Rentals, second homes and keep-or-move
Renting out your home and keeping its low-rate mortgage: what the loan lets you do
A lease of three years or less with no option to purchase cannot trigger a due-on-sale clause on a home you occupy or will occupy (12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(d)(4) and 12 CFR 191.5(b)(1)(iv)), so renting out a mortgaged house does not by itself put the loan at risk. The risk sits in a different clause: the occupancy covenant in the standard security instrument, which asks for a move-in within 60 days of signing and a full year of living there afterward. Neither clause says anything about whether a rental pays, which is a separate test worked below with every input stated.
Worksheet steps (12)
- Two clauses decide what the lender may do with a rented-out home
- A lease of three years or less cannot trigger the due-on-sale clause
- The occupancy clock: when moving out becomes a breach
- FHA, VA and other government-backed loans
- A full year of rent against a full year of costs
- What moves the answer: rent, vacancy and one bad repair
- What the cash line leaves out: equity, and the sale you did not make
- The same year on a tax return is a paper loss of $2,298
- How a lender sees the rent when you buy the next home
- The effect on the new loan, in ratios and in reserves
- A year later, Schedule E replaces the 75 percent rule when you apply again
- Refinancing the rental later: why cash-out costs you the low rate
Two clauses decide what the lender may do with a rented-out home
Most people asking whether they can rent out a house with a mortgage are really asking two separate questions. One is whether moving out breaks a promise made when the loan was signed. The other is whether letting a tenant in gives the lender the right to demand the whole balance. The standard Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac security instrument answers them in different sections, with different tests, and mixing them up is the source of most bad advice on this subject.
This page is part of our rentals, second homes and keep-or-move section. The clause wording comes from the uniform deed of trust that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau hosts, a Maryland Form 3021 from January 2001 that we read on October 23, 2026. The 2021 updates to the uniform instruments and any state rider can change details, and the document you signed controls, so find the occupancy and transfer sections in your own copy before relying on this page.
| Clause | What the text says | What it is triggered by | What limits it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section 6, Occupancy | Occupy the property as the principal residence "within 60 days" of signing, then keep occupying it "for at least one year after the date of occupancy" | Not living in the house during the first 60 days, or moving out before one year of occupancy is complete | The lender may agree otherwise in writing, "which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld," and the covenant yields where "extenuating circumstances exist which are beyond Borrower's control" |
| Section 18, Transfer of the Property | If the borrower sells or transfers the property, or any interest in it, without prior written consent from the lender, the lender "may require immediate payment in full" | A sale or transfer of the property or an interest in it, such as a bond for deed, contract for deed or installment sales contract | The option cannot be used where "prohibited by Applicable Law," and the lender must give at least 30 days' notice to pay before pursuing remedies |
A lease of three years or less cannot trigger the due-on-sale clause
Federal law answers the second question directly. The Garn-St Germain Act, 12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(d), lists transfers on which a lender cannot exercise a due-on-sale clause for residential property with fewer than five dwelling units, and item (4) is "the granting of a leasehold interest of three years or less not containing an option to purchase." The implementing rule, 12 CFR 191.5(b)(1)(iv), repeats it for "any loan on the security of a home occupied or to be occupied by the borrower," and adds a parenthetical that matters for anyone thinking about a lease-purchase arrangement: "either a lease of more than three years or a lease with an option to purchase will allow the exercise of a due-on-sale clause."
Read those words closely. A one-year lease, or a lease renewed year by year, to a tenant with no option to buy is the ordinary case, and the transfer clause cannot be used because of it. A five-year lease, or a rent-to-own arrangement with an option to buy, falls outside the protection. The uniform instrument's definition of "Interest in the Property" also includes a bond for deed, contract for deed or installment sales contract, which is why seller-financing structures that promise future title are treated as transfers and not as leases.
Keep the limit of this protection in view. The regulation also says the lender can enforce the clause if a later event disqualifies a transfer that was previously protected, so a lease that is extended or amended to add an option can lose its shelter. And the protection is against acceleration under the transfer clause. It does not touch Section 6, which is a different promise with its own test.
