How to read a refinance Loan Estimate: the five numbers that decide the deal
Read a refinance Loan Estimate for five numbers: the loan amount, the rate and term, the true closing costs in the lettered cost sections, the rate lock expiry, and the In 5 Years total. The rest of the form explains them. No later than the third business day after a lender receives your application, it must deliver or mail you this form (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(1)(iii)), and for a federally related mortgage loan it must use the standard model form, H-24, so every lender's version lines up with the next. That standardization is the point. A Loan Estimate lets you lay two refinance quotes side by side and compare them section by section instead of trusting whichever rate was spoken loudest on the phone. Most borrowers still read the top of the form, find the rate and the monthly payment, and stop. The sections that decide whether the loan wins sit further in, and they take about ten minutes to read once you know what each letter holds.
Worksheet steps (11)
- Page 1 names the loan. It does not grade the deal
- Three yes-or-no answers in the Loan Terms table
- Two clocks sit on the rate lock line
- Section A is the price the lender sets
- Sections B and C split what you can shop from what you cannot
- Cash to Close is not the closing cost total
- In 5 Years: the horizon test the form already ran
- APR and the Total Interest Percentage on a refinance quote
- Other Considerations: four lines that matter on a refinance
- Before the form arrives: what the lender cannot ask for yet
- Copy five numbers, then run both terms
Page 1 names the loan. It does not grade the deal
Page 1 shows the loan type, the term in years, whether the rate is fixed or adjustable, the interest rate itself, and the monthly principal and interest. Read those five fields as one sentence before you look at anything else. A 30-year fixed loan at one rate and a 24-year fixed loan at the same rate are different loans with different payments and different lifetime interest, and lenders know the longer term photographs better on a payment line.
Two checks belong on this page. First, the term must be the term you asked to be priced. If you asked for your remaining term and the form shows a fresh 30-year term, every comparison that follows is priced on a loan you did not request. Second, find the rate lock box. It states whether the rate is locked and the date the lock expires. A low rate with a lock that expires before your closing date is a starting point for a negotiation, not a price you hold. Regulation Z requires that box to give the date and time, with the time zone, when a lock ends (12 CFR 1026.37(a)(13)), so the expiry is never a matter of interpretation.
If you want the form in its place in the whole transaction, the how to refinance step by step guide on this site runs the procedure from the current loan check through funding and the first payment, and the how much does it cost to refinance worksheet totals the Section A to E stack into one break-even numerator on a worked $350,000 example. Use the Rate Lock date on page 1 to find the matching Freddie Mac survey week before comparing your rate with the weekly average.
Three yes-or-no answers in the Loan Terms table
Beside the loan amount, the rate and the principal and interest payment, the Loan Terms table asks the same question three times: "Can this amount increase after closing?" The answer is a plain yes or no for each of the three figures (12 CFR 1026.37(b)(6)). On a fixed-rate refinance all three should read no. A yes beside the rate means an adjustable loan, and the form must then give how often the rate can change, when it can first change, the highest it can reach and the first date it could get there. A yes beside the loan amount means the balance can grow, as it does with negative amortization, and the form must state the maximum balance.
Below those, under "Does the loan have these features?", sit the prepayment penalty and the balloon payment (12 CFR 1026.37(b)(4), (5) and (7)). Both matter more on a refinance than on a purchase, because a refinance is a bet that you will keep this loan only as long as it keeps winning. A prepayment penalty is defined in the regulation as a charge for paying all or part of the principal before it is due, and if the answer is yes the form must give the maximum penalty and the date it stops applying. A balloon payment is any payment more than two times a regular periodic payment. If either answer is yes on a quote you are comparing against a loan without one, the next refinance, or the sale of the house, now carries a price that belongs in your break-even.
Read the three answers before the rate. A quote whose rate is a quarter point lower but whose rate can rise, or whose payoff carries a penalty for the first three years, is not the same product at a better price. It is a different product, and the ARM to fixed refinance guide shows how a rate that can increase changes the arithmetic.
Two clocks sit on the rate lock line
The Rate Lock statement runs two separate clocks, and borrowers routinely read only one. The first is the lock itself. If the rate is locked, the form gives the date and time, with the time zone, when the lock ends. Locked or not, the form must also say that the interest rate, any points and any lender credits may change unless the rate has been locked (12 CFR 1026.37(a)(13)). A quote without a lock is a description of today's pricing, not a price you hold.
