Refinancing without U.S. citizenship: what FHA, Fannie Mae, VA and USDA say about green cards, work permits and ITINs
A permanent resident is named as eligible in the FHA, Fannie Mae and USDA texts. A work-permit holder is not named at FHA, which dropped non-permanent residents for case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025. USDA ended its general work-permit waiver on March 18, 2025 and now counts an EAD only with a refugee, asylee or withholding code. Fannie Mae leaves the status check to the lender, and of the program texts cited, only Fannie Mae's names an ITIN as a tax ID.
Worksheet steps (10)
- A refinance is a new application, so the rules in force today apply
- Four rulebooks and a boundary: status, tax ID and paper side by side
- Fannie Mae: the status call is the lender's, and the lender signs for it
- FHA: the 2025 letter that removed work-permit holders, and what it does to a streamline
- VA: eligibility is built on service, and the IRRRL tests are about the loan
- USDA: the waiver that ended on March 18, 2025, and the carve-out for existing borrowers
- ITINs, thin credit files and where the agency programs end
- Where an expiring document meets the closing calendar
- Mixed households: when only one borrower sits outside the listed categories
- Pricing a move off FHA when conventional is the only door: $310,000 with 27 years left
A refinance is a new application, so the rules in force today apply
A refinance pays off the old loan with a new one, and the new loan is approved, insured or sold under the written rules that apply when its application is taken. For a borrower who is not a U.S. citizen, that detail matters more than it does for anyone else, because two of the four rulebooks below changed in 2025. HUD issued Mortgagee Letter 2025-09 on March 26, 2025, and it governs FHA case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025. USDA rescinded its non-citizen waiver on March 18, 2025, according to its own job aid. Fannie Mae's non-citizen topic carries a 2015 date and runs four substantive sentences. A person approved for a purchase loan years ago can therefore meet a different set of categories at the refinance table.
Three different documents tend to get blended together in a mortgage file, and the program texts keep them apart. A permanent resident card, commonly called a green card, or a visa is evidence of immigration status. An Employment Authorization Document, the EAD, is Form I-766 and evidences permission to work. An Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, the ITIN, is a tax ID. The IRS says an ITIN is issued for federal tax purposes only and does not provide or change immigration status or authorize anyone to work legally in the United States. A lender can be satisfied on one of the three and still be waiting on another.
Federal credit regulations allow a lender to ask. Regulation B says a creditor "may consider the applicant's immigration status or status as a permanent resident of the United States, and any additional information that may be necessary to ascertain the creditor's rights and remedies regarding repayment" (12 CFR 1002.6(b)(7)). The same section bars a creditor from considering national origin (paragraph (b)(9)). So a request for status documents is a permitted underwriting step, and the programs below decide which documents satisfy it.
Four rulebooks and a boundary: status, tax ID and paper side by side
Each row comes from the program text it cites. Freddie Mac has no row, and VA's row covers only the statute and regulations, which say nothing on tax IDs or status documents. The last row is the federal statement that applies to every lender whatever the program.
| Rulebook | Statuses the text admits | Tax ID it names | What it asks the lender to document | Expiring or expired paper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae (conventional) | Lawful permanent and non-permanent residents, "under the same terms that are available to U.S. citizens" | A valid Social Security number or an ITIN, "in addition to meeting existing legal residency and documentation requirements" | The lender decides which documents, case by case; by delivering the loan it "represents and warrants" the borrower is legally present | Nothing printed in B2-2-02 or B2-2-01 |
| FHA (Title II forward) | Lawful permanent residents and citizens of the Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands and the Republic of Palau; no non-permanent-resident category for case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025 | A valid SSN, with narrow exceptions for certain employers such as a foreign embassy | Evidence of lawful permanent residence, marked on the loan application; USCIS provides that evidence; a Social Security card alone does not prove immigration or work status | No expiration, conditional-residence or renewal language in the residency paragraph |
| VA (guaranteed) | Entitlement is defined by military service in 38 U.S.C. 3702; no citizenship test appears in that section | No Social Security number or ITIN rule in 38 CFR 36.4307 or 36.4340 | No status-document list in 38 CFR 36.4307 or 36.4340 | No expiring-document language in those sections |
| USDA (Section 502 Guaranteed) | U.S. citizens, U.S. non-citizen nationals and qualified aliens (7 CFR 3555.151(b)) | A valid Social Security number | Evidence of status and legal residency; the job aid lists the accepted documents | The SSN-plus-EAD waiver was rescinded March 18, 2025; an EAD counts only with category code A3, A5 or A10; a USCIS receipt for a replacement of a listed document is accepted |
| Outside the agencies | The lender's own policy and its investor's | The lender's own policy | Still subject to the federal repayment-ability rule, which asks for verified income and current employment status, and addressed by the CFPB statement in the next row | No agency text; ask the lender in writing |
| CFPB statement, June 8, 2026 (all creditors, dwelling-secured loans) | Lists no statuses; says it provides no comprehensive analysis of how different lawful statuses bear on repayment | Names an ITIN as one example of an atypical identification method that may indicate a person is not lawfully present | Says the ability-to-repay requirements "may obligate consideration of a consumer's immigration status" where the application or records indicate income will change; it is guidance without the force or effect of law | None stated; the duty attaches to information in the application or records at or before consummation |
The same borrower can sit inside one rulebook and outside another. A lawful permanent resident is named in the FHA, USDA and Fannie Mae texts. A work-permit holder with a Social Security number is inside Fannie Mae's wording, outside FHA's current categories, and inside USDA's only if the EAD carries one of three category codes. Of the texts cited, only Fannie Mae's tax-ID test admits a borrower with an ITIN and no Social Security number. So the first question to put to a lender is which program the file is being built for, because the answer decides which document list applies before anyone looks at the rate.