The occupancy clock: when moving out becomes a breach
Section 6 is the clause that makes renting out a newly bought home risky, because it sets two periods: the move-in window after signing, and a year of continued occupancy that starts on the date you actually move in. Renting during either period is a departure from the promise unless the lender agrees in writing, which it "shall not unreasonably withhold," or unless extenuating circumstances beyond your control exist. The text gives no list of such circumstances, so do not assume a job change, a family event or a market shift qualifies; ask.
The covenant is silent about what happens after the year ends. Nothing in Section 6 requires continued occupancy beyond one year after the date of occupancy, so a borrower who has lived in the house for more than a year has performed the covenant as written. Other parts of the instrument still apply while a tenant lives there. Section 7 requires the borrower to maintain the property "whether or not Borrower is residing in the Property," and the lender's insurance requirements continue. Government-backed loans add their own rules, covered below.
| When you move out | Where you stand under Section 6 | What to do before the lease starts |
|---|---|---|
| Before you ever moved in, or within the first 60 days | The 60-day move-in has not been met | Do not sign a lease until you have the lender's written answer |
| Month 1 to month 12 of occupancy | The one-year period is still running | Ask the servicer for written consent, or document the circumstances beyond your control, before the tenant moves in |
| After 12 months of occupancy | The covenant, as written, has been performed | Check the lease length against the three-year due-on-sale limit and the option rule, then notify your insurer |
FHA, VA and other government-backed loans
FHA uses a similar structure. Section II.A.1.b.iii of the FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 asks that at least one borrower occupy the property within 60 days of signing and intend to stay for at least one year. The same section limits each borrower to one FHA-insured principal residence, and then lists the only circumstances in which a borrower with an existing FHA mortgage on a principal residence may obtain an additional FHA mortgage on a new one: relocation more than 100 miles away for an employment-related reason, an increase in family size, vacating a jointly owned property, and a non-occupying co-borrower. The table in the handbook sets the conditions for each, and a servicer or lender applies them. The handbook text was read from the PDF on hud.gov, which carries a 2019 transmittal, so use HUD's current online edition to confirm.
VA and USDA loans carry their own occupancy certifications and rules for the next loan, and they are not covered here. If your loan is VA or USDA, the lender or the agency is the source to ask before a lease is signed.
A full year of rent against a full year of costs
Clauses tell you whether you may rent. They do not tell you whether it pays. Here is a worksheet with every input stated. The house is worth $380,000. The mortgage has a $246,000 balance at 3.25 percent with 26 years (312 months) left, which gives principal and interest of $1,169 a month ($14,028 a year). Property tax is $4,560 a year and insurance on a landlord policy is $2,100. Maintenance is set aside at 1 percent of the house's value, $3,800 a year. The house rents for $2,450 a month with one month vacant each year, so $26,950 is collected, and a property manager takes 8 percent of the rent collected. Those percentages are assumptions to replace with local quotes, not market data.
Because the borrower is no longer living there, utilities during vacancy, advertising, tenant screening and some repairs would follow. They are not in the worksheet, which is deliberately generous to the rental case.
| Line | Annual amount | Monthly equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Rent collected (11 months at $2,450) | $26,950 | $2,246 |
| Mortgage principal and interest | -$14,028 | -$1,169 |
| Property tax | -$4,560 | -$380 |
| Landlord insurance | -$2,100 | -$175 |
| Maintenance reserve (1 percent of value) | -$3,800 | -$317 |
| Management fee (8 percent of collected rent) | -$2,156 | -$180 |
| Cash left after every line | $306 | $26 |
What moves the answer: rent, vacancy and one bad repair
The result is thin, and it is easy to push in either direction. The break-even rent on these inputs is about $2,420 a month; every dollar above that is the owner's, every dollar below is a monthly top-up. A manager's fee, a single vacant quarter or one large repair erases the year.
- The single biggest lever is who manages the house. Self-managing is worth $2,156 a year in this case, at the price of the owner's time and a phone that rings.
- Vacancy matters more than the sticker rent. Each extra empty month costs $2,450 in rent and keeps the carrying costs running.
