Home equity options

Reverse mortgage or cash-out refinance at 62 and older? Both loans priced on one house over ten years

A cash-out refinance keeps a monthly payment and pays the balance down; a HECM reverse mortgage removes the payment and lets the balance grow. On one $450,000 house with $95,000 owed and $60,000 needed, the cash-out costs about $1,074 a month and leaves about $311,400 of equity after ten years, while the HECM costs nothing monthly and leaves about $106,500, holding the home's value flat. The HECM household keeps about $128,900 of payments in its pocket and gives up about $204,900 of equity to do it. That trade, monthly cash now against equity later, is the whole decision. This guide builds both cost stacks from HUD's regulation and mortgagee letters, runs the ten-year balance path, and shows where each loan breaks: the first-year draw limit, the payment you must qualify for, and what happens when you move or die.

Worksheet steps (11)
  1. Two loans that run in opposite directions
  2. The HECM cost stack, from the regulation up
  3. The cash-out cost stack
  4. One house, both loans: the stated inputs
  5. The first-year draw limit, and why the $60,000 may not arrive at once
  6. The balance path over ten years
  7. Reading the gap: monthly cash now against equity later
  8. What ends each loan, and what heirs inherit
  9. Taxes on the cash and the interest
  10. Edge cases that break the comparison
  11. A decision rule you can apply to your own numbers

Two loans that run in opposite directions

Both loans turn home equity into cash and both replace the mortgage you have now. After that they disagree on almost everything. A cash-out refinance is a larger forward mortgage: you borrow more than you owe, the difference comes to you at closing, and you repay the whole amount in monthly installments. A Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, the reverse mortgage insured by FHA under 24 CFR part 206, pays off your existing loan from its proceeds and then requires no monthly principal and interest payment at all; interest and mortgage insurance are added to the balance instead, and the loan is repaid when it becomes due, usually when the home is sold.

The table puts the structural differences in one place. Each HECM row comes from the regulation or from HUD's mortgagee letters; each cash-out row comes from the Fannie Mae Selling Guide or the general mechanics of a forward loan. Read the second and third rows first. They decide most households' answer before any rate is quoted.

HECM and conventional cash-out refinance compared. Sources: 24 CFR 206, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-12, HUD press release 25-145, Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-03, IRS Publication 936, checked October 30, 2026.
FeatureHECM reverse mortgageCash-out refinance
Who can borrowYoungest borrower 62 or older at closing; home is each borrower's principal residence; counseling requiredAny age; qualifies on income, credit and equity
Monthly principal and interestNone required; interest and mortgage insurance added to the balanceRequired for the full term
Balance over timeGrowsFalls
Upfront mortgage insurance2% of the maximum claim amountNone on a conventional loan at or below 80% loan-to-value
Ongoing mortgage insurance0.50% a year of the outstanding balanceNone at or below 80% loan-to-value
Lender origination feeCapped by regulation, at most $6,000Not capped by a program formula
When it must be repaidWhen the last borrower dies or no borrower lives there, or on default such as unpaid property chargesMonthly, until paid off or the home is sold
Owner's taxes, insurance, upkeepStill owed; failing to pay can make the loan dueStill owed, usually through escrow
Tax treatment of the cashLoan advances, not income; accrued interest generally not deductibleLoan proceeds, not income; interest deductible only on debt used to buy, build or improve

Our wider comparison of home equity options sets these two beside a HELOC and a home equity loan for owners of any age. This page goes deeper on the two products a 62-plus owner is most often choosing between, and prices them on one house.

The HECM cost stack, from the regulation up

A HECM's upfront costs are unusually well defined, because HUD writes most of them. Start with the maximum claim amount. For a refinance it is the lesser of the home's appraised value and HUD's national limit. HUD announced on December 11, 2025 that the HECM maximum claim amount rises from $1,209,750 to $1,249,125 for FHA case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026, in all areas including Alaska, Hawaii, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands. On a $450,000 house, the maximum claim amount is $450,000.

