Rate-drop scenarios

Refinancing from 6.5% to 6%: is it worth it?

On these stated assumptions, refinancing from 6.5% to 6% comes out about $5,965 ahead over a 7-year stay after $6,000 of closing costs.

The smallest drop in this set and the easiest to oversell. It can work on a large balance with cheap closing costs and a long stay; it fails quietly everywhere else.

The stated example

Inputs: $400,000 balance, 27 years left, new 30-year term, $6,000 of closing costs, 7-year stay.

MeasureStay at 6.5%Refinance to 6%
Monthly principal and interest$2,622$2,398
Monthly change$224 less per month
Break-even on closing costsMonth 27
Interest over a 7-year stay$171,972$160,007 plus $6,000 costs
Net over the stay$5,965 ahead by refinancing
Lifetime interest if held to term$19,754 more with the refinance after costs, driven by the term restart

What drives this particular drop

A 0.5 point drop on $400,000 changes the payment by $224 a month before costs, against $6,000 of fees, so the fees are repaid in month 27.

Closing costs of $3,000, $6,000, $12,000

Closing costsBreak-evenNet over a 7-year stay
$3,000Month 14$8,965 ahead by refinancing
$6,000Month 27$5,965 ahead by refinancing
$12,000Month 54$35 ahead by staying

Stays of 3, 5, and 7 years at $6,000

Stay horizonNet versus staying at 6.5%Reading
3 years$326 ahead by stayingPast break-even on these inputs
5 years$3,028 ahead by refinancingPast break-even on these inputs
7 years$5,965 ahead by refinancingPast break-even on these inputs