Refinancing a VA loan into a conventional loan: what you give up, what you get back, and the month it pays
On a $300,000 VA balance at 7.75%, a conventional refinance has to beat a VA IRRRL quote by about 0.24 point at 75% loan to value with a 740-759 score (0.37 at 680-699), and by 0.7 to 1.0 points above 80 percent, to pay back inside a seven-year stay. The conventional loan skips the funding fee, then adds a price adjustment and, above 80 percent, mortgage insurance. It also ends the IRRRL option, and returns entitlement only on request.
Worksheet steps (12)
- Four things move when a conventional loan pays off a VA loan
- Staying, the IRRRL and the conventional loan, priced to month 84
- Where the difference comes from: rate, a restarted term, financed costs and the cash adjustment
- What replaces the funding fee: a price adjustment that rises with loan-to-value
- The 80 percent line on $306,000: where financed costs and the appraisal decide
- How long conventional mortgage insurance lasts: the 80 and 78 percent dates
- Break-even in months: how far under the IRRRL quote the conventional rate must sit
- The lead a conventional quote must have by month 84, from 60 to 94 percent loan-to-value
- The IRRRL door, priced: what the next refinance costs from each side
- A later VA loan: the funding fee tiers, and why restored entitlement does not reset them
- Entitlement: the statute names routes back, and one of them can be used once
- A rule from five inputs, applied to the anchor loan
Four things move when a conventional loan pays off a VA loan
Two of the four are lost. The first is the IRRRL, VA's streamlined refinance, which is open only to a borrower who already holds a VA loan. VA's IRRRL page lists three conditions: “You already have a VA-backed home loan, and You’re using the IRRRL to refinance your existing VA-backed home loan, and You can certify that you currently live in or used to live in the home covered by the loan.” Once the loan is conventional the first condition fails, and the way back to VA is a different product with a different fee, priced in the section on the IRRRL door below. The second loss is structural. VA's funding fee page says the fee exists “since the VA home loan program doesn’t require down payments or monthly mortgage insurance.” A conventional loan above 80 percent loan to value does carry insurance. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B7-1-01, dated 04/02/2025) says: “Unless the lender has provided another charter-compliant form of credit enhancement, the lender must obtain a primary mortgage insurance policy for a conventional first mortgage loan that has an LTV ratio greater than 80% at the time it is purchased for Fannie Mae’s portfolio or securitized. (For this purpose, the LTV ratio is calculated based upon the unpaid principal balance of the mortgage loan at the time it is purchased or securitized by Fannie Mae.)”
Two things come back. The new loan carries no VA funding fee, and the guaranty entitlement the old loan was using can be restored on request, on terms set in 38 U.S.C. 3702(b) and quoted in full below. Neither gain is worth the same to every borrower. The funding fee is replaced by a price adjustment that can be larger than the fee it displaced, and the entitlement matters mainly to a veteran who expects to use VA again, on this house or another.
Every figure that follows runs on one loan. The VA mortgage has a $300,000 balance at 7.75% fixed, 324 months left (36 payments into a 30-year term), payment $2,212.29 for principal and interest. The home is worth $410,000 on a fresh appraisal, so the existing balance is 73.2% of value. The owner plans to stay 84 months, seven years, and then sell. Two refinance routes are priced against staying put. Route one is an IRRRL at a hypothetical 7.00% on a 30-year term, with the 0.50 percent funding fee from VA's rate chart financed and $2,500 of other costs assumed and financed, which makes the new loan $304,020. The 0.75-point drop from 7.75% clears the 0.50-point floor covered in the IRRRL guide. Route two is a conventional 30-year loan with $6,000 of assumed closing costs, also financed, making the new loan $306,000 (Fannie Mae's limited cash-out rules allow financing closing costs, points and prepaid items) and a price adjustment from Fannie Mae's matrix paid in cash. The 7.24% conventional rate is the Freddie Mac 30-year fixed average for the week of October 29, 2026; the 15-year average that week was 6.60%.
One convention matters for the price adjustments. Fannie Mae's matrix describes them as charges on loans sold to Fannie Mae, assessed from features such as credit score and loan purpose. A lender passes that charge to the borrower through the note rate or points, so a quote that is already adjusted has the cost in it. The tables here add the adjustment at face value, in cash, to a rate that is before the adjustment. A real quote already adjusted should be read without adding the adjustment again. The $2,500 and $6,000 cost figures, the 7.00% IRRRL rate and the credit scores are assumptions chosen for the arithmetic, not quotes.
