itemizes. Points paid on a refinance are generally spread over the life of the loan rather than deducted in the year paid, and any balance left when the loan ends early is deducted in the year it ends, unless the new loan is with the same lender, in which case it is spread over the new term. And a payoff ends the interest deduction on the loan altogether, which is why the saving in the examples below is measured net of the deduction given up.

Mortgage insurance is the item where the 2025 edition is out of date for 2026 returns. That edition says the deduction for mortgage insurance premiums has expired. Public Law 119-21, section 70108(a)(1)(D), provides that clause (iv) of 26 U.S.C. 163(h)(3)(E), the termination clause that ended the treatment of premiums as interest after 2021, no longer applies, effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025. The early-release draft of Publication 936 for 2026 returns says the deduction has been reinstated for 2026 for premiums on home acquisition debt under contracts issued after 2006. The deduction is reduced by 10% for each $1,000 (or fraction) by which adjusted gross income exceeds $100,000, or for each $500 (or fraction) over $50,000 if married filing separately, so it is gone above $109,000 ($54,500 if married filing separately). Prepaid premiums other than VA and Rural Housing Service ones are spread over the shorter of the loan term or 84 months, and no deduction is allowed for the unamortized balance if the mortgage is satisfied early. For a borrower paying a mortgage down to remove insurance, the PMI removal guide covers the loan-to-value rules that end the charge.

The bracket you save at, the 37% haircut, and the dollars that straddle the line

For an itemizer, the value of a dollar of interest is the marginal rate on the last dollars of taxable income. The 2026 tables in Rev. Proc. 2025-32 start the 12% rate at taxable income above $12,400 for single filers, $17,700 for heads of household and $24,800 for joint filers. The 22% rate starts above $50,400, $67,450 and $100,800. The 24% rate starts above $105,700, $105,700 and $211,400, and the 32% rate above $201,775, $201,750 and $403,550. The 35% rate starts above $256,225, $256,200 and $512,450, and the 37% rate above $640,600, $640,600 and $768,700. These are thresholds for taxable income, which is income after deductions.

At the top there is a wrinkle. Public Law 119-21, section 70111, rewrites section 68 for years after 2025 so that itemized deductions are reduced by 2/37 of the lesser of the deductions or the taxable income above the start of the 37% bracket. When income is far enough into that bracket, each dollar of deduction counts for 35/37 of a dollar, so it saves 35 cents rather than 37. The 37% column in the table therefore uses 35%. Households in the 35% bracket or below are not affected.

The table gives the return a prepayment earns, as an effective annual rate, for a taxpayer whose interest is entirely above the standard-deduction line (d = 1 in every column except the first) and for one whose interest saves nothing. Each cell is (1 + r x (1 - t) / 12)^12 - 1 for note rate r and rate t, with t = 0 for the standard-deduction column. The net investment income tax is not in this table because it taxes the account on the other side of the comparison, not the loan.

After-tax return of an extra mortgage dollar (effective annual) by note rate and the tax value of the interest. Standard-deduction column: no deduction lost. Bracket columns: every dollar of interest saved was deductible at that rate. 37% column uses 35% because of the section 68 rule in P.L. 119-21 section 70111. Computed on this site.
Note rateStandard deduction12%22%24%32%35%37% (valued at 35%)
3.00%3.04%2.67%2.37%2.30%2.06%1.97%1.97%
3.25%3.30%2.90%2.56%2.50%2.23%2.13%2.13%
3.50%3.56%3.12%2.76%2.69%2.41%2.30%2.30%
4.00%4.07%3.58%3.17%3.08%2.75%2.63%2.63%
4.50%4.59%4.03%3.57%3.47%3.10%2.96%2.96%
5.00%5.12%4.49%3.97%3.87%3.45%3.30%3.30%
5.50%5.64%4.95%4.38%4.26%3.80%3.63%3.63%
6.00%6.17%5.41%4.78%4.66%4.16%3.97%3.97%
6.50%6.70%5.87%5.19%5.05%4.51%4.31%4.31%
7.24%7.49%6.56%5.80%5.64%5.04%4.81%4.81%

Read down the standard-deduction column and it is just the compounded loan rate: a 4.00% loan returns 4.07% and a 6.50% loan returns 6.70%. Across to the 24% column the 4.00% loan falls to 3.08%, and at 32% to 2.75%. The 7.24% note rate falls from 7.49% to 5.64% at 24%. The 24% column is the familiar rule of thumb that a 24% itemizer should treat a 4% mortgage as a 3% loan, made exact. It holds only if all the interest saved was deductible, and the standard-deduction line says when that is so.

