How your mortgage works

Prepayment penalty when you refinance: the maximum, in dollars, month by month

On a consumer mortgage that closed on or after January 10, 2014, a prepayment penalty cannot exceed 2 percent of the balance you pay off in the first two years or 1 percent in the third, and it cannot apply after year three; only a fixed-rate or step-rate, qualified, not-higher-priced loan may carry one at all. A loan made primarily for a business purpose, which includes credit to buy or improve a rental property the owner does not occupy, is outside Regulation Z. On the $317,029 balance worked below, that ceiling is $6,341, which is the first number to add to any refinance quote. Loans sold to Fannie Mae cannot have one, VA's rule lets a borrower prepay "without premium or fee," and USDA treats a required penalty as an ineligible term, so the places a penalty can still turn up are loans outside those channels and notes written under earlier rules.

Worksheet steps (12)
  1. The federal ceiling, quoted in full
  2. Three conditions a loan must meet before it can carry a penalty
  3. The maximum penalty in dollars, payoff date by payoff date
  4. What counts as a penalty and what does not
  5. What a 2 percent penalty does to the break-even month
  6. A smaller rate drop reverses the answer
  7. FHA, VA, USDA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: what each program prints
  8. Loans closed before 2014: which rule applied and how to date the clause
  9. FHA loans closed before January 21, 2015: interest to the next due date
  10. Penalty on the new loan: what a lower rate with a penalty is worth
  11. If the penalty is real: roll it in, wait, or pay part of the balance
  12. Finding the number on your own loan

The federal ceiling, quoted in full

Regulation Z, section 1026.43(g), is the federal limit on prepayment penalties for closed-end mortgages secured by a dwelling. The eCFR text, current through October 30, 2026, opens with the conditions under which a penalty may appear at all: “(1) When permitted. A covered transaction must not include a prepayment penalty unless: (i) The prepayment penalty is otherwise permitted by law; and (ii) The transaction: (A) Has an annual percentage rate that cannot increase after consummation; (B) Is a qualified mortgage under paragraph (e)(2), (e)(4), (e)(5), (e)(6), or (f) of this section; and (C) Is not a higher-priced mortgage loan, as defined in § 1026.35(a).”

Paragraph (g)(2) sets the size and the clock: “(2) Limits on prepayment penalties. A prepayment penalty: (i) Must not apply after the three-year period following consummation; and (ii) Must not exceed the following percentages of the amount of the outstanding loan balance prepaid: (A) 2 percent, if incurred during the first two years following consummation; and (B) 1 percent, if incurred during the third year following consummation.”

Paragraphs (g)(3) through (g)(5) govern the offer: “(3) Alternative offer required. A creditor must not offer a consumer a covered transaction with a prepayment penalty unless the creditor also offers the consumer an alternative covered transaction without a prepayment penalty and the alternative covered transaction: (i) Has an annual percentage rate that cannot increase after consummation and has the same type of interest rate as the covered transaction with a prepayment penalty; for purposes of this paragraph (g), the term “type of interest rate” refers to whether a transaction: (A) Is a fixed-rate mortgage, as defined in § 1026.18(s)(7)(iii); or (B) Is a step-rate mortgage, as defined in § 1026.18(s)(7)(ii); (ii) Has the same loan term as the loan term for the covered transaction with a prepayment penalty; (iii) Satisfies the periodic payment conditions under paragraph (e)(2)(i) of this section; (iv) Satisfies the points and fees conditions under paragraph (e)(2)(iii) of this section, based on the information known to the creditor at the time the transaction is offered; and (v) Is a transaction for which the creditor has a good faith belief that the consumer likely qualifies, based on the information known to the creditor at the time the creditor offers the covered transaction without a prepayment penalty.”

Paragraph (g)(4) carries the same duty into offers through a broker, and (g)(5) into offers by a creditor that is itself a loan originator: “(4) Offer through a mortgage broker. If the creditor offers a covered transaction with a prepayment penalty to the consumer through a mortgage broker, as defined in § 1026.36(a)(2), the creditor must: (i) Present the mortgage broker an alternative covered transaction without a prepayment penalty that satisfies the requirements of paragraph (g)(3) of this section; and (ii) Establish by agreement that the mortgage broker must present the consumer an alternative covered transaction without a prepayment penalty that satisfies the requirements of paragraph (g)(3) of this section, offered by: (A) The creditor; or (B) Another creditor, if the transaction offered by the other creditor has a lower interest rate or a lower total dollar amount of discount points and origination points or fees.” “(5) Creditor that is a loan originator. If the creditor is a loan originator, as defined in § 1026.36(a)(1), and the creditor presents the consumer a covered transaction offered by a person to which the creditor would assign the covered transaction after consummation, the creditor must present the consumer an alternative covered transaction without a prepayment penalty that satisfies the requirements of paragraph (g)(3) of this section, offered by: (i) The assignee; or (ii) Another person, if the transaction offered by the other person has a lower interest rate or a lower total dollar amount of origination discount points and points or fees.”

