Rentals, second homes and keep-or-move
Cash-out refinance on a rental property: the 75 percent ceiling and what stacks on top of it
Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix (dated August 5, 2026) caps a cash-out refinance at 75 percent of value on a one-unit rental and 70 percent on a two- to four-unit building, so the cash is whatever sits between that ceiling and what you owe. On a $400,000 house with a $210,000 balance that is at most $90,000 before costs, and the cash cannot be counted toward the reserves the lender asks you to hold.
Worksheet steps (11)
- The ceiling is set by occupancy, unit count and loan purpose together
- Why a four-unit building loses five points the moment it returns cash
- Twelve months on the old loan, six months on title
- Delayed financing: when the cap is what you paid, not what the house is worth
- The price stack: four charges that add up before any lender margin
- What cash-out adds to the same loan: $2,625 on a $300,000 balance
- Reserves: six months on the property, plus a slice of every other mortgage
- Counting the rent: tax-return cash flow beats the lease for a rental you already own
- The extra cash costs 16.2 percent a year nominal, 17.4 percent effective, on an old 3.75 percent loan
- Classification follows how the house is used, not how you would like it priced
- The limit that ends the plan: ten financed properties, counted by obligation
The ceiling is set by occupancy, unit count and loan purpose together
This page sits in our rentals, second homes and keep-or-move section. Most advice on this topic quotes one number, 75 percent, and stops. The matrix has a different ceiling for each combination of how the property is used, how many units it has and whether the refinance returns cash. For a rental, three of those cells matter, and the gap between two of them catches owners of small multifamily buildings.
The figures below come from the desktop-underwriting table of the Eligibility Matrix, which sets maximum loan-to-value, combined loan-to-value and home-equity combined loan-to-value ratios for loans sold to Fannie Mae. The rows that apply to a rental are the investment property rows. The principal residence rows are shown only so you can see what changes if the building has an owner-occupied unit. Other investors, and individual lenders on top of any investor, may set lower ceilings, so the number your lender quotes can sit below these.
| Property use | Units | Limited cash-out refinance | Cash-out refinance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Investment property (a rental) | 1 | 75% | 75% |
| Investment property (a rental) | 2 to 4 | 75% | 70% |
| Second home | 1 | 90% | 75% |
| Principal residence | 1 | 97% fixed, 95% adjustable | 80% |
| Principal residence | 2 to 4 | 95% | 75% |
Why a four-unit building loses five points the moment it returns cash
Look at the second row of the table. A two- to four-unit rental refinanced without cash back may reach 75 percent of value. The same building refinanced with cash out stops at 70 percent. The five-point drop is not a lender preference; it is two separate cells in the matrix. On a $500,000 fourplex it is $25,000 of borrowing power that disappears when the refinance is classified as cash-out. If you live in one of the units, the ceilings, reserves and rent rules change; the owner-occupied two- to four-unit guide sets them out unit by unit.
That makes the classification worth understanding before the application, not after the first quote. The Selling Guide's limited cash-out topic, B2-1.3-02, revised October 8, 2025, caps the cash back on a limited cash-out refinance at 1 percent of the new loan or $2,000, whichever is larger, and limits the debt that may be paid off to the existing first mortgage and subordinate liens that were used to purchase the property. A home equity line you drew to replace a roof does not qualify. Paying it off with the new first mortgage turns the whole transaction into a cash-out refinance, with the lower ceiling and the heavier price that come with it. We checked the guide on October 23, 2026.
The same logic applies to the one-unit rental, where both cells read 75 percent, so the ceiling does not move. What moves is the price, which the next section builds up layer by layer.
Twelve months on the old loan, six months on title
Cash-out has clocks that a limited cash-out refinance does not. Selling Guide B2-1.3-03 (dated December 10, 2025, checked October 23, 2026) says the first mortgage being paid off has to be 12 months old or more, counted from the old note date to the new one. At least one borrower must also have been on title for six months before the new loan is disbursed. A listing that is still live at disbursement is a separate problem: the house has to be off the market by then.
