Which way to tap home equity fits your mortgage? HELOC, home equity loan, cash-out refinance and reverse mortgage compared
The rate on your current first mortgage decides most of this. If it sits well below the 7.40% 30-year average (Freddie Mac PMMS, release of October 15, 2026), a home equity loan or HELOC leaves that cheap loan alone, while a cash-out refinance reprices all of it. On a $280,000 balance at 3.25%, raising $75,000 by cash-out cost about $137,300 more in interest and fees over 10 years than a fixed home equity loan in our illustration. A reverse mortgage sits on a separate branch: the youngest borrower must be 62 or older. Below, a decision tree comes first so you can find your branch, then the four options share one matrix, and one household is run through all of them at five different starting rates, so you can find the row that looks like your own loan.
Worksheet steps (10)
- A decision tree that starts from your own rate
- Four products, one matrix
- Why the first lien is the whole argument
- The rate sweep: one household, five starting rates
- What the sweep says, and what it hides
- One owner at 3.25%, all four options on the same 10 years
- The fixed home equity loan, up close
- Where a HELOC fits in the four-way choice
- Separate rules for the reverse mortgage branch
- The three-day right to cancel, product by product
A decision tree that starts from your own rate
Work these in order. Each step either sends you to one product or narrows the field for the next step. The 7.40% figure is the PMMS 30-year average for the week of October 15, 2026; it is a market average, and your own quote can sit above or below it. If the house carries no mortgage at all, the first step falls away, because there is no low first-lien rate to protect; a cash-out refinance on a paid-off house follows its own Fannie Mae and FHA rules.
- Is the youngest borrower 62 or older, planning to stay in the home, and willing to trade a monthly loan payment for a balance that grows? If yes, the HECM branch is worth a counseling session before anything else (step 6). If not, a HECM is not available or not the tool, so continue.
- Find the rate on your existing first mortgage and how many months remain. Set it against the 7.40% average. If your rate is at or above the average, go to step 5. If it is below, continue.
- Below the average, start with a second lien. Do you know the exact amount you need, and do you want a payment that never changes? If yes, price a fixed home equity loan. If the amount is uncertain or will be spent in stages, go to step 4.
- For staged or uncertain spending, a HELOC charges interest only on what you draw. Accept it only if you can absorb a variable rate, budget for the repayment-period payment rather than the draw-period minimum, and live with the chance that undrawn credit is frozen under 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi). If any of those fails, go back to the fixed home equity loan.
- At or above the average, price three structures on the same horizon: a cash-out refinance, a rate-and-term refinance plus a second lien, and keeping the first loan plus a second lien. Use the break-even month on closing costs and the balance owed at your move date, not the payment alone.
- On the HECM branch, compare the growing balance against the equity you want left for yourself or heirs, confirm the existing mortgage can be paid off at closing, and confirm you can keep paying property taxes, insurance and upkeep. If the remaining equity matters more than the monthly relief, return to step 2.
Four products, one matrix
Each product turns equity into cash, but they disagree on almost everything else: whether you get a lump sum or a line, whether the rate moves, what happens to the mortgage you already have, and what you owe each month. The matrix below is built from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's Ask CFPB answers, Regulation Z (12 CFR part 1026) and HUD's reverse mortgage rule (24 CFR part 206), all checked October 22, 2026. Where a cell says "varies", the answer is in your own loan documents, not in a federal rule.
Read the second row first. It is the one that separates a refinance from everything else on the page.
