Closing costs

APR or interest rate when you will keep the loan about five years: the same two quotes, re-run by stay length

Over a five-year stay, neither the interest rate nor the APR picks the cheaper loan; the dollars paid through your exit month do. On two illustrative $350,000 quotes, the loan with the lower rate (6.875% against 7.25%) also has the lower full-term APR (7.14% against 7.28%), yet it costs $1,589 more through year five. The dollar ranking flips in month 75, and the APR gives a different answer from the dollars in the seventh year, where the lower-rate loan is $1,069 ahead while its horizon APR is still the higher of the two.

Worksheet steps (12)
  1. The rate, the APR and the In 5 Years rows each measure something different
  2. Two quotes on the same $350,000, built so that the rankings can part
  3. What the APR counts and what the five-year total counts
  4. How Appendix J turns a quote into an APR, one month at a time
  5. Checking the script against the regulation’s own numbers
  6. The same two quotes at 3, 5, 7 and 10 years and the full term
  7. Month 75, month 93 and month 108: three break-evens from one pair of quotes
  8. Page 3 of the Loan Estimate for these two quotes
  9. Pricing the rate cut: when a lower APR points the wrong way
  10. Tolerance, estimates and ties between close APRs
  11. Quotes that break the simple comparison
  12. Setting a stay against the window, not a point

The rate, the APR and the In 5 Years rows each measure something different

The interest rate fixes the interest charged on the balance each month and knows nothing about fees. On the two quotes below, the first month's interest is $2,005.21 at 6.875% and $2,114.58 at 7.25%, a gap of $109.37, and that gap barely moves for years because the balances stay close together. A rate comparison therefore ranks any pair of quotes with the same loan amount the same way for the whole life of the loan, whatever the closing costs are. That is its strength and its limit: it is a complete answer only when no fee is paid.

The APR is a rate that has absorbed the fees. Paragraph (a)(1) of 12 CFR 1026.22 describes it as a yearly rate that relates the amount and timing of the value the consumer receives to the amount and timing of the payments made, and requires it to be found by the actuarial method set out in Appendix J (or the older United States Rule method). The consumer's side of that relation is the amount financed, which for a Loan Estimate or Closing Disclosure loan is the loan amount after the upfront finance charge comes out. The Closing Disclosure labels it "The loan amount available after paying your upfront finance charge" (12 CFR 1026.38(o)(3)). Points and lender fees shrink that amount, the payments stay the same, and the rate that reconciles the two is higher than the note rate. The form prints it on page 3 as one of the Comparisons rows (12 CFR 1026.37(l)(2)), and how to read a refinance Loan Estimate covers how the form frames that row; the question here is how big the gap becomes when you leave the loan years before the term ends.

The In 5 Years rows are the only one of the three tied to a horizon. Section 1026.37(l)(1) requires two dollar amounts: a first, captioned "Total you will have paid in principal, interest, mortgage insurance, and loan costs", and a second, captioned "Principal you will have paid off". Both run through the end of the 60th month after the due date of the first periodic payment. The official commentary (comment 37(l)(1)(i)-1) tells the creditor to assume payments are made as scheduled and on time, defines mortgage insurance to include prepaid or escrowed premiums, and says loan costs are the costs disclosed under 1026.37(f), which are Sections A, B and C of the form. For a loan with fewer than 60 scheduled months, the amounts run to the end of the term. Subtract the second amount from the first and you have what the loan cost over five years: interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs, with your own principal taken out because paying principal is not a cost.

Which of the three belongs in the comparison depends on how the stay compares with the term. A borrower who expects to hold the loan close to payoff gets a fair summary from the full-term APR, as long as the two loans are close in size and term. A borrower who expects about five years can read the answer straight off the In 5 Years rows. A borrower whose exit sits at three, seven or ten years is on the one horizon the form does not print, and has to compute it. For the two quotes below, the dollar answer and the APR answer part company in the seventh year, and the sections that follow locate the month where each one changes its mind.

Two quotes on the same $350,000, built so that the rankings can part

Both quotes are for a $350,000 fixed-rate loan over 30 years with the first payment one full month after closing. Quote L pays two discount points, $7,000, plus $2,150 of other lender fees to get 6.875%. Quote H pays no points and $950 of lender fees at 7.25%. Sections B and C are identical on both, $3,200: an appraisal at $700, a credit report at $55, a flood determination at $25, title insurance at $1,850 and a settlement fee at $570. Making the third-party charges equal isolates what the lender controls. The Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey 30-year average was 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026, and the two rates are placed on either side of it for realism; they are inputs to the arithmetic, not offers, and nothing here ranks lenders.