Staying, the IRRRL and the conventional loan, priced to month 84
The yardstick is the total outlay if the house is sold in month 84: every payment made, plus the balance paid off at the sale, plus any cash paid at closing. It puts a lower payment bought with a longer term or a bigger balance on the same footing as a lower rate. Staying costs $455,312: 84 payments of $2,212.29 ($185,832) plus a $269,480 payoff.
| Path | New loan | Rate | Term (months) | Payment (P&I) | Balance at month 84 | Cash at closing | Outlay through month 84 | Against staying |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stay on the VA loan | $300,000 | 7.75% | 324 | $2,212.29 | $269,480 | $0 | $455,312 | none |
| VA IRRRL | $304,020 | 7.00% | 360 | $2,022.65 | $277,106 | $0 | $447,009 | -$8,303 |
| VA IRRRL, funding fee exempt | $302,500 | 7.00% | 360 | $2,012.54 | $275,721 | $0 | $444,774 | -$10,538 |
| Conventional, score 740-759, 74.6% LTV | $306,000 | 7.24% | 360 | $2,085.38 | $279,936 | $2,295 | $457,404 | +$2,091 |
| Conventional, score 680-699, 74.6% LTV | $306,000 | 7.24% | 360 | $2,085.38 | $279,936 | $4,973 | $460,081 | +$4,769 |
On these inputs the conventional loan at 7.24% costs more than staying put, by $2,091 at the better score and $4,769 at the lower one, while the IRRRL costs $8,303 less than staying. The IRRRL needs 26 months to pull ahead of the old loan, or 15 months for a veteran who pays no funding fee. The gap between the conventional loan and the IRRRL is $10,394 at the better score. Its payment is lower than the old one by $127 a month, so the shortfall is not a payment problem. The next table splits the shortfall by cause.
Where the difference comes from: rate, a restarted term, financed costs and the cash adjustment
Each column below changes one thing from the one before it. First the $300,000 is repriced at the new rate over the 324 months that remain. Then the term is restarted at 360 months. Then the financed costs are added to the balance. Last, the price adjustment is paid in cash. Negative numbers are savings; every figure is measured at month 84, against the $455,312 of staying.
| Path | Rate repriced, same 324 months | Term restarted at 360 months | Closing costs financed (principal plus interest) | Price adjustment in cash | Net against staying |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VA IRRRL at 7.00% | -$15,835 | +$1,621 | +$5,911 | $0 | -$8,303 |
| Conventional, 740-759 at 7.24% | -$10,778 | +$1,651 | +$8,924 | +$2,295 | +$2,091 |
| Conventional, 680-699 at 7.24% | -$10,778 | +$1,651 | +$8,924 | +$4,973 | +$4,769 |
The rate step is the only one that saves money, and it is worth $10,778 at 7.24% against $15,835 at 7.00%. The term restart costs between $1,621 and $1,651 at the two rates, small here because the old loan has only 36 payments behind it. Financing $6,000 of closing costs on the conventional side adds $8,924 through month 84, which is the $6,000 itself plus $2,924 of interest and payments on it; financing the IRRRL's fee and other costs adds $5,911 on $4,020 of added balance. The price adjustment is the last piece, $2,295 at the better score and $4,973 at the lower one.
Split that way, no single feature of the conventional loan is the problem. Of the $10,394 by which the conventional loan trails the IRRRL at the better score, $5,057 is the rate, which is 0.24 point higher; $3,013 is the larger financed costs ($8,924 against $5,911); $2,295 is the price adjustment; and $30 is the difference in the term restart. At the lower score the price adjustment is $4,973 and the gap widens to $13,072. The 0.50 percent funding fee on $304,020 is $1,520 of the IRRRL's $5,911.
What replaces the funding fee: a price adjustment that rises with loan-to-value
VA's chart sets the IRRRL fee at 0.5 percent of the loan, effective April 7, 2023, on a page last updated October 5, 2026. VA's chart lists it by loan type, with no credit score or loan-to-value input. Fannie Mae's adjustments move with both. The matrix opens by saying it “provides the LLPAs applicable to loans sold to Fannie Mae,” and it adds: “Not all loans will be eligible for the features or loan-to-value (LTV) ratios described in this Matrix and unless otherwise noted, FHA, VA, Rural Development (RD) Section 502 Mortgages, and HUD Section 184 Mortgages are excluded from these LLPAs.” So the matrix prices conventional loans on a grid, while VA's chart for the IRRRL is flat.
| Credit score | 30.01 to 60% LTV | 60.01 to 70% LTV | 70.01 to 75% LTV | 75.01 to 80% LTV | 80.01 to 85% LTV | 85.01 to 90% LTV | 90.01 to 95% LTV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 780 and up | 0.000% | 0.000% | 0.125% | 0.500% | 0.625% | 0.500% | 0.375% |
| 740-759 | 0.000% | 0.250% | 0.750% | 1.125% | 1.375% | 1.125% | 1.000% |
| 700-719 | 0.000% | 0.625% | 1.250% | 1.875% | 2.125% | 1.750% | 1.625% |
| 680-699 | 0.000% | 0.875% | 1.625% | 2.250% | 2.500% | 2.125% | 1.750% |
| 660-679 | 0.125% | 1.125% | 1.875% | 2.500% | 3.000% | 2.375% | 2.125% |
The limited cash-out grid is the one that applies here, because the new loan in this example pays off an existing first mortgage and finances its own costs, which the Selling Guide's B2-1.3-02 treats as a limited cash-out refinance. Against the 0.50 percent IRRRL fee, the adjustment is the same size or smaller in 11 of the 35 cells shown, all at a 740 score or better or at 60 percent loan to value and below. In the other 24 cells it is larger. At 75.01 to 80% LTV it is 2.25 times the fee at the 740-759 score and 4.5 times at 680-699: a 740-759 score pays 1.125% and a 680-699 score 2.250%, which on the $306,000 loan is $3,443 and $6,885, against $1,530 for a 0.50 percent fee on the same amount.
