Fees rose after your Loan Estimate: which increases are allowed and how the refund works
When a refinance charge ends up higher than the Loan Estimate allows, Regulation Z gives the lender a way out: refund the excess to you no later than 60 days after closing and send a corrected Closing Disclosure (12 CFR 1026.19(f)(2)(v)). What counts as an excess depends on a fee's bucket. Lender fees and transfer taxes cannot rise, fees you shop for from the lender's list can rise 10 percent as a group, and a few items can move freely, which is why the refund can be $288 even when one line is up 33 percent.
Worksheet steps (11)
- The legal test is one sentence: what you paid cannot exceed what was disclosed
- Sort every charge into one of three buckets before comparing any numbers
- Four edge cases that decide which bucket a charge is in
- A $300,000 refinance with $288 over its limits
- Where the $288 comes from, and why $263 of the increase is legitimate
- The refund: 60 days, a corrected Closing Disclosure, and what the lender may not do
- A revised Loan Estimate moves the baseline, but only for the reason it states
- What a changed circumstance is not, with the Bureau's own limits
- The calendar: when a revised Loan Estimate counts and when it is too late
- Putting the request in writing, and who else can act
- What the $288 does to your break-even month
The legal test is one sentence: what you paid cannot exceed what was disclosed
Regulation Z, section 1026.19(e)(3)(i), says an estimated closing cost is in good faith "if the charge paid by or imposed on the consumer does not exceed the amount originally disclosed." Everything else in the tolerance rules is an exception to that sentence, or a way of resetting what "originally disclosed" means. The rule covers closed-end loans secured by real property, which includes a refinance of a mortgage. It does not cover a home equity line of credit, which is open-end credit and has its own disclosure rule in section 1026.40.
Two phrases carry the weight. The first is "paid by or imposed on". The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's official interpretation (comment 19(e)(3)(i)-2) treats the final amount at consummation or settlement, whichever is later, as the charge. Its example has a borrower pay $100 for recording at the table, with actual recording fees of $70 discovered five days later and $30 refunded; the recording fee paid is $70. So a fee corrected downward before or after closing is no violation. The second phrase is "originally disclosed". The baseline can be reset by a revised Loan Estimate, but only for reasons the rule lists, and only for the charge the reason actually affected.
This page is about those two moves: sorting each charge into its bucket, and knowing when a baseline has legitimately moved. Our guide to the Closing Disclosure on a refinance reads the form itself, and our guide to third-party fees prices each service. Here the subject is the remedy. It sits in our closing costs section beside the fee-by-fee guides.
Sort every charge into one of three buckets before comparing any numbers
Comparing a Closing Disclosure with a Loan Estimate line by line misleads in both directions. A 13 percent rise on one title insurance and settlement line may be fine, and a $20 rise on a lender fee may not be. The comparison that matters is within a bucket. The table assigns the charges a refinance borrower most often sees, using the regulation and the interpretations the Bureau published.
| Bucket and limit | Charges in it | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Zero tolerance: no increase | Fees paid to the lender; fees paid to a mortgage broker; fees paid to an affiliate of the lender or broker; transfer taxes; unaffiliated third-party fees for a service the lender did not let you shop for (commonly the appraisal); the amount of lender credits | Who is paid, and whether you were allowed to pick the provider. Comment 19(e)(3)(i)-1 lists these categories |
| 10 percent in the aggregate | Third-party services you were allowed to shop for and did not, or chose from the lender's written list (often title search, lender's title policy, settlement agent); recording fees | Provider is not the lender or an affiliate, and the lender let you shop. The sum of the group may not exceed the sum of the group's estimates by more than 10 percent |
| No limit, if the estimate was made in good faith | Prepaid interest; property insurance premiums; amounts placed in escrow; services you shopped for and chose outside the lender's list; property taxes and services the lender did not require | The estimate must have used "the best information reasonably available" when it was made. Charges must be bona fide: lawful and for services actually performed |
Four edge cases that decide which bucket a charge is in
Most of the disputes that matter happen at the edges, so these are worth knowing as separate cases.
An affiliate moves a fee up. A title or settlement fee is a 10 percent item only if the provider is not the lender or an affiliate. If the loan officer sends the file to a settlement company owned by the same parent, section 1026.19(e)(3)(ii)(B) removes it from the 10 percent group, and comment 19(e)(3)(ii)-6 puts it back in the zero bucket. The Loan Estimate does not label a provider as an affiliate, so if a title or settlement fee is paid to a company you have never heard of, ask the lender in writing whether it is an affiliate.