Silence is common in these texts, and it matters. Where a guide does not list a document, the choice belongs to the lender, and two lenders can ask for different paper for the same borrower.
Fannie Mae: the status call is the lender's, and the lender signs for it
The whole non-citizen eligibility topic, B2-2-02, runs four substantive sentences. Fannie Mae buys and securitizes loans to non-U.S. citizens "who are lawful permanent or non-permanent residents of the United States under the same terms that are available to U.S. citizens." It "does not specify the precise documentation the lender must obtain to verify that a non-U.S. citizen borrower is legally present." The lender "must make a determination of the non-U.S. citizen's status based on the circumstances of the individual case, using documentation it deems appropriate." And by delivering the mortgage to Fannie Mae, the lender "represents and warrants that the non-U.S. citizen borrower is legally present in this country." There is no category list, no document list and no sentence about a card, visa or work permit that is close to its end date.
That silence is the answer to the question most readers arrive with. The Selling Guide does not say a loan must be declined because an EAD expires before closing, and it does not say the loan can close anyway. It hands the decision to the lender and attaches the lender's warranty to the delivery of the loan, which follows closing. A lender weighing an expiring document is therefore weighing its own representation, not applying a Fannie Mae cutoff. The practical result is that policies differ: one lender may want the renewal receipt in the file, another may want the new card, and a third may decline files with any document inside a set number of months of its end date. Those are lender policies, and the Guide does not require or forbid any of them.
The remaining Fannie Mae topics treat a non-citizen borrower the same as anyone else. B3-3.1-01 says borrowers who are not U.S. citizens "must meet the same employment and income verification requirements that are required for borrowers who are U.S. citizens, regardless of the type or source of income." B2-2-01 requires a valid Social Security number or an ITIN for each borrower. Where a Social Security number has to be validated directly with the Social Security Administration and cannot be, the loan is not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae, and the lender must keep the validation record in the file.
One income rule deserves a careful reading rather than a leap. B3-3.1-01 says income must be one the lender can "reasonably expect to continue," and that if the income source "does have a defined expiration date," the lender must document that it will continue for at least three years from the application date. The topic does not say that a work-authorization end date turns wages into income with a defined expiration date. Wages from an ongoing job have no stated end, so the default treatment applies unless the lender has information to the contrary. How a lender treats a pending renewal under that sentence is its own judgment, and the Guide does not address it in terms.
Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix and loan-level price adjustments are outside this guide, and Desktop Underwriter's findings for a particular file cannot be known from any public page. A lender selling to Freddie Mac applies Freddie Mac's own rule for its loans. If the lender can say which investor it expects to sell to, ask for that rule in writing.
FHA: the 2025 letter that removed work-permit holders, and what it does to a streamline
Mortgagee Letter 2025-09, dated March 26, 2025, is the pivot. It says it "removes the Non-permanent Residents sections in its entirety, eliminating eligibility for non-permanent resident Borrowers," applies to FHA Title II forward mortgages and Home Equity Conversion Mortgages, and must be implemented for FHA case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025. HUD's stated reasoning is that FHA must evaluate a borrower's ability to sustain long-term obligations, which it says "depends on stable residency and employment." Paragraph II.A.1.b.ii(A)(8) of the Handbook still says that U.S. citizenship is not required for mortgage eligibility.