Two cases make the comparison easier to win. A veteran who is exempt from the funding fee pays nothing on the IRRRL side, which widens the gap rather than narrowing it; the exemption list on VA's funding fee page includes anyone receiving VA compensation for a service-connected disability. And the matrix has a waiver list, headed “All LLPAs will be waived for the following loans,” whose first entry is HomeReady loans and which also covers certain Duty to Serve loans with income limits. Those programs have their own borrower rules, which this guide does not test.
The 80 percent line on $306,000: where financed costs and the appraisal decide
The test is run on the new loan, not the old one. The existing balance here is 73.2% of a $410,000 value, but $6,000 of financed closing costs lifts the new loan to $306,000, 74.6% of value. A lower appraisal raises it. Fannie Mae's rule quoted above measures the loan, as unpaid principal balance, against the 80 percent line, and the Selling Guide topic on limited cash-out refinances treats ratios over 95% as a separate tier (95.01 to 97%) with added conditions.
That tier has a condition aimed at this reader. The Selling Guide (B2-1.3-02, dated 10/08/2025) says that for ratios above 95% the lender must tell Fannie Mae's underwriting system that the existing loan is owned or securitized by Fannie Mae and, when the system cannot confirm it, must document it. The topic does not say how a VA-guaranteed loan being paid off would meet that condition. A borrower who needs more than 95 percent of value should ask a lender to confirm in writing which limit applies to a VA payoff, because the ceilings by property type and occupancy sit in Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix, which this guide does not reproduce.
| Appraised value | New loan to value | Principal paid in to reach 80% | Price adjustment, score 740-759 | Price adjustment, score 680-699 | Mortgage insurance per month (assumed 0.60%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $325,000 | 94.2% | $46,000 | 1.000% = $3,060 | 1.750% = $5,355 | $153 |
| $340,000 | 90.0% | $34,000 | 1.125% = $3,443 | 2.125% = $6,503 | $153 |
| $360,000 | 85.0% | $18,000 | 1.375% = $4,208 | 2.500% = $7,650 | $153 |
| $385,000 | 79.5% | $0 | 1.125% = $3,443 | 2.250% = $6,885 | not required |
| $410,000 | 74.6% | $0 | 0.750% = $2,295 | 1.625% = $4,973 | not required |
| $440,000 | 69.5% | $0 | 0.250% = $765 | 0.875% = $2,678 | not required |
| $510,000 | 60.0% | $0 | 0.000% = $0 | 0.000% = $0 | not required |
On the $306,000 loan the 80 percent line falls at an appraisal of $382,500. At $385,000 the new loan is 79.5% of value and no insurance is needed; at $360,000 it is 85.0 percent and $18,000 of principal would have to be paid in at closing to reach 80%. Two levers move a loan across the line: paying the closing costs in cash instead of financing them, and paying principal at closing. The first changes the ratio by only 1.6% of value at a $385,000 appraisal, from 79.5% to 77.9%, and on a $360,000 appraisal it leaves the loan at 83.3%, still over the line. Only the second closes a gap of the size in the 85 and 90 percent rows.
How long conventional mortgage insurance lasts: the 80 and 78 percent dates
The Homeowners Protection Act sets the cancellation and termination schedule for private mortgage insurance on a principal-residence mortgage, in 12 U.S.C. 4901 and 4902 (uscode.house.gov, current through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026). For a refinance of the borrower's principal residence the statute defines the starting value narrowly: “In the case of a residential mortgage transaction for refinancing the principal residence of the mortgagor, such term means only the appraised value relied upon by the mortgagee to approve the refinance transaction.” So the 80 percent date is measured from the refinance appraisal, not from the price paid for the house years earlier.
Two dates follow from the definitions in section 4901, both counted on the original amortization schedule for a fixed-rate loan. The cancellation date is when the scheduled balance first reaches 80 percent of that value, and the borrower may ask for cancellation then, or earlier if actual payments bring the balance to 80 percent. The termination date is when the scheduled balance first reaches 78 percent, and insurance ends automatically if the borrower is current. The PMI removal guide sets out the conditions on a cancellation request, the midpoint rule, the loans the dates do not reach, and the Fannie Mae servicing route that removes insurance on today's value.
The table prices those dates on the conventional loan. Three assumed insurance rates, 0.30, 0.60 and 1.00 percent of the loan a year, bracket what an insurer might charge; no insurer's rate card was used, and a real quote depends on the borrower and the loan.
| Appraised value | Starting loan to value | Principal paid in at closing to start at 80% | Months to 80% (cancellation date) | Months to 78% (automatic) | Insurance per month at 0.30% / 0.60% / 1.00% | Insurance paid through month of 80% at 0.30% / 0.60% / 1.00% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $325,000 | 94.2% | $46,000 | 129 | 141 | $77 / $153 / $255 | $9,869 / $19,737 / $32,895 |
| $340,000 | 90.0% | $34,000 | 103 | 118 | $77 / $153 / $255 | $7,880 / $15,759 / $26,265 |
| $360,000 | 85.0% | $18,000 | 63 | 82 | $77 / $153 / $255 | $4,820 / $9,639 / $16,065 |
At 90.0% loan to value the scheduled balance does not reach 80% until month 103, about 8.6 years, and the insurance paid over that stretch is $7,880 to $26,265 across the assumed rates. A seven-year stay ends before the cancellation date in the top two rows, so the owner pays the insurance for the whole stay and sells with $279,936 still owed. That is the arithmetic behind the required lead in the break-even table. VA's funding fee page says the VA program does not require monthly mortgage insurance, so every dollar of the insurance in this table is a cost the VA loan did not have.
