Home equity options

Home equity loan or HELOC? Let the way you spend decide

If you need the whole amount on day one, a home equity loan usually costs less over five years: on a $45,000 one-time bill in our illustration it beats an interest-only line by about $2,775. If the spending arrives in stages over 18 months or more, a HELOC usually wins, because you pay interest only on what you have drawn. On a $90,000 project drawn in three parts it came out about $2,088 ahead, as long as its variable rate rose by less than about 0.6 of a point and the lender did not freeze the line before the last draw. The rest of this page works those numbers and reads the contract clauses that can flip them.

Worksheet steps (11)
  1. Start with the shape of the spending, not the rate
  2. What each contract actually obliges you to do
  3. Scenario A: one $45,000 bill, paid on day one
  4. Why the lump sum wins when the money leaves at once
  5. Scenario B: a $90,000 project paid in three stages
  6. Reading Scenario B without fooling yourself
  7. The freeze clause, measured on this house
  8. Fixed-rate conversion clauses: what the disclosure must tell you
  9. Disclosures that let you price a line before paying any fee
  10. Cancelling either product after you sign
  11. When neither second lien is the right tool

Start with the shape of the spending, not the rate

Both products are second mortgages that sit behind your first loan, and both put the house at risk if you cannot pay. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes the split in one line each: a home equity loan pays you a set amount as a lump sum, while a line of credit lets you draw repeatedly from a maximum and refills as you repay (CFPB Ask, home equity loan vs HELOC, last reviewed August 28, 2026, checked October 2026). Our four-way comparison of home equity options sets these two beside a cash-out refinance and a reverse mortgage. This page stays on the two second liens and asks a narrower question: given when the money leaves your account, which contract charges less and carries less risk?

The answer turns on three facts you can usually state before you apply: how much you need, when each bill is due, and how fast you plan to repay. The table below turns those facts into a starting lean. It is a framework built from the product rules cited on this page, not a rule from any regulator.

Spending pattern and the product it leans toward. Built from 12 CFR 1026.40, CFPB Ask en-106, en-107 and en-247, and the CFPB HELOC booklet. Checked October 22, 2026.
Your spending patternLeans towardWhy
One known bill, due now (roof, tuition invoice, payoff of a single debt)Home equity loanYou use every dollar from day one, so the line's pay-as-you-draw feature saves nothing, and a fixed payment removes rate drift.
Known total, paid in stages over 12 to 24 monthsHELOCInterest runs only on drawn money; a lump sum charges interest on cash that sits idle until the next invoice.
Unknown total, possible but uncertain billsHELOC, with a small limitUndrawn credit costs no interest, though annual or transaction fees may apply.
Staged spending, but the last stage cannot stop halfwayHome equity loan, or a HELOC with a cash bufferA line can be frozen or cut under 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi) before the last draw.
You need certainty of payment above allHome equity loan, or a HELOC with a fixed-rate conversion optionA HELOC rate follows an index; a conversion clause can lock part of it, at a rate the contract sets.

What each contract actually obliges you to do

A home equity loan is closed-end credit. You sign once, the full amount is advanced, and an amortizing payment starts on the whole balance. The CFPB says these loans usually carry a fixed rate (CFPB Ask, what is a home equity loan, checked October 2026), and it adds that upfront fees and costs mean you should compare more than the monthly payment. Nothing about the loan changes after closing unless your note says so.

A HELOC is open-end credit with two phases. During the draw period (the CFPB uses 10 years as its example) you borrow with special checks or a card up to the limit. After it, you stop drawing and repay, often over ten or 20 years, and the CFPB warns that payments are often significantly higher in that phase, and that some plans demand the whole balance when repayment begins (CFPB Ask, what is a HELOC, last reviewed August 28, 2026). The rate is usually variable: the booklet lenders must hand you says it must follow a publicly available index, and most lenders quote it as the index value plus a margin.

