Home equity options

Refinancing after a renovation: what the appraiser counts and which loan repays the work

Paying a contractor $62,000 does not put $62,000 on the appraisal: Fannie Mae tells appraisers to adjust for what the market pays for a feature, and says a rule of thumb is not acceptable. The bigger trap is the loan class. If a home equity line paid for the work, rolling it into a new first mortgage is a cash-out refinance, capped at 80 percent of value on a one-unit home, while a limited cash-out refinance can reach 97 percent.

Worksheet steps (10)
  1. The invoice is not in the appraisal, and the Guide says why
  2. A $24,000 shortfall between cost and credit moves the loan across the 70 percent line
  3. What the report has to say about each kind of work
  4. Where the renovation shows up in the condition rating
  5. If a home equity line paid for the work, the refinance that repays it is cash-out
  6. Renovating first and refinancing later runs into the 80 percent ceiling
  7. HomeStyle Renovation and HomeStyle Refresh: two products with different limits
  8. Proof of completion changes depending on what the appraiser wrote
  9. A new apartment, or an addition built without a permit
  10. If the goal is to drop mortgage insurance, the servicer route may already cover it

The invoice is not in the appraisal, and the Guide says why

A refinance appraisal answers one question: what would this house, in this condition, sell for on the effective date of the report. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide B4-1.3-09 (dated June 4, 2025; checked October 23, 2026) tells appraisers that their adjustments to comparable sales "must reflect the market's reaction" to a difference between two properties, and gives an example of what is not acceptable: a $20-per-square-foot adjustment chosen by rule of thumb when the market analysis supports $100. The Guide topics we read contain no table of kitchen or bathroom values and no percentage of cost that comes back as value. The appraiser is expected to find sales of similar homes with and without the feature and read the difference from them.

The cost approach, which would start from what it costs to build, is not required by Fannie Mae except for manufactured homes (B4-1.3-10, dated June 4, 2025), whose other refinance conditions are set out in our manufactured home refinance guide, and an appraisal that relies only on the cost approach is not acceptable. The Guide does say the approach may be appropriate for property undergoing renovation, as support for the sales comparison. So your receipts may appear in the report as a cross-check. They do not set the value.

This page is part of our home equity options section. The gap between what a project cost and what the appraiser credits matters because it feeds straight into the loan-to-value ratio, and the pricing tiers step at fixed ratios. The table holds everything constant except the value the appraiser reaches. A house worth $400,000 before a $62,000 kitchen is refinanced into a $320,000 rate-and-term loan by a borrower with a 740 to 759 credit score.

Same house, same $320,000 limited cash-out loan, two appraised values after a $62,000 kitchen (illustrative values; LLPA from Fannie Mae's matrix dated 09.30.2026, limited cash-out grid, terms over 15 years; October 23, 2026)
What the appraiser creditsAppraised valueLTV on $320,000Pricing charge at 740 to 759Charge in dollars
Full cost ($400,000 + $62,000)$462,00069.3% (band 60.01 to 70.00%)0.250%$800
Market-supported adjustment of $38,000$438,00073.1% (band 70.01 to 75.00%)0.750%$2,400

A $24,000 shortfall between cost and credit moves the loan across the 70 percent line

The $24,000 difference between the two rows is the amount of the project the market did not pay for. It lifts the ratio from 69.3 to 73.1 percent and puts the loan in the next pricing tier, which costs 0.500 percent of the loan, $1,600, in the matrix charge alone. A lender converts that charge into rate or fees, so the number you see differs, but the direction does not. The loan-to-value ratio also drives the mortgage insurance decision and, on a cash-out refinance, how much cash exists at all.

The $38,000 is an assumption chosen to make the arithmetic visible. It is not a typical return on a kitchen, and nothing in the Guide supports any particular percentage. In a market where nearly every comparable sale has a renovated kitchen, an appraiser may find the adjustment for yours close to nothing, because the market treats it as the baseline. In a market where the updated kitchen is rare, it may exceed cost. What the table shows is the sensitivity: the pricing tiers step at fixed ratios, and a value that lands just either side of an edge changes the charge for the whole loan.