Break-even in months: how far under the IRRRL quote the conventional rate must sit
Break-even here is the first month in which the outlay on the new loan (payments made, plus the balance owed, plus cash paid at closing) is no higher than the outlay on the loan it is measured against. It is measured twice: against staying on the 7.75% VA loan, which is the comparison for a veteran who does not qualify for or does not want an IRRRL, and against the 7.00% IRRRL, which is the comparison for one who does. The conventional loan is the $306,000 loan at 74.6% of the $410,000 value, so no insurance applies, and each rate is taken before the price adjustment.
| Conventional rate before adjustment | Points below the IRRRL quote | Payment (P&I) | Months to beat staying, 740-759 | Months to beat staying, 680-699 | Months to beat the IRRRL, 740-759 | Months to beat the IRRRL, 680-699 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.24% (Freddie Mac average, week of October 29, 2026) | -0.24 (higher) | $2,085.38 | none by month 360 | none by month 360 | none by month 360 | none by month 360 |
| 7.00% | 0.00 | $2,035.83 | 59 | 81 | none by month 360 | none by month 360 |
| 6.875% | 0.125 | $2,010.20 | 48 | 64 | 200 | none by month 360 |
| 6.75% | 0.25 | $1,984.71 | 40 | 53 | 81 | 131 |
| 6.625% | 0.375 | $1,959.35 | 35 | 46 | 51 | 82 |
| 6.50% | 0.50 | $1,934.13 | 31 | 41 | 37 | 60 |
| 6.25% | 0.75 | $1,884.09 | 25 | 33 | 24 | 39 |
| 6.00% | 1.00 | $1,834.62 | 21 | 28 | 18 | 29 |
At the 7.24% average the conventional loan does not overtake either alternative at either score by month 360, because its rate is 0.24 point above the IRRRL quote and the $2,295 to $4,973 adjustment sits on top. At the same 7.00% as the IRRRL it beats staying in month 59 at the better score and month 81 at the lower one, and it does not catch the IRRRL by month 360, because it carries the same rate and higher costs. To catch the IRRRL inside the 84-month stay, the conventional rate has to be 0.25 point lower at the better score (month 81) and, at the lower score, 0.375 point lower (month 82). The lead also changes the date quickly: in the better-score column, moving from 0.25 point under the IRRRL quote to 0.50 point moves the break-even from month 81 to month 37.
The IRRRL itself breaks even against staying in month 26, or month 15 with no funding fee, which is the benchmark every conventional row has to beat before it is worth the lost streamline door.
One feature of the staying columns needs a reading. In the rows from 7.00% down to 6.75%, the conventional loan's lead over staying reverses late in the loan, between months 276 and 359. The cause is the restarted term: the VA loan is paid off at month 324, while the new loan runs 36 months longer, and with a thin rate advantage those extra payments eventually outweigh the early saving. A stay of 84 months ends long before then, but a borrower who plans to keep the loan to payoff should compare lifetime interest as well.
The lead a conventional quote must have by month 84, from 60 to 94 percent loan-to-value
Reading one row of the break-even table at a time hides how fast the required lead changes with equity. The next table solves for it directly: the number of points by which the conventional rate has to undercut a 7.00% IRRRL quote for the two paths to cost the same through month 84, by bisection on the outlay. Above 80 percent, the assumed 0.60 percent insurance rate is included for as long as the scheduled balance stays over 80 percent of value.
| Appraised value | New loan to value | Price adjustment, 740-759 | Price adjustment, 680-699 | Insurance | Required lead, 740-759 (points) | Required lead, 680-699 (points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $325,000 | 94.2% | 1.000% | 1.750% | 129 months | 0.87 | 0.98 |
| $340,000 | 90.0% | 1.125% | 2.125% | 103 months | 0.89 | 1.04 |
| $360,000 | 85.0% | 1.375% | 2.500% | 63 months | 0.72 | 0.87 |
| $385,000 | 79.5% | 1.125% | 2.250% | none | 0.29 | 0.45 |
| $410,000 | 74.6% | 0.750% | 1.625% | none | 0.24 | 0.37 |
| $440,000 | 69.5% | 0.250% | 0.875% | none | 0.17 | 0.26 |
| $510,000 | 60.0% | 0.000% | 0.000% | none | 0.13 | 0.13 |
At 60.0 percent loan to value, 40 percent equity, the required lead is 0.13 point at either score: the price adjustment is zero, and the $1,980 difference between the $6,000 of conventional costs and the IRRRL's $4,020 of fee and costs is what the lower rate has to earn back. From there it rises to 0.29 point at the better score and 0.45 at the lower one just under 80 percent, then to 0.72 at 85.0 percent and 0.89 at 90.0 percent. Most of the step above 80 percent is the insurance; at the better score the price adjustment in the 85.01 to 90% band (1.125%) equals the one in the 75.01 to 80% band (1.125%).