Most households are neither fully below nor fully above the line. They straddle it. Let I be the year's itemized total and S the standard deduction. A prepayment that cuts interest by X lowers the deduction from the larger of I and S to the larger of I - X and S. The deduction lost is the smaller of X and I - S (and nothing if I is below S). Multiply it by the marginal rate for the tax cost. That is an exact statement for one year, and it is the rule to apply to a bank statement: the part of the saving that is taxed is the part that sat above the line.

The rule makes two checks on the bracket column worth stating. If a household is at 24% but itemizes by only a few thousand dollars, the true cost of the loan is closer to the standard-deduction column than to the 24% column, because most of the interest was never worth anything. And a household that crosses a bracket threshold when the deduction disappears pays the lower rate on part of it. Both corrections lower the tax benefit the table shows.

The interest shrinks every year, and with it the deduction

Amortization front-loads interest. On a level-payment loan the monthly interest falls each month by the principal in the payment times the rate, so a household that cleared the standard deduction line in year one may sit below it by year ten with no change in income. Two loans show how fast. The first is the $350,000, 3.25% loan with 300 months left and a payment of $1,706, the middle loan of the lock-in cost table. The second is a new $400,000, 30-year loan at 7.24%, payment $2,726, on the Freddie Mac average for the week of October 29, 2026.

Interest paid in a given year and balance at year-end, two loans, payments unchanged. Computed on this site from the standard amortization formula; principal and interest only.
Year of the loan3.25% loan: interest in year3.25% loan: balance at year-end7.24% loan: interest in year7.24% loan: balance at year-end
1$11,238$340,771$28,833$396,121
5$9,959$300,709$27,535$377,476
10$8,107$242,733$25,284$345,163
15$5,930$174,542$22,056$298,805
20$3,368$94,337$17,424$232,298
25$356$0$10,780$136,884

The 3.25% loan's interest falls from $11,238 in year one to $8,107 in year ten and $3,368 in year twenty. For a joint filer with $14,000 of other itemized deductions, its interest plus those deductions is $25,238 in year one, already $6,962 below the $32,200 standard deduction, and it never gets closer. A prepayment on that loan never touches the deduction, which is why its return is the full effective rate of 3.30%.

The 7.24% loan behaves differently. A couple with $10,000 of other itemized deductions has $38,833 of itemized deductions in year one, $6,633 above the standard deduction, and the loan's interest keeps them above it until year 15, when interest of $22,056 plus $10,000 totals $32,056 and falls under $32,200. With $14,000 of other deductions the crossing comes in year 20 (interest of $17,424), and with $20,000 it comes in year 25. After that year the deduction is gone and a prepayment earns its full rate. So even at today's rates the value of the interest deduction is a number that fades, and the part of the cushion that matters is only the part above the line in the years when the prepayment would otherwise have saved interest.

The practical reading is that the tax discount in the first table is a front-loaded number. On the 7.24% loan with $10,000 of other deductions, the first 14 years carry some deduction value and years 15 to 30 carry none, so the cost of the loan after year 14 is its full effective rate of 7.49%, whatever the bracket.

Three lump sums worked from balance to horizon

A joint filer in the 22% bracket (taxable income between $100,800 and $211,400 in 2026) has $14,000 a year of other itemized deductions, say $10,000 of state and local taxes and $4,000 of gifts, so the standard deduction is $32,200 and the question is how far mortgage interest lifts the total above it. Three households differ only in the loan. Each prepays with a lump sum, keeps making the same monthly payment, and has no closing cost on the prepayment because the servicer applies the money to principal. The table gives year-one interest saved, the part of that saving that came off a deduction, the tax on that part, and the net return as a share of the lump sum. A prepayment penalty is assumed absent, and the horizon is seven years for the balances shown.