The line also carries running costs a loan does not. The CFPB's HELOC booklet (2014 edition) lists annual membership or maintenance fees and a transaction fee each time you draw, and notes that some plans require a minimum draw, for example $300, or a minimum balance kept outstanding. It also points out that the APR on a line is based on the interest rate alone and leaves out points and closing costs, so two lines with the same APR can cost very different amounts to open.

Scenario A: one $45,000 bill, paid on day one

Inputs, all illustrations rather than quotes: you need $45,000 at once. The home equity loan is $45,000 at a fixed 8.25% over 15 years (180 months) with $900 of closing costs. The HELOC has a $45,000 limit at a variable 8.75%, held flat for the whole horizon, with a $400 opening fee and a $75 annual fee. You draw the full $45,000 on day one. The horizon is five years, 60 months. We price the line two ways: paying the interest-only minimum, and paying it down voluntarily as if it were a 15-year loan at its own rate.

We ran each figure through the usual amortization formula and rounded to the dollar. Total cost means interest paid over the 60 months plus the fees; the balance column is what you still owe at month 60.

Scenario A over 60 months. Rates and fees are illustrations, not quotes. Computed October 22, 2026.
PathMonthly paymentInterest, 60 monthsFeesInterest plus feesOwed at month 60
Home equity loan, 8.25% fixed, 15 years$437$16,787$900$17,687$35,593
HELOC at 8.75%, interest-only minimum$328$19,687$775$20,462$45,000
HELOC at 8.75%, paid as a 15-year schedule$450$17,871$775$18,646$35,886

Why the lump sum wins when the money leaves at once

The line's headline feature, interest only on what you draw, is worth nothing when you draw it all on day one. What remains are the line's handicaps: in this illustration a rate half a point higher, an annual fee, and a minimum payment that can leave principal untouched. The interest-only path costs $2,775 more than the loan over five years and still owes the full $45,000 at the end, against $35,593 on the loan.

Discipline narrows the gap but does not close it. Paying the line as if it were a 15-year loan brings the five-year cost to $18,646, still $959 above the loan, because the rate gap and the annual fee keep working. If the two rates were equal, a disciplined line would land within a few dollars of the loan on interest, and the fee difference would decide it. So in the one-bill case the question is narrower than it looks: is the line's rate, after fees, at or below the loan's fixed rate, and will you really pay principal when the minimum does not ask you to?

One more check before you call the loan the winner. The HELOC's payment of $328 is $109 a month lower than the loan's $437. If cash flow is the binding constraint, that gap matters, but it is a loan you are not paying down, not a saving. The worked example further down shows what that cheaper minimum turns into when the draw period ends.

Scenario B: a $90,000 project paid in three stages

Now the spending is staged. A renovation needs $30,000 at the start, $30,000 at month 10 and $30,000 at month 19, so the last invoice lands about 18 months after the first. The home equity loan has to be sized for the whole project on day one: $90,000 at a fixed 8.25% over 15 years, $1,200 of closing costs, payment $873 from the first month. The HELOC has a $90,000 limit at 8.75% variable, $400 to open, $75 a year. You draw each $30,000 when the invoice arrives and pay interest only through month 24. From month 25 you choose, on your own, to pay the line down on a schedule that clears it by the end of year 15, the same finish line as the loan. That schedule is your choice in this illustration; your plan may only require the interest.

Interest-only payments during the build run $219 a month on the first $30,000, $438 once $60,000 is out, and $656 at the full $90,000. In the first 24 months the line charges $9,844 of interest; the loan charges $14,342 over the same months because it bills the full $90,000 from day one. From month 25 the line's voluntary payment is $968.