The insurance rate moves that line more than the score does. At 90.0 percent loan to value and the 740-759 score, the required lead is 0.59 point at an assumed 0.30 percent insurance rate ($77 a month), 0.89 at 0.60 ($153) and 1.29 at 1.00 ($255). A real insurance quote therefore decides whether the loan is a candidate at all, which is the reason to get it before the application and not after.
A $300,000 VA payoff, three paths, month 84
Inputs: a VA mortgage with a $300,000 balance, 7.75% fixed, 324 months left, payment $2,212.29; a $410,000 appraisal (73.2% before costs); a stay of 84 months. IRRRL: a hypothetical 7.00%, 30 years, the 0.50 percent funding fee ($1,520) and $2,500 of assumed costs financed into a $304,020 loan, payment $2,022.65. Conventional: $6,000 of assumed closing costs financed into a $306,000 loan (74.6% of value, so no mortgage insurance), 30 years at 7.24% (the Freddie Mac average for the week of October 29, 2026), payment $2,085.38, and a price adjustment of 0.750% ($2,295) at a 740-759 score or 1.625% ($4,973) at 680-699, paid in cash. Result through month 84: staying costs $455,312; the IRRRL $447,009, which is $8,303 lower; the conventional loan $457,404 at the better score and $460,081 at the lower one, which is $2,091 and $4,769 higher than staying. The conventional payment is $127 a month lower than the old one but $63 higher than the IRRRL's, and the loan still owes $279,936 at the sale against $277,106 on the IRRRL. To tie the IRRRL through month 84 the conventional rate would have to be 0.24 point lower at the better score and 0.37 point lower at the other, about 6.76% and 6.63% on these inputs. All rates except the Freddie Mac average are hypothetical.
The IRRRL door, priced: what the next refinance costs from each side
A loan that stays VA can be refinanced again by IRRRL, subject to the seasoning, rate and recoupment tests in the IRRRL guide, at 0.5 percent plus whatever the lender charges. A conventional loan is refinanced into another conventional loan, or moved back to VA through the cash-out route described below. The table prices a second refinance of the same balance 36 months after the first, when the conventional loan has paid down to $296,415. The conventional column uses the same $6,000 of closing costs plus the limited cash-out adjustment for the loan-to-value band, and the IRRRL column uses 0.50 percent of the balance plus $2,500 of other costs.
| Loan to value at the second refinance | Implied value | Conventional, score 740-759 | Conventional, score 680-699 | IRRRL | Conventional costs more, 740-759 | Conventional costs more, 680-699 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60% | $494,025 | $6,000 | $6,000 | $3,982 | +$2,018 | +$2,018 |
| 70% | $423,450 | $6,741 | $8,594 | $3,982 | +$2,759 | +$4,612 |
| 75% | $395,220 | $8,223 | $10,817 | $3,982 | +$4,241 | +$6,835 |
| 80% | $370,519 | $9,335 | $12,669 | $3,982 | +$5,353 | +$8,687 |
| 85% | $348,723 | $10,076 | $13,410 | $3,982 | +$6,094 | +$9,428 |
The conventional second refinance costs $2,018 more than the IRRRL even at 60 percent loan to value, where the price adjustment is zero, and $9,428 more at 85 percent for the lower score. The table counts money only. It does not price the time and paperwork of a full application and an appraisal, which the IRRRL guide contrasts with the streamline.
The way back to VA from a conventional loan is a cash-out refinance, not an IRRRL. VA's cash-out page lists, among the reasons to take one, “Refinance a non-VA loan into a VA-backed loan,” and sets conditions: a Certificate of Eligibility, VA's and the lender's standards for credit and income, and living in the home. VA's fee chart for that loan is 2.15 percent for first use and 3.3 percent after first use, and does not change with the down payment. On the $300,000 balance, the IRRRL fee is $1,500, the after-first-use cash-out fee is $9,900, and the difference is $8,400, before the appraisal and the full underwriting that the cash-out loan requires. That $8,400 is the price of a round trip out of VA and back, and the VA cash-out guide covers how the cash-out loan is sized and priced. The rate-and-term versus cash-out guide explains how the two classifications are drawn.
A later VA loan: the funding fee tiers, and why restored entitlement does not reset them
VA's funding fee page describes no credit toward a later loan for a fee already paid on an earlier one. The refund it does describe is narrow: a veteran later awarded VA compensation, with an effective date retroactive to before closing, may be eligible. A proposed or memorandum rating received after closing does not qualify for a refund. The page lists no credit for a fee paid on an earlier loan.