- The reserve is a floor, not a forecast. A 1 percent reserve is a planning rule, and a house with an old roof needs more.
| Case | Annual cash after all costs | Per month |
|---|---|---|
| Base case: $2,450 rent, 1 vacant month, manager | $306 | $26 |
| Rent only $2,200 | -$2,224 | -$185 |
| Rent $2,700 | $2,836 | $236 |
| Three vacant months | -$4,202 | -$350 |
| An $8,000 roof or HVAC repair on top of the reserve | -$7,694 | -$641 |
| Owner manages it (no 8 percent fee), 1 vacant month | $2,462 | $205 |
What the cash line leaves out: equity, and the sale you did not make
Cash flow is not the whole return. In the first year of this loan, $6,123 of the payments reduces principal and $7,904 is interest. Counting that principal as part of the benefit, the first year is worth $6,430 in the base case ($306 plus $6,123), or $8,586 if the owner manages the house.
Against what? If the house were sold at $380,000 with 7 percent selling costs ($26,600) and the $246,000 balance paid off, the owner would walk away with $107,400. The $6,430 is about 6.0 percent of that sum in the base case and about 8.0 percent when self-managed, before taxes and before any change in the house's price. That is the number to compare with whatever else $107,400 could do for you. This page does not forecast home prices or investment returns, so the comparison is yours to make with your own alternative. The related guide on selling or staying with a low mortgage rate prices the rate side of the same decision.
A sale would also end the 3.25 percent loan, and the rate is the reason the base case is positive at all: the table charges the house only $14,028 a year of principal and interest. Put the same $246,000 on a new 30-year loan at the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average of 7.32 percent (release of October 22, 2026; a survey of purchase applications from borrowers with 740+ scores and 75 to 80 percent loan-to-value, so not a quote for a rental) and principal and interest would be about $1,690 a month, $521 more than the $1,169 you pay now. The base case would turn from $26 a month to a $495 monthly loss. Nobody can swap the old loan for a new one on the same house, so this is a measure of what the old rate is worth, not an option.
The same year on a tax return is a paper loss of $2,298
This is general information, not tax advice. Under IRS Publication 527 (2025), a home converted to rental use is depreciated on the lesser of its fair market value or your adjusted basis on the date of the change, straight line over 27.5 years. Take an adjusted basis of $240,000 for the building (land excluded), below its market value, so $8,727 a year of depreciation ($240,000 divided by 27.5, simplified because the first year is usually partial).
Taxable rental result: $26,950 collected, less the $2,156 management fee, $4,560 tax, $2,100 insurance, $3,800 maintenance, $7,904 of first-year interest and $8,727 of depreciation, equals a loss of $2,298 on paper while the owner pocketed $306 in cash. Principal repayment is not deductible and depreciation costs no cash, which is the whole gap. The passive activity rules described in Publication 527 can limit loss deductions, and a tax professional should apply them to your income. Selling later has its own tax rules, including recapture of depreciation, which Publication 523 (2025) covers.
How a lender sees the rent when you buy the next home
Most owners who rent out a house are also buying another one, and the new lender has to decide what the old payment does to the new loan. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide B3-3.8-05, Rental Income from Non-Subject Property: Departing Residence (September 2, 2026) says a principal residence "that will be vacated and converted to an investment property when the borrower purchases a new principal residence is eligible." The lender takes the monthly market rent, multiplies it by 75 percent, and subtracts the old home's full payment of principal, interest, taxes and insurance (PITIA). If the result is positive, the rent can be used to offset that PITIA only. If it is negative, the shortfall is added to the debt-to-income ratio.
On this house, PITIA is $1,724 a month ($1,169 principal and interest, $380 tax, $175 insurance). The 75 percent rule produces a different answer at each rent level.
| Market rent per month | 75 percent of rent | Result after subtracting PITIA | Treatment in the new loan's ratios |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1,900 | $1,425 | -$299 | $299 added to monthly debts |
| $2,200 | $1,650 | -$74 | $74 added to monthly debts |
| $2,450 | $1,838 | +$114 | Rent offsets the whole old PITIA; $0 added |
| $2,800 | $2,100 | +$376 | Rent offsets the whole old PITIA; surplus not counted as income |
The effect on the new loan, in ratios and in reserves
Take a household with $9,500 of gross monthly income, $400 of other monthly debts and a new home whose payment is $2,300. If the old $1,724 payment were counted in full, total monthly debts would be $4,424 and the ratio 46.6 percent. With the rent test at $2,450 market rent, the old payment drops out and the ratio is 28.4 percent. At $2,200 rent, $74 is added back and the ratio is 29.2 percent; at $1,900 rent it is 31.6 percent. The ceilings that apply to the new loan depend on the underwriting method and the lender, so use the ratios to see the size of the swing, not to judge approval.