Joint filer, 22% bracket, other itemized deductions $14,000, 2026 standard deduction $32,200. Lump-sum prepayment, payment unchanged, no closing cost, year-one effect. Computed on this site.
Loan before the prepaymentLump sumInterest saved in year oneItemized total before and afterDeduction lostTax cost at 22%Net return on the lump sumStandard-deduction rate22% column of the table
A: $350,000 at 3.25%, 300 months left, payment $1,706$50,000$1,649$25,238 to $23,589$0$03.30%3.30%2.56%
B: $480,000 at 7.24%, 360 months, payment $3,271$100,000$7,485$48,600 to $41,114$7,485$1,6475.84%7.49%5.80%
C: $400,000 at 5.50%, 324 months left, payment $2,373$100,000$5,641$35,834 to $30,194$3,634$8004.84%5.64%4.38%

Household A never itemizes: its total of $25,238 is under $32,200 before the payment and after it, so the $1,649 of interest saved is untaxed and the net return is 3.30%, well above the 2.56% that the 22% column would suggest. Household B sits $16,400 over the line, so every dollar of the $7,485 saved came off a deduction, the tax cost is $1,647, and the net return of 5.84% is within 0.04 points of the table's 22% cell. Household C is the common middle case. Its itemized total of $35,834 is only $3,634 over the line, so only that much of the $5,641 saved was ever worth a tax saving. The deduction lost is $3,634, the tax is $800, and the net return is 4.84%, between the standard-deduction rate of 5.64% and the table's 22% cell of 4.38%.

The balances at the end of year seven show what each lump sum did to the loan itself. A's balance is $215,887 against $278,641 without the payment, and the loan ends in month 240 instead of month 300. B's balance is $273,371 against $439,116, and its loan ends in month 201 of 360. C's balance is $198,071 against $344,903, and its loan ends in month 190 of 324. The payment does not change in any of the three: a prepayment shortens the loan, and only a recast lowers the payment, as the recast guide explains.

One more point comes out of the three rows. A reader who knows only the bracket gets the answer right for B, wrong by 0.46 percentage points for C and wrong by 0.74 for A. The error runs the same way each time, because the table credits a deduction that is not there, and d can be at most 1. The size of the error is greatest for low-rate loans, which is exactly where most readers asking this question are.

What Treasury par yields were in October 2026

The Treasury publishes a daily par yield curve. Its notes describe the rates as yields read from a curve based on the closing market bid prices of the most recently auctioned Treasury securities, taken from indicative bid-side quotations gathered by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York at or near 3:30 p.m., and read at fixed maturities of 1, 1.5, 2, 3, 4 and 6 months and 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, 20 and 30 years. Treasury coupons are paid semiannually, so the yields are treated here as semiannual yields and converted to effective annual rates for comparison. These are market yields on a given day. They are not what any holder will necessarily earn after buying, and a security sold before maturity can sell for more or less than it cost.

The table lists October 2026, from the first trading day (October 1) to the last (October 30), with the month's low, high and simple average across the 21 trading days. The 10-year par yield ranged from 4.94% to 5.31% within the month. The Treasury's file continues past month end: on November 2, 2026 the 10-year par yield was 4.91% and the 30-year 5.28%.

Daily Treasury par yield curve rates, U.S. Treasury, October 1 to October 30, 2026 (21 trading days; file retrieved November 3, 2026). Yields are percent per year on the semiannual coupon basis. Low, high and average computed on this site from the daily values.
MaturityOct. 1, 2026Oct. 30, 2026October lowOctober highOctober average (21 trading days)
1-year4.44%4.36%4.36%4.53%4.46%
2-year4.78%4.56%4.56%4.84%4.74%
3-year4.91%4.65%4.65%4.97%4.84%
5-year5.01%4.71%4.71%5.06%4.93%
7-year5.12%4.80%4.80%5.19%5.02%
10-year5.24%4.94%4.94%5.31%5.13%
20-year5.64%5.34%5.32%5.71%5.51%
30-year5.61%5.31%5.29%5.67%5.47%

Compare them with the mortgage market that month. The Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026, down from 7.32% a week earlier and up from 6.17% a year before, with the 15-year at 6.60%. The Treasury's 10-year par yield on October 29 was 4.98%, which puts the spread between the 30-year mortgage average and the 10-year Treasury at 2.26 percentage points that week. A new borrower pays a wide premium over the safe yield. A homeowner holding a 3% loan sits on the other side of that spread, and the question this article keeps returning to is what the safe yield looks like after tax next to the effective cost of the loan already in hand.