The second clock is the expiry of the estimated closing costs, which the form must print whether or not the rate is locked. The official commentary ties it to a ten-business-day rule: if you do not indicate an intent to proceed within 10 business days after the Loan Estimate was provided, or within any longer period the lender sets, the lender may use a revised estimate of a charge instead of the original one when good faith is measured (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(3)(iv)(E) and comment 37(a)(13)-2). In practice, a Loan Estimate you sit on for three weeks is no longer a ceiling on what the lender can charge.
The two clocks interact when you lock later. If the rate was not locked when the first Loan Estimate went out, the points and lender credits can change when it is, and the lender must send a revised Loan Estimate with the locked rate, the points, the lender credits and any other rate-dependent charges no later than three business days after the lock date (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(3)(iv)(D)). That revised form, not the first one, is the quote to run through your break-even, and a lock extension fee, if one appears later, is covered in the rate lock guide.
Section A is the price the lender sets
Section A lists what the lender itself charges: origination, application, processing, underwriting, and any discount points you agree to buy. Regulation Z lets each lender label its own charges in words that describe them, up to 13 lines under Origination Charges, with any points listed first as both a percentage of the loan amount and a dollar figure, and every other line in alphabetical order (12 CFR 1026.37(f)(1) and (f)(5)). So one lender bundles everything into a single origination line while another itemizes five charges. The packaging varies. The Section A total does not, and that total is the lender price for the loan at the stated rate and points.
Price every quote at zero points before you price points at all. A point is prepaid interest, 1% of the balance paid at closing to buy the rate down, and it belongs in the closing cost total when you take it. On a $365,000 balance one point is $3,650 before any other fee is counted. If that point buys $70 a month of payment reduction, it needs 53 months to repay itself. Ask each lender for the par quote first, the rate at no points and no lender credit, then decide whether buying the rate down earns its cost inside the stay you can defend. The discount points guide on this site works that division in full.
- Origination and lender service charges: the lender margin. Compare the Section A total across lenders, never label by label.
- Discount points: optional prepaid interest. Keep them at zero while you compare lenders, then price them as a separate bet on how long you keep the loan.
- Application, processing, and underwriting lines: real work with negotiable pricing. A total thousands above a competing Section A for the same rate needs an explanation in writing.
Sections B and C split what you can shop from what you cannot
Section B holds services the lender requires but you cannot choose the provider for, such as the credit report, flood certification, and in many files the appraisal ordered through the lender channel. Section C holds services you can shop for, most often title search, title insurance, and settlement or closing services. The split matters for two reasons. You can only save money where you are allowed to choose, and the form holds the lender to different accuracy limits for each group when the final disclosure arrives.
Get at least one outside quote for the Section C lines. Title and settlement charges vary by provider and by state, and on a mid-size balance the spread between a lender default provider and a shopped provider can run into hundreds of dollars. Every dollar trimmed from Section C is a dollar the monthly saving no longer has to repay, so it pulls the break-even month forward by exactly the same arithmetic as a lower rate would. The third-party fees and title insurance guides on this site price each of those lines separately.
Cash to Close is not the closing cost total
Page 2 ends with Section J, Total Closing Costs, and a separate Cash to Close figure. Borrowers treat the two as the same number. They are not, and the gap between them is where refinance math most often goes wrong. Sections F and G collect prepaid homeowner insurance, property taxes, per-diem interest, and the opening escrow deposits. That money settles bills you already owe on a schedule. It changes what you bring to closing. It does not change what the refinance itself costs, because keeping the current loan would have collected the same bills on their own dates.
Build the break-even numerator by hand instead of copying either printed total. Add Sections A, B, and C, add the taxes and government charges in Section E, and add any one-time charge sitting in Section H. Subtract any lender credit shown in Section J, because a credit is the lender paying part of that stack in exchange for the rate. Leave Sections F and G out. That hand-built sum is the figure the calculator on this site asks for when it says closing costs, and it is the only version of the total that divides cleanly by a monthly saving. The lender credits, prepaid items, and per-diem guides each isolate one piece of that build. When the final form arrives, the same split appears in its Calculating Cash to Close table, which our refinance Closing Disclosure guide walks through row by row.