Quote L's rate is 0.375 point lower and its payment is $88.37 a month smaller. It costs $8,200 more in loan costs: the $7,000 of points plus $1,200 more in other lender fees. Everything that follows is a consequence of those two numbers, the monthly saving and the cost of getting it, and how each measure weighs them against the length of the stay.

Two simplifications keep the algebra honest. The closing is assumed to leave exactly one full month before the first payment, so there is no prepaid interest and no odd first period. A real closing mid-month adds per-diem interest, which comment 17(c)(4)-4 treats as a prepaid finance charge that cannot be disregarded as an irregularity, and Appendix J then measures the first period in days divided by 30. And there is no mortgage insurance and no lender credit. Those features change the dollar figures on a real quote, not the method.

The two illustrative quotes. Loan $350,000, 30 years, fixed rate, first payment one full month after closing, no mortgage insurance, no prepaid interest. Rates are illustrations placed near the Freddie Mac average of 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026; they are not offers.
LineQuote L (pays for a lower rate)Quote H (no points)
Interest rate6.875%7.250%
Discount points (Section A)2.000 points, $7,000None
Other lender fees (Section A)$2,150$950
Section A total$9,150$950
Sections B and C (appraisal, credit report, flood check, title, settlement)$3,200$3,200
Total loan costs (Section D)$12,350$4,150
Amount financed for the APR (loan less Section A)$340,850$349,050
Principal and interest payment$2,299.25$2,387.62
Full-term APR (Appendix J)7.138%7.277%
Total Interest Percentage136.49%145.58%

The amount financed used for the APR is the loan less Section A only: $340,850 for Quote L and $349,050 for Quote H. Sections B and C stay out of it for a reason the next section sets out. The two amounts differ by $8,200, and that difference is itself a sign that the APRs are rates on unequal loans and not dollar costs on the same one.

What the APR counts and what the five-year total counts

The two measures draw their boundaries in different places, and the gap between the boundaries matters because a refinance carries many kinds of charge. The finance charge is defined in 12 CFR 1026.4 as the cost of consumer credit as a dollar amount, including any charge imposed directly or indirectly by the creditor as an incident to or a condition of the credit. Paragraph (b) lists what is in, paragraph (c) what is out, and several of the exclusions apply only if the fee is bona fide and reasonable in amount. The In 5 Years total instead lists its components: principal, interest, mortgage insurance and the loan costs in Sections A, B and C. Property taxes, homeowner's insurance, recording fees and transfer taxes are not among them.

Where common refinance charges land. Finance charge column: 12 CFR 1026.4 (eCFR text current as of October 30, 2026) and comment 2(a)(23) of the official interpretations. In 5 Years column: 12 CFR 1026.37(f), (g) and (l) and comment 37(l)(1)(i)-1.
ChargeIn the APR (a finance charge)?In the In 5 Years total?
Discount points, origination, underwriting and processing feesYes. Points and loan fees are listed in 1026.4(b)(3).Yes. Section A is a loan cost.
An application fee charged to every applicantNo. 1026.4(c)(1) excludes it.Yes, if it is itemized in Sections A to C.
Mortgage insurance premiumsYes. 1026.4(b)(5) covers insurance protecting the creditor against default.Yes, wherever it sits: prepaid, escrowed or inside the payment. The commentary says mortgage insurance includes prepaid or escrowed premiums.
Appraisal, credit report, flood and similar pre-closing checksNo, when bona fide and reasonable in amount. 1026.4(c)(7)(iii) and (iv).Yes. Sections B and C are loan costs.
Title search, title insurance, document preparation, settlement feeNo, when bona fide and reasonable in amount. 1026.4(c)(7)(i) and (ii).Yes. Sections B and C are loan costs.
Recording fees and taxes on the mortgage itselfMay be excluded if itemized and disclosed. 1026.4(e)(1) and (3).No. Section E (recording fees, other taxes and transfer taxes) is an other cost, not a listed component.
Prepaid (per-diem) interestYes. It is interest, and comment 17(c)(4)-4 treats per-diem interest as a prepaid finance charge.Not stated. It sits in Section F, outside the Section A to C loan costs, and the 37(l)(1)(i) commentary does not mention it. The Total Interest Percentage commentary does include it.
Escrow deposits for property taxes and homeowner’s insuranceNo. 1026.4(c)(7)(v) excludes amounts required to be paid into escrow if they would not otherwise be finance charges.No. Property taxes and homeowner’s insurance are not among the listed components.

