Should you refinance FHA to conventional to drop MIP? Check when your premium ends first
Refinancing FHA to conventional removes the annual MIP, but it only pays when the premium would otherwise run for years and the new rate is not much higher than your current one. For FHA case numbers assigned on or after June 3, 2013, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04 sets annual MIP at 11 years if your original loan-to-value was 90% or less, and the full loan term above 90%. So the first step is finding which group you are in. On the illustration below, a 0.25 point higher conventional rate breaks even in month 41 yet still ends behind once the slower principal paydown is counted.
Worksheet steps (12)
- A five-question decision framework
- How each answer points
- Two facts from closing day decide whether MIP ever ends
- Did a later Mortgagee Letter change the duration?
- Older FHA loans: the 78% cancellation that still applies
- What the conventional loan has to clear
- Pricing the refinance: the inputs
- Results at three conventional rates
- What the three rows say
- The break-even that ignores the year MIP would have ended
- Two variations that change the answer
- Other ways out of FHA mortgage insurance
A five-question decision framework
Answer these in order. Each one can end the analysis, which saves you from collecting quotes for a refinance that cannot work.
- When was the FHA case number assigned? Before June 3, 2013 with a closing after December 31, 2000: check whether MIP should already have been canceled at 78%. On or after June 3, 2013: go to question 2.
- What was the original loan-to-value, excluding financed upfront premium? 90% or less: MIP stops after year 11, so count the months left. Above 90%: MIP runs for the loan term, so every remaining month is in play.
- What is the realistic value today, and what loan-to-value would the conventional loan start at? 80% or less: no mortgage insurance. Above 80% to 95%: PMI, priced on your score. Above 95%: likely not eligible.
- How does the conventional rate compare with your FHA rate? Lower: the refinance has two sources of saving. Equal or higher: the MIP removed must carry the whole cost and the rate penalty.
- Does the break-even month land well inside both your stay horizon and the month MIP would end anyway, and does the balance gap at your horizon leave you ahead? If not, keep the FHA loan.
How each answer points
| Your situation | MIP without a refinance | What usually decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Case number before June 3, 2013, closed after 2000 | Cancellable at 78% (plus 5 years on terms over 15 years) | Ask the servicer why MIP continues before pricing a refinance |
| Original LTV 90% or less, case on or after June 3, 2013 | Ends after 11 years | Months left to year 11 against your break-even month |
| Original LTV above 90%, new LTV 80% or less | Runs for the loan term | Rate gap and closing costs; often the strongest case |
| Original LTV above 90%, new LTV above 80% | Runs for the loan term | Your PMI price and how soon it cancels on the new loan |
| Conventional quote below your FHA rate | Either | Usually favorable; also compare an FHA streamline |
| Conventional quote well above your FHA rate | Either | Rate penalty can exceed the premium; staying usually wins |
Two facts from closing day decide whether MIP ever ends
Conventional mortgage insurance and FHA's premium run on different rulebooks. The federal PMI cancellation law covers conventional loans only, and its 80% and 78% dates are laid out in our guide to removing PMI. An FHA loan follows HUD's own premium rules, and those turn on two numbers fixed at origination: the date FHA assigned your case number, and your loan-to-value ratio at that time.
HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04 (January 31, 2013, read from the Internet Archive copy of hud.gov because the live file now returns not found, checked October 22, 2026) changed the duration for every mortgage with a case number assigned on or after June 3, 2013. Where the original principal obligation, excluding any financed upfront premium, is 90% or less of value, annual MIP is assessed "until the end of the mortgage term or for the first 11 years of the mortgage term, whichever occurs first." Above 90%, FHA assesses it until the end of the term or for the first 30 years. For a 30-year loan with 3.5% down, which starts at 96.5%, that means the premium lasts as long as the loan does.
The same letter defines the ratio. FHA divides the loan amount before any financed upfront premium by the lesser of the purchase price or the appraised value. A buyer who put 10% down on a $400,000 home borrowed $360,000, a 90.00% ratio, and lands in the 11-year group. A buyer who put down 9.9% landed above 90% and pays for the full term. On a streamline refinance done without an appraisal, the letter says FHA uses the original appraised value for this calculation.
Did a later Mortgagee Letter change the duration?
Rates have changed since 2013; the duration split has not. Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 (February 22, 2023, checked October 22, 2026) cut annual MIP for case numbers endorsed on or after March 20, 2023, and its premium table keeps the same duration column: 11 years at 90% or less, mortgage term above 90%. A search of HUD's site in October 2026 turned up no later letter that changed duration, and the HUD premium page still describes termination when the mortgage is paid in full before maturity for case numbers from June 3, 2013 onward. Treat that as the state of the rules on the check date, not a promise about future letters.
