Home equity options

Refinancing only your second mortgage: five ways, priced

A new lender can replace your second mortgage without the first lender's consent, because federal law bars a due-on-sale response to a subordinate lien that does not transfer occupancy, and when the first mortgage is cheap that is almost always the better move. With a $240,000 first at 3.50 percent, folding a $50,000 line into one new $290,000 first mortgage costs about $70,000 more in interest and fees over seven years than swapping the line for a fixed 15-year home equity loan.

Worksheet steps (13)
  1. Which kind of second you hold decides the options
  2. What the first lender and the agencies say about replacing a second
  3. The second you pick today is the one you will ask to subordinate later
  4. One house, one first mortgage worth keeping, five paths for the second
  5. Rolling in costs $70,000 more, and fixing the line costs almost nothing extra
  6. Where a HELOC conversion option is disclosed, and where it is not
  7. Why rolling the second into a new first mortgage rarely wins when the first is cheap
  8. Small balances make fixed costs the whole story
  9. Which federal rules apply to a replacement second, and which do not
  10. The paperwork clock on a closed-end replacement
  11. A signing on November 10, 2026 funds on November 16
  12. The month the draw period ends
  13. When the second is bigger than the equity can carry

Which kind of second you hold decides the options

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau defines a second mortgage, also called a junior lien, as a loan secured by your house while you still owe on the first (Ask CFPB, last reviewed September 11, 2024). A home equity line of credit is open-end credit with a draw period followed by a repayment period in which, as the CFPB puts it, payments are often much higher (Ask CFPB, HELOC page, last reviewed August 28, 2026); a home equity loan is closed-end credit with a fixed schedule; a piggyback was taken out at the purchase closing.

Check the note for three things: fixed or variable rate, whether there is a draw period, and whether it was created at the purchase closing. Federal rules differ between an open-end line and a closed-end loan, as the sections below show.

What the first lender and the agencies say about replacing a second

The first lender has no veto over a new junior lien in the ordinary case. Federal law bars a lender from exercising a due-on-sale clause on residential property with fewer than five dwelling units for "the creation of a lien or other encumbrance subordinate to the lender's security instrument which does not relate to a transfer of rights of occupancy in the property" (12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(d)(1), read October 23, 2026). Replacing a second lien with another second lien is exactly that kind of event, so the first mortgage holder does not need to consent and its rate and terms do not change. The new junior lender will still check how large the first loan is, because the first lien ranks ahead of it.

The agencies do not set the price. Freddie Mac's Guide (Section 4204.1, 03/05/25, from the Bulletin 2026-14 compilation) says secondary financing is not eligible for sale to Freddie Mac, and Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B2-1.2-04, 08/06/2025) buys first-lien loans even when the property has subordinate financing; neither buys the second lien itself. A new home equity loan or HELOC therefore stays with the lender that makes it, or is sold in a private market. The practical consequence is that no published agency table tells you the maximum combined loan-to-value, the minimum credit score or the pricing for a replacement second. Each lender sets its own, which makes comparing at least three written offers worth more here than it is on a first mortgage. The rest of the home equity section covers the other ways to borrow against the house.

Do not use the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey as a yardstick for the second. For scale, the October 29, 2026 Freddie Mac release listed 7.24 percent for the 30-year fixed and 6.60 percent for the 15-year, checked November 1, 2026, but those are averages for first-lien purchase loans. A junior lien ranks behind the first and, as the CFPB notes, the second lender may recover less in a sale, which is one reason these loans often carry higher rates. Treat the survey as the floor, never as your expected rate.

The second you pick today is the one you will ask to subordinate later

If you refinance the first mortgage later, the new first lender will want your second lien to stay behind it, and each rulebook sets terms. Fannie Mae requires a recorded resubordination agreement unless state law preserves the junior lien's position (Selling Guide B2-1.2-04, 08/06/2025). Freddie Mac will buy the refinance only with evidence of subordination in the file and scheduled payments on the second that meet the interest due (Guide 4204.1(c), 03/05/25). FHA's streamline requires resubordination and sets no maximum combined ratio (Handbook 4000.1, August 2026 update). Our HELOC subordination guide works that first-lien case in full.