| Feature | Home equity loan | HELOC | Cash-out refinance | Reverse mortgage (HECM) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How the money arrives | Lump sum at closing | A line you draw on during a draw period, which could last 10 years, in the CFPB's example | Lump sum: a bigger new mortgage pays off the old one and you keep the difference | Payment options set under 24 CFR 206.19; ask which ones your lender offers |
| Effect on your first mortgage | None. It is a second lien; the first loan keeps its rate and term | None. Also a second lien | Replaced. The new rate applies to the old balance and the cash | The existing mortgage must be paid off at closing, often from the reverse mortgage itself; other liens must be subordinate |
| Rate type | Usually fixed, per CFPB; some are adjustable | Usually variable; some plans let you convert part of the balance to a fixed rate | Your choice of fixed or adjustable at closing | Rate rules in 24 CFR 206.21; interest is added to a growing balance |
| Closing costs | Fees vary by lender; compare more than the payment | Lenders can charge fees; some plans require a minimum draw | Closing costs on the whole new loan; the CFPB notes you often have to pay them | Fees and charges allowed under 24 CFR 206.31; fees are added to the balance |
| Monthly payment | Fixed amortizing payment on top of the first mortgage | Draw period minimum, often based on the balance; payments often rise sharply in repayment | One payment on the whole new loan | Interest and fees are added to the balance each month, per CFPB; the loan is repaid when the borrower no longer lives there; taxes, insurance and upkeep stay yours |
| Age rule | None | None | None | Youngest borrower 62 or older at closing (24 CFR 206.33) |
| Can the lender freeze or cut it? | No: the money is already paid out | Yes, under conditions listed in 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi) | No: the money is already paid out | Governed by separate reverse mortgage rules, not the HELOC freeze list |
| 3-day right to cancel | Yes, on your principal dwelling (12 CFR 1026.23) | Yes, at opening and at a credit limit increase (12 CFR 1026.15) | Yes with a new lender; with your same lender, only for the new money (12 CFR 1026.23(f)(2)) | Check the rescission notice in your closing package; the rule that applies depends on how the loan is structured |
| When it ends | Paid off over its term, or at sale | Draw period ends, then repayment, sometimes all at once | Paid off over the new term, or at sale | Due when the last borrower dies or the home stops being a borrower's principal residence, subject to program rules |
Why the first lien is the whole argument
A home equity loan and a HELOC are second mortgages. The CFPB's answer on the difference between them says it directly: if you already have a mortgage, either new loan is a second mortgage you pay in addition to the first (CFPB, home equity loan vs HELOC, checked October 2026). That extra payment is the cost of keeping your first loan intact. The benefit is that the rate you locked years ago keeps working on the largest debt you own.
A cash-out refinance makes the opposite trade. The CFPB's description of it is a bigger mortgage that replaces your existing one, with the difference paid to you in cash, and it adds a warning worth taking literally: look hard at the new rate if it is higher than the rate on your current mortgage (CFPB, loans similar to a HELOC, checked October 2026). On a low-rate loan, most of the cost of a cash-out refinance has nothing to do with the cash. It comes from moving the old balance onto a new rate. Other home equity topics take each product further; our page on what a cash-out refinance puts at risk covers the equity cushion and the term restart in more depth. In Texas all three products share one constitutional slot, with an 80 percent cap and a one-year spacing rule; see the Texas cash-out refinance rules.
The reverse mortgage changes the lien picture again. A HECM has to end up first in line: under 24 CFR 206.27(b)(3), other liens must be subordinate to the insured mortgage, and the CFPB's eligibility answer says that if you still owe on your home, you must be able to pay that balance off when you close on the reverse mortgage (CFPB, who can take out a reverse mortgage, checked October 2026). So a HECM also ends your current loan, but it replaces a payment with a balance that grows.
The rate sweep: one household, five starting rates
To show how much the starting rate matters, we held everything constant except the rate on the existing first mortgage. These inputs are illustrations, not quotes or averages. The household owes $280,000 with 25 years (300 payments) left and needs $75,000. The stay horizon is 10 years. The second-lien path is a $75,000 fixed home equity loan at an illustrated 8.50% over 15 years, with $1,500 of closing costs paid in cash. The cash-out path is a new 30-year loan at an illustrated 7.50%, sized at $364,000: the $280,000 payoff, the $75,000, and $9,000 of closing costs rolled into the balance. Payments are principal and interest, computed with the standard amortization formula and rounded to whole dollars.
The only number that changes from row to row is the first column. For context, the 30-year PMMS average was 7.40% in the release of October 15, 2026, against 6.27% a year earlier (Freddie Mac PMMS, checked October 22, 2026).