Two consequences follow for these quotes. First, the $3,200 of appraisal, credit, flood, title and settlement charges is invisible to the APR and fully visible to the five-year total, so a quote that buries cost in those lines looks better on APR than on In 5 Years. Had they been counted as finance charges, the full-term APRs would be 7.232% and 7.370% instead of 7.138% and 7.277%: about 0.09 point higher on both, and the same order. Second, the exclusions are conditional. A title or appraisal charge that is not bona fide and reasonable can become a finance charge, so a lender's APR is only as comparable as its fee classification is consistent. Ask each lender to say which Section A charges it treated as finance charges, for example whether an application fee is charged to every applicant (excluded by 1026.4(c)(1)) or only to those who proceed.

Prepaid interest is less clear-cut. Per-diem interest is a finance charge and enters the APR. Whether it enters In 5 Years is not stated: it sits in Section F, outside the Section A to C loan costs, the commentary to 1026.37(l)(1)(i) does not mention it, and the commentary on the Total Interest Percentage says prepaid interest is included there. The two quotes here have none. Deposits to escrow for property taxes and homeowner's insurance are in neither measure, while escrowed mortgage insurance is counted by both. A lender credit is a third case: it is reported in Section J as a negative number alongside "D + I" (12 CFR 1026.37(g)(6)), outside the loan costs that In 5 Years names, so a quote with a credit and a quote with points should be brought to the same footing by hand before their five-year rows are compared. Lender credits explained covers what the credit costs in rate.

How Appendix J turns a quote into an APR, one month at a time

The regulation defines the actuarial method in words before any equation. At the end of each unit-period the unpaid balance of the amount financed is increased by the finance charge earned during that period and decreased by the payment made at the end of it (Appendix J, paragraph (a)(2)). The APR is the unit-period rate that carries the amount financed to zero on the last payment, multiplied by the number of unit-periods in a year (paragraph (b)(1)). For a loan paid monthly, the unit-period is the month, the most frequent common period (paragraph (b)(4)), and there are 12 unit-periods a year (paragraph (b)(5)(ii)). The rate can be found only by trial. Appendix J works the trial by hand on a $1,000 loan repaid by 36 payments of $33.61, starting from a guess of 12.50% and interpolating to 12.8256%, and 12 CFR 1026.22(b) lets a creditor use the Bureau's APR tables or any other tool that reproduces the Appendix J result within the permitted accuracy.

Quote H shows the mechanism. Its amount financed is $349,050 and its payment is $2,387.62. The monthly rate that makes 360 such payments exactly retire $349,050 is 0.60645%, which times 12 is 7.277%. The table rolls it forward: the finance charge earned in month 1 is the balance times that rate, the payment comes off, and the balance that is left becomes next month's starting point. After 360 payments the balance is zero to within a hundredth of a cent. A rate any lower leaves a balance owing; a rate any higher overpays it. That is the whole test.

Roll-forward of Quote H at its APR, following Appendix J paragraph (a)(2). Starting balance is the amount financed of $349,050; monthly rate is 0.60645%. Computed on this site.
MonthStarting balanceFinance charge earnedPaymentBalance after payment
1$349,050.00$2,116.80$2,387.62$348,779.18
2$348,779.18$2,115.16$2,387.62$348,506.73
3$348,506.73$2,113.51$2,387.62$348,232.62

Two refinements in the appendix matter only when a quote departs from the tidy case. If the first payment is more or less than one full month after the finance charge begins to be earned, the fraction of a unit-period is the number of days divided by 30 (paragraph (b)(5)(ii)), and the rate for that fraction is the fraction times the full-period rate (paragraph (b)(6)). And the appendix is written for any pattern of payments, not only level ones. That generality is what makes a stay-length APR possible. A borrower who leaves in month 60 pays 60 level payments and then the balance still owed, which is one more payment in the schedule. Run through the same method, that schedule gives an APR for the stay. Call it the horizon APR. The Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure do not print it, so it is a calculation made here with the regulation's method, not a regulated figure. Set the horizon at the full term and it returns the disclosed-style APR, which is the check in the last row of the horizon table below.