The product you choose now changes what that later request looks like. Fannie Mae counts the full amount of any HELOC, drawn or not, in its home equity combined ratio, and Freddie Mac's HTLTV counts the whole credit line limit while its TLTV counts only the disbursed amount. A replacement line with $75,000 of limit and $50,000 drawn therefore consumes $25,000 more room in a future refinance than a $50,000 closed-end loan would, and the HELOC lender is a company that can say no. A fixed-payment loan has no unused limit to count and no draw period to end, which is an argument for it that has nothing to do with the rate.

One house, one first mortgage worth keeping, five paths for the second

Here are the shared inputs. The house is a one-unit primary residence worth $450,000. The first mortgage has a balance of $240,000 at 3.50 percent with 22 years (264 months) left, a payment of $1,305 principal and interest. The second is a HELOC with a $75,000 limit and $50,000 drawn at a variable 9.25 percent, paid interest only at about $385 a month. The household expects to stay 7 years (84 months). Every rate and cost below is a labelled illustration, not a quote.

The five paths are: keep the line as it is; use a fixed-rate conversion on the line; replace it with a new 15-year fixed home equity loan at 8.50 percent with $1,200 of closing costs; roll both loans into one new $290,000 30-year first mortgage at 7.25 percent with $7,500 of closing costs paid in cash; or pay $20,000 of the line from savings. Seven years is long enough for the differences in structure to show, and short enough to be a realistic stay.

Five paths for the second mortgage over a 84-month stay: $240,000 first at 3.50% with 264 months left, $50,000 drawn on a $75,000 HELOC at 9.25% interest only, home value $450,000 (all new rates and costs are illustrations; computed October 23, 2026)
PathWhat changesMonthly payment, both loansInterest and costs, 84 months (both loans)Owed after 84 months
1. Keep the lineNothing. Variable rate, interest only$1,690 ($1,305 plus $385)$84,505 (first $52,130, line $32,375)$232,524 ($182,524 first plus $50,000 line)
2. Fixed conversion on the line$50,000 converted at 8.75%, 10-year amortization, $150 fee$1,931 ($1,305 plus $627)$74,695 (first $52,130, converted balance $22,415, fee $150)$202,302
3. New fixed home equity loan$50,000 at 8.50%, 15 years, $1,200 costs$1,797 ($1,305 plus $492)$78,900 (first $52,130, new loan $25,570, costs $1,200)$216,735
4. Roll both into a new first$290,000 at 7.25%, 30 years, $7,500 costs$1,978$149,017 (interest $141,517, costs $7,500)$265,339
5. Pay $20,000 down from savings, keep the line$30,000 left at 9.25%, interest only$1,536 ($1,305 plus $231)$71,555 (first $52,130, line $19,425), plus $20,000 of cash no longer in savings$212,524 ($182,524 first plus $30,000 line)

Rolling in costs $70,000 more, and fixing the line costs almost nothing extra

Path 4 is the outlier by a wide margin. It adds about $70,000 of interest and costs over seven years compared with Path 3 and leaves a balance of $265,339 against $216,735. The reason is not the new loan's rate, which looks reasonable next to 9.25 percent. The reason is what the new loan replaces: a $240,000 first mortgage at 3.50 percent. Moving that balance to 7.25 percent costs about $65,000 more interest over the seven years than keeping it would have, before anything else changes, and the new 30-year term restarts the clock on a loan that had 22 years left.

Paths 2 and 3 are not a fair comparison as built, because one amortizes over ten years and the other over fifteen. The conversion's payment is higher ($627 against $492) and its balance lower at month 84 ($19,778 against $34,211) for exactly that reason. Put them on the same term and the gap closes: a 10-year conversion at 8.75 percent with the $150 fee costs $22,565 over the seven years against $22,912 for a 10-year home equity loan at 8.50 percent with $1,200 of costs, and on 15 years it is $26,541 against $26,770. The conversion is ahead by only $229 to $347 either way, so choose on fees, term and what the agreement allows. The CFPB's list of HELOC fees includes a conversion fee, a fee for converting a portion of your balance to a fixed interest rate (Ask CFPB, last reviewed June 27, 2024), so the $150 here is an assumed figure.