| Current first-mortgage rate | Second-lien path: monthly payment | Cash-out: monthly payment | Second-lien path: 10-year interest plus costs | Cash-out: 10-year interest plus costs | Cash-out costs more by | Owed at year 10: second-lien path / cash-out |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.25% | $2,103 | $2,545 | $129,049 | $266,351 | $137,302 | $230,184 / $315,934 |
| 4.50% | $2,295 | $2,545 | $161,328 | $266,351 | $105,023 | $239,442 / $315,934 |
| 5.50% | $2,458 | $2,545 | $187,895 | $266,351 | $78,456 | $246,435 / $315,934 |
| 6.50% | $2,629 | $2,545 | $215,026 | $266,351 | $51,325 | $253,030 / $315,934 |
| 7.50% | $2,808 | $2,545 | $242,635 | $266,351 | $23,716 | $259,207 / $315,934 |
What the sweep says, and what it hides
At a 3.25% first mortgage the second-lien path wins every column at once: lower payment, $137,302 less interest and cost over 10 years, and $85,750 less owed at the end. That is the classic low-rate case. Comparing the top and bottom rows also isolates the repricing effect: the gap shrinks by $113,586 between the 3.25% row and the 7.50% row, which is what moving $280,000 from 3.25% to 7.50% costs over the decade on this schedule. The $23,716 left at the bottom row is fees and the slower 30-year schedule.
As the starting rate climbs, the gap narrows fast. Somewhere between 5.50% and 6.50% the cash-out path starts to carry the lower monthly payment, because it stretches the whole debt over a fresh 30 years while the second-lien path pays a 15-year loan on top of a 25-year one. By 7.50% the cash-out payment is $263 a month lower.
Do not read the interest column alone at the higher rates. Part of the second-lien path's interest edge comes from faster amortization: it pays down more principal each month, so it ends the decade owing $56,727 less at the 7.50% row. A household that would take the cash-out precisely to get the lower payment is buying monthly room with a longer, more expensive schedule. That can be a reasonable trade, but it is a trade, and the balance-owed column is where it shows.
One more thing changes at the top of the range. If your first mortgage already carries a rate at or above the current average, the cash-out also reprices your old balance downward or sideways rather than upward. In that case the honest comparison is no longer cash-out versus second lien. It is a cash-out against a plain rate-and-term refinance plus a separate second lien, which our guide to rate-and-term versus cash-out refinancing prices on its own.
One owner at 3.25%, all four options on the same 10 years
Inputs, all illustrations, not quotes: a $280,000 first mortgage at 3.25% with 25 years left, a $75,000 need, a 10-year stay horizon, and an owner aged 58, so the HECM branch is closed by the 62-and-older rule. Keeping the first mortgage alone costs $1,364 a month and charges $77,924 of interest over the decade, leaving $194,186 owed. Adding a fixed $75,000 home equity loan at 8.50% over 15 years with $1,500 of closing costs brings the combined payment to $2,103, total interest plus costs to $129,049, and the year-10 balance to $230,184. Adding a $75,000 HELOC instead, fully drawn at an illustrated 9.00% held flat, interest-only, with $500 of fees, gives a combined payment of $1,927, interest plus costs of $145,924, and $269,186 owed. The cash-out refinance, a $364,000 30-year loan at an illustrated 7.50% with $9,000 of closing costs rolled in, costs $2,545 a month, $266,351 of interest plus costs, and leaves $315,934 owed. On these numbers the fixed home equity loan path is cheapest on interest and lowest on balance owed, the HELOC path has the lowest payment while interest-only lasts, and the cash-out costs about $137,300 more than the home equity loan path and about $120,400 more than the HELOC path. About $113,600 of either gap is the cost of repricing the $280,000 from 3.25% to 7.50%; the rest is closing costs and the 30-year restart. If the owner were 63 instead, the HECM would need the $280,000 paid off at closing, from its proceeds or other funds, before any cash reached the owner, which is a separate calculation with the lender and a HUD-approved counselor.
The fixed home equity loan, up close
The CFPB describes a home equity loan as money borrowed against your equity, paid out as a lump sum, and usually carrying a fixed rate (CFPB, what is a home equity loan, checked October 2026). Its comparison page says such loans may be fixed or adjustable, so confirm the rate type on your own Loan Estimate rather than assuming it.
In the sweep, the home equity loan's payment is $739 a month on $75,000 at 8.50% over 15 years. Across the 10-year horizon it charges $49,625 of interest and leaves $35,998 still owed, so about $39,002 of the borrowed principal is repaid by year 10. That pace is the reason the second-lien path finishes the decade owing less than the cash-out path at every starting rate in the table.