The text now in HUD Handbook 4000.1 matches the letter. Update 18 of the Handbook, last revised August 12, 2026, says in section II.A.1.b.ii(A)(9) that the mortgagee "must determine the residency status of the Borrower based on information provided on the mortgage application and other applicable documentation," that a Social Security card "is not sufficient to prove immigration or work status," and that two categories are eligible. The first is a borrower with lawful permanent resident status, who may be eligible "provided the Borrower satisfies the same requirements, terms, and conditions as those for U.S. citizens," with evidence of lawful permanent residence in the file and the status marked on the loan application. USCIS provides that evidence. The second is a citizen of the Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands or the Republic of Palau, on the same footing. No other residency category appears. The SSN paragraph, II.A.1.b.ii(A)(1), requires each borrower to provide evidence of a valid SSN, with exceptions for employees of the World Bank, foreign embassies and similar employers HUD identifies, state and local government agencies, and HUD-approved nonprofits.
The residency paragraph has no language about an expiration date, a conditional card or a renewal in progress. The paragraph contains no expiration, conditional-residence or renewal language. A permanent resident whose card is near its printed end date is therefore in the same position as at Fannie Mae, with the lender deciding what evidence of continuing permanent residence it will accept, and FHA's text adding only that USCIS is the source of that evidence.
The streamline question is the one the letter's table of changes hides. Mortgagee Letter 2025-09 amended two passages of the streamline text, II.A.8.d.vi(C)(1)(a) and (C)(5)(b), each marked "Text was deleted in this section." The current non-credit-qualifying exemption list names the appraisal, credit score, ownership, co-signer, principal-residence, military, federal-debt, property, loan-limit and manual-underwriting sections as not applying. It does not name Residency Requirements. The text therefore offers no carve-out for a borrower outside the listed categories who holds an existing FHA loan, and whether a given servicer or lender will take such a streamline file is a question only that company can answer, in writing. The letter marks both passages "[Text was deleted in this section.]" and does not restate the removed wording.
Two dates keep the FHA answer current. HUD's Update 18 shows November 10, 2026 effective dates on several origination headings, and Mortgagee Letter 2026-11 of October 8, 2026 contains no residency, citizenship or immigration language. The residency wording in the Handbook matches the wording in the 2025 letter, so a reader checking a later date should look for any Mortgagee Letter issued after October 8, 2026 on HUD's index.
VA: eligibility is built on service, and the IRRRL tests are about the loan
The VA home loan benefit is defined in 38 U.S.C. 3702 by periods of service, length of service and type of discharge. Subsection (a)(2) lists the qualifying veterans by service era and conditions, and the text, read through Public Law 119-136 of October 22, 2026, contains no citizenship test. VA's own eligibility page for the Certificate of Eligibility is organized the same way. It speaks of minimum service for veterans, Reserve members, surviving spouses and a few listed organizations, and it mentions citizenship once, for "a U.S. citizen who served in the Armed Forces of a government allied with the U.S. in World War II." So the entitlement is not the point of friction for a non-citizen veteran. The lender's file is.
The documents a lender must collect for a non-citizen borrower on a VA loan sit in VA's Lender's Handbook, which this guide does not cover, so it states no VA tax-ID rule, status-document list or treatment of an expiring card. The regulation text, 38 CFR 36.4307 and 36.4340, contains no citizenship, alien or immigration terms. The streamlined refinance rules look at the loan instead of the person. A loan being refinanced that is more than 30 days past due can be guaranteed only if VA approves it in advance (36.4307(a)(5)), and a streamlined refinance is exempt from the income-verification requirement only on conditions that include the veteran not being 30 days or more past due (36.4340(b)(2)(i)).
Where a lender does underwrite credit, as on a VA cash-out refinance, 36.4340 applies its ordinary income rules: employment and income that count toward repayment "must be verified," employment verifications and pay stubs "must be no more than 120 days" old, and income is used only if "it can be concluded that the income will continue during the foreseeable future." Those are income rules, and nothing in the regulation connects them to a work-authorization date. For the mechanics of the streamlined product see our guide to the VA IRRRL, and for the version that takes equity out see VA cash-out refinancing.
USDA: the waiver that ended on March 18, 2025, and the carve-out for existing borrowers
USDA states its status rule in regulation and in the handbook. Under 7 CFR 3555.151(b), applicants "must provide evidence acceptable to the Agency of their status as United States citizens, U.S. non-citizen nationals, or qualified aliens, as defined in § 3555.10." Handbook HB-1-3555, Chapter 8, paragraph 8.2.F, adds that lenders determine which of the three an applicant is, that applicants need "a valid social security number and evidence of continued residency and income," and that by submitting the request for a Conditional Commitment the lender "represents and warrants that the non-U.S. citizen applicant is legally present in the United States and meets the eligibility requirements." It then lists the qualified-alien categories by reference to 8 U.S.C. 1641: lawful permanent residents, asylees, refugees, certain parolees of at least a year, persons whose deportation is withheld, conditional entrants, Cuban and Haitian entrants, and certain battered persons.