Checking the script against the regulation’s own numbers

An APR script is only useful if it matches the figures the regulation itself prints. Appendix J carries worked examples, five single-advance ones of which are reproduced here, and the official interpretations of Regulation Z (Supplement I to Part 1026) carry four more cases with payments, finance charges and APRs stated to the cent. The script was run on all nine cases before it was run on the two quotes, and it returns the printed result every time. The step-rate case in comment 22(a)(1)-4 states that the composite APR, found "using a calculator with a 'discounted cash flow analysis' or 'internal rate of return' function", is 10.75 percent; the three discounted-variable-rate cases in comment 17(c)(1)-10.v state APRs of 11.63, 11.53 and 11.64 percent along with the payment levels and the finance charge. For the two cases with stated rates (A and B), the script regenerates the payment levels and the finance charge from those rates; for the step-rate case and for case C it takes the stated payments as given.

The Appendix J actuarial calculation, as coded for these figures, run on the worked examples printed in Appendix J itself and in the official interpretations of Regulation Z (Supplement I to Part 1026). Stated figures are the regulation’s; computed figures are this script’s output.
Example and sourceStated in the regulationComputed here
Appendix J (b)(9): $1,000 repaid by 36 monthly payments of $33.61, worked by iteration from a first estimate of 12.50%APR 12.83% (the iteration reaches 12.82557529%)12.83% (12.8256%)
Appendix J (c)(1)(i): $5,000 repaid by 24 monthly payments of $230, regular first periodAPR 9.69%9.69%
Appendix J (c)(1)(ii): $6,000 repaid by 36 monthly payments of $200, long first period of 19 extra days (t = 1, f = 19/30)APR 11.82%11.82%
Appendix J (c)(1)(iii): $5,000 repaid by 24 semimonthly payments of $219.17, short first period of 6 days (t = 0, f = 6/15)APR 10.34%10.34%
Appendix J (c)(1)(iv): $10,000 repaid by 40 quarterly payments of $385, long first period (t = 1, f = 39/90)APR 8.97%8.97%
Comment 22(a)(1)-4: $10,000 repaid over 5 years by 24 payments of $210.71, 24 of $220.25 and 12 of $222.59 (rates of 10, 12 and 14 percent)Composite APR 10.75%10.75%
Comment 17(c)(1)-10.v.A: $100,000 over 30 years, 9% for one year then 12%, no prepaid finance chargeAPR 11.63%; 12 payments of $804.62, 348 of $1,025.31; finance charge $266,463.3211.63%; $804.62 and $1,025.31; $266,463.32
Comment 17(c)(1)-10.v.B: same loan with a 2-point rate cap (9%, 11%, then 12%)APR 11.53%; 12 of $804.62, 12 of $950.09, 336 of $1,024.34; finance charge $265,234.7611.53%; $804.62, $950.09, $1,024.34; $265,234.76
Comment 17(c)(1)-10.v.C: same loan with a 7.5% cap on payment adjustments, five payment levels statedAPR 11.64%; finance charge $277,040.6011.64%; $277,040.60 (from the five stated payment levels)

The agreement is to the printed precision in all nine cases. That settles the main risk in a home-built calculator, which is a quiet departure from the actuarial convention, such as a different unit-period or a different compounding rule. The Appendix J cases also exercise the fractional first period, long and short, monthly, semimonthly and quarterly, which the two quotes avoid by construction. For disclosure purposes the regulation tolerates an APR within 1/8 of one percentage point of the exact figure for a regular transaction (12 CFR 1026.22(a)(2)), so a lender's printed figure and this script's can differ by up to an eighth of a point without either being wrong.

The same two quotes at 3, 5, 7 and 10 years and the full term

Now the horizon. For each exit point, the cost is the interest paid through that month plus the $12,350 or $4,150 of loan costs, which is the In 5 Years definition stretched to other lengths. The horizon APR uses the same amount financed as before, the level payments up to the exit month, and the remaining balance as the final payment.