| Section | What sits there | In break-even? |
|---|---|---|
| A | Lender charges and any discount points | Yes. Compare this total at zero points first |
| B | Required services you cannot shop for | Yes. One-time charges for the new loan |
| C | Title, settlement, and services you can shop for | Yes. Shopping this section pulls break-even forward |
| E | Recording fees and transfer or mortgage taxes | Yes. Government charges for the new filing |
| F and G | Prepaid bills and opening escrow deposits | No. Your own bills collected early, owed either way |
| J credit | Lender credit toward your costs | Subtract it. The lender paid that part through the rate |
One Loan Estimate on a $365,000 balance, read page by page
You owe $365,000 with 24 years left at 7.25%, so principal and interest on the remaining schedule runs near $2,678 a month. A refinance Loan Estimate offers 6.35% on a fresh 30-year term at $2,271 a month, which reads as $407 saved. The lettered sections tell the rest: Section A is $2,150 with zero points, Section B is $780, Section C is $2,420, and Section E is $500, for true closing costs of $5,850. Sections F and G add $4,300 of prepaid insurance, taxes, and escrow deposits to Cash to Close, and that $4,300 stays out of the break-even math because you owe those bills on the current loan too. On the 30-year term, $5,850 divided by $407 puts break-even in month 15. Price the same 6.35% on the 24 years you actually have left and the payment is $2,472, the saving is $206, and break-even moves to month 29. On a seven-year stay both structures clear break-even. Only the second one tells you what the rate alone bought, because the first payment mixed a lower rate with six added years. Balance $365,000, terms 24 years left and 30 years new, true closing costs $5,850, stay horizon seven years.
In 5 Years: the horizon test the form already ran
The Comparisons table near the end of the form opens with a figure built for exactly the question this site asks. Regulation Z defines "In 5 Years" as two dollar amounts: the total of principal, interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs scheduled to be paid through the end of the 60th month after the first payment is due, labelled "Total you will have paid in principal, interest, mortgage insurance, and loan costs", and the principal paid in the same 60 months, labelled "Principal you will have paid off" (12 CFR 1026.37(l)(1)). The commentary says the lender assumes payments are made as scheduled and on time, that loan costs means the costs in the Loan Costs table, Sections A to C, and that mortgage insurance includes prepaid or escrowed mortgage insurance. Property taxes, homeowner's insurance and their escrow deposits are not part of the figure.
Read the two numbers together, never the first alone. The total includes principal, and principal is not a cost: it is your own balance going down. Subtract the second number from the first and you get the cost of the loan over five years, interest plus mortgage insurance plus loan costs. That single subtraction turns In 5 Years into a five-year break-even for any quote, and it works across quotes with different points, different credits and different terms, because the form computes every one of them the same way.
Work it on three quotes for a $365,000 balance, with every rate a labelled illustration. Quote A is 6.35 percent on 30 years with no points and $5,350 of loan costs. Quote B is 6.10 percent on 30 years with one point, $3,650, so loan costs of $9,000. Quote C is 6.35 percent on the 24 years left on the current loan, with the same $5,350. For contrast, apply the same arithmetic to the current loan, 7.25 percent with 288 payments left and no new loan costs.
Show the five-year numbers for each loan
| Loan | Monthly P&I | In 5 Years total | Principal paid off | Five-year cost (total minus principal) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Current, 7.25%, 288 payments left | $2,677.66 | $160,660 | $34,044 | $126,616 |
| A: 6.35%, 30 years, no points | $2,271.16 | $141,620 | $23,915 | $117,704 |
| B: 6.10%, 30 years, 1 point | $2,211.88 | $141,713 | $24,935 | $116,778 |
| C: 6.35%, 24 years, no points | $2,472.16 | $153,680 | $38,066 | $115,614 |
Read the chart the wrong way and quote A wins: its In 5 Years total, $141,620, is the lowest of the four. Read it the right way and the order changes. Five-year cost is about $117,704 on quote A, $116,778 on quote B and $115,614 on quote C, against $126,616 on the current loan. Quote B's point, $3,650 for a saving of $59.28 a month, pays for itself in about 62 months, which is why B is $906 behind A at three years and $926 ahead of it at five. Quote C costs the most each month and the least over five years, because the shorter term pays down about $38,066 of principal where A pays about $23,915.
The lesson is not that C is the right loan. It is that the In 5 Years pair lets you rank quotes on cost rather than payment without building a spreadsheet, as long as your horizon is near five years. For a shorter or longer stay, the discount points guide moves the same comparison to any month, and the Loan Estimate comparator lays two forms side by side.
APR and the Total Interest Percentage on a refinance quote
The other two Comparisons figures are lifetime measures, and both assume you keep the loan to the end. The APR carries its own warning on the form: "Your costs over the loan term expressed as a rate. This is not your interest rate." (12 CFR 1026.37(l)(2)). Because it spreads the loan costs across the full term, it understates what those costs mean on a refinance you hold for a few years, and it says nothing about the loan you are leaving.