Path 1 is cheapest on required payments, which is why people stay in it, and it is the only path where the principal never falls. It also carries the rate risk. Every 1 percentage point increase in the line's rate adds about $500 a year in interest on $50,000. The line's repayment period is a separate risk, covered in the section on payment shock below.

Path 5 is a use of savings, not a loan. It saves $12,950 of interest over seven years on the $20,000 at 9.25 percent. Whether that beats the household's alternative uses of the cash depends on the emergency cushion it leaves. If the same line can be redrawn, paying it down and keeping the line is a flexible form of the same thing.

Where a HELOC conversion option is disclosed, and where it is not

Regulation Z tells a HELOC lender what to disclose at application: the length of the draw period and any repayment period, how the minimum payment is determined, an example of the minimum payment based on a $10,000 balance and a recent annual percentage rate, and the fact that the rate, payment or term may change under a variable-rate feature (12 CFR 1026.40(d)(5) and (d)(12)(i), eCFR text read October 23, 2026). We found nothing in 1026.40 that requires the terms of a conversion to a fixed rate to be disclosed, so they live in your agreement and in the lender's fee schedule.

Before you count on Path 2, get four answers in writing: the fixed rate offered on the day you ask, the repayment term of the fixed portion, the fee, and whether the rest of the line stays variable and available. A conversion that leaves a variable remainder and a live draw period solves a smaller problem than a replacement loan does.

Why rolling the second into a new first mortgage rarely wins when the first is cheap

A combined refinance does not average your two old rates. The new lender prices one new loan at the new rate on the whole amount. The household's current combined cost is a blend: $240,000 at 3.50 percent and $50,000 at the 8.50 percent of a replacement home equity loan, which is a weighted rate of about 4.36 percent. A new first mortgage at 7.25 percent or higher is nowhere near 4.36, and the loan balance it applies to is five times larger than the part you wanted to fix.

Run it the other way to find where rolling in would pay. Keep Path 3's replacement second and change the existing first mortgage's rate until the seven-year cost matches Path 4's $149,017. Over 84 months the keep-both approach (existing first plus replacement second) costs $139,283 if the first mortgage is at 7.25 percent, $147,587 at 7.75 percent and $151,757 at 8.00 percent. So the two paths tie on interest-plus-cost only when the existing first mortgage is near 7.85 percent, which means it was not a low-rate loan to start with. Even at that tie the roll-in owes about $29,000 more at month 84, because the 30-year term has restarted.

The rule of thumb that follows is narrow and checkable. If your first mortgage rate is below today's market for a new first mortgage, the question to answer is how to fix the second on its own. If your first mortgage rate is at or above the new first-mortgage rate you can get, then a combined refinance may be worth pricing, and the guide to rate-and-term versus cash-out refinancing covers how a lender classifies a loan that also pays off a second. For the general case of a house with both a first mortgage and a HELOC, refinancing with a HELOC open covers the first-lien side.

Small balances make fixed costs the whole story

A first mortgage refinance moves hundreds of thousands of dollars, so a rate gap of one point is worth thousands a year. A second mortgage is often $25,000 to $100,000, and the same one-point gap is worth far less while the closing costs are roughly the same size. That makes the break-even month much more sensitive on a second. The table shows the months needed to recover $1,200 of closing costs through interest savings alone, using interest-only arithmetic (balance times the rate gap divided by 12).

Read across the rows: on $25,000, a half-point gain needs 115 months, nearly ten years, so extra payments beat a $1,200 refinance; on $100,000, a one-point gain recovers the cost in month 14. The shortcut ignores principal reduction and the value of removing a floating rate, so put real quotes into the Stay or Refi Calculator afterwards, and see home equity loan versus HELOC for the draw-pattern comparison.