What the report has to say about each kind of work

The appraisal form forces an appraiser to classify what was done, measure what was added and say whether it was permitted. The Guide's rules for those classifications are public, and knowing them tells you what documents help and what does not. The table lists the kinds of work homeowners ask about and what the Guide requires the report to do with each. It describes what the appraiser must report, not what the market will pay.

How the Selling Guide directs an appraiser to treat common renovation work (B4-1.3-05 and B4-1.3-06, both dated June 4, 2025; October 23, 2026)
Work doneWhat the report must doWhere it is written
Kitchen or bath brought up to market expectationsClassify the area as "Updated" (limited in scope and cost, refurbishing or replacing components) or "Remodeled" (replacing cabinets, bathtub or tile, relocating plumbing, gas or appliances, moving walls)B4-1.3-06, definitions of Not Updated, Updated and Remodeled
New room with interior access, above gradeMeasure finished area by the ANSI Z765-2021 method and report it in the above-grade finished area and room countB4-1.3-05, square footage
Finished basementReport below-grade area on its own line and adjust there; a level with any portion below grade is below-grade whatever its finish or windowsB4-1.3-05
Attached addition with no interior accessReport as noncontinuous finished area on a separate line, outside the main living area and room countB4-1.3-05
Detached finished structureSeparate line in the adjustment grid, outside the main finished areaB4-1.3-05
Accessory dwelling unitDescribe it, analyze its effect on value and marketability, and report it on its own line unless it sits inside the home with interior access and above gradeB4-1.3-05, Accessory Dwelling Units
Addition built without a required permitComment on the quality and appearance of the work and its effect, if any, on market valueB4-1.3-05, Additions without Permits
Solar, efficiency upgradesNote them in the improvements section; the contribution to value varies by climate, utility cost and market reactionB4-1.3-05, special energy-saving items

Where the renovation shows up in the condition rating

Every UAD appraisal assigns the subject a condition rating from C1 to C6 and a quality rating from Q1 to Q6, and Fannie Mae requires the rating to reflect "a holistic view" of the property. The Guide says it would be inappropriate to select a higher or lower overall rating because of one or two inferior or superior areas. A single renovated kitchen in a house with 20-year-old mechanicals and worn floors will not by itself move a rating, though it can move the adjustment for the kitchen line. The rating that most often matters after a renovation is C2, which the Guide describes as an older property that "has been recently completely renovated", with no deferred maintenance and outdated components updated or replaced, and C3, a well-maintained house where "some components, but not every major building component, may be updated".

The Guide also gives the appraiser a rule about age: residential properties of fifteen years or less often reflect an original condition with no updating, and older ones are considered not updated if appliances, fixtures and finishes are predominantly dated. That is why recency of the work and its coverage matter more than a total spent. A $20,000 project that touches every room can move a rating that $60,000 spent on one room may not.

The rating also governs eligibility, not only value. A C6 rating signals deficiencies that affect safety, soundness or structural integrity, and a loan on a C6 property is not eligible to be sold to Fannie Mae. The appraisal must be completed "subject to" the repair with a minimum resulting rating of C5. If the reason for the project was a failing roof, foundation settlement or active water intrusion, the lender will need proof of completion before the loan closes or is sold, which is the next part of the sequence.

If a home equity line paid for the work, the refinance that repays it is cash-out

This is the rule that changes the arithmetic most often. A limited cash-out refinance may pay off the existing first mortgage and subordinate liens, but Selling Guide B2-1.3-02 (revised October 8, 2025) says "Only subordinate liens used to purchase the property may be paid off and included in the new mortgage." The one exception is a PACE loan or other secured or unsecured debt used solely for energy-related improvements. A HELOC you drew for a bathroom, a roof or a deck is not one of those. Paying it off with a new first mortgage makes the transaction a cash-out refinance, even though you take home no cash. Debt on a credit card or personal loan that paid for the work behaves the same way, because only the first mortgage and purchase-money subordinate liens are on the list of what a limited cash-out refinance can retire.

The class matters in three places. The ceiling falls: a one-unit principal residence is capped at 80 percent on a cash-out refinance and at 97 percent (fixed rate) on a limited one, per the Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026. Above 95 percent, a limited cash-out refinance is also conditioned on Fannie Mae already owning the loan being paid off. The price rises: the cash-out grid in the Loan-Level Price Adjustment Matrix dated September 30, 2026 charges 1.000 percent at a 740 to 759 score between 60.01 and 70.00 percent, against 0.250 percent on the limited grid. And the seasoning clocks apply: the first mortgage being repaid has to be a year old by note date, and one borrower must have held title six months (B2-1.3-03, December 10, 2025). The 12-month rule does not apply to subordinate liens being paid off, so a line opened recently is not a seasoning problem.

