Refinancing by loan type

Refinancing without an appraisal: which loans skip it, and what the skip changes

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide topic B4-1.4-10, last updated June 3, 2026, lets its Desktop Underwriter offer a refinance with no appraisal, but only for a one-unit home valued under $1,000,000, generally only when an earlier appraisal sits in Fannie Mae's database, and only if the lender chooses to use the offer. FHA, VA and USDA streamlines skip the appraisal for a different reason: they never test the value. Your existing loan and the lender's system decide which path you are on, not a request from you.

Worksheet steps (9)
  1. No federal rule makes a lender order the appraisal; the loan's buyer does
  2. Fannie Mae value acceptance: what Desktop Underwriter has to find first
  3. The offer expires, and the lender can decline it
  4. Value acceptance plus property data: the version where someone walks through the house
  5. FHA, VA and USDA streamlines never test the value
  6. Why a streamline can skip it: the loan cannot grow
  7. Loans Fannie Mae already owns: the high LTV refinance option and its valuation rule
  8. What a skipped appraisal does to the break-even month
  9. When an appraisal is ordered anyway: the copy, the timing and the cost of a second one

No federal rule makes a lender order the appraisal; the loan's buyer does

People often ask whether an appraisal is the law. For most home loans it is not, and that is why waivers exist. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency's appraisal rule lists the transactions that do not need a state-certified or licensed appraiser, and several apply to ordinary refinances: a residential transaction of $400,000 or less, a transaction that is wholly or partly insured or guaranteed by a federal agency, and one that qualifies for sale to a government-sponsored enterprise such as Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac (12 CFR 34.43(a), read October 23, 2026). Where the appraisal is not required, the same section says the institution must still get an "appropriate evaluation" of the collateral for the $400,000 case. We read the OCC's version; other federal banking regulators publish parallel rules that we did not review, and credit unions follow their own regulator's text.

The one federal rule that does require an appraisal on a particular kind of loan is the higher-priced mortgage loan rule. A creditor may not make a higher-priced mortgage loan without a written appraisal by a certified or licensed appraiser who has visited the interior of the home, unless the loan is exempt. The exemptions in 12 CFR 1026.35(c)(2) include a loan that meets the qualified mortgage definition and a first-lien refinance in which the credit risk stays with whoever held it before, or the new loan is insured or guaranteed by the same agency as the old one, the payments cannot grow the principal or end in a balloon, and the proceeds only pay off the old loan and the cost of the refinance. That last exemption is the legal outline of an FHA, VA or USDA streamline.

So the real gatekeeper is the investor. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA and USDA each write their own valuation rules for the loans they buy or back. The sections below take them in the order a conventional borrower is most likely to meet them, then the government-backed paths, then the rule for borrowers whose loan Fannie Mae already owns. This page belongs to our section on refinancing by loan type, where the program-specific rules sit side by side.

Fannie Mae value acceptance: what Desktop Underwriter has to find first

Value acceptance is Fannie Mae's name for an appraisal waiver. When a lender submits a refinance to Desktop Underwriter (DU), the system may return an offer of value acceptance, in which case, in the Selling Guide's words, "an appraisal is not required." Three conditions sit underneath that offer. DU must find a prior appraisal of your property in Fannie Mae's Collateral Underwriter data, and that appraisal must be usable: if it carries an overvaluation flag or could not be scored, no offer is made. The casefile must receive an Approve/Eligible recommendation. And the transaction must not fall into one of the excluded categories (Selling Guide B4-1.4-10, 06/03/2026).

The excluded list is longer than most lender web pages admit, and each item has a plain meaning for a homeowner.

Who can receive a Fannie Mae value acceptance offer (Selling Guide B4-1.4-10, dated June 3, 2026; checked October 23, 2026)
Feature of your loan or homeOffer possible?What it means in practice
One-unit home, condominium includedYesThe ordinary case. Condos are named as eligible, though the building still needs its own condo project review or waiver.
Two- to four-unit propertyNoA duplex or fourplex is always appraised.
Co-op unit or manufactured homeNoBoth are excluded by type; a manufactured home is appraised in full and must first pass the real-property title and foundation tests for a manufactured home refinance.
Principal residence or second homeYesNamed as eligible occupancies.
Investment property refinanceYes, with a limitEligible, but the lender may not use the offer if it counts rent from the subject property to qualify you.
Purchase price or estimated value of $1,000,000 or moreNoThe test is the value entered in DU, not the loan balance.
Leasehold, community land trust or resale-restricted propertyNoIncludes casefiles using the Affordable LTV feature.
Texas Section 50(a)(6) home equity loanNoThese are always appraised.
Gift of equity in the transactionNoNot available when equity is gifted.
Manually underwritten loan, or DU recommendation other than Approve/EligibleNoThe offer exists only inside an approved DU run.
HomeStyle Renovation or HomeStyle Refresh loanNoRenovation loans need a value after improvements.
Proposed construction or construction-to-permanent loanNoThere is no finished home to compare, and the exclusion covers single-close and two-close loans alike; our guide to construction loan to permanent mortgage rules shows which appraisal each structure uses instead.

