Decision guides

Does shopping for a refinance hurt your credit? The inquiry window, and what a few points cost

Shopping several lenders for the same refinance costs you one small hit, not several: FICO and the CFPB say mortgage inquiries inside a shopping window count as one, and the window is 14 days for older FICO versions and VantageScore 4.0, 45 days for the newest FICO versions. Keep every application inside two weeks and you are inside the shortest figure any of them gives. For most people one inquiry takes less than five points off, and that costs money only if your score sits just above a Fannie Mae price line, where crossing it adds $750 to $1,875 on a $300,000 loan.

Worksheet steps (9)
  1. Two CFPB pages, two windows, and the plan that fits both
  2. Which window your lender's score uses, model by model
  3. What an application actually puts on your file
  4. A shopping sprint on the calendar
  5. Soft pulls, hard pulls, and what a single inquiry costs
  6. How far a few points can move your price: the Fannie Mae LLPA grid
  7. Who sets the price when two people sign
  8. Pricing the extra $1,500: a refinance that shifts from month 34 to month 44
  9. Where the real credit damage comes from: new debt and old reports

Two CFPB pages, two windows, and the plan that fits both

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau answers this question on two pages, and the numbers differ. Its page on what happens when a mortgage lender checks your credit, last reviewed August 28, 2026, says that within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded on your credit report as a single inquiry, so the impact is the same no matter how many lenders you consult, as long as the last check falls within 45 days of the first. A second CFPB page, last reviewed December 31, 2024, on credit inquiries with no effect on your score, gives a range instead: inquiries for the same type of loan within 14 to 45 days of each other are treated as no more than a single inquiry, and mortgage, auto and student loan inquiries made in the 30 days before a score is calculated have no effect at all.

The range is explained by scoring versions, which the next section lays out. The plan that satisfies every figure is simple: finish all your applications within 14 days. A two-week sprint is long enough to collect Loan Estimates from several lenders, because each one must send yours within three business days of your application, and short enough to sit inside the shortest window any model uses. If a lender is slow, the CFPB's own advice is that going past 45 days is still usually worth it, because one extra inquiry has a small effect and a better quote can save a lot. The sprint is a way to avoid thinking about the window, not a reason to take a worse quote.

Which window your lender's score uses, model by model

Neither the CFPB page nor your lender will tell you in advance which window applies, because it depends on the scoring model the lender asks the bureaus to run. FICO's own pages on credit checks and inquiries, which we read October 23, 2026, state it this way: FICO Scores group multiple hard inquiries made within a short time frame of 14 to 45 days into one inquiry; for scores calculated from older versions of the scoring formula the shopping period is any 14-day span; for the newest versions it is any 45-day span; and each lender chooses which version of the FICO scoring formula it wants the credit reporting agency to use. For loans that commonly involve rate shopping (mortgage, auto and student loans), FICO adds that its scores ignore inquiries made in the 30 days before scoring, so an inquiry from a loan you found within a month does not count while you are still shopping.

VantageScore, the other model family, publishes a single figure. In the FAQ on its website, VantageScore states that its 4.0 model counts inquiries that appear in a credit file within a 14-day window as a single inquiry, so that people shopping for a favorable rate are not treated as applying for several credit products. The table puts the statements side by side with what Fannie Mae requires, which is what most refinance lenders must follow when they sell loans to it.

The Fannie Mae row is where the gap shows. Section B3-5.1-01 of the Selling Guide, dated April 22, 2026, requires three specific classic FICO versions for loans underwritten through Desktop Underwriter or manually (Equifax Beacon 5.0, Experian/Fair Isaac Risk Model V2 and TransUnion FICO Risk Score, Classic 04) and lists VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T as approved models, with FICO 10T not yet deliverable. FICO does not say on the pages we read which of its versions it calls older, so we cannot confirm whether those three classic versions use the 14-day span. The safe reading is that they may, which is why the plan above uses 14 days.