The Chapter 8 revision cited is the April 1, 2024 revision, archived July 21, 2024, and it contains a temporary waiver: individuals "with a valid social security number and work authorization, as evidenced by documentation such as an Employment Authorization Document" could participate, and, unless extended, the waiver "will expire on May 2, 2025." A later USDA document supersedes that date. The job aid for determining the eligibility of qualified aliens, revised April 28, 2025, refers to "the waiver recission date of March 18, 2025." For applications that had not received a Conditional Commitment before that date, it says they "must meet the current eligibility requirements." So the working rule is the earlier date in the later document, and a reader who finds the May 2, 2025 date in an archived chapter should treat it as superseded.
The job aid's list of accepted evidence is short and specific: the permanent resident card (Form I-551), an EAD (Form I-766) annotated A3 for refugees, A5 for asylees or A10 for persons granted withholding of deportation or removal, the refugee travel document (I-571), an arrival-departure record (I-94) with listed annotations, or a USCIS receipt showing that a replacement for one of those listed documents has been applied for and the supporting documentation has been verified. That last item is the only cited text that speaks to a document being replaced, and it applies to replacement of documents in the listed categories only. An EAD in another category does not appear on the list.
The part that matters most to a refinancing borrower is a question and answer in the same job aid. Asked whether a borrower originally approved under the waiver, who "now wants to refinance their existing guaranteed loan," is eligible even without meeting the new requirements, USDA answers: "Yes, the applicant remains eligible to refinance their existing guaranteed loan." The answer does not say which of the three refinance types it covers. HB-1-3555 Chapter 6, revised May 5, 2025, describes them: non-streamlined, streamlined and streamlined-assist, each requiring that the existing loan closed at least 180 days before submission to USDA and showed no delinquency greater than 30 days in the previous 180 days. The new loan must be fixed for 30 years at a rate no higher than the old one. A waiver-era borrower asking about a refinance should ask the lender which type it is submitting and whether USDA's answer covers it, and our USDA streamline refinance guide explains the $50 tangible-benefit test the streamlined-assist version uses.
ITINs, thin credit files and where the agency programs end
An ITIN settles one of the three things a file needs, the tax ID, and of the texts cited only Fannie Mae's names it. B2-2-01 accepts "a valid Social Security number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN)," but adds that the borrower must also meet "existing legal residency and documentation requirements." FHA asks for a valid SSN and lists narrow exceptions that are about the employer, not about an ITIN. USDA's handbook says applicants are required to have a valid Social Security number. The IRS says an ITIN does not qualify anyone for Social Security benefits, provide or change immigration status, or authorize work. In program terms, an ITIN can be a tax ID. It never stands in for status.
Borrowers with ITINs and recent arrivals often have no U.S. credit score, and Fannie Mae's route for that is nontraditional credit, B3-5.4-01. The scope is narrower than the ordinary loan. For a manually underwritten loan with a borrower who has no credit score, the property must be a one-unit principal residence, the transaction must be a purchase or limited cash-out refinance, the loan must fit within baseline loan limits so high-balance loans are not eligible, and the maximum debt-to-income ratio is 36%. There is no minimum reserve requirement if at least one borrower documents a housing payment history as a nontraditional credit reference; otherwise 12 months of reserves are required. When Desktop Underwriter finds no borrower with even one credit account, the property must be a one- to four-unit principal residence occupied by all borrowers and the transaction a purchase or limited cash-out refinance. A cash-out refinance for a borrower with no score or no credit accounts is outside both descriptions.
B3-5.4-03 sets the reference standards. For each nontraditional reference there cannot be any delinquency on housing payments in the past 12 months, only one account other than housing can show a 30-day delinquency in that period, and no collections other than medical collections or judgments can have been filed in the past 24 months. And for the group at issue here, the topic has a sentence of its own: if a non-U.S. citizen or foreign borrower "lacks sufficient credit references in the United States," the lender "must use credit references from foreign countries to achieve the required number of nontraditional credit references." The Guide therefore contemplates a file that is built on documented payment history rather than a score. Our guide to refinancing with bad credit covers the score side for borrowers who do have one.