The offer expires, and the lender can decline it

Two clocks and one choice limit how a waiver plays out. The offer may be exercised only if it is "not more than four months old on the date of the note and the mortgage." A refinance that stalls in underwriting past that window needs a fresh DU run, and a fresh run can come back with a different answer if the prior appraisal data changed or your balance, cash-out amount or value estimate changed. Anyone planning to close near a four-month boundary should ask the loan officer when the offer was issued.

The choice belongs to the lender. The Guide says the lender "may not exercise a value acceptance offer" in four situations: DU could not detect an ineligible feature (the example it gives is a Texas 50(a)(6) loan), the lender is required by law to get an appraisal, the lender is using rental income from the subject property to qualify the borrower, or the lender believes an appraisal is warranted based on information it has about the property or later events. It also says a lender may not exercise the offer if an appraisal is obtained for the transaction. For a borrower, that last sentence has a consequence: paying for your own appraisal to "make sure" cancels the waiver, because the appraisal then governs. The same guide section on high loan-to-value refinances, B5-7-02, says it more bluntly: if an appraisal is obtained, it must be used for valuation even if value acceptance is offered.

Lenders also carry a duty not to cherry-pick. They "may not adversely select against Fannie Mae in determining which value acceptance offers to accept," and Fannie Mae may monitor how offers are used. In practice that means a lender cannot keep the waiver for easy files and appraise the shaky ones as a pattern. It does not mean you have a right to the waiver on your file.

Value acceptance plus property data: the version where someone walks through the house

A second DU offer exists for some one-unit properties: value acceptance plus property data (B4-1.4-11, 12/10/2025). No appraiser is involved, but a trained, background-checked property data collector must visit and record the interior and exterior to a Uniform Property Dataset, with photos and a floor plan to an ANSI standard, and submit it to Fannie Mae's Property Data API before the note date. The collection is valid for 12 months, the offer for four, and the loan carries Special Feature Code 774 at delivery. The exclusions mirror the plain offer with one difference: investment properties are ineligible whenever rental income is used to qualify the borrower.

The two options differ most in who stands behind what. Fannie Mae's property value representations and warranties rule (A2-2-06, 06/03/2026) says that under plain value acceptance the lender gives no warranty on value and marketability, on physical property characteristics, or on property eligibility including condition. Only the recent-disaster warranty remains. Under value acceptance plus property data, the lender does warrant physical characteristics and eligibility, including that the property is safe, sound and structurally secure. If the data collection shows a failing item such as a well, septic, foundation, roof, electrical or mold concern, the lender may need a professional report and evidence of repairs before the loan is sold.

That table of warranties is worth reading as a homeowner. Under plain value acceptance nobody has inspected your house for this loan, so the safety net that an appraiser's condition notes normally provide is absent. A leaking roof or a failing septic tank is yours to find. The same section says the value Fannie Mae accepts is "the lender's or borrower's estimate of value for a refinance transaction," and that Fannie Mae "does not warrant that the estimated value provided by the lender is the actual value." The estimate is a representation made on a federally backed loan. Give an honest one.

FHA, VA and USDA streamlines never test the value

Government-backed streamlines do not need a waiver because the program does not apply a value limit to them. The table sets out each path with the sentence that supports it.