Rate-shopping windows as stated by each publisher (FICO and VantageScore pages, CFPB pages and Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-5.1-01, read October 23, 2026)
SourceModel or versionWindow it statesWhat the source does not say
FICO (myFICO credit education)Older FICO versionsAny 14-day span counts as one inquiryWhich version numbers are 'older'
FICO (myFICO credit education)Newest FICO versionsAny 45-day span counts as one inquiryWhich version numbers are 'newest'
FICO (myFICO credit education)Mortgage, auto and student loansInquiries in the 30 days before scoring are ignoredWhether this applies to every version
VantageScore (FAQ page)VantageScore 4.014-day window counts as one inquiryWindows for earlier VantageScore models
Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-5.1-01Beacon 5.0, Experian V2 and TransUnion Classic 04 required; VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T approvedNone; the guide sets eligibility models, not a shopping windowWhich window those classic versions use
CFPB (two Ask CFPB pages)General statement for borrowers45 days on one page; 14 to 45 days on the otherWhich model a given lender uses

What an application actually puts on your file

For Loan Estimate purposes Regulation Z treats an application as complete once the lender holds six items, and the one that matters for your credit is the Social Security number, supplied so the lender can obtain a credit report (12 CFR 1026.2(a)(3)(ii)); the other five are income, name, property address, a value estimate and the loan amount. The Social Security number is in that list because it is what a lender needs to obtain your credit report, and once all six items are in the lender's hands the three-business-day Loan Estimate clock is running. A name and a rate request typed into a website supplies only two of the six.

What the lender pulls is more than one report. Fannie Mae's section B3-5.2-01 requires a three in-file merged credit report, which combines the files at Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and it requires the report to generate an inquiry that will appear on future credit reports and to list every inquiry made in the previous 90 days. The Selling Guide also says, in B3-5.3-04, that the lender must review those inquiries and, where they show recent attempts to obtain credit, must confirm that you have not taken on additional credit that is missing from the application. If you did, the debt must be verified and counted in your ratios.

You are not charged for any of this until you choose to proceed. Regulation Z, 1026.19(e)(2)(i), bars a lender from imposing a fee in connection with your application before you have received the Loan Estimate and told the lender you intend to proceed, with one exception: a bona fide and reasonable fee for the credit report itself. You may signal intent to proceed in any manner you choose unless the lender requires a particular one. The same section lets a lender give you a written estimate before the Loan Estimate, but only if the top of the first page, in at least 12-point type, says that your actual rate, payment and costs could be higher and that you should get an official Loan Estimate before choosing a loan. A quote that carries that sentence is a pre-application estimate, not a Loan Estimate, and cannot be compared line for line with one.

A shopping sprint on the calendar

The table lays one sprint against real dates. It assumes you submit complete applications to three lenders on Monday, November 16, 2026, and that none of the lenders' offices is closed on a weekday that week. The three-business-day deadline uses the general Regulation Z definition of a business day (a day on which the creditor's offices are open to the public for substantially all of its business functions), so a lender open on Saturday may count it. Ask each lender its own count rather than assuming.

One shopping sprint, three applications submitted Monday, November 16, 2026 (dates computed for this page; windows are the CFPB figures quoted above)
DateWhat happensWhy it matters for your credit
Mon Nov 16Three lenders receive the six application items, including your Social Security numberEach pulls a merged report; all three inquiries fall on one day
Thu Nov 19Latest date for each Loan Estimate if the lender counts weekdays (3 business days)The estimate is due even if you have not heard the rate you hoped for; compare only forms that carry the Loan Estimate heading, not earlier written estimates
Fri Nov 20You compare totals and tell one lender you intend to proceedThird-party fees such as an appraisal can now be charged; the credit report fee could be charged earlier
Mon Nov 3014 days after the first pullInside the shortest window the CFPB states for same-type inquiries
Thu Dec 3145 days after the first pullOutside this date, a further check may count as a separate inquiry; the CFPB says shopping is usually still worth it

Soft pulls, hard pulls, and what a single inquiry costs

FICO separates inquiries into two kinds. Soft inquiries, such as viewing your own credit report, do not affect FICO Scores, and FICO lists loan pre-approval screenings and background checks among the uses of a soft inquiry. Hard inquiries, such as actively applying for a new credit card or a mortgage, may affect your score. A lender's pre-approval screen is therefore not always a hard pull, but a full application with your Social Security number is, so ask before you submit whether the first step is a soft or a hard check.

FICO puts a size on the effect. Its page says that credit inquiries in general have a small impact on FICO Scores, that for most people one additional inquiry takes less than five points off, and that inquiries can have a greater impact if you have few accounts or a short credit history. Hard inquiries stay on a report for up to two years but affect the scores for only a year. This sits comfortably beside the 'a few points' wording on FICO's New Credit page: five points is the ceiling for most people, and for someone with a long file it is often less.

Five points is the number to carry into the price grid in the next section. A sprint that records one inquiry costs, for most people, less than five points, and a move within a score band costs nothing in price. The dollar cost appears only when the five points carry you across a band edge.