A Treasury security's interest is subject to federal income tax and exempt from state and local income tax, according to TreasuryDirect. That makes the state of residence irrelevant to the Treasury side of the comparison, which is a convenience here, since the tables below carry only federal tax. A taxable account that holds a corporate bond fund, a bank certificate or a savings account would be taxed by the state too, and its pre-tax yield would have to be higher to match.

The mortgage rate at which a Treasury yield and a prepayment tie

The break-even question has a definite answer for each maturity. Take the 10-year par yield of 4.94% on October 30, 2026, convert it to an effective annual yield of 5.00% and tax it at 24%: 3.80% remains after federal tax. A mortgage whose effective cost equals 3.80% breaks even, and that cost corresponds to a note rate of 3.74% for a household taking the standard deduction. At lower note rates the loan costs less than the Treasury yields after tax, and a prepayment earns less than a 10-year note held to maturity. At higher note rates, the prepayment earns more.

For a household that itemizes with every dollar deductible, the bracket cancels. The Treasury interest is taxed at t and the mortgage interest saved is taxed at t, so the break-even note rate is close to the Treasury's pre-tax yield whatever the bracket. That is why the 22% and 24% itemizing cells are nearly identical and sit near 4.9% for the 10-year. The 32% itemizing cell is lower, at 4.65%, because the net investment income tax of 3.8% applies to Treasury interest for filers above $250,000 of modified adjusted gross income ($200,000 for single filers and heads of household, $125,000 for married filing separately), according to the IRS, but does nothing to the mortgage deduction. The 32% columns include it: a federal rate of 35.8% on the Treasury side and 32% on the mortgage side.

Mortgage note rate at which an extra mortgage dollar earns the same after-tax return as a Treasury held to maturity, using the October 30, 2026 par yield for the maturity shown (converted to an effective annual yield, taxed federally, state tax exempt). Standard-deduction columns: no deduction lost. Itemizing columns: all interest saved was deductible at the bracket. 32% bracket adds the 3.8% net investment income tax on the Treasury interest. Computed on this site.
Maturity (par yield, Oct. 30)Standard deduction, 22%Itemizing, 22%Standard deduction, 24%Itemizing, 24%Standard deduction, 32% + NIITItemizing, 32% (Treasury side + NIIT)Pre-tax effective yield
2-year (4.56%)3.54%4.54%3.45%4.54%2.92%4.30%4.61%
5-year (4.71%)3.66%4.69%3.56%4.69%3.02%4.44%4.77%
7-year (4.80%)3.72%4.78%3.63%4.78%3.07%4.52%4.86%
10-year (4.94%)3.83%4.91%3.74%4.92%3.16%4.65%5.00%
20-year (5.34%)4.14%5.31%4.04%5.31%3.42%5.03%5.41%
30-year (5.31%)4.12%5.28%4.01%5.28%3.40%5.00%5.38%

A note rate below the cell means the loan is cheaper than the Treasury earns after tax. So a 3.25% loan with the standard deduction sits under every cell in the 22% and 24% standard-deduction columns, from the 2-year to the 30-year: the 10-year after-tax yield at 24% is 3.80% against the loan's 3.30%, a gap of 0.50 percentage points in the Treasury's favor. A 7.24% loan sits far above every cell: its effective cost of 7.49% against the same 3.80% is a gap of about 3.7 points the other way. The cells in the table are where the crossover sits for everything in between, and the only inputs are the filing situation and the maturity.

Matching the maturity matters more than it looks. A prepayment is a claim on a loan's remaining life. If a loan has 25 years left, the right Treasury is the one that matches the horizon over which the money would be kept, and a household that expects to need the money in seven years is comparing with the 7-year yield, not the 30-year one, because the 7-year security is repaid at par and the 30-year one would have to be sold at whatever price the market sets. Reinvestment is the other limit: a Treasury note's yield is locked only until maturity, and the rate on the money that comes back is not known. A mortgage prepayment has no equivalent exposure, since the interest stops for the loan's remaining life.