A short case shows the price effect in isolation. A home appraises at $460,000 after the work. The borrower owes $255,000 on the first mortgage and $55,000 on the HELOC that paid for the project, and adds $5,000 of closing costs to the loan: $315,000, or 68.5 percent of value. The cash-out charge is 1.000 percent ($3,150) and the limited cash-out charge for the same loan would be 0.250 percent ($788). The classification costs 0.750 percent, or $2,363, on a loan with the same balance, the same value and the same borrower.

Renovating first and refinancing later runs into the 80 percent ceiling

The ceiling cuts harder than the price when the project is large relative to the equity. Take a one-unit home that will be worth $400,000 once the work is done, a first mortgage of $290,000, a $60,000 project and $6,000 of closing costs on the refinance. Three financing orders put the same work on the same house.

Order one is the one-loan route. A single new loan of $290,000 plus $60,000 plus $6,000, or $356,000, is 89.0 percent of the $400,000 as-completed value. That fits under the 97 percent fixed-rate ceiling for a limited cash-out refinance on a principal residence. The pricing charge at a 740 to 759 score in the 85.01 to 90.00 percent band is 1.125 percent, $4,005. Order two is renovating with a HELOC and refinancing afterwards: the new first mortgage would have to repay $290,000 and $60,000 and cover costs, which is the same $356,000, but it is a cash-out refinance with an 80 percent ceiling. Eighty percent of $400,000 is $320,000. After $6,000 of costs and the $290,000 first mortgage, only $24,000 of the $60,000 line fits inside the new loan. The borrower would have to pay down $36,000 of the line from savings or keep it as a second lien. Order three is to keep the first mortgage and the line, which is a different decision and is priced in the refinance versus HELOC guide.

The difference between the first two is mostly timing. The appraiser values the house as completed in order one, so the ratio is measured against the finished value from the first day, and that is why the one-loan route can lend against equity that the work has not created yet.

The same $60,000 project, financed two ways at closing (principal residence, one unit, fixed rate; as-completed value $400,000; first mortgage $290,000; closing costs $6,000; Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026; October 23, 2026)
RouteLoan classCeiling in the matrixLoan neededLTV on $400,000Result
Fold the work into one new loan (HomeStyle)Limited cash-out, as-completed value97% fixed$356,00089.0%Eligible on the ratio; matrix charge 1.125% at 740 to 759, $4,005
Finish with a HELOC, then refinance everythingCash-out (HELOC payoff)80%$356,00089.0%Over the ceiling; largest loan $320,000, so $36,000 of the line stays or is paid down

HomeStyle Renovation and HomeStyle Refresh: two products with different limits

Fannie Mae has two programs that finance the work inside the refinance, and they are not interchangeable. HomeStyle Renovation (Selling Guide B5-3.2-02, December 10, 2025) is the full program. HomeStyle Refresh (B5-3.3-01, August 5, 2026) is a lighter one for smaller projects that a lender can deliver without special approval. Both appraise the property on an "as completed" basis, subject to the work being done. Neither is a cash-out product: HomeStyle Renovation says the borrower "may not receive any cash proceeds", and the Guide says improvements on a cash-out refinance are permitted but the transaction is then not a HomeStyle Refresh loan. Whether a lender offers either one is a lender decision. We describe the rules, not who offers them.

FHA's 203(k) renovation loan has its own rules in the HUD Handbook and was not reviewed for this page.