Scenario B over 60 months. HELOC rate held flat at 8.75% unless stated. Illustrations, not quotes. Computed October 22, 2026.
PathInterest, months 1 to 24Interest, 60 monthsFeesInterest plus feesOwed at month 60
Home equity loan, $90,000 at 8.25% fixed$14,342$33,575$1,200$34,775$71,187
HELOC drawn in three stages, rate flat$9,844$31,912$775$32,687$77,226
Same HELOC, rate up 1.00 point from month 13$10,594$35,296$775$36,071$77,988
Same HELOC, rate up 2.00 points from month 13$11,344$38,697$775$39,472$78,717
Same HELOC, balance converted to 9.00% fixed at month 25$9,844$32,569$775$33,344$77,419

Reading Scenario B without fooling yourself

At a flat rate the line costs $2,088 less in interest and fees over five years. Most of that is the interest the loan charges on money waiting for the next invoice: $60,000 sits idle for the first nine months and $30,000 for the next nine, which at 8.25% is roughly $5,569 of interest, an approximation that ignores the small amount of principal the loan repays in that time. You could park the idle cash in savings and earn something back, which shrinks the line's edge by whatever that account pays.

Do not read the balance column as a tie. At month 60 the line still owes $77,226 against $71,187 on the loan, because the loan started repaying all $90,000 in month one while the line repaid nothing until month 25. The fair measure is interest plus fees, since every dollar of principal paid is a dollar you no longer owe. On that measure the line is ahead only while its rate behaves.

That is the real trade. A rise of between 0.60 and 0.65 of a point from month 13 erases the line's lead in this illustration, and a two-point rise leaves it $4,697 behind the loan. The fixed-rate conversion row shows the other way out: locking the $90,000 at an illustrative 9.00% in month 25 costs $657 more than the flat-rate line, which is the price of removing rate risk for the next decade. Whether a conversion costs or saves depends on the fixed rate your contract sets against where the variable rate goes, and nobody can tell you the second part in advance.

The freeze clause, measured on this house

Scenario B quietly assumes the last $30,000 is still there at month 19. Regulation Z lets a lender block further draws or lower the limit while any of six listed conditions lasts, including a significant decline in the home's value below the appraised value used for the plan, a material change in your finances that leads the lender to reasonably believe you cannot repay, or default on a material obligation of the agreement (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi), checked October 2026). Separately, paragraph (f)(3)(i) lets the initial agreement allow the same freeze while the plan's maximum APR is in effect, which bears directly on the rate-rise rows above.

The official interpretation of that rule gives a test you can run on your own numbers. A decline always counts as significant once it cuts in half the original cushion between your credit limit and your available equity (comment 40(f)(3)(vi)-6 in Supplement I to part 1026). It can count sooner, because the comment says the answer otherwise varies with circumstances. Take a house appraised at $500,000 for the plan, a first mortgage of $300,000 and a $90,000 line. Available equity is $200,000, the cushion above the line is $110,000, and half of it is $55,000. A fall in value to $445,000, an 11.0% drop, is enough on its own for the lender to stop your draws.

Now put that on the renovation calendar. If values slip 11% between month 10 and month 19, you could have $60,000 drawn, a half-built kitchen and no access to the last $30,000. A home equity loan borrower in the same market already holds the cash. That is the hidden value of the lump sum in a staged project, and it does not show up in any interest total.

  • Notice: under 12 CFR 1026.9(c)(1)(iii) the lender must send written notice with specific reasons no later than three business days after it acts. That count uses the general Regulation Z business-day meaning, days the lender's offices are open, not the Sunday-and-holiday count used for cancellation.
  • Temporary only: the commentary says the freeze may last only while the condition exists, and credit must be restored as soon as reasonably possible once it ends.
  • No reinstatement fee: a lender may pass on bona fide appraisal and credit report costs incurred to check whether the condition continues, but it may never charge a fee to reinstate the line once the condition is gone (comment 40(f)(3)(vi)-3).
  • Reinstatement may be on you: a lender can shift the duty to you to ask for reinstatement, and can require that request in writing if its notice says so.
  • A cut cannot force a bigger payment: the limit may not be reduced below the balance you already owe if that would raise your required payment (comment 40(f)(3)(vi)-1).

Fixed-rate conversion clauses: what the disclosure must tell you

The CFPB notes that some HELOCs let you move some or all of the balance from a variable to a fixed rate, and the booklet adds that some lenders let you turn part of the line into a fixed-term installment loan. Whether you have that option, and on what terms, is set in your plan, not by federal law.