Quote L against Quote H on $350,000 over 30 years, re-run at five exit points. Cost is interest plus Sections A to C loan costs paid through the exit month. Horizon APR is the Appendix J actuarial APR with the balance still owed at exit treated as the final payment. Computed on this site; the quotes are illustrations.
StayCost, Quote LCost, Quote HCheaper by dollarsHorizon APR, LHorizon APR, HLower by horizon APR
3 years$83,404$79,161Quote H by $4,2437.87%7.35%Quote H
5 years$129,322$127,733Quote H by $1,5897.52%7.32%Quote H
7 years$173,878$174,947Quote L by $1,0697.37%7.30%Quote H
10 years$237,714$242,750Quote L by $5,0367.26%7.29%Quote L
Full 30-year term$490,080$513,692Quote L by $23,6127.14%7.28%Quote L

In dollars, Quote H is cheaper through year 3 by $4,243 and through year 5 by $1,589; Quote L is cheaper through year 7 by $1,069, through year 10 by $5,036 and over the full term by $23,612. The ranking flips between the fifth and seventh years, and the flip month computed below is 75, which is six years and three months.

The horizon APRs tell a related but different story. Quote L's APR climbs steeply as the stay shortens, from 7.14% over the term to 7.26% at ten years, 7.37% at seven, 7.52% at five and 7.87% at three, because its $9,150 of Section A charges are spread over fewer months. Quote H moves much less, from 7.28% to 7.35%, because it pays $950 up front. At ten years Quote L's horizon APR is ahead (7.26% against 7.29%); at seven years it is not (7.37% against 7.30%), though Quote L is $1,069 ahead in dollars. The two measures disagree in the seventh year, and that disagreement is the subject of the next section.

Month 75, month 93 and month 108: three break-evens from one pair of quotes

A break-even month answers "when has the extra up-front cost been earned back", and the answer depends on how earnings are counted. The simplest count divides the extra loan costs, $8,200, by the monthly payment saving of $88.37, which gives month 93. It is the simple count, and break-even, explained sets out why it and the interest count disagree. It undercounts what Quote L's lower rate delivers. Quote L's saving in interest is $109.37 in the first month, not $88.37, because the lower payment also includes $21.01 more principal: Quote L pays $294.04 of principal in month 1 against $273.03 for Quote H. That extra principal is equity kept, not cost. By month 60 Quote L owes $1,309 less than Quote H does ($329,017 against $330,326).

Counting interest only, the way the In 5 Years rows do once principal is subtracted, moves the break-even to month 75. The monthly interest saving stays near $111 through that stretch, so the $1,589 by which Quote H leads at month 60 closes in about 14.3 more months, which puts the flip in month 75: the same answer from the other direction. Both of those counts treat a dollar paid at closing as equal to a dollar of interest saved in year seven.

Discounting does not. If the $8,200 paid up front could otherwise have earned or saved money at the market rate, each month's saving is worth less than its face value, and the flip moves to month 108 at an assumed 7.24%. That is also the month where the two horizon APRs cross. The APR is a compounding rate, so it embeds a time-value assumption, and it prefers the loan that spends less cash early. The month-75 answer assumes the borrower puts no price on having that cash earlier; the month-108 answer assumes it is worth about the loan's own rate. Neither is a forecast, and the reader's own opportunity cost, which no quote shows, is what chooses between them.

Four ways to ask when Quote L (6.875%, 2 points) overtakes Quote H (7.25%, no points). Computed on this site; the discount rate in the third row is the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026, used as an assumption.
TestWhat it adds upQuote L first ahead in month
Payment gapExtra loan costs of $8,200 divided by the $88.37 monthly payment saving93
Dollars through exit (the In 5 Years basis)Interest plus Sections A to C, counted in the month paid75
Dollars discounted at 7.24%The same cash flows, each month’s amount divided by (1 + 0.0724/12) raised to that month, with the exit balance included108
Horizon APRThe month where the two horizon APRs cross108

For stays shorter than 75 months, every count in the table favours Quote H. For stays of 75 months or more but fewer than 108, the dollars-through-exit count favours Quote L, the payment-gap count joins it only from month 93, and the horizon APR still favours Quote H. From month 108, everything favours Quote L. That 33-month window, from year 6 and 3 months to year 9, is the range of stays where the choice of measure changes the answer, and it is wide enough to matter, since a seven-year stay sits inside it.