Whether a later loan pays the first-use or the after-first-use rate depends on whether the veteran has ever had a VA loan, not on whether entitlement has been restored. The definition is in 38 U.S.C. 3729(b)(4)(D)(i): “The term ‘initial loan’ means a loan to a veteran guaranteed under section 3710 or made under section 3711 of this title if the veteran has never obtained a loan guaranteed under section 3710 or made under section 3711 of this title.” The exception in clause (ii) covers a dwelling substantially damaged or destroyed in a presidentially declared major disaster, where the next loan within three years, made only for repairs or construction, is treated as initial. VA's chart adds one more: a veteran who used VA only to buy a manufactured home still pays the first-time rate. Neither exception turns on a refinance out of VA.
The table prices the fee on a $400,000 purchase at the three down-payment tiers on VA's chart. In this table the penalty for having used VA before shows up only below 5 percent down.
| Down payment | Loan amount | First use | After first use | Extra for having used VA before |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| under 5% (0% down) | $400,000 | 2.15% = $8,600 | 3.3% = $13,200 | $4,600 |
| 5% down | $380,000 | 1.5% = $5,700 | 1.5% = $5,700 | $0 |
| 10% down | $360,000 | 1.25% = $4,500 | 1.25% = $4,500 | $0 |
Two dated facts bear on timing. The statute's table lists rates for loans closed on or after April 7, 2023 and before June 9, 2034, and different rates for loans closed on or after June 9, 2034: 1.40 percent for an initial 0-down loan and 1.25 percent for a subsequent one, so a subsequent loan would then cost less than an initial one. That schedule is the statute as enacted today and Congress can change it. A veteran receiving VA disability compensation is exempt from the fee under 38 U.S.C. 3729(c) and the list on VA's page, so every fee figure in this section is zero for that borrower and only the IRRRL and entitlement points remain.
Entitlement: the statute names routes back, and one of them can be used once
VA's eligibility page lists three situations in which a veteran may restore entitlement used on an earlier loan to buy another home: “You’ve sold the home you bought with the prior loan and have paid that loan in full, or A qualified Veteran-transferee agrees to assume your loan and substitute their entitlement for the same amount of entitlement you used originally, or You’ve repaid your prior loan in full, but haven’t sold the home you bought with that loan (you can only do this once).” A veteran who refinances into a conventional loan and keeps the house is in the third one. Requests go through a COE with an entitlement restoration, online, through the lender, or on VA Form 26-1880.
The authority is 38 U.S.C. 3702(b) (uscode.house.gov, current through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026), which says: “In computing the aggregate amount of guaranty or insurance housing loan entitlement available to a veteran under this chapter, the Secretary may exclude the amount of guaranty or insurance housing loan entitlement used for any guaranteed, insured, or direct loan under the following circumstances:” Paragraph (1) covers a property disposed of or destroyed and a loan repaid in full or the Secretary released; paragraph (2) covers a veteran-transferee who assumes the loan and substitutes entitlement. Paragraph (3) reads: “(A) The loan has been repaid in full; and (B) the loan for which the veteran seeks to use entitlement under this chapter is secured by the same property which secured the loan referred to in subparagraph (A) of this paragraph.” Paragraph (4) applies “[i]n a case not covered by paragraph (1) or (2)” and offers two alternatives: “(A) the loan has been repaid in full and, if the Secretary has suffered a loss on the loan, the loss has been paid in full; or (B) the Secretary has been released from liability as to the loan and, if the Secretary has suffered a loss on the loan, the loss has been paid in full.” The subsection ends: “The Secretary may, in any case involving circumstances the Secretary deems appropriate, waive one or more of the conditions prescribed in paragraph (1). The authority of the Secretary under this subsection to exclude an amount of guaranty or insurance housing loan entitlement previously used by a veteran may be exercised only once for that veteran under the authority of paragraph (4).”
On the text, a veteran who leaves VA by refinance and keeps the house has two different footings. Paragraph (3) fits a later VA loan secured by the same house, and its wording contains no once-only limit. For buying a different house while still owning this one, paragraph (4) is the catch-all, and the closing sentence limits it to one use per veteran. VA's page states the once-only rule for the repaid-and-kept case without mentioning paragraph (3), so how VA applies the two together is a question for VA or the lender when the request is made. The word “may” also means restoration is a decision made on a request, not an automatic event at payoff. The Entitlement Charged column in the COE's table of prior loans is where a veteran can see what an earlier restoration did, and VA's loan-limits page (last updated August 12, 2025) explains how the column feeds the calculation.
What restoration is worth depends on what the veteran would do with it. VA's loan-limits page says that with full entitlement “You don’t have a loan limit (as long as you can afford the loan amount and the property appraisal supports the purchase price of the home).” For a veteran with entitlement still charged, the page gives the method: multiply the county's one-unit limit by .25, subtract the entitlement already used, and multiply the remainder by 4 to get the loan most lenders will make without a down payment. FHFA announced on November 25, 2025 that the 2026 baseline one-unit limit is $832,750, so one quarter is $208,187.50. For the anchor veteran, who originally borrowed about $309,000, entitlement charged is assumed to be 25 percent of that, $77,250; the COE's Entitlement Charged column controls in a real file.