If the plan offers it, the official interpretation of 12 CFR 1026.40(d)(5)(ii) (comment 2) requires the early disclosures to explain the rules: the period during which you can choose it, how long repayment runs, any fee for using it, and either the specific fixed rate or the index and margin that will set it. A fixed rate built from an index must use one outside the lender's control and available to the public. Read those four items as a price list. A conversion that sets the fixed rate at a margin above the same index as your variable rate will usually cost more than the variable rate on the day you convert; you are paying for certainty.

One structural detail matters if you convert mid-draw. The general commentary to 1026.40 (comment 40-5) says that if the conversion is agreed after opening and the converted amount does not refill your available credit as you repay it, the new piece is treated as closed-end credit with its own disclosures, and the HELOC rules, including the freeze list, stop applying to that piece. If the converted amount does refill the line, the open-end rules keep applying to the whole plan. Ask which kind your lender offers, because it decides whether you keep the line's flexibility after locking the rate.

Disclosures that let you price a line before paying any fee

A HELOC application comes with a disclosure set that most borrowers skim. Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.40(d), requires several items that answer the questions in this guide directly. The payment terms must give the length of the draw and repayment periods, explain how the minimum payment is set, and warn when minimum payments may not repay principal and a balloon may result. A worked example on a $10,000 balance must show the minimum payment, any balloon and how long repayment takes at a recent rate. For a variable-rate plan, the lender must state the maximum APR, the minimum payment at that maximum on $10,000, and a historical example of how rates and payments would have moved over the most recent 15 years of index values.

Scale those $10,000 figures to your own draw to stress-test Scenario B before you open anything. Two timing rules protect you while you do. Under 1026.40(h), no one may charge a nonrefundable fee until three business days after you receive the disclosures and the booklet. And if a disclosed term other than the index value changes before the plan opens and you walk away for that reason, the lender must refund every application fee under 1026.40(g). The booklet's own example shows the stakes of the index: interest-only payments on $10,000 are about $83 a month at 10% and $125 at 15%.

Cancelling either product after you sign

Both carry a three-business-day right to cancel when your principal dwelling secures them; for a line it attaches when the plan is opened and when the limit is raised, not to ordinary draws within the limit (12 CFR 1026.15). How those days are counted, and what the lender must return, is worked through in our guide to the right of rescission.

When neither second lien is the right tool

Both products assume your first mortgage is worth keeping, or that there is one at all; on a house owned free and clear, a new first lien is a third candidate, priced per $1,000 drawn in the paid-off house cash-out guide. That is usually true when its rate is well below today's market. In Freddie Mac's weekly survey released October 29, 2026, first mortgages averaged 7.24% on a 30-year fixed and 6.60% on a 15-year fixed (Freddie Mac PMMS). Those are first-mortgage averages; the survey publishes no figure for home equity loans or lines, which is why every second-lien rate on this page is a labelled illustration. Our weekly rate tracker keeps the dated history.

If your first mortgage rate is at or above current quotes, a cash-out refinance can beat both second liens, and the refinance versus HELOC comparison prices that case on one horizon. Read the risks a cash-out refinance carries before you go that way. And if the spending is ongoing living costs rather than a project with an end date, neither a lump sum nor a line fixes the shortfall; both move it onto the house. The home equity topic hub gathers every guide on this site about borrowing against the house. If you already hold a second and only its rate is the problem, see refinancing only the second mortgage.

What the $328 interest-only payment becomes

Take Scenario A's line, $45,000 drawn on day one at 8.75%, and suppose you pay only the interest-only minimum of $328 a month for a 10-year draw period. You arrive at the repayment period still owing all $45,000. If the plan then repays the balance over 20 years at the same 8.75%, the payment becomes $398, a jump of $70. That looks mild, but you have already paid $39,375 of interest over the ten years and repaid nothing. Run the same arithmetic on Scenario B's full $90,000: $656 a month interest-only becomes $795 on a 20-year repayment schedule or $1,128 on a 10-year schedule, and if the plan instead ends in a balloon, the whole $90,000 falls due at once. The CFPB booklet's warning is that you must be ready to cover a balloon by refinancing, borrowing elsewhere or paying cash, and that failing to do so could cost you the home. All rates are illustrations held flat; a variable rate can make each step larger.