The Total Interest Percentage is printed with the statement "The total amount of interest that you will pay over the loan term as a percentage of your loan amount." (12 CFR 1026.37(l)(3)). The commentary tells the lender to assume every payment is made in full and on time with no extra payments, and to include prepaid interest. On the three illustration quotes, before prepaid interest, it comes to about 124.00 percent for A, 118.16 percent for B and 95.06 percent for C. The current loan's remaining schedule, run the same way, comes to about 111.28 percent of the same balance. Quote A has the lower rate and the higher lifetime interest, the term restart showing itself in one number, which the mistake guide prices in dollars.
Use the two lifetime figures as tie-breakers between quotes on the same term, not as the verdict. Your horizon decides the verdict, and In 5 Years is the one Comparisons figure already measured on a fixed horizon. When the APR and the In 5 Years rows rank two quotes in opposite orders, APR or interest rate for a short stay re-runs one pair at 3, 5, 7 and 10 years and finds the month the ranking flips.
Other Considerations: four lines that matter on a refinance
The last table on the form is easy to skip because it reads like boilerplate. Four of its lines are specific to your loan and worth a minute each (12 CFR 1026.37(m)).
- Assumption: whether a later buyer may be permitted to assume the loan on its original terms. If your current loan is an FHA or VA loan that a buyer could take over, compare this line on the new form with what you would give up.
- Servicing: whether the lender intends to service the loan or transfer servicing to another company. A planned transfer changes where you send payments, not your terms.
- Refinance: the fixed statement "Refinancing this loan will depend on your future financial situation, the property value, and market conditions. You may not be able to refinance this loan." It is a reminder that a plan to refinance again when rates fall is not a feature of the loan.
- Liability after Foreclosure: on a refinance the form must say briefly that certain state law protections against liability for a deficiency after foreclosure may be lost, what that can mean, and that you should consult an attorney. It appears only on refinances, and in states with such protections it is a line that can change your risk rather than your cost.
The Late Payment line belongs on the list too: it states the late charge and the number of days a payment must be late before the charge applies. Compare it with your current note before you assume the grace period carries over.
Before the form arrives: what the lender cannot ask for yet
The rules around the Loan Estimate also protect the days before you have one. Until you have received the Loan Estimate and told the lender you intend to proceed, neither the lender nor anyone else may charge you a fee in connection with the application, except a bona fide and reasonable fee for pulling your credit report (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(2)(i)). The lender also may not require documents verifying the information in your application before it provides the Loan Estimate (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(2)(iii)). An appraisal deposit or an application fee requested before the form exists is a request the rule does not allow.
Any written, borrower-specific estimate handed over before the Loan Estimate must carry, at the top of its first page in type no smaller than 12-point, the statement "Your actual rate, payment, and costs could be higher. Get an official Loan Estimate before choosing a loan." It also may not be made to look substantially like the official form (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(2)(ii)). A rate sheet or worksheet with that sentence on it is a sales document. It is useful for asking questions and useless for a break-even, because none of its numbers are subject to the good-faith limits that bind a Loan Estimate.
So the order of operations on a refinance is simple: ask for the Loan Estimate first, compare it with one or two others, and pay nothing beyond a credit report fee until you have chosen. The step-by-step refinance guide places those days on the full calendar from application to funding.
Copy five numbers, then run both terms
One line of scrap paper finishes the reading. Write your payoff balance from your current statement, the new rate from page 1, the new term from page 1, the true closing cost total you built from Sections A through E, and the stay horizon you can defend from your own plans. The first four numbers sit on the form. The fifth never does, and it is the one that decides the verdict, because a break-even month only means something measured against the date you might actually leave this loan.
Enter those five numbers in the calculator twice. Run the new term exactly as quoted, then run the term you have left at the same rate. The first run shows the payment the lender led with. The second run separates the rate saving from the term restart, and it is the run that tells you what the lower rate bought on its own. If break-even lands well inside your stay on the term-matched run, the Loan Estimate describes a refinance that wins on the rate rather than on added years. If it only clears on the restarted term, you are looking at a longer loan with a friendlier payment, and the lifetime interest lines in the calculator show what those added years collect. Comparing the final bill with this form is governed by the Loan Estimate tolerance rules.
Page-by-page checks on your Loan Estimate
- On page 1, confirm the loan type, the term in years, and whether the rate is fixed or adjustable. All three must match what you asked for before any other line matters.
- Add Sections A, B, C, and E together, plus any one-time charge in Section H. Set Sections F and G aside. That sum is the true closing cost figure for break-even.
- Compare the Section A total at zero points across lenders before you compare any rate with points folded in.