Two features deserve a direct look before you sign. First, the term: a 15-year second lien is expensive per month but cheap in total; a 30-year second lien halves the pain and doubles the interest. Second, the CFPB's warning that if you cannot repay a home equity loan, the lender could foreclose. A second lien is still a mortgage on the house, and debt moved onto it from credit cards becomes debt secured by your home. Folding the same card balances into a first-mortgage cash-out has its own test, the payoff-matched payment worked in the guide to paying off credit cards with a cash-out refinance.
Where a HELOC fits in the four-way choice
Our HELOC versus refinance comparison already prices a line of credit against a cash-out on a single project, so the focus here is where the line sits among all four options.
The HELOC's place in the four-way choice is narrow: it wins when you will draw less than the full line, or repay fast, and you can carry a variable rate. Drawn in full and left interest-only, it is the dearer of the two second-lien paths in the worked example above, and a one-point rise to 10.00% held for the decade adds $7,500 of interest. Its two structural risks are the payment jump when the draw period ends, which the CFPB's HELOC answer describes (checked October 2026), and a lender's right under 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi) to freeze or cut the undrawn line in listed situations, such as a significant fall in the home's value. Repaying a $75,000 balance over 20 years at an illustrated 9.00% would take $675 a month. For the line's freeze test worked on a real balance, and its fixed-rate conversion clauses, see the home equity loan vs HELOC draw-pattern guide.
Separate rules for the reverse mortgage branch
The Home Equity Conversion Mortgage is the most common type of reverse mortgage, per the CFPB, and it is insured under HUD's rules in 24 CFR part 206. The CFPB's answer on types lists three kinds: those insured by the Federal Housing Administration, proprietary loans that are not FHA-insured, and single-purpose loans offered by state and local governments (CFPB, types of reverse mortgages, checked October 2026). The rules below are for HECMs.
The eligibility list is short but firm. Under 24 CFR 206.33, the youngest borrower must be 62 or older at closing. Under 206.39 the property must be each borrower's principal residence at closing. Under 206.41 the borrower, any non-borrowing spouse and any non-borrowing owner must receive counseling, and the lender must hand over a list of counselors at first contact. The CFPB adds that you cannot owe federal debt such as federal income taxes or federal student loans, and that you must have the money, or set aside loan funds at closing, to pay property taxes, insurance, maintenance and repairs.
The payment structure is what sets this branch apart from the rate sweep. The CFPB's reverse mortgage answer says interest and fees are added to the loan balance each month, so the balance grows, and that the loan is repaid when the borrower no longer lives in the home, usually by selling it (CFPB, what is a reverse mortgage, checked October 2026). The HECM rule requires the mortgage to state that the borrower has no personal liability for the outstanding balance (24 CFR 206.27(b)(8)), and it lists the events that make the balance due, including the death of the last borrower or the home ceasing to be a borrower's principal residence (206.27(c)).
So the HECM question is not "which rate is lower". It is how much equity you are willing to let interest and fees consume over the years you stay, against the cash the loan provides now. That is why the decision tree puts it on its own branch rather than in the sweep.
The three-day right to cancel, product by product
Federal law gives you a cooling-off period on most home equity borrowing, but the rule is not identical across the four products, and one common case is narrower than people expect.
For closed-end credit secured by your principal dwelling, for example a home equity loan, or a cash-out refinance with a different lender, 12 CFR 1026.23 lets you rescind until midnight of the third business day after the latest of consummation, delivery of the rescission notice, or delivery of all material disclosures. For a HELOC, 12 CFR 1026.15 applies the same three-business-day window when the plan is opened and when the credit limit is increased.
The narrow case is a cash-out refinance with the lender that already holds your loan. Under 1026.23(f)(2), a refinance by the same creditor of debt already secured by your home is exempt, except to the extent the new amount financed exceeds the unpaid balance, earned unpaid finance charges and the costs of the refinance. In plain terms, the right to cancel covers the new money, not the refinance of the old balance. Purchase-money loans are exempt altogether under 1026.23(f)(1), which matters if a HECM is used to buy a home. For owners 62 and older choosing between the reverse mortgage branch and a cash-out refinance, our reverse mortgage versus cash-out refinance guide runs both on one house over ten years, with HUD's fee formulas and the first-year draw limit.
Common questions
What is the difference between a home equity loan and a HELOC?