| Situation | Entitlement charged | Remaining bonus entitlement | Most a lender would typically lend with no down payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entitlement restored (full entitlement) | $0 | $208,187.50 | No VA loan limit; the lender sets the amount from income, credit, assets and the appraisal |
| Original VA loan kept, one VA loan outstanding | $77,250 | $130,937.50 | $523,750 |
| Two VA loans outstanding | $120,000 | $88,187.50 | $352,750 |
The anchor veteran who keeps the VA loan can still use VA to buy another home to live in, up to $523,750 with no down payment, in a baseline-limit county. Restoration adds value for a second purchase above that figure, in a high-cost county, or when the second purchase would come after other VA loans have taken more of the entitlement. For a veteran whose next purchase fits under the ceiling, a conventional refinance does not need to be justified by the entitlement it frees. A later purchase with less than 5 percent down pays the 3.3% after-first-use fee on VA's chart whether or not entitlement was restored.
A rule from five inputs, applied to the anchor loan
The tables reduce to five inputs, each of which has a number on the lender's paperwork. First, loan to value on the new loan with financed costs inside it: 74.6% here, which clears the 80 percent line with room for an appraisal 6.7% lower. Second, the conventional rate before price adjustment and the IRRRL rate quoted for the same day. Third, the stay: 84 months, with sale before the month-103 cancellation date that applies at 90 percent loan to value. Fourth, the funding-fee status: the exempt veteran has the strongest case for the IRRRL, since the 0.50 percent fee is the cost the conventional loan avoids, and an exempt veteran has no such cost to avoid. Fifth, the next VA purchase: a second house above the ceiling in the entitlement table, or in a high-cost county, is the case where restoration has a dollar value.
On the anchor loan the answer at the dated average is clear. At the 7.24% average and an IRRRL at 7.00%, staying beats the conventional loan by $2,091 to $4,769 through month 84, and the IRRRL beats it by $10,394 to $13,072. Through month 84 on these inputs, the conventional loan becomes the cheaper path at 74.6 percent loan to value only if its rate is 0.24 to 0.37 point under the IRRRL quote, and at 90.0 percent only if the lead is 0.89 to 1.04 point on the assumed insurance rate. Those leads are hypothetical. They are the line to hold a real conventional quote up against, and the break-even guide shows how to run the same test on a real Loan Estimate.
A last case sits outside the IRRRL comparison. A VA borrower whose loan is already below today's rates, or who cannot meet the IRRRL's tests, has staying and the conventional loan to compare, and the staying columns of the break-even table apply. A veteran whose goal is to cash out equity belongs with the VA cash-out guide, where the funding fee is weighed against Fannie Mae's cash-out adjustments. A homeowner coming the other direction, from an FHA loan to conventional, faces the same insurance line with different rules, in the FHA to conventional guide.
Documents that settle the numbers before a conventional lender prices the payoff
- The VA loan’s payoff statement with the current balance, note rate, remaining months and whether any subordinate lien is open.
- Your Certificate of Eligibility, with the Entitlement Charged column for each prior loan and any earlier restoration.
- Whether you are exempt from the VA funding fee (a VA rating letter showing compensation), because it removes the one cost a conventional loan avoids.
- A written IRRRL quote on the same day as the conventional quote, with the rate, the financed funding fee and the other costs itemized.
- The conventional Loan Estimate with the rate before any price adjustment, the points, and whether the quote is already adjusted for credit score and loan to value.
- An appraisal estimate and the total new loan amount with financed costs, so the loan-to-value ratio is known before the insurance question.
- A mortgage insurance quote in dollars a month if the ratio is above 80 percent, with the lender’s statement of how the cancellation date is set.
- Your plans for the next VA loan, and the size of any second purchase, to see whether restored entitlement has a dollar value for you.
Questions about leaving a VA loan for a conventional one
Can I refinance a VA loan into a conventional loan?
Yes, lenders make these loans. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B2-1.3-02, 10/08/2025) lists paying off an existing first mortgage as an eligible purpose of a limited cash-out refinance and allows closing costs, points and prepaid items to be financed; the topic's 95.01 to 97% tier adds a condition about Fannie Mae-owned existing loans. The new loan is underwritten on the conventional standards and carries mortgage insurance above 80 percent loan to value. The VA loan's IRRRL option ends with the payoff.
Do I get my VA entitlement back after paying the loan off?
It can be restored on request, not automatically. VA lists restoration where the home was sold and the loan paid in full, where a qualified veteran-transferee assumes the loan and substitutes entitlement, and where the loan is repaid in full and the home is kept, which VA says can be done once. The statute, 38 U.S.C. 3702(b), says the Secretary “may exclude” the entitlement used. Request it with a COE that asks for restoration or on VA Form 26-1880.
Will I pay mortgage insurance on the conventional loan?
If the new loan, with financed costs included, is above 80 percent of the appraised value, Fannie Mae requires mortgage insurance unless the lender supplies another charter-compliant form of credit enhancement. At 80 percent or below it does not. On the anchor loan, $306,000 against $385,000 is 79.5% and needs none, while against $360,000 it is 85.0 percent and does. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, borrower-paid insurance can be cancelled on request when the scheduled balance reaches 80 percent of the refinance appraisal, and ends automatically at 78 percent.