A missing list keeps a fee in the 10 percent group. If the lender lets you shop but does not give the written list of providers required by section 1026.19(e)(1)(vi)(C), comment 19(e)(3)(iii)-2 sends the fee to the 10 percent test, not the no-limit bucket, unless the provider is the lender or an affiliate. A lender that skipped the list cannot treat your own pick as unlimited.
Choosing your own provider moves a fee out of the comparison. When the lender permits shopping, provides the list, and you choose a provider that is not on it, the actual amount "need not be compared to the original estimates." The protection is conditional, however. If the estimate was unreasonably low when made, the comment's example is a $20 settlement agent estimate where local prices average $150, then good faith is tested under the zero bucket. The estimate has to be honest to move a fee out of the test.
A no-limit item stays free only if its estimate was honest. Property taxes are the clearest case. Comment 19(e)(3)(iii)-3 says that if a lender omits a property tax charge or includes an unreasonably low estimate, the charge "would be subject to the good faith determination under 1026.19(e)(3)(i)," which is the zero bucket. Comment 19(e)(3)(iii)-1 applies the same best-information test to the other free-moving items: a lender that requires homeowner's insurance and leaves the premium off the estimate has not complied, and neither has one that knows the loan must close on the 15th and estimates prepaid interest from the 30th.
Lender credits belong in the same zero-tolerance test, from the other side. The official commentary to 12 CFR 1026.19(e)(3)(i) treats a credit that shrinks between the Loan Estimate and closing as a charge that grew, which matters most on a no-closing-cost refinance, where the credit is doing all the work.
A $300,000 refinance with $288 over its limits
The numbers are an illustration, not a quote from any lender: a $300,000, 30-year refinance, a Loan Estimate whose costs from Sections A to E, net of a $900 lender credit, total $5,199, a monthly payment saving of $180, and a seven-year stay horizon. At closing the borrower receives a Closing Disclosure without any revised Loan Estimate in between. Every line below was compared to the figure in the bucket it belongs to, using unrounded dollars, as the interpretation (comment 19(e)(3)(i)-7) requires.
| Charge | Bucket | Loan Estimate | Closing Disclosure | Allowed | Over the limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Origination charge | Zero | $1,800 | $1,800 | $1,800 | $0 |
| Underwriting fee | Zero | $995 | $995 | $995 | $0 |
| Appraisal, lender-ordered | Zero | $600 | $750 | $600 | $150 |
| Credit report | Zero | $60 | $60 | $60 | $0 |
| Flood certification | Zero | $14 | $14 | $14 | $0 |
| Lender credit | Zero | $900 credit | $800 credit | $900 credit | $100 |
| Settlement agent (lender's list) | 10% group | $650 | $700 | group total | see below |
| Lender's title policy (lender's list) | 10% group | $1,450 | $1,640 | group total | see below |
| Title search (lender's list) | 10% group | $350 | $350 | group total | see below |
| Recording fee | 10% group | $180 | $241 | group total | see below |
| 10% group total | 10% group | $2,630 | $2,931 | $2,893 | $38 |
Where the $288 comes from, and why $263 of the increase is legitimate
The zero bucket supplies $250: the appraisal is $150 over, and the lender credit is $100 short. A smaller credit is an increase in your charges (see lender credits). The official interpretation (comment 19(e)(3)(i)-5) gives the identical case, a $750 credit disclosed and $500 delivered, as a violation of the good-faith rule, and adds the mirror case. A credit disclosed to cover a $750 appraisal fee that rises by $150 may rise by $150 in step, because the borrower's cost did not change. A credit that falls $50 because the fee fell $50 is a violation, because the borrower's cost rose.
The 10 percent group supplies the other $38. The four estimates total $2,630, so the allowed ceiling is $2,630 times 1.10, which is $2,893. The actual group is $2,931, so the excess is $38. The title policy rose 13.1 percent by itself, the recording fee 33.9 percent and the settlement agent 7.7 percent, and none of that percentage matters. Comment 19(e)(3)(ii)-2 says good faith "depends on whether the sum of all charges subject to" the 10 percent test "increases by more than 10 percent, regardless of whether a particular charge increases by more than 10 percent." The comment's own example has a $300 settlement agent fee that may exceed $330 as long as the group of $1,000 stays under $1,100.