Appraisal rules by refinance path (rule text read October 23, 2026; sources listed below the article)
Refinance pathNew appraisal?What stands in for the valueWhere the rule is
FHA Streamline Refinance (credit qualifying or not)NoNothing. The mortgage amount is capped by the old balance and original balance, not by value. For mortgage insurance, the value from the previous mortgage is used to calculate the loan-to-value ratio.Handbook 4000.1, Streamline Refinances (l): "Appraisals are not required on Streamline Refinances." Having one "does not affect the eligibility or maximum mortgage amount."
FHA Simple Refinance (no cash-out, not a streamline)Value is testedThe handbook caps the loan at 97.75% of value for a principal residence and 85% for an approved secondary residence, which needs a value to measure.Handbook 4000.1, Simple Refinance, maximum LTV
VA Interest Rate Reduction Refinance Loan (IRRRL)Not required by the statuteThe statute's reasonable-value limit is written to exclude loans made under the IRRRL clause. Ginnie Mae says that when VA does not require an appraisal, it will not either, and the lender must document a reasonable value estimate for the 25% guaranty-plus-equity test.38 USC 3710(b)(5); Ginnie Mae MBS Guide Chapter 24
VA cash-out refinanceYesThe new loan may not exceed 100% of reasonable value, so a VA appraisal sets the ceiling. The VA page says the lender will order the appraisal.38 USC 3710(b)(8); 38 CFR 36.4306(a)(1)
USDA streamlined refinanceNo new appraisalThe payoff of the existing guaranteed loan, with limits on what may be added.7 CFR 3555.101
USDA streamlined-assist refinanceNo, except one caseNo loan-to-value test. An appraisal is required only for a Section 502 direct borrower who received a subsidy.7 CFR 3555.101
USDA non-streamlined refinanceYes, new and currentThe new loan must be supported by equity shown in an appraisal.7 CFR 3555.101
Fannie Mae conventional refinance with a value acceptance offerNo, if offered and usedThe lender or borrower value estimate entered in DU.Selling Guide B4-1.4-10; A2-2-06

Why a streamline can skip it: the loan cannot grow

The common thread in the table is that a streamlined loan is built so the lender's exposure does not rise. The FHA handbook sets the maximum base loan amount for a principal residence as the lesser of the existing balance (plus interest due and mortgage insurance due) and the original principal balance, less any refund of the upfront premium. For an investment property the figure is the lesser of the outstanding and original balances. With no new money going out, the insured collateral position is the same as it was, which is why a missing appraisal is not a missing risk check. The details of the net tangible benefit test and the refund of the upfront premium are in our FHA streamline guide.

The Ginnie Mae pooling rule for VA loans explains the same logic from the securities side. A VA lender that sells into Ginnie Mae must show that the VA guaranty plus cash or equity equals at least 25 percent of the new loan amount. When VA does not require an appraisal, Ginnie Mae allows "a reasonable value estimate other than an appraisal" for the equity portion, with no particular method specified, provided written documentation of the estimate exists and is available for Ginnie Mae review. The rule applies to an IRRRL done at a lower rate with no cash out. The VA streamline guide covers the seasoning and recoupment tests that apply to it.

FHA streamline borrowers sometimes assume that skipping the appraisal means skipping the old value as well. It does not. The premium table in the handbook's mortgage insurance appendix says that for mortgages where FHA does not require an appraisal, the value from the previous mortgage is used to calculate the loan-to-value ratio that sets the annual premium. A home that has appreciated since the original loan is not recognized by the streamline, and one that has lost value is not penalized by it.

Loans Fannie Mae already owns: the high LTV refinance option and its valuation rule

A narrower route exists for a conventional borrower whose existing loan is owned by Fannie Mae and whose loan-to-value ratio is above the ordinary limit. The Selling Guide calls it the high LTV refinance option (B5-7-02, 09/03/2025). It has no maximum debt-to-income ratio and no minimum credit score, outside the alternative qualification path, and does not require the lender to confirm the property is not listed for sale. Eligibility turns on payment history over the previous 12 months: no delinquencies in the most recent six, and in months seven through twelve no more than one 30-day delinquency and nothing worse.

On valuation, the same section says DU may offer value acceptance or value acceptance plus property data on these loans. Otherwise an appraisal with an interior and exterior inspection is required, and a manually underwritten high LTV refinance always needs one. A lender that exercises the offer delivers Special Feature Code 807, or 774 for the property data version. The offer rules mirror the standard ones: four months old at most on the note date, and no appraisal obtained. Which borrowers can use the option at all, and how the ratio ceilings compare across programs, is tabled in refinancing when your home value has dropped; this page only needs the fact that being underwater does not by itself force an appraisal if the loan is one Fannie Mae owns.

What a skipped appraisal does to the break-even month

A waiver saves a fee. It does not change the rate, the mortgage insurance rules or the price adjustments tied to your credit score and loan-to-value band. The saving is real but small, so the useful question is how much it moves the month your payment savings repay the costs. Here is one case with every input stated.