For loans with a term over 15 years and a base amount at or below the $726,200 threshold in that letter, the annual rates are 50 basis points at 95% or less and 55 basis points above 95%. Larger loans pay 70 or 75. Fifteen-year terms are cheaper: 15 basis points at 90% or less for the smaller loans. The upfront premium for most purchases and refinances is 1.75% of the base loan amount.
| Base loan amount | Original LTV | Annual MIP | Duration |
|---|---|---|---|
| $726,200 or less | 90.00% or less | 0.50% | 11 years |
| $726,200 or less | Above 90.00% to 95.00% | 0.50% | Mortgage term |
| $726,200 or less | Above 95.00% | 0.55% | Mortgage term |
| Above $726,200 | 90.00% or less | 0.70% | 11 years |
| Above $726,200 | Above 90.00% to 95.00% | 0.70% | Mortgage term |
| Above $726,200 | Above 95.00% | 0.75% | Mortgage term |
Older FHA loans: the 78% cancellation that still applies
If your case number was assigned before June 3, 2013, the earlier cancellation policy governs. The table in ML 2013-04 lists the previous rule for terms over 15 years as cancellation at 78% loan-to-value combined with at least five years of premiums, and for terms of 15 years or less as cancellation at 78% alone. HUD's single family premium page says that cancellation route, under Mortgagee Letter 2000-46, is available to active cases with a closing date after December 31, 2000 and a case number assignment date before June 3, 2013.
Many of those loans are now well past both tests. A 30-year loan closed in 2012 at 96.5% has had more than a decade of amortization. If you hold one and still see MIP on your statement, the question for the servicer is why, not whether to refinance. For loans that closed on or before December 31, 2000, HUD's page does not extend this cancellation path; ask the servicer what applies, because this page has not verified those older rules.
What the conventional loan has to clear
Leaving FHA means meeting conventional rules, and the loan-to-value of the new loan is the number that sets your cost. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, B7-1-01 (checked October 22, 2026) requires primary mortgage insurance on a conventional first mortgage with a loan-to-value ratio greater than 80%. At 80% or below, the new loan has no mortgage insurance at all, and the refinance ends the premium entirely. Above 80%, you trade FHA's premium for private mortgage insurance, which can later be canceled under the federal 80% and 78% rules covered in the PMI guide.
A refinance that only pays off the FHA loan and closing costs is a limited cash-out refinance in Fannie Mae's terms. On a manufactured home, Fannie Mae's Chapter B5-2 adds property tests of its own, including a ban on homes moved from another site, which our manufactured home refinance table compares with FHA's. On a condo, the FHA approval may not carry over: Fannie Mae accepts it only for established projects approved through HUD's own review, as our condo refinance project review table shows. Selling Guide B2-1.3-02 (checked October 22, 2026) caps cash back at the greater of 1% of the new loan amount or $2,000 and allows closing costs, points and prepaids to be financed. It permits loan-to-value from 95.01% to 97% only when the existing loan being refinanced is owned or securitized by Fannie Mae. Unless your servicer confirms that about your FHA loan, plan on 95% as the practical ceiling. A borrower who is not a U.S. citizen should also know that FHA and Fannie Mae word their residency tests differently; our guide to refinancing without U.S. citizenship sets the two side by side.
Pricing works differently too. The CFPB's mortgage insurance explainer (last reviewed August 28, 2026) notes that FHA insurance costs the same regardless of credit score, while private mortgage insurance rates vary with down payment and credit score. A borrower whose score sat in the low 600s when buying may find a conventional quote with PMI priced well above the FHA premium it replaces. Our guide to what lenders check on a lower credit score covers that side.
Pricing the refinance: the inputs
This case uses a borrower who bought in early 2024, so the loan sits in the life-of-loan group. Every number is an illustration, not a quote. Purchase price $400,000 with 3.5% down, so a base loan of $386,000 and an original ratio of 96.5%. Upfront premium of 1.75% financed, $6,755, for a total FHA loan of $392,755 at 6.75% over 30 years. Principal and interest: $2,547 a month. Annual MIP: 0.55%, the ML 2023-05 rate above 95% for a base loan under $726,200.
Today, after 33 payments, the balance is $380,531. Monthly MIP is about $176, approximated here as 0.55% of the balance at the start of each loan year divided by 12; HUD's own calculation schedule for your loan will differ slightly, and your statement shows the real figure. A valuation puts the home at $500,000, so a conventional loan for the full balance starts at 76.11% and needs no mortgage insurance. Closing costs of $7,500 are paid in cash. The new loan is a 30-year fixed, and the stay horizon is eight years, 96 months.