Add $250 and $38 and the lender owes $288. The remaining $263 of difference is the group's allowed drift. It is a real cost that the rule permits, which matters in your own break-even. Two features of the group deserve noting. A fee omitted from the estimate and then charged still counts toward the same group total (the comment's example is a $10 notary fee), and a service that was estimated but never performed comes out of the estimated total. The comment's example is a $100 pest inspection not obtained, which lowers the estimated base for the 10 percent test.
For comparison, the Bureau's own worked example for refunds has four zero-tolerance charges over by $30, $25, $25 and $15, a total of $95, and a 10 percent group of $1,190 against $1,000 estimated, $90 over the $1,100 ceiling, so the refund is $185. The arithmetic is the same shape as ours: the zero bucket is summed by excess, the 10 percent group is tested once, and the two are added.
The refund: 60 days, a corrected Closing Disclosure, and what the lender may not do
Section 1026.19(f)(2)(v) is the cure. If amounts paid exceed the tolerance, "the creditor complies with paragraph (e)(1)(i) of this section if the creditor refunds the excess to the consumer no later than 60 days after consummation," and complies with the final disclosure requirement "if the creditor delivers or places in the mail corrected disclosures that reflect such refund no later than 60 days after consummation." Two parts, one deadline. A refund without the corrected Closing Disclosure is incomplete, and the form is the document that shows your records what happened.
For a signing on Tuesday, December 8, 2026, day 60 falls on Saturday, February 6, 2027. The regulation does not extend a deadline that lands on a weekend, so treat Friday, February 5 as the last practical day to have a check or credit in hand, and write to the lender well before it.
The timing is also a reason to ask earlier. The cure is the lender's safe harbor, not your only moment. The text of the rule speaks of the charge "paid by or imposed on" you, and the comment pegs it at the end of consummation or settlement, so a lender that lowers a fee or raises a credit at the table has no excess to refund. Asking before you sign works the same arithmetic, and it avoids waiting for a refund that depends on the lender noticing.
A revised Loan Estimate moves the baseline, but only for the reason it states
A lender who wants to charge more than the original estimate must issue a revised Loan Estimate for a reason listed in section 1026.19(e)(3)(iv). The table lists the six reasons with the cases the Bureau's interpretations use and the limits they set. Reason (F) applies only to new construction and has no refinance use.
| Reason | What the rule says | Example from the official interpretation | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| (A) Changed circumstance | An extraordinary event beyond anyone's control; information the lender relied on that was inaccurate or changed; or new information specific to you or the loan the lender did not rely on | Appraiser finds the house sits on a farm and a different fee schedule applies, so a $200 estimate becomes $400. A title insurer closes during underwriting. Income stated as $90,000 verifies at $80,000 | The estimate may rise only to the extent the reason raised that charge |
| (B) Eligibility | A changed circumstance affecting creditworthiness or property value makes you ineligible for a charge or program | A program that needed no appraisal no longer applies after a past mortgage delinquency surfaces, so an appraisal is added | Unrelated increases, such as title fees, stay compared with the original |
| (C) Your request | You ask for a change in credit terms or the settlement that raises an estimated charge | A power of attorney for someone else to sign adds a recording fee | Only the cost of what you asked for |
| (D) Rate not locked | Points or lender credits change because the rate was not locked when the Loan Estimate was issued | Rate locked after the estimate; revised estimate due within three business days of the lock | Covers interest-rate-dependent charges only |
| (E) Expiration | You indicate intent to proceed more than 10 business days after the Loan Estimate was delivered, or after a longer period the lender stated | A $500 underwriting fee on a Monday Loan Estimate becomes $700 when you say yes 11 business days later | No reason for the change is needed beyond the lapse |
| (F) New construction delay | Settlement expected more than 60 days out on new construction | Not applicable to a refinance | Not applicable |
What a changed circumstance is not, with the Bureau's own limits
The farm example needs the full sequence to work. The lender estimated a $200 appraisal on information the borrower supplied, the appraiser found a single-family dwelling on a farm, a different fee schedule applies, and the lender issues revised disclosures. The final $400 appraisal is then compared with the revised $400, not the original $200. Without a revised Loan Estimate, the comparison stays at $200, so the lender absorbs the $200 difference.