The balance is $280,000 with 25 years left at 7.25 percent, and the quote is a new 25-year loan at 6.50 percent. Both rates are illustrations, not quotes. Monthly principal and interest falls from $2,023.86 to $1,890.58, a saving of $133.28. If the closing costs are $5,200 including a $650 appraisal, the payment savings repay them in month 40, because $5,200 divided by $133.28 is 39.0 and the repayment lands inside the 40th month. If a value acceptance offer removes the $650, costs are $4,550 and the break-even month is 35, since $4,550 divided by $133.28 is 34.1. The waiver pulled the break-even in by five months and nothing else changed. Over a seven-year stay, both versions clear their costs with years to spare, which is how most of these decisions end up: the appraisal fee rarely decides whether to refinance. It decides how long the borrower waits before the refinance is paid for.

The same arithmetic shows when the waiver matters more. At a payment saving of $50 a month, the same $650 is 13 months of the saving, and on a refinance that already breaks even in month 60 it can be the difference between clearing the costs before a likely move and not clearing them. The break-even guide shows how to run your own figures, and the appraisal fee guide explains what the fee usually covers and who orders the appraisal.

When an appraisal is ordered anyway: the copy, the timing and the cost of a second one

If the lender orders an appraisal, federal law sets the borrower's rights to see it. Regulation B (12 CFR 1002.14) requires a creditor to give an applicant a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations developed in connection with an application for credit secured by a first lien on a dwelling. The copy is due promptly upon completion, or three business days before consummation, whichever is earlier. An applicant may waive the timing, but the waiver must be obtained at least three business days before consummation unless the new version contains only clerical changes. The creditor must send a written notice of the right to a copy no later than the third business day after the application. It may not charge for the copy, though it may charge a reasonable fee to reimburse the cost of the appraisal itself.

The rule applies whether the application ends in a loan or not. If the borrower waives the timing and the loan never closes, the creditor must still deliver the copies within 30 days after it decides the loan will not close. The definition of "valuation" is any estimate of the value of a dwelling developed in connection with an application, which is wider than a full appraisal report, so a desktop or hybrid product the lender developed is covered by the same copy right.

When the number comes in lower than expected, the appraisal rules interact with the pricing tiers and mortgage insurance rules discussed in what to do when a refinance appraisal comes in low. The reconsideration process and the pay-down arithmetic are there. The only thing to add here is the reverse risk: the waiver is the lender's offer, and a borrower who asks for an appraisal to prove a higher value gives up the waiver on that loan. Files with unusual liens, such as a solar fixture filing or a PACE assessment that must be paid off, raise their own title and value questions, covered in our solar and PACE refinance guide.

Common questions

Is the $1,000,000 limit on value acceptance about my loan amount or my home's value?

Its test is "either the purchase price or estimated value provided to DU," so it is the value. A $700,000 loan on a home the lender enters at $1,150,000 is excluded, and a $950,000 loan on a $990,000 home is not excluded by this rule. The rule is written in dollars of value, so high-cost county loan limits do not change it.

Does value acceptance cover a cash-out refinance, or only rate-and-term?

B4-1.4-10 lists "certain purchase, limited cash-out, and cash-out refinance transactions" as eligible, so a cash-out loan can be offered a waiver. The ceiling does not move: the August 5, 2026 Eligibility Matrix still caps a one-unit principal residence cash-out refinance at 80 percent, and the value used for that test is the estimate entered in DU.

Can my lender tell me that Fannie Mae appraised or valued my home?

No. A2-2-06 says the lender "may not make any statements to any third party (including the borrower) that Fannie Mae performed any kind of appraisal or valuation of the property." Under value acceptance Fannie Mae accepts a submitted estimate and does no valuation of its own, so a borrower told otherwise has been given the wrong description.

Does the high LTV refinance option require pay stubs or tax-return income?

Not in the ordinary case. B5-7-02 asks for one of three things: a verbal verification of employment for at least one borrower, documentation of a non-employment income source, or 12 months of the new housing payment in liquid reserves. Outside the Alternative Qualification Path the lender need not verify income or assets or calculate a debt-to-income ratio, though each borrower signs IRS Form 4506-C.

Can a rental property get an appraisal waiver?

An investment property refinance is on the eligible list for plain value acceptance, but the lender may not exercise the offer if it uses rental income from the subject property to qualify you. For value acceptance plus property data, an investment property that uses rental income to qualify is excluded outright.

Next: what a low value does to the price.

Sources and verification

This page does not tabulate Freddie Mac's own appraisal waiver rules: its Guide pages could not be retrieved as text in this review, so Freddie Mac loans may follow different eligibility lists than the Fannie Mae ones shown. The HUD Handbook copy we read is the PDF HUD posts, with streamline sections last revised in 2019, and later Mortgagee Letters may have changed details. The 7.25 and 6.50 percent rates and the $650 fee in the break-even example are illustrations, not market data or quotes. No lender decides your waiver because of this page; the system run on your application does.