Paragraph (g)(6) closes the subsection: “(6) Applicability. This paragraph (g) applies only if a covered transaction is consummated with a prepayment penalty and is not violated if: (i) A covered transaction is consummated without a prepayment penalty; or (ii) The creditor and consumer do not consummate a covered transaction.”

The defined term comes from § 1026.32(b)(6), which section 1026.43(b)(10) adopts. For a closed-end loan it reads: “(i) Closed-end credit transactions. For a closed-end credit transaction, prepayment penalty means a charge imposed for paying all or part of the transaction's principal before the date on which the principal is due, other than a waived, bona fide third-party charge that the creditor imposes if the consumer prepays all of the transaction's principal sooner than 36 months after consummation, provided, however, that interest charged consistent with the monthly interest accrual amortization method is not a prepayment penalty for extensions of credit insured by the Federal Housing Administration that are consummated before January 21, 2015.”

Three features of that text drive every number that follows. The percentages apply to the principal prepaid, not to the original loan amount, so the dollar ceiling shrinks only as the balance does. The ceiling steps down at the anniversaries of closing instead of sliding month by month. And it is a ceiling, not a permission: the first condition makes the federal text apply on top of the note and any state law, so a note can set a smaller penalty or none. The Bureau's official comment on paragraph (g)(2) gives the example of a note that charges a penalty for two years after closing at 1 percent of the amount prepaid in each of those years.

Three conditions a loan must meet before it can carry a penalty

The first condition is a rate that cannot rise. An adjustable-rate loan fails it by definition, because its annual percentage rate can increase after closing. Paragraph (g)(3)(i) sorts the loans that can carry a penalty into fixed-rate and step-rate mortgages, and it requires the penalty-free alternative a lender must offer to be the same type.

The second condition sends the loan to the qualified mortgage definitions. Section 1026.43(g)(1)(ii)(B) names five routes: the general definition in (e)(2), the agency definitions in (e)(4), small-creditor portfolio loans in (e)(5), the temporary balloon-payment rules in (e)(6), and the balloon-payment exemption in (f). Paragraph (e)(4), headed “Qualified mortgage defined” for other agencies, reads in full: “Notwithstanding paragraph (e)(2) of this section, a qualified mortgage is a covered transaction that is defined as a qualified mortgage by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under 24 CFR 201.7 and 24 CFR 203.19, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs under 38 CFR 36.4300 and 38 CFR 36.4500, or the U.S. Department of Agriculture under 7 CFR 3555.109.” That is why an FHA, VA or USDA loan can be a qualified mortgage under Regulation Z while each program's own text, covered below, settles whether a penalty is allowed.

The third condition is price. Section 1026.35(a)(1) defines the higher-priced mortgage loan: “(1) “Higher-priced mortgage loan” means a closed-end consumer credit transaction secured by the consumer's principal dwelling with an annual percentage rate that exceeds the average prime offer rate for a comparable transaction as of the date the interest rate is set: (i) By 1.5 or more percentage points for loans secured by a first lien with a principal obligation at consummation that does not exceed the limit in effect as of the date the transaction's interest rate is set for the maximum principal obligation eligible for purchase by Freddie Mac; (ii) By 2.5 or more percentage points for loans secured by a first lien with a principal obligation at consummation that exceeds the limit in effect as of the date the transaction's interest rate is set for the maximum principal obligation eligible for purchase by Freddie Mac; or (iii) By 3.5 or more percentage points for loans secured by a subordinate lien.” The Bureau publishes the average prime offer rates in a table updated at least weekly (§ 1026.35(a)(2)). A fixed-rate qualified mortgage priced at or above those spreads is higher-priced, and it loses the right to carry a penalty.

Two kinds of credit sit outside section 1026.43 altogether. Paragraph (a) excludes a home equity line of credit subject to § 1026.40 and a mortgage secured by a timeshare plan. A closed-end second mortgage or home equity loan is inside, because paragraph (b)(1) covers any consumer credit transaction secured by a dwelling that paragraph (a) does not exempt. A line of credit follows other text: § 1026.32(b)(6)(ii) defines the penalty on an open-end plan as a charge imposed if the consumer terminates the plan before the end of its term, and the high-cost mortgage rules go further. A loan whose terms let the lender charge a penalty more than 36 months after closing, or penalties that can exceed 2 percent of the amount prepaid in total, is itself a high-cost mortgage under § 1026.32(a)(1)(iii), and § 1026.32(d) (“A high-cost mortgage shall not include the following terms”) lists in paragraph (6): “Prepayment penalties. A prepayment penalty, as defined in paragraph (b)(6) of this section.” The HELOC versus refinance guide covers the other differences between a line and a closed-end loan.