Two more conditions sit in the same section. The lender must verify six months of reserves for the vacated property's PITIA when the borrower has less than 12 months of property management experience, which here is $10,344, and that sum is in addition to any reserves required for multiple financed properties. And the lender must document a current housing payment to use any rental income from the departing residence.
A year later, Schedule E replaces the 75 percent rule when you apply again
The 75 percent test is for a home you are leaving. Once the house has been a rental long enough to appear on a tax return, a lender that later considers the rent for another loan uses a different method. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide B3-3.8-04, Rental Income from Non-Subject Property (September 2, 2026) says that when the property is on Schedule E of the most recent Form 1040, the lender performs a cash flow analysis from that schedule: net rental income plus any depreciation, interest, association dues, taxes and insurance, averaged over the months in service or 12 months depending on whether a lease may be used, minus the property's PITIA. If the property is not yet on a return, it falls back to 75 percent of the lease amount, minus PITIA.
On the example house, the Schedule E net is a loss of $2,298. Adding back $8,727 of depreciation, $7,904 of interest, $4,560 of tax and $2,100 of insurance gives $20,993, or $1,749 a month. Subtracting the $1,724 PITIA leaves $25 a month. The first method gave +$114 at the same $2,450 rent. The difference is that Schedule E counts the $3,800 of maintenance and the $2,156 management fee as real costs and counts the vacant month as lost rent.
The practical consequence is that the way you keep your books shows up in a later loan file. A house that is repaired, managed and kept clean looks less profitable on Schedule E than the rent roll suggests, and the guide lets a lender add back non-recurring property expenses only when they are documented. The same section also separates borrowers by experience: with at least 12 months of rental property management experience a positive result can be used in full, and with less it can only offset the property's PITIA. The same experience rule applies when the rent comes from an accessory unit in the house you live in, which is worked in rent from a roommate, an ADU or Airbnb guests.
Refinancing the rental later: why cash-out costs you the low rate
Sooner or later someone asks whether the rental could fund the down payment on the next house. A cash-out refinance can, but it replaces the whole mortgage, including the part that carries the low rate. An owner who tried to sell first should also know that Fannie Mae requires a listing to be off the market by the disbursement date, one of the rules compared in refinancing after listing a home for sale. Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix, in the version dated August 5, 2026, limits a cash-out refinance of a one-unit investment property to 75 percent of its value. On this house that is $285,000, so the cash available before costs is $39,000 ($285,000 less the $246,000 balance).
The price of that cash is in two places. First, the LLPA Matrix dated September 30, 2026 adds charges to a 740 to 759 credit-score, 70.01 to 75 percent loan-to-value cash-out loan of 1.625 percent, plus 2.125 percent for an investment property, 3.75 percent in all, which is about $10,688 on $285,000. Second, the whole $285,000 is re-priced. At an illustrated 8.00 percent (a labelled illustration, not a quote, chosen to sit above the 7.32 percent purchase average for an investment property) the principal and interest on a new 30-year loan is $2,091, against $1,169 now: $922 a month more to borrow $39,000. A second loan on the rental, a home equity line, or a sale, would leave the first mortgage alone, and the comparison in our guide to refinance versus HELOC is the right starting place; whether a lender will make a second loan on a rental, and on what terms, is each lender's own policy.
If instead the rental later becomes your home again, the loan priced as an investment property can be refinanced as a principal residence, with its own conditions, described in our guide to refinancing an investment property into a primary residence. Once the house is a rental, drawing equity from it is priced in the rental cash-out guide.
The lease you cannot use to qualify for the next house
When the new lender counts rent from the home you are leaving, Selling Guide B3-3.8-05 says lease agreements are not permitted for a departing residence. The lender instead documents market rent with an appraisal that includes market rents, a comparable rent schedule, or a market analysis with at least three comparable rental properties. A signed lease at $2,450 does not change that, and a lease at a rent above market does not change the 75 percent figure. Plan the new purchase on the market rent the lender will find, not on the rent a tenant has agreed to pay.
Common questions
Do I have to tell my mortgage servicer that I am renting the house out?