A change that is real can still fail the 10 percent test. The Bureau's example has a $400 title estimate and a newly found unreleased lien that raises the cost to $500. The extra work raises the group by only 5 percent, so the changed circumstance did not push the group over 10 percent. A revised Loan Estimate may still be issued, but at closing the actual title fees of $500 are compared with the original $400 because the change did not cause the group to exceed the limit. A small surprise stays inside the original baseline.
The lender cannot claim as a changed circumstance something it was presumed to know. Under comment 19(e)(3)(iv)(A)-3, a lender is presumed to have collected the six application items before it issues the estimate (the list is in our credit inquiry guide). Information the lender should already have held, such as the property address, cannot later be called new.
One limit applies in every row: a revision counts only "to the extent that the reason for revision... actually increased the particular charge." Comment 19(e)(3)(iv)-2 uses a rate lock extension requested by the consumer. The revised estimate may add the extension fee, which cannot exceed what the lender normally charges, and "the creditor may not rely on changes to other charges unrelated to the rate lock extension." A revised estimate full of other increases is therefore a revision for one reason and a bare estimate for the rest. Our guide to rate lock fees and extensions prices that extension.
Documentation backs the rule. The lender must keep evidence of compliance with section 1026.19(e) and (f) for three years after the later of consummation or the date an action was required (12 CFR 1026.25(c)(1)(i)), and each completed Closing Disclosure and its related documents for five years after consummation (1026.25(c)(1)(ii)(A)). Comment 19(e)(3)(iv)-3 spells out what a changed-circumstance file must show: the original estimate, the reason for revision and how it affected the cost, that the revised estimate increased only to the extent of the cause, and that the timing rule was met.
The calendar: when a revised Loan Estimate counts and when it is too late
Three clocks apply, and two of them count business days differently from the ordinary meaning. For the revised-disclosure deadlines in section 1026.19(e)(4)(ii) and the final-disclosure waiting period in section 1026.19(f)(1)(ii), section 1026.2(a)(6) defines a business day as every calendar day except Sundays and the federal legal public holidays. Saturdays count. The three-business-day deadline to issue a revision after the lender learns of a change, and the 10-business-day expiration in reason (E), use the other definition in the same section, a day on which the lender's offices are open for substantially all of their business. Ask what the lender's business days are before relying on a count.
| Event | Deadline or effect | Latest date for the Dec 8 closing |
|---|---|---|
| Revised Loan Estimate received by you | Not later than four business days before consummation (1026.19(e)(4)(ii)) | In person by Thursday, December 3 |
| Revised Loan Estimate mailed or emailed | Treated as received three business days after it is sent | Sent by Monday, November 30 to be treated as received on December 3 |
| First Closing Disclosure issued | No revised Loan Estimate may be issued on or after the day the Closing Disclosure is provided | Any revision after the issue date must come as a corrected Closing Disclosure |
| Closing Disclosure received | At least three business days ahead of the signing (1026.19(f)(1)(ii)(A)) | In person by Friday, December 4; sent by Tuesday, December 1 if mailed or emailed |
| Closing Disclosure becomes inaccurate in APR, product or by adding a prepayment penalty | A corrected form and a new three-business-day wait (1026.19(f)(2)(ii)) | A new date at least three business days after receipt |
| Other changes before closing | Corrected form at or before consummation, with no new wait (1026.19(f)(2)(i)) | At the table, December 8 |
| Excess refund and corrected Closing Disclosure | Within 60 days of consummation (1026.19(f)(2)(v)) | Saturday, February 6, 2027 |
Putting the request in writing, and who else can act
The most useful message is short and names the numbers. Say which charge or group you believe is over its limit, give the Loan Estimate figure and the Closing Disclosure figure, and ask whether a revised Loan Estimate was issued and for what reason under section 1026.19(e)(3)(iv). If one was, ask for its date; a revision that arrived inside the four-business-day window is the one the rule treats as valid. If none was, ask for the refund, or for the fee to be lowered at closing, and for a corrected Closing Disclosure. The lender must be able to produce its file under the retention rule above.
If the answer does not arrive, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau accepts mortgage complaints at consumerfinance.gov/complaint. The page says most companies respond within 15 days, and some cases take up to 60. A written request first is worth more than a complaint alone because it fixes the date you raised the issue relative to the 60-day refund deadline.