Past the edge of these programs, the written rules come from the lender and its investor, and no agency publishes them. What binds every lender regardless of product is the federal repayment-ability rule for dwelling-secured loans. Under 12 CFR 1026.43(c)(2), a creditor must consider, among other factors, the borrower's current or reasonably expected income or assets and, if the creditor relies on employment income, "the consumer's current employment status." Under (c)(3), it must verify the information it relies on "using reasonably reliable third-party records," although employment status may be verified orally if the creditor records what it learned. That is the same sort of verification the agency programs ask for, which is why a file outside the agency programs still needs the paychecks, tax returns and bank records to line up. On June 8, 2026 the CFPB published a statement on this rule (Federal Register document 2026-11447, 91 FR 34607, issued consistent with Executive Order 14406). It says the ability-to-repay requirements in Regulation Z "may obligate consideration of a consumer's immigration status, especially where removal from the United States may disrupt the consumer's income." The statement ties that to information in the file: a creditor relying on income from U.S.-based employment must consider information in the application or other records indicating that the consumer's repayment ability will change because of immigration status, as it must consider any other information indicating a change after consummation, and it need not consider a change that cannot reasonably be anticipated from those records. Among the possible sources of such an indication it lists direct inquiry and reliance on atypical identification methods, and it gives an ITIN as an example. It also says that many lawful statuses exist, that they cannot be assumed to carry identical abilities to repay, and that it offers no comprehensive analysis of them. The statement describes itself as guidance with no force or effect of law and cites the Bureau's January 12, 2026 notice withdrawing a joint statement on the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and noncitizen borrowers (91 FR 1138). This site publishes no non-agency rates, lender names or eligibility lists, and no source cited here supplies them. A non-agency quote should go through the calculator like any other, and the questions to put to the lender are in the checklist below.
Where an expiring document meets the closing calendar
The program texts attach their status checks to different moments, and none of them lists what a lender may ask for when a card, visa or EAD is about to lapse or already has. What they do show is when the lender is exposed. FHA's letter sets its applicability date by case number, May 25, 2025, and the Handbook names no moment at which residency is determined. USDA's lender makes its representation when it requests a Conditional Commitment. Fannie Mae's lender makes its representation at delivery, which follows closing. Around those moments sit the age limits on the other paper in the file, and those are the clocks a closing date has to fit.
Everything in the table concerns origination of the new loan. The sources cited say nothing about what a servicer may do with an existing loan when a borrower's status changes, so servicing is outside the scope here. The note, the mortgage and the federal servicing rules govern an existing loan.
| Checkpoint | Rule found | What it means for an expiring document |
|---|---|---|
| FHA applicability date | Borrower categories apply to case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025; evidence of lawful permanent residence goes in the mortgage file | The Handbook sets no expiration test and names no moment at which residency is determined, so a card printed to lapse later is a lender-policy question |
| USDA Conditional Commitment request | The lender "represents and warrants" the applicant is legally present and eligible; applications with no commitment before March 18, 2025 meet current rules | A USCIS receipt for a replacement of a listed document is accepted evidence; other expiring paper is not addressed |
| Fannie Mae credit documents | Credit reports and employment, income and asset documents "no more than four months old on the note date" | The topic does not list identity or status documents among them, so no four-month rule is printed for a card or EAD |
| Fannie Mae verbal verification of employment | Within 10 business days on or before the note date (15 in one documented case); may be obtained after closing up to delivery | Confirms the job continues; says nothing about work-authorization dates |
| Fannie Mae note date | B2-2-02 prints no status rule tied to this date | The lender's own determination governs |
| Fannie Mae delivery | The lender represents and warrants legal presence on delivery | The lender's exposure is greatest here, which is why a lender has to care about current evidence in the file |
| VA, where credit is underwritten | Employment verifications and pay stubs no more than 120 days old (36.4340(f)(1)); the regulation names no status document | No status rule can be stated |
The clocks that are printed all run on the employment and credit paper, so a closing date can be pushed too far on those even when the status paper is fine: a verbal verification of employment is good for 10 business days before the note date, and a lock extension to wait for a renewal can push the note date past it. Our guide to rate-lock fees and extensions prices that delay. USDA's job aid is the one place where a receipt for a replacement document is expressly accepted, and it accepts it for listed documents only. For FHA and Fannie Mae, ask the lender in writing whether it accepts a USCIS receipt or a pending renewal and what the file must show.
A December 15 EAD end date against a December 22 note date
Take the $310,000 hypothetical borrower from the pricing table below (324 months left, $7,500 in closing costs, a 72-month stay) on a conventional refinance, whose EAD is printed to expire on Tuesday, December 15, 2026. The application is taken on October 5, the credit report is dated October 6, and the note is scheduled for Tuesday, December 22. Fannie Mae's four-month age limit on credit documents is not the problem: a report dated October 6 is good on a note date as late as February 6, 2027. The verbal verification of employment must be obtained no more than 10 business days on or before the note date, which counts back to Tuesday, December 8, with no federal holiday in between. The EAD therefore lapses one week before the note date and falls inside the verification window, while the lender's warranty about legal presence is made at delivery, which follows the note date. B2-2-02 does not say the loan cannot close in that sequence, and it does not say it can. The lender's own determination decides, and its answer will turn on what it accepts as evidence while a renewal is pending. If it declines to proceed on a pending renewal, the paths left include moving the note date to Friday, December 11, before the printed date, which depends on how long the rate lock runs, or waiting for the renewed card and locking again.