Liquidity is not in the yield and is not a quibble. Cash sent to a mortgage comes back through a sale, a refinance or home equity borrowing, and each has its own cost. Interest on home equity borrowing is deductible only if the money is used to buy, build or substantially improve the home, according to Publication 936, so cash taken back out for another purpose carries interest that is not deductible. Treasury securities can be sold on any business day, at the market price that day. The HELOC comparison and the home equity options guide set out what taking equity back costs.

A $100,000 prepayment on a 5.50% loan, from interest saved to the balance at year seven

Inputs: Household C. A joint-filing couple in the 22% bracket owes $400,000 on a loan at 5.50% with 324 months (27 years) left and a payment of $2,373, and has $14,000 of other itemized deductions in 2026 against a standard deduction of $32,200. They send $100,000 to principal. Closing cost of the prepayment: $0, with no prepayment penalty assumed. Stay horizon: seven years. Result: first-year interest falls from $21,834 to $16,194, a saving of $5,641. Their itemized total falls from $35,834 to $30,194, so the deduction falls only to the standard deduction, a loss of $3,634 and a tax cost of $800 at 22%. The net saving is $4,841, or 4.84% of the $100,000. At the 10-year Treasury par yield of 4.94% on October 30, 2026, which is 5.00% effective and 3.90% after 22% federal tax, the same $100,000 would produce about $3,900 in the first year, so the prepayment out-earns the Treasury by about 0.94 percentage points on these numbers. At the end of year seven the loan stands at $198,071 instead of $344,903, the payment is unchanged at $2,373, and the loan ends in month 190 instead of 324. If the same couple had only $9,000 of other itemized deductions, the itemized total would be $30,834 before the payment, under the standard deduction, no deduction would be lost at all, and the net return would be the full 5.64%. Nothing here says the Treasury is the better or worse place for the money, since a Treasury note can be sold and the home cannot.

I bonds: a fixed rate that lasts and an inflation add-on that resets

TreasuryDirect says an I bond's overall rate combines a fixed rate, which never changes for the life of the bond, with an inflation rate that is reset every six months. The rate for I bonds issued from November 1, 2026 to April 30, 2027 is 5.51%: a fixed rate of 1.40% plus a semiannual inflation rate of 2.04%, through the formula fixed rate + (2 x semiannual inflation) + (fixed rate x semiannual inflation), which gives 0.0140 + 0.0408 + 0.0002856 = 0.0550856, rounded to 5.51%. That 5.51% is the rate for the first six months. Only the 1.40% lasts for the life of the bond, and the inflation part is reset on the bond's own six-month cycle. Bonds issued in the May to October 2026 window carry a fixed rate of 0.90% and an overall rate of 5.00% for their first six months. Fixed rates for the last several issue periods were 1.20% (November 2024), 1.10% (May 2025), 0.90% (November 2025 and May 2026), and now 1.40%.

The rules around the bond matter as much as the rate. An I bond can be bought only electronically in TreasuryDirect. One Social Security number or employer identification number may buy up to $10,000 in electronic I bonds in a calendar year, according to the TreasuryDirect page. A bond can be cashed after 12 months, but a bond cashed in less than five years loses the last three months of interest. Federal income tax applies and state and local income tax does not, and the owner chooses between reporting each year's interest and waiting to report it all when the bond is cashed. The $10,000 limit is the practical constraint. A year's purchase is 2.9% of a $350,000 balance. Even five years of maximum purchases total $50,000.

That makes the I bond a small instrument against a mortgage balance, but its arithmetic is simple, and it shows a different kind of break-even. The table asks what inflation component the bond would need, on average over a holding period, to match the after-tax cost of a loan for a household taking the standard deduction. It starts with the loan's effective cost, grosses it up for federal tax (22% and 24%, state exempt, no credit given for deferral), converts it to an overall rate compounded semiannually, and backs out the semiannual inflation rate with the formula above at the 1.40% fixed rate. The inflation rates in the table are annualized, meaning twice the semiannual figure. The inflation component announced for November 2026 is 2.04% per half year, or 4.08% annualized.