How far a few points can move your price: the Fannie Mae LLPA grid

FICO says an inquiry usually has a small impact, that many kinds of inquiries are ignored completely, that the score allows for rate shopping, and that an inquiry can lower your score by a few points depending on the rest of your report. Treat 'a few points' as the working figure. Whether it matters depends on where you stand relative to the lines on Fannie Mae's Loan-Level Price Adjustment (LLPA) grid, because LLPAs are the pricing charges lenders apply to loans they sell to Fannie Mae, and they step up at fixed score breaks rather than sliding smoothly.

Fannie Mae's LLPA Matrix dated September 30, 2026, which we downloaded October 23, 2026, lists charges for limited cash-out refinances on terms over 15 years, which is the grid that covers an ordinary rate-and-term refinance. The table below reads three loan-to-value columns on a $300,000 loan, changing nothing but the score band. Each dollar figure is the percentage times $300,000. How a lender folds that charge into your quote (rate, points or credit) is the lender's decision, and the Loan Estimate shows the result, not the grid.

The last two columns are the ones that matter if a pull knocks you down a few points. Moving from the 740 to 759 band to the 720 to 739 band costs $1,500 at 78.9 percent LTV and $750 at 65.2 percent. Moving within a band costs nothing: 745 and 758 pay the same charge.

Fannie Mae LLPA, limited cash-out refinance, terms over 15 years, $300,000 loan, by Classic FICO or VantageScore 4.0 band (Matrix dated 09.30.2026; downloaded October 23, 2026)
Score bandLTV 60.01 to 70% ($460,000 value, 65.2%)LTV 70.01 to 75% ($410,000 value, 73.2%)LTV 75.01 to 80% ($380,000 value, 78.9%)Added by dropping to this band from the one above, at 78.9%
780 or higher0.000% ($0)0.125% ($375)0.500% ($1,500)n/a
760 to 7790.125% ($375)0.375% ($1,125)0.875% ($2,625)$1,125
740 to 7590.250% ($750)0.750% ($2,250)1.125% ($3,375)$750
720 to 7390.500% ($1,500)1.000% ($3,000)1.625% ($4,875)$1,500
700 to 7190.625% ($1,875)1.250% ($3,750)1.875% ($5,625)$750
680 to 6990.875% ($2,625)1.625% ($4,875)2.250% ($6,750)$1,125
660 to 6791.125% ($3,375)1.875% ($5,625)2.500% ($7,500)$750
640 to 6591.375% ($4,125)2.125% ($6,375)2.875% ($8,625)$1,125
620 to 6391.750% ($5,250)2.500% ($7,500)3.500% ($10,500)$1,875

Who sets the price when two people sign

The score the grid uses is not your highest and not an average. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, B3-5.1-02, dated April 22, 2026, says the representative credit score is used for pricing on all loans and is built in two steps. For each borrower, take the middle of three scores (or the lower of two). If there are several borrowers, the lowest of those single scores is the loan's representative score. Fannie Mae's own examples show 700, 680 and 680 producing 680, and 700, 700 and 680 producing 700.

Put that against the grid. Say borrower A has scores of 752, 748 and 741, so A's middle score is 748, which sits in the 740 to 759 band. Borrower B has 739, 731 and 722, so B's middle score is 731, in the 720 to 739 band. The loan is priced on 731. At 78.9 percent LTV on $300,000, A alone is a 1.125 percent charge ($3,375); the two of them together are 1.625 percent ($4,875). The $1,500 difference is a result of B's file, not A's, and it is the same dollar amount as the whole cost of dropping one band, which is why a co-borrower's inquiries, late payments and card balances belong in your pre-application review as much as your own.

The same rule explains why a single co-borrower's inquiry history can cost more than your own. An extra inquiry that lowers B's median by four points, from 731 to 727, changes nothing, because the band is 720 to 739. An inquiry that lowers it from 721 to 719 costs $750 on this loan, because 719 falls in the 700 to 719 band.

Pricing the extra $1,500: a refinance that shifts from month 34 to month 44

The effect of a band change on the decision is arithmetic, and it is worth running once so that you know when the dip matters. The example holds everything fixed except one input, the closing cost. The balance is $300,000. The current loan is a 30-year fixed at 7.25 percent, giving a principal-and-interest payment of $2,047. The new loan is a 30-year fixed at 6.50 percent, giving $1,896. Both rates are illustrations, not quotes. The payment saving is $151 a month. The stay horizon is 5 years.