Mixed households: when only one borrower sits outside the listed categories
Every rulebook above is written borrower by borrower, so a household with one citizen and one non-citizen borrower gets sorted twice. Two FHA passages show how this plays out. For a non-credit-qualifying streamline, a borrower is eligible if all borrowers on the existing mortgage remain on the new one, with a single exception for divorce, legal separation or death where the remaining borrower has made the payments for at least six months before case number assignment. A household cannot satisfy the first test by dropping a borrower who no longer fits a category. The credit-qualifying streamline is more flexible: at least one borrower from the existing mortgage must remain. And for a non-occupying co-borrower or co-signer on any FHA loan except a non-credit-qualifying streamline, which exempts that section, the Handbook requires that the person "must either be United States (U.S.) citizens or have a Principal Residence in the U.S."
USDA's rules differ by refinance type. For non-streamlined and streamlined refinances, existing borrowers may be removed when one of the original borrowers remains. For streamlined-assist, existing borrowers must remain on the new loan, and only a deceased borrower may be removed. Fannie Mae evaluates each borrower's identity, tax ID and income under the same topics. B2-2-04, which governs non-occupant borrowers, is outside this guide. Removing or adding a borrower changes the underwriting file on every program, and our guide to removing a cosigner or co-borrower works through the income and debt arithmetic of that change.
Pricing a move off FHA when conventional is the only door: $310,000 with 27 years left
The numbers below are a hypothetical built for the arithmetic; no lender offered them. A borrower holds an FHA loan with a $310,000 balance and 27 years (324 months) left at 8.00%, and the new loan is conventional at 7.25%. The 7.25% sits beside the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average of 7.24% for 30-year fixed loans in the week released October 29, 2026, used as context only: a real quote reflects credit, loan-to-value and the investor, and a non-agency quote can sit well above it. Closing costs are $7,500 paid in cash, the stay horizon is 6 years (72 months), and mortgage insurance on both loans is left out, so add yours to the quote.
To keep the rate effect apart from a term restart, one version of the new loan keeps the old payoff date, 324 months. The current principal and interest payment is $2,338.27. At 7.25% over the same 324 months it is $2,183.00, a drop of $155.27 that comes from the rate alone. $7,500 divided by $155.27 is 48.3, so the refinance recovers its costs from the payment saving in month 49, inside the 72-month stay. The second version restarts at 30 years, which lowers the payment to $2,114.75 and makes the break-even look faster at month 34, but it pushes the payoff date out by 36 months.
| Option | Payment (P&I) | Break-even | Interest paid, months 1-72 | Balance at month 72 | Cash position at month 72 | Interest over the full loan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stay at 8.00%, 324 months left | $2,338.27 | Not applicable | $143,361 | $285,006 | $453,361 | $447,599 |
| Refinance at 7.25%, same 324 months | $2,183.00 | Month 49 | $129,310 | $282,134 | $446,810 | $397,292 |
| Refinance at 7.25%, new 30-year term | $2,114.75 | Month 34 | $130,529 | $288,268 | $448,029 | $451,309 |
The rate change alone saves $14,051 of interest over the 72 months, which is $6,551 after the $7,500 in costs, and the borrower owes $2,872 less at month 72. The 30-year restart gives back $1,219 of that advantage by month 72, and it leaves $3,262 more principal outstanding than staying put would. Over the whole life of each loan, the restart pays $3,710 more interest than the existing loan would have, so a lower payment bought with a longer term is a different product from a lower rate. On these numbers the refinance wins on the stay entered, and the win comes from the rate.
A cap on the quote is worth knowing before the quotes arrive. Holding the 324-month payoff date, the payment saving recovers $7,500 within 72 months only if the new rate is about 7.50% or lower. Counting the balance, the refinance beats staying at month 72 only if the rate is about 7.60% or lower. A quote above those lines fails on a six-year stay. To test your own balance, rate and horizon, use the Stay or Refi Calculator, and for the method read break-even explained.
What to gather before the first lender call
- Every status document in hand, with its printed dates: the permanent resident card, the EAD with its category code and any renewal receipt, and the passport page that goes with the visa.
- The Social Security number card or letter, or the ITIN assignment notice, so the lender can see which tax ID each borrower will use before it picks a program.
- A written answer to which investor and program the lender expects to use for the file, and whether it will accept a USCIS receipt or a pending renewal for a document that expires before closing.
- The last two years of tax returns as filed, plus pay stubs and employer contact details for the verbal verification of employment, which falls within 10 business days of the note date.
- Twelve months of rent or mortgage payments with proof, and any foreign credit references, if no U.S. credit score exists.