A boundary comes before any of this. Regulation Z covers consumer credit, and § 1026.3(a) exempts “(1) An extension of credit primarily for a business, commercial or agricultural purpose. (2) An extension of credit to other than a natural person, including credit to government agencies or instrumentalities.” Comment 3(a)-4 adds that credit extended to acquire, improve, or maintain rental property that is not owner-occupied is deemed to be for business purposes, whatever the number of housing units, and gives a house rented to another person to live in as an example. A penalty on a loan like that is not held to the 2 and 1 percent ceiling; the note and state law decide it, and so they do for a loan made to an LLC or other entity borrower. A refinance of a rental property is judged by the purpose of the credit, which is a question for the lender's file, so an investment-property refinance is a case where the note should be read before any quote is priced.

The maximum penalty in dollars, payoff date by payoff date

Take a $320,000, 30-year fixed-rate loan at 7.00% (an illustration rate, not a quote), principal and interest $2,128.97 a month, that closed on November 18, 2025 with the first payment due January 1, 2026. Assume the lender wrote the largest penalty the rule allows: 2 percent through the second anniversary of closing and 1 percent through the third. The table prices a full payoff on each date. The percentage applies to the principal still owed, so the balance after the most recent payment due date is what counts.

Maximum prepayment penalty under 12 CFR 1026.43(g)(2) on a $320,000, 30-year, 7.00% loan that closed November 18, 2025; full payoff on each date; payment due the 1st of each month from January 1, 2026. Illustration; whole payoff of principal; balances to the cent.
Payoff datePayments madePrincipal balanceCeiling that appliesMaximum penalty
December 20, 20250$320,000.002 percent$6,400.00
January 20, 20261$319,737.702 percent$6,394.75
June 20, 20266$318,403.062 percent$6,368.06
November 20, 202611$317,029.032 percent$6,340.58
May 20, 202717$315,326.552 percent$6,306.53
October 20, 202722$313,861.742 percent$6,277.23
November 10, 202723$313,563.632 percent$6,271.27
November 25, 202723$313,563.631 percent$3,135.64
June 20, 202830$311,427.581 percent$3,114.28
October 20, 202834$310,167.371 percent$3,101.67
November 10, 202835$309,847.711 percent$3,098.48
November 25, 202835$309,847.71None$0.00

Across the first 23 payments the balance barely moves, from $320,000 to $313,564, so the 2 percent ceiling slides only from $6,400 to $6,271, a drop of $129 in nearly two years. Then the percentage halves in one step. A payoff on November 10, 2027 and one on November 25, 2027 sit on the same $313,563.63 balance, and the ceiling goes from $6,271.27 to $3,135.64, a difference of $3,135.63 for fifteen days of waiting. The third anniversary removes the remaining $3,098.48.

The table treats each anniversary of the closing date as the day the next tier begins. A note words “the first two years following consummation” in its own way, so the end date printed on the Loan Estimate (§ 1026.37(b)(7)) and the servicer's written payoff quote are the dates to rely on, not a date worked out from a calendar.

The same percentages apply to a partial payoff. The definition reaches a charge for paying “all or part” of the principal early, and the cap is measured on “the amount of the outstanding loan balance prepaid,” so an extra $20,000 paid in the first two years carries a ceiling of $400, and the same $20,000 after the second anniversary carries $200. Whether a particular note charges anything on partial prepayments is set by that note. The standard Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac note, quoted below, does not. Because the cap is a flat percentage, any other balance can be priced by hand: 2 percent of $450,000 is $9,000 in the first two years and 1 percent is $4,500 in the third.

What counts as a penalty and what does not

The cap would mean little if a lender could relabel the charge, so the Bureau's official comments list what is and is not a penalty. They are published in Supplement I to Regulation Z, and the examples below come from comments 32(b)(6)-1, 32(b)(6)-2 and 37(b)(4)-1 through 37(b)(4)-3.

Counted as a penalty: interest charged for time after the payoff. The comment's example is a loan with monthly interest accrual amortization, where $3,000 of interest is due on May 1 for April whether the payment arrives on April 20 or May 10. If the borrower prepays in full on April 20, when only $2,000 has accrued, a $3,000 charge is a penalty of $1,000. Also counted: a closing fee the lender waived on the condition that the loan is not prepaid, a minimum finance charge on a simple-interest loan, and a refund of unearned interest computed by a method less favorable than the actuarial method.

Not counted: a waived, bona fide third-party charge the lender recovers if the whole loan is paid off within 36 months of closing. The comment's example waives $3,000 of third-party charges at closing and lets the lender recoup $4,500 on an early payoff. The first $3,000 is not a penalty; the extra $1,500 is, and it falls under the same cap and the same disclosure. Also not counted: fees for preparing and providing payoff documents when the loan is paid in full, if they are charged whether or not the loan is prepaid (the comment names a payoff statement, a reconveyance document and a release of the lender's security interest), and loan guarantee fees.