Overall I bond rate and annualized inflation component needed, on average over the holding period, for a bond with the current 1.40% fixed rate to match the after-tax cost of a mortgage with no deduction lost. Federal tax at 22% or 24%, state tax exempt, no value given to deferral. Computed on this site; an annualized inflation figure is twice the semiannual rate TreasuryDirect publishes.
Mortgage note rateOverall rate needed at 22%Annualized inflation component needed at 22%Overall rate needed at 24%Annualized inflation component needed at 24%
3.00%3.86%2.45%3.96%2.55%
4.00%5.16%3.73%5.29%3.86%
5.00%6.46%5.02%6.62%5.19%
6.00%7.76%6.31%7.96%6.51%
7.24%9.38%7.92%9.62%8.16%

At 3.00% the bond needs an average inflation component of about 2.45% a year at the 22% rate. At 5.00% it needs about 5.02%. At 7.24% it needs 7.92% a year, nearly twice the 4.08% annualized component announced for November 2026. At 3.00% the announced component is already about 1.7 times what the bond needs. Those are thresholds, not forecasts: the table does not say what inflation will be, and the next reset is set on May 1, 2027.

The comparison also depends on the horizon. A bond cashed before five years gives up three months of interest, which at a 5.51% rate is about 1.4% of the bond's value, so for a holding of 12 to 18 months the penalty alone can erase the difference between the bond and a lower-yielding but fully liquid alternative. For a hold of five years or longer the penalty no longer applies.

The return a taxable fund has to earn to match: pre-tax, by account type

Everything so far set the loan's after-tax cost against Treasury securities, which are the instruments with a published, dated, certain yield. A stock or bond fund is a different comparison, because its return is not known in advance and any number would be a forecast. What can be done without forecasting is the reverse calculation: given a required after-tax return, how high must the account's pre-tax return be to deliver it, where the account is taxed in a particular way. The same dollar in a tax-free account (a Roth account or a health savings account used for medical costs) needs to earn exactly the required return. In a taxable account that pays interest, the tax is due each year at the saver's rate. In a taxable stock fund that is held and sold, tax on the gain comes due when the shares are sold, at the long-term capital gains rate.

For 2026, Rev. Proc. 2025-32 sets the top of the 0% long-term rate at $98,900 of taxable income for joint filers, $66,200 for heads of household and $49,450 for single filers, and the top of the 15% rate at $613,700, $579,600 and $545,500. Above those amounts a higher rate applies, and the 3.8% net investment income tax may apply on top. The table uses 15%, a rate that fits the middle of the income range, and ignores state taxes and any dividend yield taxed each year. A fund holding for 10 years needs a smaller pre-tax return than a bond paying the same after tax, because the tax is deferred, and deferral works for longer holdings.

Pre-tax annual return an account must earn to deliver a given after-tax annual return. Bond or savings interest taxed each year at the federal rate shown (35.8% is 32% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax); stock fund held with the whole gain taxed once at 15% on sale after 10 or 25 years. State taxes ignored. Computed on this site.
After-tax return requiredTax-free accountInterest taxed yearly at 22%Interest taxed yearly at 24%Interest taxed yearly at 35.8%Stock fund, 15% on sale after 10 yearsStock fund, 15% on sale after 25 years
3.00%3.00%3.85%3.95%4.67%3.46%3.36%
4.00%4.00%5.13%5.26%6.23%4.58%4.44%
5.00%5.00%6.41%6.58%7.79%5.69%5.49%
6.00%6.00%7.69%7.89%9.35%6.80%6.54%
7.00%7.00%8.97%9.21%10.90%7.89%7.58%

Pair the table with the first table in this article and the answer is concrete. A 5.00% loan with the standard deduction costs 5.12% effective a year. A bond account taxed at 24% would need 6.73% before tax to match (5.116 divided by 0.76), and a stock fund sold after 10 years would need 5.82%. An itemizer at 24% with all interest deductible faces a 3.87% hurdle on the same loan, whose pre-tax bond equivalent is 5.09% and whose 10-year stock fund equivalent is 4.43%. Those are requirements. Whether any account will earn them is the part nobody can supply, and no table here claims to.