- The existing loan's payment history from the servicer, since the 30-day and 12-month tests in the other guides apply to the loan being refinanced.
- A dated list of the closing-date risks: rate lock expiry, the document end dates, and the verification window, side by side on one calendar.
Questions borrowers ask about refinancing without citizenship
Can I refinance a mortgage with a green card?
A permanent resident is named as eligible in the FHA Handbook, the USDA handbook and regulation, and Fannie Mae's non-citizen topic. FHA says a borrower with lawful permanent resident status may be eligible if the borrower satisfies the same requirements, terms and conditions as U.S. citizens. USDA lists lawful permanent residents among qualified aliens. Fannie Mae says lawful permanent and non-permanent residents are accepted under the same terms as citizens, and leaves the document choice to the lender. The remaining tests are the ordinary ones: credit, income, equity and payment history.
Can I refinance with a work visa or an EAD?
It depends on the program. Fannie Mae accepts non-permanent residents and lets the lender decide the documents. FHA no longer has a non-permanent-resident category for case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025. USDA rescinded its work-permit waiver on March 18, 2025, and now accepts an EAD only with category code A3, A5 or A10, though it says borrowers originally approved under the waiver remain eligible to refinance their existing guaranteed loan. A lender outside the agency programs follows its own policy.
Does an ITIN let me refinance?
An ITIN is a tax ID and nothing more: the IRS says it does not provide or change immigration status or authorize work. Fannie Mae accepts a valid Social Security number or an ITIN, but still requires legal residency and documentation. FHA and USDA ask for a valid Social Security number. Borrowers with no U.S. credit score can use Fannie Mae's nontraditional credit route, which covers purchase and limited cash-out refinances, not cash-out refinances.
What happens if my EAD or visa expires before closing?
No single answer appears in the texts checked. Fannie Mae's topic leaves the documents to the lender and makes the lender warrant legal presence on delivery. FHA's Handbook has no expiration language, and USDA's job aid accepts a USCIS receipt for a replacement of a listed document. Fannie Mae's verbal verification of employment must fall within 10 business days of the note date, and credit documents must be no more than four months old on that date. Ask the lender in writing what it accepts for a pending renewal.
I have an FHA loan from before May 2025 and I am not a permanent resident. Can I use an FHA streamline?
The Handbook text offers no carve-out. The non-credit-qualifying streamline exemption list does not include Residency Requirements, and the residency paragraph names only permanent residents and citizens of three Pacific nations. Mortgagee Letter 2025-09 amended both streamline passages and removed the non-permanent-resident sections, but the letter marks both passages "[Text was deleted in this section.]" and does not restate the removed wording. Whether a servicer or lender will take such a file is for that company to answer in writing, and Fannie Mae's non-citizen topic is the documented alternative route.
Can a lender ask about my immigration status?
Yes. Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.6(b)(7), says a creditor may consider the applicant's immigration status or status as a permanent resident of the United States, and any additional information necessary to ascertain the creditor's rights and remedies regarding repayment. Paragraph (b)(9) of the same section bars considering national origin. On June 8, 2026 the CFPB published a statement saying the ability-to-repay requirements in Regulation Z "may obligate consideration of a consumer's immigration status, especially where removal from the United States may disrupt the consumer's income" (Federal Register document 2026-11447). The statement is guidance without the force or effect of law, and it ties the duty to information in the application or records indicating that repayment ability will change. Questions about what a particular status means belong with USCIS or a licensed immigration professional, not with a mortgage lender.
Sources and verification
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B2-2-02 Non-U.S. Citizen Borrower Eligibility Requirements (07/28/2015; Guide published October 7, 2026): Lawful permanent and non-permanent residents on the same terms as citizens; lender chooses the documentation and warrants legal presence on delivery. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B2-2-01 General Borrower Eligibility Requirements (09/03/2025): Each borrower needs a valid Social Security number or ITIN, in addition to legal residency and documentation requirements; SSA validation rules. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-3.1-01 General Income Information (10/07/2026): Same employment and income verification for non-U.S. citizens; continuance of income and the three-year rule for income with a defined expiration date. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-3.1-04 Verbal Verification of Employment (10/07/2026): Verbal VOE within 10 business days on or before the note date; may be obtained after closing up to delivery. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B1-1-03 Allowable Age of Credit Documents and Federal Income Tax Returns (04/02/2025): Credit documents, including credit reports and employment, income and asset documentation, no more than four months old on the note date. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-5.4-01 Eligibility Requirements for Loans with Nontraditional Credit (11/05/2025): Manual underwriting and DU conditions for borrowers without a credit score: purchase or limited cash-out refinance, 36% DTI, baseline loan limits. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-5.4-03 Documentation and Assessment of a Nontraditional Credit History (02/07/2024): Foreign credit references for non-U.S. citizen and foreign borrowers; delinquency limits on nontraditional references. Checked November 3, 2026.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-09, Revisions to Residency Requirements (March 26, 2025): Removes the Non-permanent Residents sections; effective for FHA case numbers assigned on or after May 25, 2025; amends the streamline passages II.A.8.d.vi(C)(1)(a) and (C)(5)(b). Checked November 3, 2026.
