Two offers, one horizon

Loan Estimate comparator

Two Loan Estimates rarely crown the same winner. One buys the rate down with points and fees paid on day one; the other charges less upfront and more every month. Which one is cheaper depends on how long you keep the loan. Enter both offers, state your horizon, and this comparator totals each offer the same way: closing costs plus the interest you would pay over that horizon, with the balance still owed shown so the cheaper-rate offer cannot hide behind a slower payoff.

  • Runs only on numbers you type in
  • Saved only in your browser, on this device
  • No rate is published, prefilled as current, or suggested
  • The worked example is labelled and stated in full

Short answer

Copy each offer's loan amount, rate, points, lender fees, third-party fees, and term from its Loan Estimate, then set the years you expect to keep the loan. The comparator names the cheaper offer over that horizon and the dollar gap. If you are weighing one offer against the loan you already have, the refinance offer worksheet computes that break-even month instead; if you do not have offers yet, start with the lender directory.

This comparator runs only on the numbers you type in, copied from Loan Estimates you actually received. Nothing you enter leaves your browser: your entries are saved only in this browser, on this device, so you can come back to them. No rate is published, pulled, or suggested here.

Worked example loaded. The two sample offers below sit on one stated basis: a $400,000 loan amount, a 30-year term, and a 7-year horizon. They are teaching examples that show how the verdict is built. They are not quotes, not today's rates, and not rates any lender has offered you. Type over them with the figures from your own Loan Estimates.

How long do you expect to keep this loan?

The winner between two offers depends on this answer. Points and fees are paid on day one, while a lower rate saves a little every month, so a loan you keep for two years and a loan you keep for twelve can crown different offers. Enter the horizon you honestly expect: until you move, refinance again, or pay the loan off.

Points are entered as

Monthly principal and interest: $2,627.72

Points cost: $4,000.00. Total closing costs: $8,045.00

Total cost over your 7 year horizon: $192,648.46

Points are entered as

Monthly principal and interest: $2,694.87

Points cost: $0.00. Total closing costs: $3,845.00

Total cost over your 7 year horizon: $195,507.21

The verdict over your horizon

Over 7 years, Sample offer A is the cheaper offer by $2,859 in total cost (closing costs plus interest paid over the horizon). That verdict holds only for this horizon: shorten it and the low-fee offer gains, lengthen it and the low-rate offer gains.

MeasureSample offer A (cheaper over your horizon)Sample offer B
Monthly principal and interest$2,627.72$2,694.87
Points cost$4,000.00$0.00
Total closing costs (points + lender fees + third-party fees)$8,045.00$3,845.00
Payments made over your 7 year horizon$220,728.08$226,369.42
Interest paid over the horizon$184,603.46$191,662.21
Balance still owed at the horizon$363,875.38$365,292.79
Total cost over the horizon (closing costs + interest paid)$192,648.46$195,507.21
Interest over the full term, if you kept the loan to the end$545,977.49$570,154.67
Total interest as a share of the loan amount (TIP style)136.5%142.5%

How the headline figure is built. Total cost over your horizon = closing costs + interest paid over the horizon. The same figure, built the long way: closing costs + every payment you make over the horizon + the balance you would still owe if you sold or refinanced at the horizon, minus the amount you borrowed. Principal you repay is not a cost, because it comes back to you as equity or a lower payoff; that is why the balance sits in the long build, and why the two builds agree.

Monthly payment formula. Payment = loan amount x monthly rate / (1 - (1 + monthly rate) raised to minus the number of months in the term), with monthly rate = interest rate / 100 / 12. At a 0% rate the payment is simply the amount divided by the months. Points cost is the points percent multiplied by the loan amount, or the dollar figure you entered when points are given in dollars.

Taxes, homeowner's insurance, and mortgage insurance are left out of every figure here. They depend on the home and the borrower more than on which lender wrote the offer, and the Loan Estimate lists them separately from the loan's own price. This comparator gives educational estimates from your inputs, not a loan offer.

How to fill it in

  • Loan amount, rate, and term sit at the top of page 1 of the Loan Estimate. Use the same loan amount and term for every offer when you can; the comparator warns you when the offers are not on the same basis.
  • Points live in Section A (origination charges) on page 2, listed either as a percent of the loan amount or as a dollar figure. The toggle on the form takes either shape.
  • Lender fees are the rest of Section A: underwriting, processing, application, and origination charges. Third-party fees are Sections B and C together: appraisal, credit report, title, recording, and the other services the lender requires but does not provide.
  • Leave out prepaids and escrow deposits (Sections F and G), and leave out taxes and insurance. You owe those on any loan, and they price the home and the borrower, not the lender's offer.
  • Set the horizon to the years you honestly expect to keep this loan. Then move it: watch the verdict at 3 years, 7 years, and 12 years before you decide, because the winner can change with the horizon.

The formulas used

Monthly principal and interest uses the standard fixed-rate amortization formula, the same one on the methodology page: payment = loan amount x monthly rate / (1 - (1 + monthly rate) raised to minus the number of months in the term), with monthly rate = rate / 100 / 12. Interest paid over the horizon is summed month by month from the amortization, and the balance still owed is what remains after those payments. Total cost over the horizon = total closing costs + interest paid over the horizon. Built the long way, closing costs + every payment made + the balance still owed at the horizon - the amount borrowed gives the identical figure, because repaid principal returns to you as equity or a lower payoff and is not a cost. The full-term interest share is the total interest over the whole term divided by the loan amount, the same basis as the Total Interest Percentage printed on page 3 of every Loan Estimate.

Common questions

How is this different from the refinance offer worksheet?

The refinance offer worksheet weighs each offer against the loan you already have and finds the month its payment savings repay its upfront costs. This comparator weighs the offers against each other over the years you set, counting both closing costs and interest, which is the right test when you have already decided to take a new loan and are choosing which one. Many borrowers run both: the worksheet to decide whether to move at all, the comparator to pick the offer.

Why does the horizon change the winner?

Points and fees are paid once, at closing. A lower rate saves a small amount every month. Over a short horizon the one-time costs have few months of savings to beat, so the low-fee offer usually wins; over a long horizon the monthly savings pile up past the upfront cost, so the low-rate offer usually wins. The break-even guide explains the same arithmetic one offer at a time.

Why is the balance still owed in the table if it is not in the headline cost?

Because two offers at different rates pay the balance down at different speeds, and a borrower who only compared payments plus interest could be misled about the loan they would still owe if they sold at the horizon. The balance is shown on its own row, and the formula note shows the long build (closing costs + payments + balance still owed - amount borrowed) agreeing with the headline figure, so nothing is hidden in either direction.

Are the two sample offers real rates I can get?

No. They are teaching examples loaded so the form never starts blank and you can watch the verdict being built. Their basis is stated in full on the form: a $400,000 loan amount, a 30-year term, and a 7-year horizon. This site never publishes a rate as current unless it is dated and sourced to Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey, the way the rate tracker does. Your Loan Estimates are the only rates that belong in this form.

Is anything I type sent anywhere?

No. The comparator computes in your browser only. Your entries are stored in this browser, on this device, so the form is as you left it when you return; there is no account, no submission, and no tracking of your figures. The Clear button removes them.

Sources and verification

Loan Estimate sections, fee categories, and the Total Interest Percentage follow the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's Loan Estimate explainer and the form itself. Arithmetic follows the amortization and cost-over-horizon formulas shown on the methodology page and above. This comparator provides educational estimates from your inputs, not a loan offer.