Questions to settle before you choose

  • Write down each bill and the month it is due. If nearly all of it is due in the first month, Scenario A is your closer model; if it is spread over a year or more, Scenario B is.
  • For the line: draw period length, repayment period length, whether the minimum is interest-only, and whether the plan can end in a balloon.
  • Index, margin, rate cap and the maximum APR, plus the $10,000 payment at that maximum from the disclosures.
  • Annual fee, per-draw fee, any minimum draw or minimum balance, and any fee to convert to a fixed rate.
  • Whether a fixed-rate conversion exists, when you can use it, how its rate is set, and whether the converted amount refills the line.
  • Your own freeze threshold: half of the cushion between your limit and your equity at the plan's appraised value.
  • For a staged project, a cash reserve or a plan B for the last stage if the line is frozen.

Common questions

Can I switch part of a HELOC balance to a fixed rate?

Only if your plan includes that option. The CFPB says some HELOCs let you convert some or all of the balance from a variable to a fixed rate. When a plan offers it, Regulation Z requires the disclosures to state when you can choose it, how long repayment lasts, any fee, and the rate or the index and margin that will set it. Compare that fixed rate with your current variable rate before you act; converting buys certainty and may cost more on the day you do it.

Do I have to borrow a minimum amount each time I use a HELOC?

Some plans require it. The CFPB gives $300 as an example of a minimum draw and notes that some plans require a minimum balance to stay outstanding or an advance when the line is set up. Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.40(d)(10), makes the lender disclose any minimum draw or minimum balance before you open the plan, so the requirement should be in writing.

Why does a HELOC's APR often look lower than a home equity loan's APR?

Partly because they are measured differently. The CFPB's HELOC booklet explains that the APR on a line is based on the periodic interest rate alone and does not include points or other charges, while the APR on a closed-end loan takes account of points and other finance charges. Compare the line's fees in dollars beside its APR, as Scenario A does, rather than comparing the two APRs alone.

Can a lender charge me to turn a frozen HELOC back on?

No. The official interpretation of 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi) bars any fee to reinstate a line once the condition that allowed the freeze has ended. The lender may pass on bona fide and reasonable appraisal or credit report costs it actually incurs while checking whether the condition still exists. If your freeze notice says you must request reinstatement, make that request in writing and keep a copy.

How do lenders decide how large my HELOC limit can be?

The CFPB booklet describes a common method: take a percentage of the home's appraised value, 75 percent in its example, and subtract the balance on your existing mortgage. On a $400,000 appraisal with $220,000 owed, that method gives $300,000 minus $220,000, or $80,000. The lender also weighs your income, debts and credit history, so the final limit can be lower. The percentage is the lender's choice, not a federal rule.

Does the weekly mortgage rate survey track home equity loan or HELOC rates?

No. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey reports averages for 30-year and 15-year fixed first mortgages, 7.24% and 6.60% in the release of October 29, 2026. It is useful for judging whether your first mortgage is worth keeping, but it does not price second liens, so get the index, margin and fees for a line, or the fixed rate and costs for a loan, from each lender in writing.

If your first mortgage rate is close to today's averages, a cash-out refinance belongs in the comparison too, and our refinance versus HELOC worked example prices that third path on a single seven-year horizon.

Sources and verification

Every rate, fee and draw schedule on this page is an illustration with its inputs stated, checked October 22, 2026, not a quote, an average for second liens, or a forecast; the HELOC rate is held flat except in the rows that say otherwise. Your own plan agreement sets the draw and repayment periods, minimum payment, caps, conversion terms and the conditions a lender can rely on to freeze the line, and lenders differ widely on all of them. The examples ignore any interest you might earn on idle cash and any tax effect of home-secured interest, which depends on how the money is used; ask a tax professional about that. This is educational material, not a loan offer or advice to take either product.