The clocks have exceptions, and each one has a paper trail the lender must document.
| Clock | Rule | Exception or credit |
|---|---|---|
| Age of the first mortgage being paid off | 12 months, note date to note date | Does not apply to subordinate liens paid off, or when buying out a co-owner under a legal agreement |
| Time on title | At least one borrower, six months before disbursement | None if the property came by inheritance or was awarded in a divorce, separation or dissolution of a domestic partnership |
| Time held by an LLC | Counts toward the six months if the borrower majority-owns or controls the LLC | Title must be transferred out of the LLC into the individual borrower before closing |
| Time held by a revocable trust | Counts if the borrower is the trust's primary beneficiary | Applies in addition to the 12-month rule |
| Property bought within six months | Delayed financing exception | Cash purchase, documented source of funds, new loan capped at the documented investment plus closing costs, prepaid fees and points |
Delayed financing: when the cap is what you paid, not what the house is worth
The exception in the last row of the table is the one investors who buy with cash use, and it changes which limit binds. Under the delayed financing exception in B2-1.3-03, a borrower who bought the property within the past six months can take a cash-out refinance if the original purchase was an arms-length transaction, the settlement statement shows no mortgage financing was used, the preliminary title report shows no liens, and the sources of the purchase funds are documented. The new loan then cannot exceed the documented amount of the borrower's initial investment plus the closing costs, prepaid fees and points on the new loan, and it still has to fit under the loan-to-value ceiling on the current appraised value.
Two cases on a one-unit rental show which test controls. Buy for $320,000 cash with $4,000 of closing costs, and suppose the appraisal comes in at $400,000: 75 percent of value is $300,000, and the investment cap is $324,000 plus the new loan's costs, so the loan-to-value ceiling binds and the loan is $300,000. Now buy for $240,000 cash with $2,800 of closing costs, and suppose the appraisal again says $400,000 because the market moved or the house was a bargain: 75 percent is still $300,000, but the investment cap is $242,800 plus the new loan's costs, so the cap binds and the largest loan is about $242,800 plus those costs. Value above the price does not release extra cash inside the six-month window. The guide adds that if the purchase money came from an unsecured loan or a loan secured by something other than the subject property, such as a line on another house, the settlement statement must show the cash-out proceeds going to pay that loan down or off, and the payments left on it are counted in the debt-to-income ratio. Gift funds used to buy cannot be reimbursed from the new loan.
The price stack: four charges that add up before any lender margin
The Loan-Level Price Adjustment Matrix that Fannie Mae reissued on September 30, 2026, which we downloaded on October 23, 2026, states that adjustments are cumulative and calculated on the loan balance on the acquisition date. For a rental cash-out refinance four of them can apply at once: the credit-score-and-LTV charge for a cash-out loan, the investment property charge, the two- to four-unit charge, and a condo or high-balance charge if either applies. The matrix prices the loan to the lender; lenders turn those charges into a higher rate, a fee, or a mix, and the conversion differs from lender to lender and day to day. The percentages tell you the size of the penalty, not the line on your Loan Estimate.
The grid below is the cash-out table for loans with terms over 15 years, cut to the loan-to-value bands a rental can actually reach. The last column adds the investment property charge from the attribute table.
| Credit score | 60.01 to 70.00% LTV | 70.01 to 75.00% LTV | Investment add-on in that band (60.01-70 / 70.01-75) | Total at 70.01 to 75.00% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 780 or higher | 0.625% | 0.875% | 1.625% / 2.125% | 3.000% |
| 740 to 759 | 1.000% | 1.625% | 1.625% / 2.125% | 3.750% |
| 700 to 719 | 1.625% | 2.625% | 1.625% / 2.125% | 4.750% |
| 680 to 699 | 2.000% | 2.875% | 1.625% / 2.125% | 5.000% |
| 660 to 679 | 2.750% | 4.000% | 1.625% / 2.125% | 6.125% |
What cash-out adds to the same loan: $2,625 on a $300,000 balance
Hold everything fixed and change only the loan purpose. A borrower with a 740 to 759 score and a $300,000 loan at 75 percent of value pays 1.625 percent plus the 2.125 percent investment charge on a cash-out refinance, 3.750 percent in total, or $11,250. The limited cash-out grid shows 0.750 percent for the same score and band, plus the same 2.125 percent, 2.875 percent in total, or $8,625. The difference, $2,625, is what returning cash adds to the price of an otherwise identical loan. On a two- to four-unit building the 0.375 percent unit charge for the 60.01 to 70.00 percent band is added on top.