Disclosure follows the same definition. Under § 1026.37(b)(4), the Loan Estimate states whether the transaction includes a prepayment penalty, and comment 37(b)(4)-1 adds that if interest is assessed on the balance for a full month even when the consumer pays in full before month end, the transaction includes a prepayment penalty that must be disclosed. When the answer is yes, § 1026.37(b)(7) requires the maximum amount of the penalty and the date the penalty period ends. Separately, a payoff-document fee is not a penalty, but it is a charge that can appear on a payoff statement, and it is worth asking whether the payoff figure includes it.

What a 2 percent penalty does to the break-even month

Carry the loan forward to today, November 3, 2026. Eleven payments are in, the balance is $317,029.03, and a lender quotes 6.00% fixed on a loan sized to the same payoff date (349 months), with $6,200 of closing costs paid in cash. The new payment is $1,922.33 against $2,128.97 now, a saving of $206.64 a month. Without a penalty, the closing costs break even in month 31: $6,200 divided by $206.64 is 30.004, so the 31st payment is the first to complete the recovery.

With the maximum penalty, 2 percent of $317,029.03 is $6,340.58. The cost of leaving the old loan becomes $12,540.58, of which 50.6 percent is the penalty, and the break-even month moves from 31 to 61. The penalty alone equals 30.7 months of the payment saving. The break-even explainer walks through the month count; the new input here is a second cost that is not one of the new loan's closing costs, because the penalty belongs to the loan being paid off and arrives inside the payoff figure.

The table asks a further question. Because the penalty steps down on fixed dates, a borrower can wait for a lower tier. The three rows price the same 6.00% quote taken now, taken the day after the second anniversary, and taken the day after the penalty ends, each on a loan matched to the old loan's payoff date. Net is interest saved minus closing costs minus penalty, counted to the same calendar date for all three rows, and it assumes the same 6.00% quote can be had later. Rates move, so that assumption is arithmetic, not a forecast.

Same 6.00% quote at three refinance dates; $6,200 closing costs in cash; term-matched new loan; net = interest saved - closing costs - penalty, counted 36, 60 and 84 months after November 3, 2026. Illustration, not quotes.
Refinance onBalance paid offMaximum penaltyMonthly savingBreak-even month after that refinance (payment basis, with penalty)Net 36 months after Nov. 3, 2026Net 60 months after Nov. 3, 2026Net 84 months after Nov. 3, 2026
Now (November 3, 2026)$317,029.03$6,340.58$206.64Month 61-$3,004$3,363$9,709
After the second anniversary (November 25, 2027)$313,563.63$3,135.64$202.37Month 47-$3,055$3,233$9,502
After the penalty ends (November 25, 2028)$309,847.71$0.00$197.95Month 32-$3,100$3,106$9,295

At a 1.00-point rate drop the timing barely matters. The three rows end within $257 of each other at 60 months and within $414 at 84 months, and at 36 months all three are still negative, by between $3,004 and $3,100. The reason is in the penalty's own structure. Waiting through the first tier removes $3,204.94 of penalty (2 percent of today's balance minus 1 percent of the slightly lower balance a year later). A year of a 1.00-point lower rate on a balance this size saves $3,173.65 in interest, about 1 percent of the balance. The two nearly cancel.

A smaller rate drop reverses the answer

That cancellation is a rule of thumb that holds on these numbers. A year of waiting forgoes interest worth about the rate drop expressed as a percent of the balance (a 1.00-point drop is about 1 percent of the balance a year), and a tier step removes 1 percent of the balance. With a drop of exactly 1.00 point the choice is a wash. With a smaller drop, waiting for the penalty to fall wins. With a larger drop, refinancing now wins. The table runs the same loan, closing costs and 84-month horizon at three quotes.

Net at 84 months after November 3, 2026, by quote and refinance date. $6,200 closing costs in cash, term-matched new loan, maximum penalty at each date, old rate 7.00%.
QuoteDrop from 7.00%Monthly saving if taken nowNet, refinance nowNet, after the second anniversaryNet, after the penalty ends
6.50%0.50 points$104.44-$1,391$102$1,561
6.00%1.00 points$206.64$9,709$9,502$9,295
5.75%1.25 points$256.85$15,239$14,186$13,151

At 6.50%, a drop of 0.50 point, the monthly saving taken now is $104.44, and the $6,340.58 penalty equals 60.7 months of it. Interest saved in the first twelve months is $1,587.21, against $3,204.94 of penalty removed by waiting those twelve months. Refinancing now is still $1,391 under water 84 months out, and the same quote taken after the penalty ends is $1,561 ahead. At 5.75%, a drop of 1.25 points, twelve months of the lower rate saves $3,966.50, more than the penalty step, and refinancing now ends $1,053 ahead of waiting for the second anniversary and $2,088 ahead of waiting for the end.

The rule of thumb fails when the horizon is short. In the 6.00% table every row is negative at 36 months, and a borrower who expects to sell or refinance again inside three years from today loses on all three dates; the penalty only changes how much. The guide to refinancing too often covers what repeated early exits do to the cost of each loan, and the rate-drop guide sets the spread that usually justifies a refinance with no penalty in the picture.