HomeStyle Renovation compared with HomeStyle Refresh on a refinance (Selling Guide B5-3.2-02, B5-3.2-03, B5-3.2-04, B5-3.3-01, B4-1.2-05; October 23, 2026)
FeatureHomeStyle RenovationHomeStyle Refresh
Property typesOne- to four-unit principal residence, one-unit second home, one-unit investment property, manufactured home, eligible condo, PUD or co-op unitAll one- to four-unit existing properties and all occupancy types
Cost limit on a refinance75% of the as-completed appraised valueUp to 15% of the as-completed appraised value
Loan-to-value ratioLoan divided by the as-completed value, against the matrix limited cash-out cellsLimited cash-out cells; as-completed value if delivered before the work is done, appraised value if the appraisal followed completion
Typical workLarger projects, planned and costed from the plans and specifications and the contractor bidsKitchen and bath updates, decks, porches, pools, an accessory dwelling unit, energy or water efficiency, disaster resilience and repair
Contractor and plansLicensed contractor chosen by the borrower and vetted by the lender, plans and specifications by a licensed general contractor, consultant or architect; do-it-yourself work capped at 10% of as-completed value on a one-unit homeThe lender must give the appraiser all plans and specifications, manage the completion escrow and monitor the work
CompletionFunds held in a renovation escrow and released as work is finished; the attestation-letter and alternative completion methods are not permittedCompletion escrow; work due within 180 days of the note date; up to 50% may be drawn at closing; the appraiser certifies completion on Form 1004D
Contingency and reserves10% contingency reserve required on two- to four-unit properties; up to six payments may be escrowed on a principal residence that cannot be occupiedUp to 20% contingency on top of the improvement cost
Cash to the borrowerNone; surplus reduces principal or pays for documented added workStandard limited cash-out allowance (the greater of 1% of the loan or $2,000) applies

Proof of completion changes depending on what the appraiser wrote

When the work is finished before the appraisal, the appraiser sees the finished house and the report is "as is". Nothing remains to prove, except in the narrow case that a safety or soundness repair was written as a condition. When the work is unfinished at closing, the value is "as completed" and the loan has to be tied to evidence that the work happened. Selling Guide B4-1.2-05 (December 10, 2025; checked October 23, 2026) lets a borrower attest in writing for repairs and alterations to existing construction in place of a completion report from the appraiser, with a signature, a visually verifiable exhibit of the completed work and either the signature of a qualified professional, a professionally prepared report or paid invoices. The Guide states that the attestation-letter method is not permitted for HomeStyle Renovation. A house built from the ground up follows a separate Selling Guide chapter, with a completion report on a single-close loan or a new appraisal on a two-closing one, as our guide to refinancing a construction loan into a permanent mortgage sets out.

The size of the postponed work is also limited. For a HomeStyle Refresh loan the work must be completed within 180 days of the note date, a contingency of up to 20 percent can be included in the escrow, and any money left over reduces the loan balance. The Guide adds that the value of sweat equity and do-it-yourself work is not reimbursable. If a Refresh project runs past 180 days, the lender must report the reason and the loan stays subject to recourse until completion is proven. Those are lender obligations, but they explain why a lender may ask for a contractor bid and a timeline before it will quote.

The lender also has to update title before releasing the final funds, to confirm that no mechanic's or materialman's liens have attached. In states where a contractor's lien can outrank a mortgage, the lender must collect lien releases. An unpaid contractor is the lien risk that title update is looking for.

A new apartment, or an addition built without a permit

The most valuable improvements are often the ones that change what the property is, and those are where the Guide is most specific. An accessory dwelling unit is described as additional living area independent of the main dwelling, with living, sleeping, cooking and bathroom facilities on the same parcel. Whether a property counts as a one-unit property with an ADU or as a two- to four-unit property depends on characteristics such as separate utility meters, a unique postal address and whether the unit can be legally rented. The appraiser decides as part of the highest-and-best-use analysis, and the report must show the improvements are acceptable to the market using an aged settled sale as a comparable, with an active listing or contract sale as supporting evidence.

The classification then feeds the loan: a one-unit home with an ADU and a two-unit home sit in different rows of the Eligibility Matrix, and income from an ADU is limited to purchase and limited cash-out transactions with the rental income capped at 30 percent of total qualifying income (B3-3.8-02). The two-unit side of that line, including how the other unit's rent reaches the debt-to-income ratio, is worked in refinancing an owner-occupied duplex, triplex or fourplex. The one-unit side, including how an ADU's rent is measured and what a roommate's or a short-term guest's rent can do, is worked in rent from a roommate, an ADU or Airbnb guests. If zoning does not allow an ADU, the property can still be eligible, on conditions: the lender confirms the unit will not jeopardize a future insurance claim, the use conforms to the neighborhood and market, the appraisal is based on current use and states that the use does not comply with zoning, and the report shows at least two comparable sales with the same non-compliant use, for a total of three settled sales.