Page 3 of the Loan Estimate for these two quotes

If both quotes arrived as Loan Estimates, the Comparisons table on page 3 would carry the rows below. The two In 5 Years amounts are the definitions in 1026.37(l)(1) applied to 60 scheduled payments, the APR is the full-term figure and the Total Interest Percentage is total interest over the loan amount.

The page-3 Comparisons rows for the two quotes, computed from the definition in 12 CFR 1026.37(l) with 60 scheduled payments. The APR and Total Interest Percentage rows are the full-term figures. Computed on this site.
Comparisons rowQuote LQuote H
In 5 Years: Total you will have paid in principal, interest, mortgage insurance, and loan costs$150,305$147,407
In 5 Years: Principal you will have paid off$20,983$19,674
Total minus principal (the cost of the loan over five years)$129,322$127,733
Annual Percentage Rate7.14%7.28%
Total Interest Percentage136.49%145.58%

The form gives the five-year gap directly: Quote L's total is $2,898 higher, its principal is $1,309 higher, so its five-year cost is $1,589 higher. The APR row says the opposite (7.14% against 7.28%) and so does the Total Interest Percentage (136.49% against 145.58%). Those two rows are lifetime measures, and a borrower who stops at the first number that looks decisive will pick the wrong loan for a five-year stay. They are not wrong; they answer a question about year 30.

The form stops at year 5, which is the limit of what can be learned from it alone. To find the flip month from two forms, take the gap at five years and divide it by the monthly interest saving, which is the difference between the two loans' interest in a typical month and is close to the first-month figure. Here that is $1,589 divided by about $111, roughly 14.3 months past month 60, so the flip lands in month 75. For any other horizon h, the cost is loan costs plus h payments minus the principal paid, and the balance after h payments is the loan amount times (1+r)^h minus the payment times ((1+r)^h - 1)/r, where r is the rate divided by 12. A payoff table from the servicer shows the same balance without the algebra. One caution on counting: the regulation measures from the due date of the first periodic payment to the end of the 60th month after it, and the count here is 60 payments, so a lender's printed figure may differ by about one payment ($2,299 for Quote L).

Five years on $350,000: the Loan Estimate rows, the APR and the flip month for the same two quotes

Inputs: a $350,000 balance on a new 30-year fixed loan, a stay horizon of 5 years (60 payments), closing costs of $12,350 for Quote L (6.875%, 2 points) and $4,150 for Quote H (7.25%, no points), the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.24% for the week of October 29, 2026 as context only. Result: the payments are $2,299.25 and $2,387.62. Through month 60, Quote L's In 5 Years total is $150,305 with $20,983 of principal, so its five-year cost is $129,322; Quote H's total is $147,407 with $19,674 of principal, a five-year cost of $127,733. Quote H is cheaper by $1,589 even though Quote L has the lower rate (6.875% against 7.25%) and the lower full-term APR (7.14% against 7.28%). The horizon APRs at five years are 7.52% and 7.32%, which agree on Quote H. At seven years the dollars favour Quote L by $1,069 while the horizon APR still favours Quote H (7.30% against 7.37%), and the flips fall at months 75 (dollars) and 108 (horizon APR and dollars discounted at 7.24%). The principal and interest figures leave out taxes, insurance and escrow, which are owed on either loan.

Pricing the rate cut: when a lower APR points the wrong way

The 6.875% rate cost two points in the base case. Lenders price the same rate cut at different numbers of points, and the price changes every figure above. The table holds Quote H and the other charges fixed and re-prices only the points on the 6.875% quote.

The 6.875% quote re-priced at different point charges against Quote H (7.25%, $950 of lender fees). Other lender fees ($2,150) and Sections B and C ($3,200) are unchanged. Computed on this site.
Points on the 6.875% quoteSection A totalFull-term APRFull-term APR ranks the 6.875% quoteDollars flip in monthHorizon-APR flip in month
1.0$5,6507.036%Lower (better)4352
1.5$7,4007.086%Lower (better)5977
2.0$9,1507.138%Lower (better)75108
2.5$10,9007.189%Lower (better)91149
3.0$12,6507.241%Lower (better)107214
3.5$14,4007.293%Higher (worse)122None in 30 years
4.0$16,1507.346%Higher (worse)139None in 30 years

Each extra half point on the 6.875% quote ($1,750) pushes the dollar flip back by 15 to 17 months, from month 43 at one point to month 139 at four. The horizon-APR flip moves faster, from month 52 to month 214 at three points, because its time-value penalty grows with the up-front amount. At 3.0 points, the full-term APR of 7.241% still ranks the 6.875% quote ahead of Quote H's 7.277%, yet the dollars do not catch up until month 107, almost nine years in. A borrower who read only the full-term APR would see a clear winner and a nine-year break-even hidden behind it.