The initial mortgage insurance premium is set by HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-12, effective for case numbers assigned on or after October 2, 2017: 2.00 percent of the maximum claim amount. On $450,000 that is $9,000, and it does not depend on how much you draw. The same letter set the annual premium at 0.50 percent of the outstanding balance, and the regulation at 24 CFR 206.105 describes it as accruing from closing on the remaining balance. That annual premium is added to the balance along with interest, which is why the balance of a HECM grows faster than its note rate alone.

The lender's origination fee has a formula in 24 CFR 206.31(a)(1): the greater of $2,500 or 2 percent of the first $200,000 of the maximum claim amount, plus 1 percent of any portion above $200,000, with the total capped at $6,000. On $450,000 the formula gives $4,000 plus $2,500, or $6,500, and the cap brings it to $6,000. The regulation lets the lender charge less, and lets the fee be financed. Third-party closing costs such as the appraisal, title work and recording fees are allowed at reasonable and customary amounts not exceeding what the lender actually paid.

  • Initial mortgage insurance: 2.00% of the maximum claim amount, $9,000 on $450,000.
  • Origination: greater of $2,500 or 2% of the first $200,000 plus 1% above it, capped at $6,000.
  • Third-party costs: appraisal, title, recording and similar, at amounts actually paid.
  • Ongoing: interest at the note rate plus 0.50% a year mortgage insurance, both added to the balance.

The cash-out cost stack

A conventional cash-out refinance has fewer named charges and one large hidden one. The named charges are the ordinary closing costs this site breaks down line by line in its guide to refinance closing costs: lender fees, title, appraisal, recording and any points. There is no upfront mortgage insurance at or below 80 percent loan-to-value, which is the usual ceiling for a one-unit cash-out refinance sold to Fannie Mae.

The hidden cost is the rate on the old balance. A cash-out refinance does not add a new loan beside your mortgage; it replaces the mortgage. If your existing loan carries a lower rate than the cash-out quote, every dollar you already owed is repriced upward. On the example below, the existing $95,000 sits at 4.00 percent with 12 years left, and moving it to an illustrated 7.00 percent over a fresh 30 years costs more than the $60,000 of new cash does over the first decade. Our page on what a cash-out refinance puts at risk works through the same effect from the equity side.

Fannie Mae's cash-out rules, in Selling Guide section B2-1.3-03, also require the existing first mortgage being paid off to be at least 12 months old, measured note date to note date, and at least one borrower to have been on title for six months before disbursement. Most owners in their sixties clear both easily. The real gate is income: a cash-out lender needs the payment to fit within debt-to-income limits, which a reverse mortgage does not ask in the same way.

One house, both loans: the stated inputs

Every figure below is an illustration chosen to show the arithmetic, not a quote, a market average, or a HUD principal limit factor. An owner aged 68 has a home worth $450,000 and owes $95,000 at 4.00 percent with 12 years left, paying about $831.75 a month in principal and interest. The owner wants $60,000 for a roof, a car and a cash cushion, and expects to stay at least ten years. To keep the comparison clean, the home's value is held flat at $450,000 for all ten years. That is an assumption to isolate the loans, not a forecast.

Cash-out refinance: a new 30-year fixed loan for the $95,000 payoff, the $60,000 of cash and $6,500 of closing costs, about $161,500 at an illustrated 7.00 percent, paying about $1,074.46 a month. That is about 35.9 percent of value, far below any cash-out ceiling.

HECM: an adjustable-rate HECM at an illustrated 6.50 percent note rate, with the 0.50 percent annual mortgage insurance on top, so the balance grows at about 7.00 percent a year compounded monthly. Upfront costs are the $9,000 initial premium, the $6,000 capped origination fee and $3,500 of third-party costs, all financed. Suppose the lender's quote shows an initial principal limit of $215,000. That figure is a hypothetical input for this page; the real one comes from HUD's principal limit factor for the youngest borrower's age and the expected rate on your own quote.