Do I pay the VA funding fee again if I use VA later?
Yes, unless you are exempt from the fee, for example by receiving VA compensation for a service-connected disability. A later VA loan carries its own funding fee, and VA's page lists no credit for the fee paid on the first loan. The rate depends on loan type and, for purchases, on the down payment. With less than 5 percent down the after-first-use rate is 3.3 percent against 2.15 percent for first use; with 5 percent or more down both are 1.5 percent, and with 10 percent or more down both are 1.25 percent. Restoring entitlement does not make the later loan an initial loan under 38 U.S.C. 3729(b)(4)(D).
Is an IRRRL cheaper than refinancing to a conventional loan?
On the anchor loan it was. The IRRRL charges a 0.50 percent funding fee, $1,520 on $304,020, while the conventional loan's price adjustment was $2,295 to $4,973 at 70.01 to 75 percent loan to value, plus $6,000 of closing costs against $2,500. A conventional loan needs a lower rate than the IRRRL quote to make up the difference, by 0.24 to 0.37 point at 74.6 percent loan to value on these assumptions. A veteran must also pass the IRRRL's own seasoning, rate and recoupment tests.
Can I go back to a VA loan after refinancing out of one?
Through a VA cash-out refinance, which VA's page describes as a way to refinance a non-VA loan into a VA-backed loan. It requires a COE, meeting VA's and the lender's credit and income standards, an appraisal and living in the home, and the funding fee is 3.3 percent after first use ($9,900 on $300,000), against 0.5 percent ($1,500) for an IRRRL. The IRRRL itself is open only to a borrower who already has a VA-backed home loan.
Sources and verification
- VA, VA funding fee and loan closing costs (last updated October 5, 2026): Fee charts effective April 7, 2023: IRRRL 0.5%, cash-out 2.15% first use and 3.3% after first use, purchase tiers by down payment; exemptions; refund rule; the statement that the program does not require monthly mortgage insurance. Checked November 3, 2026.
- VA, Interest rate reduction refinance loan (IRRRL) (last updated January 7, 2026): Eligibility conditions, including an existing VA-backed home loan; costs may be included in the new loan. Checked November 3, 2026.
- VA, VA-backed cash-out refinance loan (last updated January 7, 2026): Refinancing a non-VA loan into a VA-backed loan; requirements for a COE, credit and income standards, occupancy and appraisal. Checked November 3, 2026.
- VA, Eligibility for VA home loan programs (last updated September 22, 2026): Three situations for restoring entitlement, including repaid in full with the home kept (once); how to request restoration. Checked November 3, 2026.
- VA, Home loan entitlement and limits (last updated August 12, 2025): Full entitlement and no loan limit; remaining bonus entitlement method and the four-times no-down-payment ceiling. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 38 U.S.C. 3702, Basic entitlement (uscode.house.gov, current through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026): Subsection (b): paragraphs (1) to (4) and the closing sentences on waiver and the once-only limit under paragraph (4). Checked November 3, 2026.
- 38 U.S.C. 3729, Loan fee (uscode.house.gov, current through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026): Fee table for loans closed April 7, 2023 to June 8, 2034 and from June 9, 2034; definitions of initial loan and subsequent loan; waiver in subsection (c). Checked November 3, 2026.
- 12 U.S.C. 4901 and 4902, Homeowners Protection Act (uscode.house.gov, current through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026): Original value for a refinance; cancellation date at 80% and termination date at 78%; request conditions; midpoint; high-risk exception. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B7-1-01 Provision of Mortgage Insurance (04/02/2025; Guide published October 7, 2026): Primary mortgage insurance required on a conventional first mortgage above 80% LTV unless other credit enhancement is provided. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B2-1.3-02 Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (10/08/2025; Guide published October 7, 2026): Payoff of an existing first mortgage; financing closing costs; the 95.01 to 97% tier and its Fannie Mae-owned existing-loan condition. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Loan-Level Price Adjustment Matrix (09.30.2026): Limited cash-out grid by credit score and LTV; exclusion of VA loans; waiver list. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: Weekly averages as of October 29, 2026: 30-year fixed 7.24%, 15-year fixed 6.60%. A dated reference, not a quote. Checked November 3, 2026.
- FHFA, 2026 conforming loan limit values (November 25, 2025): Baseline one-unit limit of $832,750 for 2026. Checked November 3, 2026.
Payments, outlays, break-even months and required leads follow from the inputs stated beside each table, rounded to the dollar; they are illustrations and not advice to take a loan. The 7.00% IRRRL rate, the $2,500 and $6,000 cost figures, the credit scores, the 0.30, 0.60 and 1.00 percent insurance rates and the 25 percent entitlement charge are assumptions for the arithmetic. The 7.24% figure is the Freddie Mac conventional average for the week of October 29, 2026. The page does not cover the Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix, Freddie Mac's guide, VA's lender handbook, private mortgage insurers' rate cards, or the IRRRL seasoning and recoupment tests, which are in the linked guides. Statute text is as shown on uscode.house.gov through Public Law 119-136 (October 22, 2026). Educational only, not a loan offer, tax or legal advice.