The distance from the best to the worst row is the bigger lever. At 70.01 to 75.00 percent, moving from a 780 score to a 680 score takes the total from 3.000 to 5.000 percent. On $300,000 that is $6,000 of pricing on the credit score alone, so a rental cash-out is the refinance where paying down a card or waiting for a score update has the largest dollar effect. Two cautions apply. The matrix is Fannie Mae's price list to its seller, so an FHA, VA, Freddie Mac or portfolio lender prices differently. And the matrix's change log records that on November 17, 2025 (Announcement SEL-2025-09) Fannie Mae removed the reference to a 620 minimum credit score for loans submitted to Desktop Underwriter, so ask the lender for its own minimum rather than assuming the old floor.
Reserves: six months on the property, plus a slice of every other mortgage
Reserves are liquid assets left after closing, measured in months of the payment on the loan you are taking. Selling Guide B3-4.1-01 (dated August 7, 2024; checked October 23, 2026) says Desktop Underwriter requires six months for an investment property transaction. If you own other financed properties, it adds a percentage of their combined unpaid balance: 2 percent for one to four financed properties, 4 percent for five or six, 6 percent for seven to ten. The balance of the subject property and of your principal residence are left out of that sum, as are properties pending sale.
Two rules shape what counts. First, cash proceeds from a cash-out refinance on the subject property are on the guide's list of unacceptable sources, so the money the loan releases cannot be the money that satisfies the reserve test. Second, funds needed to close are subtracted from your assets before reserves are measured. Take a borrower with the $300,000 loan used throughout this page at an illustrative 7.75 percent over 30 years, a property tax bill of $4,800 and insurance of $1,500 a year. The principal and interest payment is $2,149, so the housing payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance) is $2,674. Six months is $16,045. If the borrower also has two other mortgaged rentals with balances of $180,000 and $140,000, the second layer is 2 percent of $320,000, or $6,400. The reserve requirement comes to $22,445, which has to sit in accounts that are not the cash-out proceeds, after the cash needed to close has been set aside.
Counting the rent: tax-return cash flow beats the lease for a rental you already own
When the rented property is the collateral, Selling Guide B3-3.8-02 (dated September 2, 2026; checked October 23, 2026) sets the test for a refinance. The lender needs an appraiser's rent schedule (Form 1007, or Form 1025 on a multifamily building) and the most recent federal return with Schedules 1 and E. If the property is on Schedule E, net rental income is a cash-flow analysis from the return, averaged over the months the property was in service, minus the housing payment of the new loan. If it is not on Schedule E, the lender takes 75 percent of the lease amount and subtracts the housing payment. A lease substitutes for the return only in the situations the guide lists in B3-3.8-01, such as a property placed in service in the current year.
A positive result can be used in full only if you have at least 12 months of property management experience; with less, it can only offset the housing payment. A negative result is added to your monthly obligations, so it counts against the debt-to-income ratio. For Desktop Underwriter the maximum total ratio is 50 percent; for a manually underwritten loan it is 36 percent, or up to 45 percent with the credit score and reserves in the matrix (B3-6-02, dated April 2, 2025). If the market rent in the appraiser's report does not reasonably support the rent on the return or lease, the lender must document why the income is stable or use the lesser amount.
A short rent schedule matters here. If the lease and the return say $2,200 a month but the appraiser's rent schedule supports $2,000, the guide sends the lender to a written explanation of why the higher figure is stable or to the lesser amount. A $200 shortfall in monthly rent is $2,400 a year, and every dollar of it comes straight out of the adjusted net rental income.