With $5,000 in total closing costs, the saving repays the cost in month 34 ($5,000 divided by $151 is 33.1 months, so the first month with the cost fully repaid is 34) and the net gain by the end of month 60 is $4,060 ($151 times 60, minus $5,000). Add the $1,500 band difference to the cost and the same payment saving repays $6,500 in month 44 ($6,500 divided by $151 is 43.0), with a net gain by month 60 of $2,560. The refinance still wins at five years in both cases; the dip moved the break-even by ten months and took $1,500 off the five-year result.

That is the useful test. If your quote already clears break-even by a wide margin before the inquiry, a few points cannot change the answer. If the quote clears break-even only barely, check which side of a band edge you sit on before you apply, and read how to run break-even with the costs left in for the full method. If a quote only works when you keep the house past the month the cost is repaid, the decision guides cover the cases where a lower rate still loses, with or without an inquiry on the file.

Where the real credit damage comes from: new debt and old reports

The inquiry is the smallest credit event in a refinance. The CFPB's page warns that applying for a credit card, car loan or other loan adds an inquiry that can lower your scores, and says to avoid doing so right before or during the mortgage process. The reason is bigger than the inquiry. A new account changes your balances, your payments and your average account age, and FICO states that new credit makes up 10 percent of a FICO Score and that opening a new account can lower the scores even for people who have used credit for a long time.

A new account can also change your approval. Fannie Mae's B3-5.3-04 tells the lender to confirm that no additional credit has been obtained beyond what the report and the application show, and to qualify you on the new payment if it has. FHA's Handbook 4000.1 PDF, which HUD hosts and which we read October 23, 2026, makes the same demand for its loans: the mortgagee must review all credit report inquiries so that any new debt payments from material inquiries are counted in the ratios. A new car payment of $400 a month, for example, raises your debt-to-income ratio by about 4.8 points on $100,000 of annual income ($400 times 12, divided by $100,000), which can matter more to an approval than any inquiry does.

The other way to meet a second credit pull is delay. Fannie Mae's B1-1-03, dated April 2, 2025, says credit documents, including credit reports, must be no more than four months old on the note date, and that if they are older the lender must update them. Four months is long for a refinance that closes on time, but a lock that expires, an appraisal that comes in low or a title problem can use it up. If you extend a lock, ask whether the extension will push the credit report past four months before the note date. The cost side of extensions is in rate lock fees and extensions.

Common questions

Do mortgage inquiries made in the last 30 days count at all?

Under FICO's published method they do not, when the score is calculated for a loan type that involves rate shopping. FICO says its scores ignore mortgage, auto and student loan inquiries made in the 30 days before scoring, and the CFPB's page on inquiries repeats the 30-day statement. That is why a lender's check on day 20 of your sprint may not appear in the score that lender sees on day 21.

If I also apply for a car loan during the sprint, does it fall in the same window?

No. The CFPB says that shopping for two different loan types, such as a mortgage and an auto loan, generally counts as multiple credit inquiries and can lower your score. Each loan type gets its own grouping, so schedule the car purchase after the mortgage closes.

Is it safe to look at my own credit before I apply?

Yes. The CFPB says checking your own credit does not affect your scores, and FICO classes viewing your own report as a soft inquiry. The CFPB points to annualcreditreport.com for a free copy and advises correcting errors before you apply.

Will the lender pull my credit again before closing?

Fannie Mae's rule does not require a second pull at closing. It requires that credit documents be no more than four months old on the note date, and that the lender update them if they are older. A lender that does choose to pull a new report after the initial underwriting decision must re-underwrite the loan (B3-6-02).

I was declined after one pull. Did that inquiry stay on my report?

Yes. Fannie Mae's credit report requirement says the report must generate an inquiry that appears on future credit reports, whether or not a loan results. FICO says hard inquiries remain on the report for up to two years but affect its scores for only a year. The denied-refinance guide covers the notice you should receive.

Compare the Loan Estimates you collected in the Loan Estimate comparator before telling any lender you intend to proceed.

Sources and verification

The dollar figures are the LLPA grid times a $300,000 loan, not a price any lender will quote; each lender decides how to apply the charge, and some loans are not sold to Fannie Mae at all. The 7.25 and 6.50 percent rates are arithmetic inputs, not market data. The windows come from the publishers' own pages, which do not name the version numbers behind 'older' and 'newest' or give a window for earlier VantageScore models. Nothing here is credit advice or a lender recommendation.