Three payoff dates against a 6.00% quote on the same loan

Inputs, all illustrations: a $320,000 30-year fixed loan at 7.00% (payment $2,128.97) that closed November 18, 2025, a balance of $317,029.03 after 11 payments on November 3, 2026, a 6.00% quote on a 349-month loan, $6,200 of closing costs in cash, a stay horizon of 84 months, and the maximum penalty the rule allows. Refinancing now pays off $317,029.03 with a $6,340.58 penalty; the new payment is $1,922.33 and the saving $206.64. Break-even is month 31 on closing costs alone and month 61 with the penalty. The net at 84 months is $9,709. Waiting until after November 18, 2027 cuts the penalty to $3,135.64 on a $313,563.63 balance and ends at $9,502; waiting until after November 18, 2028 removes it and ends at $9,295. At a 0.50-point drop (6.50%), the order reverses: refinancing now ends with a loss of $1,391 and waiting for the penalty to end with a gain of $1,561. The gaps between the three dates come only from the penalty and the months of lower rate given up; the term is matched in every row, so none of it is a term restart.

FHA, VA, USDA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: what each program prints

The federal ceiling is the outer limit. Inside it, each program has its own text on prepayment, and for the agency channels that text either excludes a penalty or describes none. The table quotes each source and gives its date.

What each program's own primary text says about prepayment; dates of the texts are in the Sources list.
ProgramWhat the text saysSource
Fannie Mae conventional loanSelling Guide: “Loans subject to prepayment penalties are ineligible for sale to Fannie Mae.” The uniform note, section 4 in full: “4. BORROWER'S RIGHT TO PREPAY I have the right to make payments of principal at any time before they are due. A payment of principal only is known as a "Prepayment." When I make a Prepayment, I will notify the Note Holder in writing that I am doing so. I may not designate a payment as a Prepayment if I have not made all the Monthly Payments then due under this Note. I may make a full Prepayment or partial Prepayments without paying a Prepayment charge. The Note Holder will use my Prepayments to reduce the amount of Principal that I owe under this Note. However, the Note Holder may apply my Prepayment to the accrued and unpaid interest on the Prepayment amount, before applying my Prepayment to reduce the Principal amount of the Note. If I make a partial Prepayment, there will be no changes in the due date or in the amount of my Monthly Payment unless the Note Holder agrees in writing to those changes.”Selling Guide A3-2-02, Responsible Lending Practices (09/01/2021); Form 3200 Multistate Fixed Rate Note (07/2021)
Freddie Mac conventional loanThe same Form 3200 is titled “Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac UNIFORM INSTRUMENT” and carries the same section 4. A state variant, the West Virginia fixed-rate note (Form 3249, 07/2021), carries it too.Form 3200 (07/2021); Form 3249 (07/2021)
FHA loan closed on or after January 21, 2015“With respect to FHA-insured mortgages closed on or after January 21, 2015, notwithstanding the terms of the mortgage, the mortgagee shall accept a prepayment at any time and in any amount. The mortgagee shall not require 30 days' advance notice of prepayment, even if the mortgage instrument purports to require such notice. Monthly interest on the debt must be calculated on the actual unpaid principal balance of the loan as of the date the prepayment is received, and not as of the next installment due date.”24 CFR 203.558(a), eCFR current through October 30, 2026
VA-guaranteed loan“The debtor shall have the right to prepay at any time, without premium or fee, the entire indebtedness or any part thereof not less than the amount of one installment, or $100, whichever is less. Any prepayment in full of the indebtedness shall be credited on the date received, and no interest may be charged thereafter. Any partial prepayment made on other than an installment due date need not be credited until the next following installment due date or 30 days after such prepayment, whichever is earlier. The holder and the debtor may agree at any time that any prepayment not previously applied in satisfaction of matured installments shall be reapplied for the purpose of curing or preventing any subsequent default.”38 CFR 36.4311, eCFR current through October 30, 2026
USDA guaranteed rural housing loan (7 CFR part 3555)“(b) Repayment period. The term of the loan may not exceed 30 years. Adjustable rate mortgages, balloon term mortgages or mortgages requiring prepayment penalties are ineligible terms.”7 CFR 3555.104(b), eCFR current through October 30, 2026
Portfolio or other non-agency loanOutside the agency programs above, the ceiling in 12 CFR 1026.43(g) is the outer limit, and the note and any state law decide what is charged below it.12 CFR 1026.43(g)

Two cautions on reading the table. The FHA rule is written about acceptance and interest calculation. It describes no charge for prepaying, and it bars two things that worked like one: a 30-day notice requirement and interest running to the next installment date. The Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac note is a uniform instrument “with limited variations in some jurisdictions” (section 10 of Form 3200), so a state-specific note is worth a glance, though the multistate form and the West Virginia form both carry the identical sentence.