The cash-out can turn a rental that qualifies on its own into one that does not. The cash flow in the next table comes from a Schedule E showing $26,400 of rent, then adding back depreciation, mortgage interest, taxes and insurance as the guide's note describes.
| Line | Amount per year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Rents received | $26,400 | $2,200 a month |
| Expenses on Schedule E (insurance $1,500, interest $7,900, repairs $2,400, taxes $4,800, depreciation $8,200, other $1,700) | $26,500 | Schedule E net is minus $100 |
| Add back depreciation, interest, taxes, insurance | $22,400 | $8,200 + $7,900 + $4,800 + $1,500 |
| Cash flow before the housing payment | $22,300 | $1,858 a month, averaged over 12 months |
| Housing payment on the existing loan | $1,694 a month | $1,169 principal and interest at 3.75 percent over 22 years, plus $525 taxes and insurance |
| Adjusted net rental income, existing loan | +$164 a month | Positive, usable as income with 12 months of experience |
| Housing payment on the new $300,000 loan | $2,674 a month | $2,149 principal and interest plus $525 taxes and insurance |
| Adjusted net rental income, new loan | -$816 a month | Negative, added to monthly obligations |
The extra cash costs 16.2 percent a year nominal, 17.4 percent effective, on an old 3.75 percent loan
A cash-out refinance on a rental reprices the whole balance, not just the new money, and that is where the cost hides. To see it, treat the transaction as borrowing the extra cash and measure what it costs. Take a rental worth $400,000 with a first mortgage of $210,000 at 3.75 percent and 22 years left. The owner refinances into $300,000 over 30 years at an illustrative 7.75 percent, with $6,500 of closing costs and the pricing charges folded into that rate. After paying off the old loan and the costs, $83,500 comes back. The payment rises from $1,169 to $2,149, which is $980 more each month. After a 10-year stay the old loan would have a balance of $135,431 and the new one $261,799, so the borrower owes $126,368 more.
The extra cash flows are therefore $83,500 received at the start, $980 paid every month for 120 months, and $126,368 owed at the end. The rate that equates them is 1.35 percent a month, which is 16.2 percent a year nominal and about 17.4 percent compounded. That is not a typo, and it is not the 7.75 percent the loan carries. The extra money costs far more than the new rate because 7.75 percent now applies to $210,000 that was previously costing 3.75 percent, and the 30-year restart spreads the new loan over eight more years of interest than the old one had left.
That figure prices the money, not the decision: cash used for something that earns more than the hurdle after tax and risk may justify it, and this site cannot judge your use. The hurdle shrinks as the old rate rises, because there is less repricing to pay for, and the refinance versus HELOC guide and the cash-out risks guide price the alternatives that leave a low first mortgage alone. The old rate is the only variable that moves in the next table. Everything else, the $300,000 loan, the 7.75 percent rate, 30 years, $6,500 of costs and a 10-year horizon, is unchanged.
| Existing rate | Existing payment | Extra monthly payment | Extra balance owed at year 10 | Cost of the extra cash, nominal / effective |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.75% | $1,169 | $980 | $126,368 | 16.2% / 17.4% |
| 5.00% | $1,313 | $836 | $119,827 | 14.0% / 15.0% |
| 6.50% | $1,497 | $652 | $112,369 | 11.3% / 11.9% |
Classification follows how the house is used, not how you would like it priced
A house you rent to a tenant is an investment property in Fannie Mae's terms: Selling Guide B2-1.1-01 defines it as owned but not occupied by the borrower, and an investment property attracts a pricing adjustment on every loan. The application has to say what the property is. A rental cannot be moved to the second-home column because it prices better, and a lender who finds a signed occupancy statement that does not match the facts can refuse the loan. If your plan is to live in the house, that is a different transaction with different rules and different clocks, covered in refinancing an investment property into a primary residence. If you moved out and rented the house you used to live in, the rent-out guide covers the loan clauses that apply while you hold it.
The limit that ends the plan: ten financed properties, counted by obligation
For a second home or an investment property, Fannie Mae's maximum number of financed properties is 10 for loans underwritten through Desktop Underwriter (Selling Guide B2-2-03, dated November 5, 2025; checked October 23, 2026). The count is of one- to four-unit residential properties where you are personally obligated on a mortgage, counting your own home if it is financed, counting a two-unit building once, and counting jointly financed property once across co-borrowers. Commercial property, buildings of more than four units, timeshares, vacant lots and chattel-financed manufactured homes are not counted.