Months to recover $1,200 of closing costs through a lower rate on a second mortgage, interest-only equivalent (computed October 23, 2026)
Balance being replaced0.50 point lower1.00 point lower2.00 points lower
$25,000Month 115Month 58Month 29
$50,000Month 58Month 29Month 14
$100,000Month 29Month 14Month 7

Which federal rules apply to a replacement second, and which do not

The kind of second you take determines the paperwork. A replacement home equity loan is closed-end credit secured by real property, and under Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.19(e)(1)(i), the creditor must give a good faith estimate of the disclosures in 1026.37, which is the Loan Estimate (eCFR text read October 23, 2026). A replacement HELOC is open-end credit and falls under 12 CFR 1026.40 instead: the Loan Estimate does not apply, but 1026.40(h) bars the lender from imposing nonrefundable fees until three business days after you receive the disclosures and brochure, and 1026.40(g) requires fees to be refunded if a disclosed term changes and you decide not to open the plan.

The ability-to-repay rule is narrower than many borrowers expect. Section 1026.43 applies to consumer credit transactions secured by a dwelling but exempts a home equity line of credit subject to 1026.40, so the closed-end replacement faces the rule's full requirement that the creditor make a reasonable, good faith determination that you can repay according to the loan's terms, while a replacement line does not. That is one reason closed-end seconds can be harder to qualify for at a given balance, and why you should look at both product types before assuming the line is the easy answer.

Both products create a lien on your principal dwelling, which brings the right of rescission under 12 CFR 1026.23: you may cancel until midnight of the third business day after consummation, and funds are not released until that window closes. Our rescission calendar shows how the days count around weekends and federal holidays.

The paperwork clock on a closed-end replacement

A replacement home equity loan runs on fixed regulatory dates that you can use to plan the payoff of the old line. The table lists them in order, with the rule each comes from (12 CFR 1026.19 and 1026.23, eCFR text read October 23, 2026).

Required timing for a closed-end second-lien refinance, in order
StepRuleWhat it means for the payoff date
Application receivedLoan Estimate delivered or mailed not later than the third business day after the application (1026.19(e)(1)(iii)(A))Collect Loan Estimates from at least three lenders in the same week so the offers can be compared
Before the Loan Estimate and your intent to proceedNo fee may be imposed other than a bona fide, reasonable fee for the credit report (1026.19(e)(2)(i))An application or appraisal fee demanded earlier is a question to put to the lender
Before signingFinal disclosures received no later than three business days before consummation (1026.19(f)(1)(ii)(A))Signing cannot be moved up at the last minute
After signingRight to rescind until midnight of the third business day after consummation (1026.23(a)(3))The old line is paid off only after the window closes

A signing on November 10, 2026 funds on November 16

Suppose the consummation date is Tuesday, November 10, 2026. For rescission, Sundays and federal public holidays do not count and Saturdays do. Wednesday, November 11 is Veterans Day, so the three business days are Thursday the 12th, Friday the 13th and Saturday the 14th. The right to cancel runs through midnight Saturday, and funds move on Monday, November 16. Anyone who planned to stop the old line's interest on Friday the 13th pays the line's interest for three more days: about $38 on $50,000 at 9.25 percent. That is small beside the fees, but a payoff statement quoted for the wrong date can come up short, and the old lender must send an accurate one within seven business days of a written request, as the FAQ below explains.

The month the draw period ends

Many people refinance a second mortgage for a reason that has nothing to do with the rate: the draw period is ending. On the example line, $50,000 at 9.25 percent costs $385 a month in interest only. If the line enters a 20-year repayment period at the same rate, the payment becomes $458. If it enters a 10-year repayment, the payment becomes $640, an increase of $255 a month. If the lender requires the balance in full at the end of the draw period, a possibility the CFPB's booklet describes under the heading of a balloon payment, you need to refinance or find the money. The booklet puts the consequence plainly: if you are unable to make the balloon payment, you could lose your home.