The program rules leave loans a lender keeps on its own books, or sells outside the agency channels, as the place a penalty can still be written, and the federal ceiling is the limit there. On a refinance out of an agency loan, the program text often settles the question of whether the old loan has a penalty before any quote does. The FHA streamline guide, the VA IRRRL guide and the USDA streamline guide cover what those refinances require once the payoff question is settled.

If a penalty on the old loan does exist, the new loan can often carry it. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide lists, among the acceptable uses of a limited cash-out refinance, “paying off the existing first mortgage (which may include additional amounts required to pay off the loan, such as prepayment penalties, a deferred balance resulting from completion of a prior loss mitigation solution, and late fees)” (B2-1.3-02, 10/08/2025). VA's refinancing rule says: “A refinancing loan may include contractual prepayment penalties, if any, due the holder of the mortgage or other lien indebtedness to be refinanced” (38 CFR 36.4306(e)). Rolling the penalty in is a financing choice with a price, covered below.

Loans closed before 2014: which rule applied and how to date the clause

Section 1026.43 took effect on January 10, 2014 (78 FR 6408, January 30, 2013, DATES paragraph). The Bureau stated in the preamble that its treatment of interest charged under monthly interest accrual amortization as a prepayment penalty applies only to transactions consummated on or after that date, and that for FHA loans compliance with that part of the definition was optional for transactions consummated before January 21, 2015. For a loan consummated earlier, the ceiling above is not the measure. The note and the rules of its day are.

From October 1, 2009 until the 2014 rule, the Federal Reserve Board's higher-priced mortgage loan rule applied (73 FR 44522, July 30, 2008). As adopted, § 226.35(b)(2) read: “(2) Prepayment penalties. A loan may not include a penalty described by § 226.32(d)(6) unless: (i) The penalty is otherwise permitted by law, including § 226.32(d)(7) if the loan is a mortgage transaction described in § 226.32(a); and (ii) Under the terms of the loan-- (A) The penalty will not apply after the two-year period following consummation; (B) The penalty will not apply if the source of the prepayment funds is a refinancing by the creditor or an affiliate of the creditor; and (C) The amount of the periodic payment of principal or interest or both may not change during the four-year period following consummation.” The current text of section 1026.35 has no prepayment paragraph.

Compared with today's paragraph (g), the 2008 text had a shorter window (two years, not three), set no percentage cap for these loans, had no qualified-mortgage gate, and excused a penalty when the money came from a refinance by the same lender or an affiliate. The current paragraph (g), quoted above, contains no such exception. That paragraph reached only higher-priced loans; high-cost loans had their own limit in § 226.32(d)(6) and (d)(7) as adopted. For a prime-priced loan from the same years, the 2008 paragraph did not apply, and the size and length of any penalty came from the note and from state law, which this guide does not map.

The practical question in November 2026 is date arithmetic. A higher-priced loan closed in the October 2009 to January 2014 window could not carry a penalty past its second anniversary, so for the last such loan, closed on January 9, 2014, the penalty could not outlast January 9, 2016. For any other pre-2014 note, add the length of the clause to the closing date. A loan closed in December 2013 is nearly thirteen years old in November 2026, so a clause still running on it would have to be longer than twelve years, far beyond the two- and three-year windows in the two federal rules. Where the note is unclear, the servicer's written payoff quote is the figure to get, with any penalty on its own line.

A hypothetical shows how to price an old clause when one is live. Suppose a note says the borrower pays 3 percent of the amount prepaid if the loan is paid off in full within a stated period. On a $280,000 balance the clause is worth $8,400. Today's ceiling on the same balance would be $5,600 in years one and two and $2,800 in year three. The clause is invented for arithmetic only; whether any state allowed it is a question about that state's law and that note.

FHA loans closed before January 21, 2015: interest to the next due date

One older-loan rule can still apply in 2026, because an FHA loan closed in 2014 would still be outstanding on a 30-year schedule. For an FHA-insured mortgage closed before January 21, 2015, the regulation says: “(2) With respect to FHA mortgages insured on or after August 2, 1985, but closed before January 21, 2015, the mortgagee shall not require 30 days' advance notice of prepayment, even if the mortgage instrument purports to require such notice. If the prepayment is offered on other than an installment due date, the mortgagee may refuse to accept the prepayment until the next installment due date (the first day of the month), or may require payment of interest to that date, but only if the mortgagee so advises the mortgagor, in a form approved by the Commissioner, in response to the mortgagor's inquiry, request for payoff figures, or tender of prepayment.” (24 CFR 203.558(b)(2)). Paragraph (b)(3) adds that a mortgagee that does not make the required disclosure may be subject to forfeiture of the interest collected for the period after the date prepayment in full was received.