The first-year draw limit, and why the $60,000 may not arrive at once

A cash-out refinance pays its cash at closing. A HECM limits what can be paid out in the first year. Under 24 CFR 206.25, for an adjustable-rate HECM the most that can be disbursed at closing and during the first 12 months is the lesser of two amounts: the greater of a Commissioner-set share that may not be less than 50 percent of the principal limit, or the mandatory obligations plus a Commissioner-set percentage of at least 10 percent of the principal limit; and the principal limit less certain set-asides. HUD sets the exact percentages by notice, so ask your lender for the first-year limit printed on your own quote.

Mandatory obligations include the payoff of existing liens and the financed closing costs. On the example they are the $95,000 payoff plus $18,500 of costs, $113,500 in all. The regulation's floor guarantees at least those obligations plus 10 percent of the $215,000 principal limit, or $135,000, which leaves at least $21,500 of cash in year one. The remaining $38,500 of the owner's $60,000 waits until the first 12 months have passed. Fifty percent of the principal limit would be only $107,500, below the obligations, so in this case the obligations-plus-10-percent route is the one that applies, unless HUD's current notice sets a higher figure.

That timing can decide the choice. An owner who needs the whole $60,000 for an urgent repair in month two may find the HECM delivers only part of it, while the cash-out pays it all at the table. An owner who needs a little now and a line of credit for later finds the HECM fits the need better. A fixed-rate HECM is different again: under 24 CFR 206.17(b)(1), fixed-rate HECMs must use the single lump sum payment option, so there is no line of credit to draw from later.

The balance path over ten years

Now run both loans forward. The HECM starts at $135,000, the mortgage obligations plus the $21,500 first-year draw, and takes the second draw of $38,500 at the end of month 12. The cash-out starts at $161,500 and amortizes. The third column shows the existing loan for reference, as if the owner borrowed nothing at all.

Balance owed on a $450,000 home, value held flat, illustration with stated inputs. Arithmetic by StayOrRefi, October 30, 2026.
Point in timeHECM balanceCash-out balanceKeep existing loan, no cash
Closing$135,000$161,500$95,000
End of year 1, after second drawAbout $183,259About $159,859About $88,704
End of year 5About $242,278About $152,023About $60,850
End of year 10About $343,460About $138,587About $19,154
Monthly payment$0$1,074.46$831.75 for 12 years
Total paid in 10 years$0About $128,936About $99,810
Equity at year 10About $106,540About $311,413About $430,846

The HECM column compounds 7.00 percent a year monthly on the balance. If the home's value never moves, the HECM balance would reach 95 percent of $450,000 in about month 158, a little after year 13. Past that point the loan's non-recourse feature, discussed below, starts to matter.

Reading the gap: monthly cash now against equity later

After ten years the cash-out household has paid about $128,936 in mortgage payments and holds about $311,413 of equity. The HECM household has paid nothing and holds about $106,540. The equity gap is about $204,873. Take away the payments the HECM household never made and the HECM has cost about $75,937 more over the decade, before counting anything the HECM household earned or avoided by keeping $1,074 a month. That is the price of turning a mortgage payment into a growing balance on these inputs.

Whether that price is worth paying depends on what the monthly payment would have displaced. For an owner whose income comfortably covers $1,074 a month, the cash-out leaves far more wealth at year ten. For an owner whose income would be stretched by any mortgage payment, the HECM may be the only way to get the cash without risking the home through missed payments, and the equity it consumes buys security of a kind the table cannot price. For an owner whose main goal is leaving the house to heirs, the cash-out or the keep-the-old-loan path preserves far more.

Notice the third column too. Keeping the 4.00 percent loan and raising the $60,000 another way, through a home equity loan or HELOC beside the first mortgage, avoids repricing the $95,000 at all. Our comparison of a cash-out refinance against a HELOC prices that route; at 68, with income to support a second payment, it often beats both loans on this page. More options on that list are in our home equity hub.