For an ordinary addition the Guide's wording is short. An appraiser who finds an addition without the required permit must comment on the quality and appearance of the work and its impact, if any, on market value. The Guide does not say the space must be excluded or that a loan must be refused. What happens to a specific property then depends on the investor, the lender's own rules and local law, so check the permit record before the appraiser visits, not after the report posts a problem. The space also has to be measured under the ANSI method, so a room that is finished but reached through unfinished space is reported on a separate nonstandard line rather than in the main living area.

If the goal is to drop mortgage insurance, the servicer route may already cover it

Many people refinance after a renovation hoping the new value removes private mortgage insurance. On a conventional loan owned by Fannie Mae you may not need a new loan to do that. Servicing Guide B-8.1-04 (May 15, 2019; checked October 23, 2026) allows borrower-initiated termination on current value for a one-unit principal residence or second home when the loan-to-value ratio is 75 percent or less with seasoning between two and five years, or 80 percent or less after five years. If the two-year minimum seasoning is waived because the borrower's improvements increased the value, the ratio must be 80 percent or less. The borrower has to give the servicer the details of the work, and the guide distinguishes improvements, "typically renovations that substantially improve marketability and extend the useful life", such as kitchen and bathroom renovations or added square footage, from repairs that merely keep the property maintained.

The servicer also requires a property valuation from an inspection of the interior and exterior, and the payment history conditions in the same section apply. The PMI removal guide works that path, and the break-even question for a new loan is in rate-and-term versus cash-out. If PMI is the only reason to refinance, price the servicer request against the closing costs first, using the break-even guide. If the renovation was a solar installation financed by a lease, a fixture-filed loan or a PACE assessment, the rules are different again; see our guide to refinancing with solar panels.

Common questions

Can an investment property use HomeStyle Renovation?

Yes, a one-unit investment property is an eligible property type under B5-3.2-02, and the Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026 lists a 75 percent maximum LTV for a HomeStyle Renovation limited cash-out refinance on a one-unit investment property, against 97 percent on a principal residence. The principal residence rows are not available for a rental, and two- to four-unit investment properties are not listed.

Is my own labor reimbursable if I do the work?

Not as labor. Under HomeStyle Renovation the do-it-yourself option is limited to one-unit properties and to 10 percent of the as-completed value, the lender must approve the work in advance and inspect any item costing more than $5,000, and you can be reimbursed for materials or documented contract labor but not for sweat equity. HomeStyle Refresh also excludes it.

What happens to money left in a HomeStyle Renovation escrow?

Under B5-3.2-04, unused contingency funds, unless they came directly from you, must reduce the loan balance once the work is done and completion is certified. You may instead use leftover contingency on additional improvements if the lender warrants the planned work is finished, the extra work is documented with paid receipts from your own funds, and the appraiser who wrote the as-completed report inspects it.

What if the plans change after closing?

The lender must require a HomeStyle Change Order Request (Form 1200) or a similar document describing the change, its cost and its completion dates before approving it. If damage, death, divorce or another event alters the project, B5-3.2-03 requires an updated appraisal to test the as-completed value, and a loan that ends up over the eligibility ratios can be pushed back to the lender for repurchase.

Can I use HomeStyle Renovation on a condo?

Yes, a unit in an eligible condo, PUD or co-op project is an eligible property type, but for a condo or co-op unit the work has to be permitted by the bylaws or approved in writing by the association, and it is limited to the interior of the unit, including attic fire walls.

Gather the permit numbers, contractor invoices and a dated list of what changed in each room before the appraiser visits; if the value still lands short of the cost, what a low value does to the loan shows the moves that are left.

Sources and verification

The $400,000 and $462,000 values, the $38,000 adjustment, the $290,000 first mortgage, the $55,000 line and the closing costs are chosen illustrations, and the matrix percentages are what Fannie Mae charges its seller, not quotes to you. Nothing here says what an appraiser will credit for your project. FHA, VA, Freddie Mac and portfolio renovation products were not reviewed, and lenders set their own overlays on the Fannie Mae rules. Rules were checked October 23, 2026.