Read your agreement for three dates: the end of the draw period, the length of the repayment period, and whether the plan allows renewal. Start the replacement process several months before the earliest of them. A line frozen or reduced during the process makes it harder. Regulation Z lets a creditor prohibit further draws or reduce the limit when the value of the dwelling declines significantly below its appraised value, 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi)(A).

When the second is bigger than the equity can carry

A new lender wants a combined loan-to-value ratio it can live with. The inputs here are $240,000 plus $50,000 against a $450,000 value, a combined ratio of 64.4 percent, with more than a third of the value unborrowed. If home values near you have dropped so that the same debts sit at 90 or 100 percent of value, a replacement second may be unavailable at any price, and the better question is whether the existing lender will modify the terms. In that case compare the options for payments you cannot carry before spending money on applications. If you only suspect a lower value, a low appraisal changes the arithmetic in the way described in our guide to a refinance appraisal that comes in low.

Do not take a new loan to repay a second you cannot afford to rebuild. Replacing a line with a longer-term loan lowers the required payment, but it can raise the total interest paid, which the CFPB warns about when equity is used to pay other debts: the debt is replaced with one secured by your home, and stretching repayment over many years can cost more overall.

Common questions

How do I get an exact payoff for my current second mortgage or HELOC?

Ask in writing. Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.36(c)(3), requires the creditor, assignee or servicer to send an accurate statement of the total outstanding balance needed to pay the obligation in full as of a specified date within a reasonable time and in no case more than seven business days after a written request. The paragraph applies to a home equity line of credit secured by a dwelling even though the rest of section 1026.36 does not. Ask for the figure as of your expected funding date, after the rescission window, and ask whether a closure fee applies.

Will closing my old HELOC cost a fee?

It can. Among the fees the CFPB says some lenders charge is one for ending a HELOC early, typically in the first two or three years (Ask CFPB, last reviewed June 27, 2024). Read the agreement for the early closure clause before choosing the replacement date, and add any fee to the cost of Paths 2 to 4. A line opened more than three years ago often has no such fee, but the agreement controls.

Does the right to cancel apply when my current lender makes the replacement loan?

Often only in part. 12 CFR 1026.23(f)(2) exempts certain refinancings by the same creditor, but rescission still applies to the extent the new amount financed exceeds the unpaid principal balance. A replacement loan that adds cash, or finances closing costs on top of the old balance, therefore carries the three-day window on the new money. Ask the lender in writing which parts of your loan are rescindable.

Is interest on a replacement home equity loan deductible?

It depends on how the money was originally spent, not on the new lender. IRS Publication 936 (2025 edition, read October 23, 2026) limits the deduction for home equity interest to cases where the borrowed funds paid for acquiring, building or major improvement of the same property that backs the loan, and treats refinanced acquisition debt as acquisition debt only up to the old balance. A line spent on a remodel keeps that character when replaced; a line spent on a car does not gain it. This is general information, not tax advice.

Can I convert only part of my HELOC to a fixed rate and keep drawing on the rest?

Some plans allow it. The CFPB says some HELOCs let you convert part or all of your balance to a fixed rate, which is usually higher but more predictable (Ask CFPB, last reviewed August 28, 2026). Whether the remainder stays available, how many conversions the agreement allows and what the fee is are contract terms. A partial conversion leaves the unused limit counting in future combined-ratio tests, as described above.

Before you collect second-lien quotes, put the first mortgage through the stay-horizon test in how much lower a rate has to be to refinance, so you know whether the 3.50 percent loan is worth protecting.

Sources and verification

Specific to this page: the five-path table keeps the first mortgage at 3.50 percent and 264 months in every path except the roll-in, uses an interest-only line against amortizing replacements, and treats the $150 conversion fee and every new rate as stand-ins, so the 7.85 percent tie point is the number to recompute with real quotes. The November 2026 calendar example follows the federal holiday list and does not account for a lender's own closing schedule. Second-lien pricing, combined-ratio ceilings and fees are set lender by lender and none is published here. Purchase-money seconds, assistance loans and investment properties are not covered, and the page is general education, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a loan offer.