Where the entity owns the property matters. The guide's own examples show that a borrower with 50 percent of an LLC that holds four financed two-unit buildings, and who is not personally obligated on those mortgages, counts none of them. The count also sets the reserve percentage. The borrower in the earlier example has the subject rental, two other rentals and a financed home, four financed properties, so the 2 percent tier applies. A borrower with six financed properties in all would be in the 4 percent tier, and on the same $320,000 of other balances that would be $12,800 rather than $6,400, an extra $6,400 of cash to hold.
Common questions
Does living in one unit of a fourplex change the ceiling?
Yes. If you occupy one unit, the property is a principal residence of two to four units, and the Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026 lists 75 percent for a cash-out refinance. An investment fourplex is capped at 70 percent. The classification is a matter of fact on the application, and occupancy statements are signed.
I own only one rental. Do I have the 12 months of management experience the guide asks for?
It depends on what your return shows. B3-3.8-01 asks for the latest federal return with Schedules 1 and E showing rental income that supports 365 fair rental days, or a return plus a 12-month lease where the property has been owned a year but was not rented the whole year. A property first rented last spring will not meet that, and then positive rental income can only offset the housing payment, not add to your income.
I am refinancing two rentals at once. Do I need reserves for both?
Not cumulatively. B3-4.1-01 says that when a lender processes several second home or investment applications at the same time, the same assets may satisfy each one, and only the requirement for each application has to be met. Its example has one application needing $5,000 and another $10,000, and the lender verifies $10,000, not $15,000.
Would calling the rental a second home lower the price?
No, and it is not a label a borrower can choose: a second home must be occupied by the borrower for some part of the year and cannot be a rental property. The matrices show why it would not help anyway. The LLPA attribute table charges a second home the same percentages as an investment property (1.125, 1.125, 1.625, 2.125 and 3.375 percent across the bands), and the cash-out ceiling for a one-unit second home is also 75 percent.
Do a condo or a high-balance loan add to the stack?
Yes, the adjustments are cumulative. In the cash-out grid a condo adds 0.125 percent between 60.01 and 75 percent (not for co-ops or detached condo units), and a high-balance fixed-rate loan adds 1.500 percent in the same bands, so a 740 to 759 borrower at 70.01 to 75 percent on a high-balance condo rental sits at 1.625 + 2.125 + 0.125 + 1.500 = 5.375 percent before any lender margin.
Sources and verification
- Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026), Desktop Underwriter Version 12.1: Maximum LTV, CLTV and HCLTV for cash-out and limited cash-out refinances by occupancy and unit count. Downloaded October 23, 2026 with browser headers; the PDF is dated August 5, 2026. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Loan-Level Price Adjustment Matrix (09.30.2026): Cash-out refinance grid by credit score and LTV, investment property and two- to four-unit attribute charges, cumulative-charge rule, change log entry SEL-2025-09. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B2-1.3-03, Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (12/10/2025): 12-month note age, six months on title, exceptions, delayed financing, listing rule. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (10/08/2025): Permitted payoffs and cash-back allowance. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B3-4.1-01, Minimum Reserve Requirements (08/07/2024): Six months for an investment property in Desktop Underwriter, multiple-financed-property percentages, cash-out proceeds excluded. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B2-2-03, Multiple Financed Properties for the Same Borrower (11/05/2025): Ten-property limit and counting rules. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B3-3.8-01 and B3-3.8-02, Rental Income (09/02/2026): Schedule E cash flow, 75 percent lease method, 12-month management experience, lease conditions. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios (04/02/2025): Maximum DTI of 36 percent manual (45 percent with the matrix conditions) and 50 percent through Desktop Underwriter. Checked October 23, 2026.
- Selling Guide B2-1.1-01, Occupancy Types (10/05/2022): Definition of an investment property. Checked October 23, 2026.
The $300,000 loan, 7.75 percent rate, $6,500 of closing costs, 3.75 percent existing rate and the Schedule E lines are stated assumptions chosen to be checkable, not quotes or market data. The 16.2 percent nominal (17.4 percent effective) figure is an internal rate of return on those assumptions and moves with every input, and the pricing percentages are Fannie Mae's charges to a seller, not what a lender will quote you. Freddie Mac, FHA, VA, portfolio and non-qualified-mortgage lenders were not reviewed, and tax treatment of the interest and the proceeds was left out because it depends on how the cash is used. Rules were checked October 23, 2026.