Regulation Z carves this out. The definition quoted at the top says interest charged under monthly interest accrual amortization is not a prepayment penalty for FHA-insured loans consummated before January 21, 2015. The charge is not a penalty under the cap, but it is still money. On a $180,000 balance at 4.50%, interest runs $22.19 a day (balance times rate over 365). A payoff on the 10th of a 30-day month with interest required to the first of the next month is 21 days, $466.03; a payoff just after a due date could be charged nearly a full month, about $665.75. Neither amount counts as a penalty under the cap, which is why it is worth asking whether a payoff quote includes interest to the next due date. A payoff received on the installment due date leaves no days to charge. For a loan closed on or after January 21, 2015, paragraph (a) of the same section computes interest to the day the prepayment is received.

Penalty on the new loan: what a lower rate with a penalty is worth

The cap matters for the loan being paid off and for the loan being taken. Under paragraph (g)(3), a lender that quotes a refinance with a penalty must also offer one without. The pair is a price for a risk: a lower rate in exchange for a penalty on an early payoff. The arithmetic can be run before choosing. On the $317,029.03 balance, a 6.00% quote with no penalty has a payment of $1,922.33, and a 5.75% quote with the maximum penalty has $1,872.12, $50.21 less a month. The table compares the two by when the loan ends, whether by sale or by another refinance. Net is interest saved by the lower-rate loan minus the maximum penalty at that month; the penalty is 2 percent of the balance through month 24, 1 percent through month 36, and none after.

Net of taking the 5.75% loan with a maximum penalty instead of the 6.00% loan with none, by the month the loan is paid off; $317,029.03, 349 months, no closing-cost difference. Illustration, not quotes.
Paid off in monthInterest saved by the 5.75% loanMaximum penaltyNet of choosing the penalty loan
12$793$6,254-$5,461
24$1,586$6,161-$4,575
25$1,652$3,077-$1,425
36$2,379$3,032-$653
37$2,445None$2,445
60$3,960None$3,960
84$5,529None$5,529

The lower rate is a bet that the loan lasts past the penalty window. At any exit in the first 36 months the penalty loan loses, by between $653 (paid off in month 36) and $5,461 (paid off in month 12), and the first month it comes out ahead is month 37, when the penalty has expired. For a borrower who might move or refinance again within three years, the 0.25-point discount costs more than it saves. The Loan Estimate answer on the penalty line decides which side of the table the offer sits on, and the no-closing-cost refinance guide prices the other common rate-for-cost trade.

If the penalty is real: roll it in, wait, or pay part of the balance

Rolling a penalty into the new loan avoids cash at the table and raises the balance. On the 6.00% quote, financing the $6,340.58 penalty gives a new loan of $323,369.61 and a payment of $1,960.78, $38.45 a month more than the $1,922.33 payment on $317,029.03. The monthly saving against the old payment shrinks from $206.64 to $168.19. Eighty-four months after today, the financed loan balance is $287,575.23, against $281,936.85 when the penalty is paid in cash and $286,828.80 on the old loan if it were kept. The financed loan leaves the borrower owing $746.43 more than if they had never refinanced, even before counting the closing costs paid in cash. Financing is a legitimate use of the loan, and the break-even should be recomputed on the larger balance.

Waiting is the second route, and the tables above show when it pays: when the rate drop is narrower than about one point and the horizon is long enough for the new loan to pay off at all. The penalty percentage changes on the anniversary date, so if an anniversary falls within weeks of the planned payoff, the first table above shows what moving the payoff across it is worth: on the example loan, $3,135.63 at the second anniversary. Whether that outweighs the cost of the delay, including a rate-lock extension, is a break-even question.

The third route is a partial payoff. The cap applies to “the amount of the outstanding loan balance prepaid,” so paying down part of a loan costs a fraction of the full-payoff ceiling when the note charges on partial prepayments, and costs nothing when it does not. Principal reduction without a new loan is the subject of the recast guide. Whether a partial payment is charged at all is a question for the clause in the note.

Finding the number on your own loan

The documents answer the question in a fixed order of reliability. The Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure from the loan's closing carry a “Prepayment Penalty” line, answered yes or no under the heading “Does the loan have these features?” (§ 1026.37(b)(4) and (b)(7)); the Closing Disclosure's Loan Terms table repeats it (§ 1026.38(b)), and its Other Disclosures section tells the consumer to refer to the loan documents for “prepayment rebates and penalties” (§ 1026.38(p)(2)). A yes must show the maximum amount and the date the period ends. The loan estimate walkthrough and the closing disclosure guide show where the line sits on each form.

The note is the controlling document. On the uniform note, the clause is section 4, “Borrower's Right to Prepay.” A non-uniform note names the penalty in a clause on prepayment, early payoff or prepayment charge, with a percentage or a formula and a time window. The servicer's payoff quote is the third check. Ask for it in writing, with a good-through date, and compare it with the principal balance plus accrued interest: any difference beyond ordinary fees is the number to ask about, and a penalty should appear as its own line.