At 3.5 points the full-term APR itself turns: 7.293% for the 6.875% quote against 7.277% for Quote H, so the APR now ranks Quote H as cheaper, although the 6.875% loan has the lower rate and costs $18,362 less over the 30 years in undiscounted dollars. The crossover sits at about 3.35 points ($11,718 on this loan). This is the same discounting at work, now over the whole term: the points are paid on day one, the savings arrive over three decades, and the APR values day-one cash at the loan's own rate. The point is not that the APR is wrong but that it is a different question from "which loan costs less money", and the answer to the second question for a five-year stay is the In 5 Years subtraction. The discount points break-even guide prices the same trade from the other end, starting from the points.

Tolerance, estimates and ties between close APRs

A printed APR is not exact. The regulation treats a disclosed APR as accurate if it is within 1/8 of one percentage point above or below the figure determined under Appendix J (1026.22(a)(2)), and for a mortgage it adds a second route: an APR that results from a finance charge disclosed within its own tolerance is also accurate (1026.22(a)(4)). On a Closing Disclosure, the finance charge itself is treated as accurate if it is understated by no more than $100 or is greater than the amount required to be disclosed (1026.38(o)(2)). A $100 understatement of Quote H's finance charge moves its APR by about 0.0029 point, so the dollar tolerance alone barely matters. The 1/8-point tolerance does: the two full-term APRs here differ by 0.14 point, only a little more than that tolerance, so two printed APRs that close could in principle sit in either order.

A Loan Estimate is also an estimate. Fees can change within the limits that Loan Estimate tolerance rules lays out, a lock can expire, and the Closing Disclosure that arrives before signing carries the final figures, as the Closing Disclosure walk-through explains. Re-run the horizon comparison on the Closing Disclosure figures when they arrive; the method does not change, and a difference of a few hundred dollars in Section A can move the flip month by several months.

Quotes that break the simple comparison

Everything above compares two 30-year loans of the same amount. Three common departures need extra care. A quote with a different term, such as a 15-year loan against a 30-year loan, produces payments and a total interest figure that mostly reflect the term, and the APR then compares rates on very different schedules; the restart effect is handled in the shorter-term reset cost. A quote with a different loan amount, such as a cash-out against a rate-and-term, changes the denominator of the TIP and the amount financed, so the APR gap and the dollar gap need not match. And a quote with a lender credit has costs that live partly in the rate, where an APR sees them, and partly in a negative number in Section J, where In 5 Years does not.

In each case the safe move is the same: put both quotes on a common cash basis, with the same amount borrowed and the same stay, and then compare the dollars through the exit month. The APR and the TIP remain useful as screens and tie-breakers, as the guide on reading the Loan Estimate says, but they are measured to a horizon that is the end of the loan, and many stays end well before that.

Setting a stay against the window, not a point

A stay is an estimate, so a single flip month is less useful than the window around it. For these two quotes the picture is short. Under 75 months, Quote H wins on dollars and on horizon APR. From 75 months, Quote L wins on dollars. From 108 months, it wins on horizon APR too. The In 5 Years rows put Quote H ahead by $1,589 at month 60, which is a lead that disappears in about 14 months, so a borrower who might stay slightly past five years has reason to compute rather than rely on the form.

A different quote pair moves the window but not its structure. The flip month is the extra up-front cost divided by the monthly interest saving, with a time-value adjustment for the horizon APR. More points for the same rate, or a smaller rate cut for the same points, push the window out. Points scale with the loan amount and fixed-dollar fees do not, so when the lower-rate quote carries more fixed-dollar fees, as Quote L does by $1,200, the same rate cut flips later on a smaller loan. To test a pair of your own, enter the rates, points and fees into the CalculatorVillage points and amortization calculators, then read the cost through your own exit month as above.