Retirement accounts follow a similar algebra, with the twist that the tax rate at contribution and at withdrawal can differ. A dollar contributed pre-tax costs 1 minus the contribution rate in take-home pay, and is taxed at the withdrawal rate when it comes out. When the two rates are equal, the account has to earn the required return, the same as a tax-free account. When the withdrawal rate is lower, the hurdle falls: with 5.00% required over 20 years, a 24% contribution rate and a 12% withdrawal rate need 4.23% a year in the account, and a 32% contribution rate with a 22% withdrawal rate needs 4.28%. An employer match changes the arithmetic entirely. A hypothetical 50% match on a contribution is a 50% return on the contributed dollar before the fund earns anything, a figure that exceeds every rate in the first table.

A bad first year raises the bar for the nine years that follow

The mortgage side of the comparison has one path and the investment side has many, and the path matters. If the goal is to end a 10-year horizon ahead of a prepayment that earned a fixed rate, an account that loses money early has to earn more in the remaining years to catch up, not just the average. The table shows how much more. It assumes the comparison is a ten-year endpoint, takes a first-year return from 0% down to -40% as an illustration of a possible path rather than a forecast of one, and solves for the annual return needed in each of the following nine years to finish equal to a fixed annual rate compounded for ten years.

Annual return needed in years 2 to 10 to finish a 10-year horizon level with a fixed annual hurdle, after a given first-year return. Hypothetical path; no return is predicted. Computed on this site.
First-year returnTo match a 3% hurdleTo match a 5% hurdleTo match a 7% hurdle
0% (flat)3.34%5.57%7.81%
-10%4.56%6.81%9.08%
-20%5.93%8.22%10.51%
-30%7.52%9.84%12.17%
-40%9.37%11.74%14.10%

A flat first year raises the 5% hurdle to 5.57% over the remaining nine years. A 20% first-year loss raises it to 8.22%, and a 30% loss to 9.84%. The smaller the starting hurdle the smaller the catch-up, but the pattern is the same in all three columns: early losses do not average out, they compound against the horizon. A fixed prepayment return has no such sensitivity, because its yield on the money is the same in year one as in year ten. This is not a claim that markets will fall. It is a statement of what a given path would require.

The reverse also holds. A path that gains in the first year lowers the later requirement, and a horizon longer than ten years spreads the catch-up thinner. The table is meant as a check on the sentence 'stocks average more than my mortgage rate', which is a statement about an average that a 10-year endpoint does not have to deliver.

What a lump sum leaves unchanged, and what other routes do instead

Prepaying principal shortens the loan but leaves the required payment where it was. In the three examples above the payment is the same after the lump sum as before it, and the benefit shows up as a loan that ends 60 to 159 months early. A household that wants the payment to fall instead needs a recast, in which the servicer re-amortizes the lower balance over the original term; the recast guide compares that with a refinance and lists what servicers require. A household whose rate is the problem is in a different decision. The case for paying down a 3% loan is a different question from the case for a refinance, and the refinance break-even guide answers the second.

The same lump sum can also keep a low rate through a move. Selling ends the loan, so a household that expects to sell within a few years does not collect the prepayment return for the years it does not own the house: the return runs only to the sale date and the money comes back as equity in the sale. The sell-or-stay guide puts a dollar figure on what giving up a low rate costs, and the guide to renting out the home and keeping the loan covers the rental route. In both, the question of where a spare dollar goes sits beside the question of whether the loan will still be there.

The tax effects interact with what is paid. Refinance closing costs and points follow their own deduction rules, covered in the refinance closing costs and taxes guide. That guide treats the same 2025 edition of Publication 936 and the 2026 draft this article uses. A payoff by a lump sum has no closing costs of its own, which is why the examples show none, but a payoff that comes with a prepayment penalty adds one, and that penalty is deductible as interest only for an itemizer.

Calculators help with the payment side. CalculatorVillage has a debt payoff calculator with extra payments that shows how a lump sum or a higher monthly payment moves the payoff date. It does not model the deduction, so the tax step in this article is the part to add by hand.