The written quote also settles timing. If a tier step falls between today and the planned closing, the date of the payoff, not the date of the application, decides the percentage. A rate lock that runs past an anniversary is a reason to ask the servicer which date it will treat as the payoff date. The rate lock fee guide covers the lock side of that timing, and the loan estimate tolerance rules cover what happens when a term on the new loan changes: a penalty added to the new loan after the Closing Disclosure is issued requires corrected disclosures at least three business days before closing (comment 19(f)(2)(ii)-1).

Documents and numbers to have before you ask for a payoff

  • The Loan Estimate or Closing Disclosure from the loan being paid off, turned to the Loan Terms table and the Prepayment Penalty line, with the maximum amount and end date if the answer is yes.
  • The note, opened to the prepayment clause: on the uniform Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac note it is section 4, and a different clause or a rider is the signal to ask more.
  • The closing date of that loan, so each anniversary can be dated and the current tier (2 percent, 1 percent or none) identified.
  • A written payoff quote with a good-through date and the penalty, if any, on its own line.
  • For an FHA loan closed before January 21, 2015, the per-day interest and the day of the month the payoff will land.
  • The new quote's closing costs and monthly saving, so break-even can be run with and without the penalty.

Questions about prepayment penalties and refinancing

Can my new refinance loan carry a prepayment penalty?

Only if it is a fixed-rate or step-rate qualified mortgage that is not higher-priced, and then no more than 2 percent of the balance prepaid in the first two years, 1 percent in the third and nothing after (12 CFR 1026.43(g)). The lender must also offer you a loan without a penalty. The Loan Estimate shows yes or no on the Prepayment Penalty line, with the maximum amount and end date when the answer is yes.

Do extra principal payments trigger a penalty?

The definition covers a charge for paying "all or part" of the principal early, and the cap is measured on the balance prepaid, so a note may charge on partial prepayments within the ceiling. The standard Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac note says you may make a full or partial prepayment without paying a prepayment charge. Your own note decides, and the Loan Estimate answer applies to the whole loan.

How do I find out whether my current mortgage has a penalty?

Check the Prepayment Penalty line on the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure from closing, the prepayment clause in the note, and a written payoff quote from the servicer that lists the penalty on its own line. On the uniform note, the clause is section 4, "Borrower's Right to Prepay."

Do FHA, VA or USDA loans have prepayment penalties?

The FHA rule (24 CFR 203.558) requires the lender to accept a prepayment at any time and in any amount and describes no charge for it. VA's rule (38 CFR 36.4311) gives the borrower the right to prepay "without premium or fee." USDA's guaranteed program (7 CFR 3555.104(b)) lists mortgages requiring prepayment penalties as an ineligible term. FHA loans closed before January 21, 2015 can still be charged interest to the next installment date.

My loan closed in 2012. Does the 2 percent cap apply?

Section 1026.43(g) took effect on January 10, 2014 and does not set the limit for a 2012 loan. If it was a higher-priced loan, the 2008 rule let a penalty run no longer than two years from closing, so any penalty ended in 2014. If it was prime-priced, the clause length in the note decides, and it would have to run more than a decade to be open now.

Does the 2 percent cap apply to a rental-property loan?

Not if the credit is for a business purpose. Regulation Z exempts credit extended primarily for a business, commercial or agricultural purpose and credit to a borrower that is not a natural person (12 CFR 1026.3(a)), and comment 3(a)-4 deems credit to acquire, improve or maintain a rental property the owner does not occupy to be business purpose. The note and state law set the penalty on such a loan, so read the prepayment clause before pricing a refinance.

Is interest through the end of the month a prepayment penalty?

For loans consummated on or after January 10, 2014, interest charged under monthly interest accrual amortization counts as a prepayment penalty under Regulation Z and must be disclosed as one. For FHA-insured loans consummated before January 21, 2015, it does not count as a penalty, and the lender may require interest to the next installment date if it gave the required notice (24 CFR 203.558(b)).

Get a written payoff quote with the penalty on its own line, then enter the new quote, closing costs and your stay horizon in the Stay or Refi Calculator, adding the penalty to the closing costs. If the old loan is only a few weeks from an anniversary, run the break-even again for the later date. The guide on how soon you can refinance covers the seasoning rules that run alongside this one, and the refinance hub for how your mortgage works lists the neighboring explainers.

Sources and verification

Dollar figures use a stated illustration: a $320,000, 30-year fixed loan at 7.00% closed November 18, 2025, closing costs of $6,200, quotes of 6.50%, 6.00% and 5.75% on a term-matched loan, and an 84-month horizon; they are not quotes or advice on any particular loan. Business-purpose loans fall outside Regulation Z and are not priced here. State prepayment law, state-specific note forms other than West Virginia, loans closed before October 1, 2009, USDA direct loans and Freddie Mac's Guide text are not covered; Freddie Mac appears only through the joint uniform note. The federal text is the eCFR as current through October 30, 2026, and your note and written payoff quote decide your own figure.