For rate context, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed average at 7.40% in its release of October 15, 2026, up from 6.27% a year earlier. Averages are not your quote, so the test runs three conventional rates: one below, one above, and one at the weekly average.
Results at three conventional rates
Monthly saving is the old principal and interest plus MIP, minus the new payment. Break-even is the month cumulative savings first repay the $7,500. The last column subtracts the extra principal still owed on the new loan after 96 months, because a fresh 30-year schedule repays more slowly than an FHA loan that is already 33 payments in.
| Conventional rate | New P&I | First-month saving | Break-even | Cash saved by month 96 | Extra balance owed | Net at month 96 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.50% | $2,405 | $318 | Month 24 | $21,980 | $8,444 | $13,536 ahead |
| 7.00% | $2,532 | $191 | Month 41 | $9,788 | $11,622 | $1,834 behind |
| 7.40% | $2,635 | $88 | Not within 96 months | $100 short of costs | $14,031 | $14,131 behind |
What the three rows say
At 6.50%, a quarter point under the FHA rate, the refinance pays twice: once through the rate and once through the premium. Break-even in month 24 and a clear lead at month 96 make it the textbook case for leaving FHA.
At 7.00%, a quarter point over, the MIP alone still produces $191 a month at first, and cumulative cash covers the costs in month 41. Look one column further. After 96 months the conventional loan owes $11,622 more than the FHA loan would have, because the new 30-year schedule puts more of each early payment toward interest. Counting that, the borrower is $1,834 behind. A cash break-even inside the horizon is not the same as winning, which our walk-through of break-even with the costs left in explains in detail.
At 7.40%, the weekly average on the check date, the higher rate swallows most of the premium. The monthly saving is $88, the costs are not repaid within eight years, and the borrower ends $14,131 behind. For an FHA loan made at 6.75%, refinancing at the average rate to drop MIP loses on these inputs.
Running your own numbers is quicker in the StayOrRefi refinance calculator: enter your FHA principal and interest plus the MIP from your statement as the current payment, and the conventional quote as the new loan. Use the line-by-line refinance cost worksheet for the closing cost figure instead of a rule of thumb.
The break-even that ignores the year MIP would have ended
For a borrower in the 11-year group, every month after year 11 gives the FHA loan a payment drop with no refinance at all. A break-even computed on today's MIP figure, carried forward forever, overstates the conventional loan's advantage past that point. Compare the refinance only against the MIP you would actually pay: the months between now and year 11, at a premium that shrinks as the balance falls. If your break-even month lands after the month MIP ends anyway, the refinance cannot pay back on premium savings alone.
Two variations that change the answer
Variation one: the 11-year group. Same purchase price, but 10% down, so a base loan of $360,000 at exactly 90%, a total loan of $366,300 with the financed premium, $2,376 of principal and interest, and annual MIP of 0.50% that ends after year 11. After 33 payments the balance is $354,899 and MIP runs about $149 a month for 99 more months, roughly $13,827 in total. Against a conventional loan at 6.50% with the same $7,500 costs, break-even comes in month 27 and the borrower is $10,830 ahead at month 96. At 7.00%, break-even slips to month 47 and the borrower is $3,461 behind at month 96. A borrower in this group who expects to stay beyond year 11 should also remember that the FHA payment drops on its own when MIP ends, while the conventional loan keeps its rate for life.
Variation two: the value is lower. Back to the 96.5% loan, but the valuation comes in at $440,000 instead of $500,000. The conventional loan now starts at 86.48%, above Fannie Mae's 80% line, so it needs private mortgage insurance. Assume a PMI premium of $110 a month as an illustration; your quote depends on score and coverage. At 7.00%, the new loan's schedule reaches 80% of the $440,000 appraised value after payment 74, when a written cancellation request becomes possible, and 78% after payment 92. Paying PMI until month 74 pushes break-even to month 87, and the borrower is $9,974 behind at month 96 once the balance gap is counted. If the appraisal is the problem, the options in our guide to a refinance appraisal that comes in low are worth pricing before giving up.
Other ways out of FHA mortgage insurance
If rates have fallen since you closed, the FHA streamline refinance may lower the payment without leaving FHA, but it keeps the premium and charges a new upfront one; the streamline benefit test and its costs are covered in that guide. It is a rate move, not an MIP exit.