Inputs to collect before running your own prepayment test

  • Your servicer's payoff statement or latest statement showing the balance, note rate and payment, plus the months left on the term.
  • Last year's Form 1098, box 1 for mortgage interest and box 5 for mortgage insurance premiums, and the current year's standard deduction for your filing status.
  • A count of your other itemized deductions for the year: state and local taxes up to the cap, gifts, and medical costs above their floor, added to the interest to see whether the total beats the standard deduction.
  • Your marginal bracket from the 2026 tables, checked against taxable income and not gross pay.
  • The amount by which your itemized total sits above the standard deduction. It is the most the deduction can fall in a year, and so the cap on the tax cost of a prepayment.
  • The dated yield you are comparing with, from the Treasury par curve at the maturity that matches your horizon, with the check date written beside it.
  • Any prepayment penalty clause in the note, and the treatment of a lump sum (applied to principal or held as an advance payment) in writing from the servicer.

Questions about paying down a mortgage and the tax side

Is it smarter to pay off a low-rate mortgage early or invest the money?

The arithmetic can say which clears the hurdle, but not which is smarter. A prepayment on a 3.25% loan earns 3.30% a year with certainty if the household takes the standard deduction, against 5.00% effective on a 10-year Treasury on October 30, 2026 (3.80% after 24% federal tax). The table of required returns does the same work for any rate and bracket. What it cannot supply is the return of an account that is not a Treasury, since that is unknown.

Does paying off my mortgage cost me the mortgage interest deduction?

Only if you itemize, and then only for the part of the interest above the standard deduction line. Publication 936 allows the deduction only for a household that files Form 1040 or 1040-SR and itemizes on Schedule A. In 2026 the standard deduction is $32,200 for joint filers, $24,150 for heads of household and $16,100 for single filers (Rev. Proc. 2025-32). A household whose itemized total is below that figure has no deduction to lose.

How much mortgage interest do I need before itemizing makes sense?

Enough that mortgage interest plus your other itemized deductions exceeds your standard deduction. A joint filer with $10,000 of state taxes and gifts needs $22,200 of mortgage interest, which is a balance of about $307,000 at 7.24% and about $683,000 at 3.25%. The state and local tax cap is $40,400 for 2026 under Public Law 119-21, section 70120, reduced for modified adjusted gross income above $505,000.

Are I bonds a better place for the money than a mortgage payoff?

Comparing them takes care. The 5.51% on I bonds issued from November 1, 2026 to April 30, 2027 is an overall rate for the first six months, made of a 1.40% fixed rate that lasts and a 2.04% semiannual inflation rate that resets. TreasuryDirect caps purchases at $10,000 a year per Social Security number or employer identification number, and cashing in before five years loses three months of interest. The fixed 1.40% is the only part known in advance.

Is mortgage insurance deductible again?

For 2026, yes under Public Law 119-21, section 70108, which removes the termination clause that ended the treatment of premiums as interest after 2021. The early-release draft of Publication 936 for 2026 says the deduction is reinstated and phases out between $100,000 and $109,000 of adjusted gross income ($50,000 to $54,500 if married filing separately). The final 2025 edition still says the deduction expired, because it covers 2025 returns.

Does paying extra on the mortgage lower my monthly payment?

No. The required payment stays the same, and the loan ends earlier. In the examples above the payment did not change after a lump sum of $50,000 or $100,000, and the loans ended 60, 159 and 134 months early. A recast, in which the servicer re-amortizes the balance over the original term, is the way to lower the payment, and it is a separate request.

Run your balance, rate and payment through CalculatorVillage's debt payoff calculator with extra payments to see how a lump sum moves your payoff date, then apply the standard-deduction test from this page to the interest it saves. The keep-or-move topic lists the other routes for a low rate.

Sources and verification

State income tax, the alternative minimum tax, phaseouts other than those named and Medicare income-related premiums are not modeled. The tables assume level payments, a fixed rate, a lump sum applied to principal at once and tax values held at one bracket for the year. Charitable gifts and medical costs are treated as a single amount of other itemized deductions, and the 0.5% floor on charitable gifts is not modeled. Treasury yields are dated market snapshots, not forecasts, and no return is predicted for any stock or bond fund. This page is educational and gives no individual tax or investment advice.