- Copy five numbers onto one line: your payoff balance, the new rate, the new term, the true closing cost total, and the stay horizon you can defend. Run the calculator on the new term and on the term you have left.
- Find the rate lock expiry on page 1 and count the days to your planned closing. A rate that expires before closing is a different quote.
- In the Comparisons table, subtract Principal you will have paid off from the In 5 Years total for each quote. The smaller result is the cheaper loan over five years, whatever the payment says.
- Check the three Can this amount increase after closing answers and the prepayment penalty line. On a fixed-rate refinance you are comparing against a loan without a penalty, all four should normally read no. If the penalty line reads yes, the prepayment penalty guide shows the maximum in dollars by payoff date.
Common questions
How soon should I receive a Loan Estimate after I apply?
The lender must deliver or place in the mail the Loan Estimate no later than the third business day after it receives your application (12 CFR 1026.19(e)(1)(iii)). Until you have received it and said you intend to proceed, the only fee anyone may charge you is a reasonable credit report fee, and the lender may not require documents verifying your application first.
Why do two lenders quote the same rate with different closing costs?
Because the rate is only one input. Section A lender charges, points folded into the price, and the shoppable services in Section C can differ by thousands of dollars between lenders quoting the same rate on the same day. The rate tells you the price of money. Sections A through E tell you the price of getting it, and break-even is driven by the second figure as much as the first.
Is Cash to Close the same as my closing costs?
No. Cash to Close is everything you must bring or finance to settle the loan, including prepaid insurance and taxes in Section F and the first escrow deposits in Section G. Those are your own bills collected early, owed on the current loan as well. True closing costs for break-even are the one-time charges in Sections A, B, C, and E, plus any one-time charge in Section H. The prepaid and escrow guides on this site show how to separate the two stacks line by line.
What if Section A shows one bundled line instead of itemized fees?
It is common, and the rules allow it. Regulation Z lets each lender label its charges in its own descriptive words, with points listed first and the rest in alphabetical order. Neither layout proves the price is fair. Compare the Section A total for the same rate, same term, and zero points. The total is the lender price. The labels are packaging.
Can the numbers change between the Loan Estimate and closing?
Some can, inside limits set by the good-faith rules. Charges paid to the lender, transfer taxes and services you were not allowed to shop for generally cannot rise at all; shoppable services from the lender's list and recording fees can rise 10 percent as a group; prepaid interest, insurance premiums and escrow deposits are not capped, as long as the estimate used the best information reasonably available to the lender. The lender must also deliver a Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing. The Loan Estimate tolerance rules guide works the refund arithmetic.
What does In 5 Years on a Loan Estimate tell me?
It gives two figures for the first 60 months after the first payment: the total of principal, interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs, and the principal paid off. Subtract the second from the first to get the five-year cost of the loan. On the illustration in this guide that ranks three $365,000 quotes by cost, $115,614 to $117,704, and puts quote C first, where the payment alone would have ranked it last.
Sources and verification
- 12 CFR 1026.37, Content of disclosures for certain mortgage transactions (Loan Estimate): Rate Lock statement (a)(13); Loan Terms and the "Can this amount increase after closing?" answers (b); Loan Costs sections and item ordering (f); Prepaids and escrow (g); Comparisons: In 5 Years, APR, Total Interest Percentage (l); Other Considerations (m); standard form H-24 (o). Checked October 29, 2026.
- 12 CFR 1026.19(e), Provision of Loan Estimate and good-faith limits: Delivery by the third business day after application; no fee before receipt and intent to proceed except a credit report fee; no verification documents; the 12-point statement on pre-Loan Estimate worksheets; revised Loan Estimate within three business days of a rate lock; the 10-business-day expiration. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Regulation Z official interpretations (Supplement I to Part 1026): comments 37(a)(13), 37(l)(1)(i)-1, 37(l)(3)-1, 37(o)(1)-1: Closing-cost expiry and the 10-business-day rule; In 5 Years counts loan costs from the Loan Costs table and assumes on-time payments; the total interest percentage includes prepaid interest; federally related loans must use form H-24. Checked October 29, 2026.
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey: Weekly national average rate survey, used on this site only as market context beside a borrower quote. A quote on a Loan Estimate is the lender figure for one file, never a survey average. Checked October 6, 2026.
Educational only, not a loan offer. This page teaches a reading method. The figures in the worked examples are labelled hypotheticals built to show the arithmetic, not quotes. Only the Loan Estimate a lender issues for your loan, and the Closing Disclosure that follows it, state the real numbers for your file.