Do not read a cure as a reason to sign a Closing Disclosure you disagree with. The 60-day refund protects the lender who made an error from a violation, and it protects you only if someone sends it. If the numbers are wrong on December 4, say so on December 4.
What the $288 does to your break-even month
Return to the $300,000 example and its $180 monthly saving. On the Loan Estimate the net cost from Sections A to E was $5,199, which breaks even in 28.9 months. The Closing Disclosure's net cost is $5,750 because every line moved: $551 higher. Without a cure the break-even slides to 31.9 months, three months later. With the $288 cure applied, the cost is $5,462 and the break-even is 30.3 months. The slip is measured the way our break-even guide measures it, as costs divided by the monthly saving. The remaining 1.4-month slip is the $263 of drift the 10 percent group is allowed to carry.
That is the practical lesson of tolerance rules for a refinancer. They cap the surprises on the lines you could not control, and they leave a drift allowance on the lines you could shop. If a quote's break-even only works with no drift at all, it did not clear the stay horizon with room to spare. Re-run the cost you were quoted, plus ten percent of the third-party group, in the calculator before you commit to the lock.
Common questions
Can the lender charge me a fee for preparing the Closing Disclosure?
No. Section 1026.19(f)(5) says no fee may be imposed on any person, as part of settlement costs or otherwise, by a creditor or servicer for the preparation or delivery of the Closing Disclosure. A line that looks like a document-delivery or disclosure charge belongs in the written request.
May a settlement service be billed at more than the provider actually received?
Generally not. Section 1026.19(f)(3)(i) says the amount imposed for a settlement service shall not exceed the amount the provider actually received for it. The exception is average-charge pricing under (f)(3)(ii), which needs a class of similar transactions defined by period, area and loan type, one average used for every transaction in the class, and never applies to insurance or to charges based on loan amount or property value.
What if a mortgage broker handled my refinance?
Fees paid to the broker, or to an affiliate of the broker, are in the zero bucket under comment 19(e)(3)(i)-1, the same as the lender's own fees. A broker may deliver the Loan Estimate, but section 1026.19(e)(1)(ii) makes the creditor responsible for the disclosures, so the refund obligation stays with the lender.
What must the lender's written list of providers contain?
At least one available provider for each service you may shop for, plus a statement that you may choose a different one. Comment 19(e)(1)(vi)-4 says it must give enough information to contact the provider, such as the business name, address and telephone number. A model form, H-27, is deemed compliant. A list without contact details is a reason to ask for a corrected one before you rely on it.
Can the lender raise fees if I wait too long to say I want to proceed?
Yes, for any charge, and without giving a reason beyond the lapse. Under reason (E) the window is 10 business days from delivery of the Loan Estimate. Comment 19(e)(3)(iv)(E)-2 adds that if the lender communicates a longer period, even orally, that longer period governs. Telling the lender you intend to proceed within the window keeps the original baseline.
Sources and verification
- eCFR, 12 CFR 1026.19, Certain mortgage and variable-rate transactions: Paragraphs (e)(1)(vi), (e)(3), (e)(4), (f)(1), (f)(2)(ii) and (v); read from the versioner text for October 20, 2026. Checked October 23, 2026.
- eCFR, Supplement I to Part 1026, Official Interpretations (comments 19(e)(3) and 19(f)(2)(v)): Comments on zero tolerance, the 10 percent aggregate, best information, changed circumstance examples and the refund example. Checked October 23, 2026.
- eCFR, 12 CFR 1026.2(a)(6) and 1026.25(c): Business-day definitions and the three-year and five-year record retention periods for the disclosures. Checked October 23, 2026.
- CFPB, Submit a complaint: Mortgages accepted; most companies respond within 15 days and some take up to 60. Checked October 23, 2026.
The $300,000 loan, the line amounts, the $180 monthly saving and the December 8, 2026 closing are invented for arithmetic and are not data about any lender. Business-day counts assume no federal holiday between November 30 and December 8 and the Sunday-and-holiday definition for the revised-disclosure and final-disclosure deadlines. State law, loan-type rules (FHA, VA) and the lender's own policies can add protections and were not reviewed. This is not legal advice; for a dispute, consult a housing counselor or attorney.