If the loan is in the 11-year group, waiting is a real option, and its cost is simply the MIP between now and year 11. If you are in the life-of-loan group, selling the home or paying off the loan ends the insurance, and HUD's premium page says that for case numbers from June 3, 2013 onward, the insurance can be terminated when the mortgage is paid in full before maturity. Extra principal payments on an FHA loan do not create a cancellation date the way they do for conventional PMI, because the post-2013 duration is counted in years, not in loan-to-value.
Lender credits can cut the cash cost of the conventional refinance in exchange for a higher rate, which changes the break-even arithmetic in both directions; how lender credits are priced shows how to compare that version. The VA version of the same exit, where the insurance line is 80 percent and the funding fee and entitlement also change, is priced in refinancing a VA loan into a conventional loan. More loan-type comparisons sit in the refinance by loan type hub.
Common questions
How long do I have to pay mortgage insurance on an FHA loan?
For case numbers assigned on or after June 3, 2013, annual MIP lasts 11 years if your original loan-to-value was 90% or less, and for the full mortgage term if it was above 90%, per HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04. Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 lowered the rates in 2023 but kept those durations. Older loans with closing dates after December 31, 2000 and earlier case numbers follow the previous 78% cancellation policy.
Can I remove FHA mortgage insurance without refinancing?
Only if your loan qualifies for the 11-year end date, falls under the pre-June 2013 cancellation rules, or is paid in full. A loan in the life-of-loan group has no cancellation date, and the conventional PMI law does not apply to FHA. The usual exits are a refinance into a conventional loan, a sale, or payoff.
How much equity do I need to refinance FHA to conventional without PMI?
Enough that the new loan is 80% or less of the appraised value, which means at least 20% equity after closing costs if you finance any of them. Above 80%, Fannie Mae requires mortgage insurance on the new loan. Up to 95% can work with PMI, subject to Fannie Mae's eligibility limits and lender rules; above that is limited to existing loans Fannie Mae already owns or securitized.
Is it worth refinancing from FHA to conventional if the conventional rate is higher?
Sometimes, but the MIP saved has to cover both the closing costs and the higher rate. On this page's illustration, a conventional rate 0.25 points higher broke even on cash in month 41 and still finished $1,834 behind after eight years once the extra balance was counted. Run your own quote with the balance gap included before deciding.
Will I get part of my FHA upfront premium back if I refinance to conventional?
Do not plan on it. Any upfront premium credit discussed in FHA material is tied to refinancing into a new FHA loan, and this page has not verified a refund for a conventional payoff. Ask your servicer in writing before closing, and leave it out of the break-even unless they confirm an amount.
Does an FHA streamline refinance remove MIP?
No. A streamline keeps the loan inside FHA, so it carries a new upfront premium and annual MIP under the current schedule. It can lower the rate and payment, but it is not a way out of mortgage insurance.
Sources and verification
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2013-04, Revision of FHA policies concerning cancellation of the annual MIP and increase to the annual MIP: 11-year and mortgage-term durations for case numbers assigned on or after June 3, 2013; LTV definition; previous 78% cancellation rules. Read from the Internet Archive copy because the hud.gov file now returns not found. Checked October 22, 2026.
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2023-05, Reduction of FHA Annual MIP Rates: Annual MIP rates and unchanged duration column for case numbers endorsed on or after March 20, 2023; 1.75% upfront premium; $726,200 base loan threshold. Checked October 22, 2026.
- HUD, Single Family Mortgage Insurance Premiums (monthly premium cancellation): ML 2000-46 cancellation for closings after December 31, 2000 with case numbers before June 3, 2013; termination on payoff for later case numbers. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B7-1-01 Provision of Mortgage Insurance: Mortgage insurance required on conventional first mortgages above 80% LTV. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B2-1.3-02 Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions: Cash-back cap, financed closing costs, and the 95.01% to 97% tier limited to loans Fannie Mae owns or securitized. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is mortgage insurance and how does it work?: FHA premium does not vary with credit score; PMI pricing varies with down payment and score. Checked October 22, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey: 30-year fixed average of 7.40% in the release of October 15, 2026, 6.27% a year earlier; rate context only. Checked October 22, 2026.
Duration and rate rules are stated as published in HUD Mortgagee Letters 2013-04 and 2023-05 and on HUD's premium page, and conventional eligibility as published in Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-1-01 and B2-1.3-02, all checked October 22, 2026; Handbook 4000.1 is the controlling text and later letters can change it. Freddie Mac and lender overlays were not verified. The FHA rate, conventional rates, $500,000 and $440,000 valuations, $110 PMI premium and $7,500 closing costs are illustrations, not quotes, and monthly MIP is approximated from the balance at the start of each loan year. The example assumes on-time payments, costs paid in cash, and no change in taxes or insurance. Educational only, not a loan offer.