What ends each loan, and what heirs inherit

A cash-out refinance ends when it is paid off, whether by the last payment, a sale, or another refinance. If the owner dies, the loan continues as a debt secured by the house, and a relative who inherits can usually keep paying it under the protections our guide on inheriting a house with a mortgage explains.

A HECM ends on events written into the mortgage. Under 24 CFR 206.27(c), the balance becomes due in full when a borrower dies and the property is not the principal residence of at least one surviving borrower, subject to a deferral period for an eligible non-borrowing spouse, or when the borrower conveys title and no other borrower keeps it. With HUD's approval it can also become due if the home stops being a borrower's principal residence, if a borrower is absent for more than 12 consecutive months because of physical or mental illness, or if the borrower fails to pay property charges such as taxes and insurance. That last trigger is the one owners underestimate: a reverse mortgage has no payment, but it still needs the tax bill and the insurance premium paid on time.

When a HECM becomes due, 24 CFR 206.125 lets the borrower, the estate or the heirs pay the balance in full, or sell the property for at least an amount HUD sets by notice, which can be no more than 95 percent of the appraised value, with net proceeds applied to the loan. The HECM mortgage must also state that the borrower has no personal liability for the outstanding balance. In the example, if the house were worth less than the balance when the loan came due, the heirs would not owe the difference; FHA's insurance absorbs it, which is part of what the mortgage insurance premiums pay for.

Taxes on the cash and the interest

IRS Publication 936 (2025) treats reverse mortgage payments as loan advances, not income, so the amount you receive is not taxable. It also says that interest, including original issue discount, accrued on a reverse mortgage is generally treated as interest on home equity debt and generally is not deductible. For many owners who take the standard deduction this changes nothing, but for an owner who itemizes, the HECM's growing interest bill does not produce a deduction while it accrues.

Cash-out proceeds are loan proceeds too, so they are not income. The same publication says debt not used to buy, build or substantially improve a qualified home is not home acquisition debt, which limits how much of the new interest can be deducted. On the example, the part of the cash-out that repays the old $95,000 and the part spent on a new roof would be treated differently from the part spent on a car. If the deduction matters to you, keep records of what the cash paid for, and see our guide on refinance closing costs and taxes for how points on each loan are handled.

Edge cases that break the comparison

The ten-year table assumes a single owner who stays, a home that holds its value and an existing loan with nothing unusual about it. Each of the situations below changes the answer.

  • A spouse under 62. Only borrowers who are 62 or older at closing can be HECM borrowers, and the principal limit depends on the youngest borrower or eligible non-borrowing spouse. The regulation's deferral period protects an eligible non-borrowing spouse from the loan becoming due on the borrower's death, subject to its conditions, and that spouse must also attend counseling.
  • A move within a few years. The HECM's $18,500 of upfront costs on the example are paid whether the loan lasts two years or twenty. On a short stay they dominate, and the cash-out's lower upfront cost and falling balance usually win.
  • A recent second lien. Under 24 CFR 206.36, other liens can be paid off with HECM proceeds only if they have been in place longer than 12 months before closing, or resulted in $500 or less of cash to the borrower.
  • A PACE assessment. HUD treats a PACE obligation as a mandatory obligation that must be paid at closing on a HECM; our solar and PACE refinance guide explains the forward-mortgage side.
  • A home worth more than the national limit. The maximum claim amount stops at $1,249,125 for 2026 case numbers, so value above that does not raise the principal limit, while a cash-out can still lend against it within the loan-to-value cap.
  • Income too low for a cash-out. If the cash-out payment does not fit, that path is closed regardless of the arithmetic, and the decision is between a HECM, a smaller cash need, or selling.

A decision rule you can apply to your own numbers

Run your own version of the ten-year table before choosing. The HECM figures come from your lender's quote and your counseling session: maximum claim amount, principal limit, first-year limit, note rate and costs. The cash-out figures come from a Loan Estimate. The Stay or Refi Calculator handles the forward-loan side; for the HECM, the counselor HUD requires you to see before applying can walk through the balance projection with you. Then use the rules below as a first sort.