A home equity loan pays you a fixed amount up front as a lump sum. A HELOC is a line you can draw on repeatedly, and repaying it frees up the credit again, much like a credit card. Home equity loans are usually fixed-rate, though the CFPB notes some are adjustable; HELOCs usually carry variable rates. If you already have a mortgage, either one is a second mortgage with its own payment.
Can anyone take out a reverse mortgage loan?
No. For a HECM, the youngest borrower must be 62 or older at closing under 24 CFR 206.33, the home must be your principal residence, any existing mortgage must be paid off at closing, you cannot owe federal debt, you need to cover taxes, insurance and upkeep, and you must complete counseling with a HUD-approved agency. Proprietary reverse mortgages that are not FHA-insured set their own terms.
What other types of loans are similar to a HELOC?
The CFPB lists a home equity loan, a cash-out refinance, a personal line of credit, and a credit card. The first two use your home as collateral like a HELOC does. A personal line of credit is based on your credit alone, so limits may be lower and rates higher. The sweep on this page shows how the home-secured options compare once your current first-mortgage rate is in the picture.
I wanted to take out a HELOC but the lender told me the terms have changed. What can I do?
If a term the lender had to disclose changes before the plan is opened, other than a change from the index moving on a variable-rate plan, and you decide not to open the plan because of it, 12 CFR 1026.40(g) requires the creditor to refund all fees you paid to anyone in connection with the application. Ask for the refund in writing and keep the original disclosures.
Do I get three days to cancel a cash-out refinance?
When the loan is secured by your principal dwelling and comes from a new lender, generally yes, under 12 CFR 1026.23. With the lender that already holds your mortgage, the right covers only the new money: the amount financed above your unpaid balance, earned unpaid finance charges and the refinance costs. Your rescission notice at closing states the deadline for your loan.
How is a reverse mortgage repaid?
The CFPB describes it this way: interest and fees are added to the loan balance each month, the balance grows, and the loan is repaid when the borrower no longer lives in the home, usually by selling it. You still must pay property taxes, homeowners insurance and maintenance, and falling behind on those can make the loan due. The balance comes due when the last borrower dies or the home stops being a borrower's principal residence, under program rules.
Sources and verification
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: 30-year fixed average 7.40% and 15-year 6.71% in the release of October 15, 2026; year-earlier 30-year 6.27%. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a home equity loan?: Lump sum, usually fixed rate, foreclosure risk, compare fees. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a home equity line of credit (HELOC)?: Draw period, repayment over 10 or 20 years, variable rate, possible fixed-rate conversion, freeze on value decline. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Home equity loan vs HELOC: Both are second mortgages; home equity loan fixed or adjustable; HELOC usually adjustable. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What other types of loans are similar to a HELOC?: Cash-out refinance definition and the caution about a rate higher than the current mortgage. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is a reverse mortgage? and Can anyone take out a reverse mortgage loan?: Age 62, principal residence, existing mortgage paid at closing, federal debt, property charges, counseling; balance grows with interest and fees (en-224). Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What you should know about home equity lines of credit (booklet): Comparison table of money sources, including cash-out refinance and the HECM age-62 row. Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.40, 1026.15 and 1026.23: HELOC freeze and reduction conditions (1026.40(f)(3)(vi)), fee refund when terms change (1026.40(g)), rescission for open-end (1026.15) and closed-end credit (1026.23), same-creditor exemption (1026.23(f)(2)). Checked October 22, 2026.
- eCFR, HUD Home Equity Conversion Mortgage rule, 24 CFR part 206: Age 62 (206.33), principal residence (206.39), counseling (206.41), subordinate liens, no personal liability and due-and-payable events (206.27). Checked October 22, 2026.
This page compares loan structures on stated illustrations: a $280,000 balance with 25 years left, a $75,000 need, a 10-year horizon, and illustrated rates and closing costs that are not quotes, averages, or predictions. Real home equity pricing depends on your credit, combined loan-to-value, lender and state; HELOC rates move with their index, and the example holds them flat. HECM payouts, insurance premiums and lending limits change and are set by HUD and your lender, so they are not estimated here. Tax treatment of interest is outside this page. Educational only, not a loan offer; your loan documents and a HUD-approved counselor, for the reverse mortgage branch, are the authorities for your own case.