The sample uniform instrument has no clause requiring notice of a tenancy, which can read as "no", but that is the wrong conclusion inside the first year. Section 6 asks for a year of occupancy, and an FHA loan carries the same 60-day and one-year occupancy rule, while VA and USDA loans have their own occupancy rules that we did not review. Asking first, in writing, is the safe course in the first year or on any government-backed loan. After that, read your signed documents and tell your insurer before the tenant moves in.
Can my tenant take over my mortgage?
Letting a tenant take over your loan is a transfer, and Section 18 gives the lender the option to require payment in full without its written consent unless a federal exemption applies. Lawful assumptions run through the lender or servicer and are limited to certain loan types, which our guide to assumable mortgages and release of liability explains. If you are weighing a sale with an assumption against renting the house out, what an assumable mortgage is worth to a seller puts a dollar ceiling on the sale side.
What does a new lender count if I have rented the house for more than a year?
Under Selling Guide B3-3.8-04, a property on Schedule E is analyzed from the tax return rather than from a lease, with depreciation, interest, taxes and insurance added back and the PITIA subtracted. A lease is used only in listed situations, and the lender documents either a current housing payment or a year of rental receipts. Individual lenders may add requirements.
What if the tenant stops paying and I fall behind on the mortgage?
The loan is owed whether or not rent arrives, and the Section 7 duty to maintain the property continues while it is vacant. If a payment becomes unaffordable, contact the servicer early; our comparison of mortgage hardship options sets out what servicers may offer and what each costs, and a lender is not obliged to offer any particular option.
Does a lease-option or rent-to-own arrangement change the answer?
Yes. The regulation parenthetical says a lease with an option to purchase allows the lender to exercise a due-on-sale clause, and the sample instrument definition of an interest in the property includes a contract for deed or installment sales contract. Treat those structures as a possible transfer and take them to a real estate attorney before signing.
Sources and verification
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Maryland Deed of Trust (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac Uniform Instrument, Form 3021 1/01): Sections 6 (Occupancy), 7 (Preservation, Maintenance and Protection), 18 (Transfer of the Property or a Beneficial Interest in Borrower). Checked October 23, 2026.
- U.S. Code, 12 U.S.C. 1701j-3, Preemption of due-on-sale prohibitions (GovInfo, 2024 edition): Subsection (d)(4): leasehold interest of three years or less not containing an option to purchase. Checked October 23, 2026.
- eCFR, 12 CFR 191.5, Limitation on exercise of due-on-sale clauses: Paragraph (b)(1)(iv) and (b)(5), including the lease-longer-than-three-years and option-to-purchase parenthetical. Text read through the eCFR renderer API. Checked October 23, 2026.
- HUD, FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1: Section II.A.1.b.iii: occupancy within 60 days and intent for one year, one-principal-residence limit, and the exception categories. The PDF carries a 2019 transmittal. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-3.8-05 Rental Income from Non-Subject Property: Departing Residence (09/02/2026): Eligibility, market-rent documentation, 75 percent factor, PITIA offset, six months of reserves, no lease agreements. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-3.8-04 Rental Income from Non-Subject Property (09/02/2026): Schedule E cash flow analysis, add-backs, 75 percent lease method, experience conditions. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (version dated August 5, 2026) and Loan-Level Price Adjustment Matrix (dated September 30, 2026): 75 percent cash-out ceiling for a one-unit investment property; cash-out LLPA grid and investment-property add-on at https://singlefamily.fanniemae.com/media/9391/display. Checked October 23, 2026.
- IRS Publication 527 (2025), Residential Rental Property: Basis for property changed to rental use, 27.5-year straight line depreciation, passive activity limits. Checked October 23, 2026.
- IRS Publication 523 (2025), Selling Your Home: Two-of-five-year ownership and use tests and depreciation recapture. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: Release of October 22, 2026: 30-year fixed 7.32 percent, 15-year fixed 6.68 percent. Context only. Checked October 23, 2026.
The cash sheet is built on stated assumptions (1 percent maintenance, 8 percent management, one vacant month, 7 percent selling costs) and leaves out utilities during vacancy, advertising, screening and local landlord licensing. The 8.00 percent cash-out rate is a labelled illustration for a rental, not a quote. Section text comes from a Maryland sample instrument, so your signed documents and state law govern. Freddie Mac loans, VA and USDA loans, and lender overlays were not reviewed. Matrix dates: Eligibility Matrix August 5, 2026; LLPA Matrix September 30, 2026.