What to line up before choosing between two quotes for a known stay

  • The Loan Estimate for each quote, with the rate, the points line in Section A and the Section D total written side by side.
  • The two In 5 Years amounts from page 3 for each quote, and the difference between them, which is the five-year cost.
  • The monthly principal and interest payment on each quote, and the balance after 36, 60, 84 and 120 payments from a payoff table or the formula in the Loan Estimate section above.
  • A written statement from each lender of which Section A charges it counted as finance charges when it computed the APR, including how it treated any application fee.
  • The stay you expect, as a range in years, and the flip months for the pair under the three tests: payment gap, dollars through exit, and horizon APR.
  • Whether either quote contains a lender credit, a prepayment penalty or mortgage insurance, none of which the two quotes above include, and what each does to the dollars through your exit month.
  • A note of the Freddie Mac average and its release date next to any rate you use as context, so the comparison can be re-run when the Closing Disclosure arrives.

Questions about APR, interest rate and a short stay

Should I compare the APR or the interest rate if I will keep the loan about five years?

Neither decides it. The interest rate ignores fees, and the APR spreads them over the whole term. For a five-year stay, subtract the "Principal you will have paid off" amount from the "Total you will have paid" amount in the In 5 Years rows and compare the results. On the two quotes here, the lower rate and the lower APR belong to the loan that costs $1,589 more through year five.

Why does the loan with the lower APR cost more over five years?

The APR assumes the loan runs 30 years, so a $9,150 Section A charge is spread over 360 payments. A borrower who leaves after 60 payments has paid the whole fee and collected 60 of the 360 months of rate saving. On Quote L, the APR over a five-year stay is 7.52%, against 7.14% over the term.

Does the APR include appraisal, credit report and title fees?

Not when they are bona fide and reasonable in amount: 12 CFR 1026.4(c)(7) excludes title, document preparation, notary, credit report and appraisal fees from the finance charge. The In 5 Years total includes them, because Sections B and C are loan costs. Points, loan fees and mortgage insurance premiums are in both.

What does the In 5 Years row leave out?

It counts principal, interest, mortgage insurance (prepaid, escrowed or in the payment) and the loan costs in Sections A to C through the 60th month. Property taxes, homeowner's insurance, recording fees and transfer taxes are not among its components, the commentary does not say whether prepaid interest counts, and a lender credit appears in Section J, not in the loan costs. It is not adjusted for what your cash could otherwise earn.

How do I get the cost at 3 or 7 years when the form only shows 5?

Add the loan costs to the payments made through that month and subtract the principal paid. The principal paid is the loan amount minus the balance after that many payments, which a servicer payoff table or the amortization formula gives. For Quote L, the cost through 84 months is $173,878 and for Quote H $174,947.

Can a lender’s printed APR be off by a meaningful amount?

Within limits, yes. For a regular transaction, 12 CFR 1026.22(a)(2) treats an APR as accurate if it is within 1/8 of one percentage point of the exact figure, and mortgages get an additional route tied to the finance charge tolerance. Two APRs less than about a quarter point apart should not decide the choice on their own.

To test your own pair, put the rates, points and fees into CalculatorVillage's mortgage points calculator and its amortization calculator for the balance at your exit month, then subtract as above. The closing costs hub lists the guides on each fee line that feeds the comparison.

Sources and verification

The two quotes are illustrations: the rates, points and fees were chosen so that the rankings part inside an ordinary stay, and they are not offers or a ranking of lenders. Every dollar figure, APR and flip month is computed on this site from the inputs beside each table, using a monthly-period implementation of the Appendix J actuarial method with a regular first period, and rounded for display. The horizon APR is a calculation made here with the regulation's method and is not a figure any lender discloses. The 7.24% used to discount the cash flows is the Freddie Mac 30-year average for the week of October 29, 2026, an assumption for the arithmetic and not a forecast of what a borrower's cash would earn. The script reproduces five of the single-advance examples in Appendix J (paragraphs (b)(9) and (c)(1)(i) to (iv), printed as images in the Code of Federal Regulations, and taken from the govinfo 2025 edition) and the numeric examples in the official interpretations (comments 22(a)(1)-4 and 17(c)(1)-10.v). The two quotes use only the regular first period. The page does not cover odd first periods in the quotes, multiple-advance transactions, adjustable-rate or step-rate loans, mortgage insurance, prepayment penalties, lender credits, loans of different amount or term, or the tax treatment of points, and it does not model the exact count of payments in the In 5 Years definition beyond 60 payments. Educational only, not a loan offer, tax or legal advice.