- HUD Handbook 4000.1, FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook (Update 18, last revised 8/12/2026): II.A.1.b.ii(A)(1) Social Security Number, (6) non-occupying co-borrowers, (8) citizenship not required, (9) Residency Requirements; II.A.8.d.vi(C) streamline exemptions and borrower eligibility. Checked November 3, 2026.
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2026-11 (October 8, 2026): Contains no residency, citizenship or immigration language. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 38 U.S.C. 3702, Basic entitlement (uscode.house.gov, through Public Law 119-136, October 22, 2026): VA housing loan entitlement defined by service; no citizenship test in the section. Checked November 3, 2026.
- VA, Eligibility for VA home loan programs: Certificate of Eligibility criteria by service; citizenship mentioned only for World War II service in an allied force. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 38 CFR 36.4307, Interest rate reduction refinancing loan (eCFR, current as of October 29, 2026): (a)(5): a loan more than 30 days past due needs VA's advance approval. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 38 CFR 36.4340, Underwriting standards, processing procedures, lender responsibility, and lender certification (eCFR, current as of October 29, 2026): (b)(2)(i) income-verification exemption conditions; (f)(1) employment verifications no more than 120 days old; (f)(3) income reliability. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 7 CFR 3555.151, Eligibility requirements (eCFR, current as of October 29, 2026): (b): evidence of status as U.S. citizen, non-citizen national or qualified alien. Checked November 3, 2026.
- USDA HB-1-3555, Chapter 8 Applicant Characteristics (revised 04-01-24, PN 609; Wayback copy, saved July 21, 2024): Paragraph 8.2.F: acceptable citizenship or immigration status, valid Social Security number, lender representation at Conditional Commitment, the temporary EAD waiver dated to May 2, 2025. Checked November 3, 2026.
- USDA, Job Aid to Assist in Determining the Eligibility of Qualified Aliens (revised 04/28/2025; Wayback copy, saved December 19, 2025): Waiver rescission date of March 18, 2025; accepted documents including EADs coded A3, A5 or A10; borrowers approved under the waiver remain eligible to refinance their existing guaranteed loan. Checked November 3, 2026.
- USDA HB-1-3555, Chapter 6 Loan Purposes (revised 05-05-25, PN 640; Wayback copy, saved October 12, 2026): Non-streamlined, streamlined and streamlined-assist refinance conditions: 180 days seasoning, no delinquency greater than 30 days in 180 days, 30-year fixed term. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN): An ITIN is issued for federal tax purposes only and does not provide or change immigration status or authorize work. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 12 CFR 1002.6, Rules concerning evaluation of applications (Regulation B; eCFR, current as of October 29, 2026): (b)(7) a creditor may consider immigration status; (b)(9) national origin may not be considered. Checked November 3, 2026.
- 12 CFR 1026.43, Minimum standards for transactions secured by a dwelling (eCFR, current as of October 29, 2026): (c)(2) factors including current employment status; (c)(3) verification using reasonably reliable third-party records. Checked November 3, 2026.
- CFPB, Statement on Ability To Repay and Immigration Status (Federal Register document 2026-11447, 91 FR 34607, June 8, 2026): Statement under Regulation Z (12 CFR 1026.43) and Executive Order 14406: ability-to-repay requirements "may obligate consideration of a consumer's immigration status"; guidance without the force or effect of law. A search of Federal Register documents from June 1 to November 3, 2026 found no later CFPB notice on the subject. Checked November 3, 2026.
- Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey history (30-year fixed, week released October 29, 2026): 30-year fixed average 7.24%, used as context for the hypothetical 7.25% refinance rate. Checked November 3, 2026.
The lender and agency requirements described above are documented general information, not legal advice, immigration advice, a statement about any person's status, or a loan offer, and nothing here takes a position on who qualifies in a particular case. The Freddie Mac Seller/Servicer Guide, the VA Lender's Handbook and the Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix were not reviewed, which is why the table has no Freddie Mac row and no VA document list. The USDA Chapter 8 text is the April 1, 2024 revision as archived in July 2024; a later revision may exist, and the April 28, 2025 job aid governs the waiver date. Program rules and lender overlays change, so confirm with the lender in writing. The balance, rates and costs in the worked example are invented for the arithmetic and are not offers.