  1. If a monthly payment would strain your income, the cash-out is the riskier loan even when it is cheaper; start with the HECM and the counselor.
  2. If the payment fits easily and you plan to stay ten years or more, price the cash-out and the keep-the-old-loan-plus-second-mortgage route first; they usually leave more equity.
  3. If you need all the cash immediately, check the HECM first-year limit on your quote before going further.
  4. If you might move within five years, weigh the HECM's upfront costs against the cash-out's on that short horizon.
  5. If leaving the house to heirs matters most, compare equity at your expected horizon, not monthly cash.
  6. Whichever you choose, budget for taxes, insurance and upkeep, which both loans leave with you.

Counting the skipped payment as money saved

Comparing the HECM's zero payment with the cash-out's monthly payment and stopping there. The payment you skip is not saved; it is added to the balance with interest and mortgage insurance on top. On the example, keeping about $128,900 of payments cost about $204,900 of equity in ten years.

Numbers to collect before choosing

  • Your maximum claim amount: the lesser of appraised value and $1,249,125 for 2026 case numbers.
  • HECM upfront costs: 2% initial premium, origination by the HUD formula, third-party costs.
  • Principal limit and first-year disbursement limit from your own quote.
  • A cash-out Loan Estimate with the rate applied to your whole balance.
  • Balance and equity at your expected horizon on both loans, value held flat.
  • A plan for property taxes and insurance under either loan.

Common questions

Is a reverse mortgage or a cash-out refinance cheaper?

On upfront and total cost, a cash-out refinance is usually cheaper for an owner who can afford its payment, because its balance falls while a HECM's grows with interest and 0.50 percent annual mortgage insurance. On the example here, the HECM left about $204,900 less equity after ten years while saving about $128,900 of payments.

How much does a HECM cost upfront?

The initial mortgage insurance premium is 2 percent of the maximum claim amount under HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-12. The origination fee is the greater of $2,500 or 2 percent of the first $200,000 plus 1 percent above it, capped at $6,000 by 24 CFR 206.31. Third-party closing costs are added on top.

Can I get all my reverse mortgage money at closing?

Not always. For adjustable-rate HECMs, 24 CFR 206.25 limits first-year disbursements, with a floor of the mandatory obligations, such as paying off your current mortgage and costs, plus at least 10 percent of the principal limit. Fixed-rate HECMs pay a single lump sum at closing.

What is the HECM limit for 2026?

HUD announced on December 11, 2025 that the HECM maximum claim amount is $1,249,125 for FHA case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026, up from $1,209,750, and that it applies in all areas, including Alaska, Hawaii, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands.

Do my heirs owe the reverse mortgage if it exceeds the home's value?

No. The HECM mortgage must state that the borrower has no personal liability for the outstanding balance, and under 24 CFR 206.125 the estate or heirs may satisfy the loan by paying it or by selling for at least an amount HUD sets, which can be no more than 95 percent of the appraised value.

Is reverse mortgage money taxable?

IRS Publication 936 says reverse mortgage payments are loan advances, not income, so they are not taxable. It also says interest accrued on a reverse mortgage is generally treated as home equity debt interest and generally is not deductible.

If the monthly payment fits your budget, start with the forward side: enter your current loan, the cash-out quote and your planned years in the home in the Stay or Refi Calculator to see what repricing your existing balance costs. Then take that figure to the HECM counseling session, where the balance projection gives you the other half of the comparison.

Sources and verification

Educational explanation, not a loan offer, not tax advice and not a substitute for the HECM counseling HUD requires. Rates, the principal limit and closing costs in the example are labelled illustrations, not quotes, market averages or HUD principal limit factors. Home value is held flat to isolate the loans and is not a forecast. Proprietary reverse mortgages and state programs follow different rules.